Killing of Robert S. Maynard

Last updated

Robert S. Maynard was a 21-year-old American man [1] from Illinois who was lynched in Jacksonville, Oregon, in May 1852 as a result of his murder of J. C. Platt. As Maynard was extrajudicially killed by hanging, this was the first recorded hanging and first recorded lynching in Southern Oregon, [2] where no courts had yet been appointed. [3]

Contents

Background

Maynard used the aliases Jackson Maynard and "John Brown," [4] [5] and multiple sources use solely Brown. [6] [7] He was described as a gambler, [8] [9] and as a man from Pike County, Illinois. [10] [11] Gold having been discovered late in 1851, [12] Jacksonville was only founded the same year of the killing, and the area was known at the time as Rogue River. [13] [7]

Murder

Maynard shot J.C. Platt [14] (also known as John D. Platt [7] and as Samuel Potts [6] [15] ) with a borrowed gun [16] because Platt called him a liar; [17] [14] the shot man "made no attempt to assault." [18]

Lynching

Maynard was executed by hanging [8] [14] by miners in what The Daily Alta California characterized as a "lynching." [7] Maynard asked the onlookers that they point to his grave and "say there lies a man who would not be insulted". [19]

As there were no organized courts of law at the time, [20] the killing was called "mob law" and "necessary" by press in New York; [21] likewise, the 1884 History of Southern Oregon described the extrajudicial killing as "a law higher, stronger, more effective than written codes [...] administered by the people's court." [22]

Conversely, Herman F. Reinhart attested a few years later that «excited miners [...] worked up a prejudice against the gambler», as gamblers had become «very obnoxious to the miners, who had lost money» with them, Maynard being one of those, and as a consequence the «miners were for lynching» Maynard right away. The miners appointed «fifty men (Vigilantes)» to keep Maynard from escaping until the hanging. [23]

Fifty years after the hanging, The Sunday Oregonian characterized the lynching as "swift and unerring justice of the miners." [24]

References

  1. ↑ ( The Oregon Statesman 1852 , p. 2): "He was twenty-one years of age."
  2. ↑ ( Plymale 1903 , p. 15): "this was the first execution in Southern Oregon"
  3. ↑ ( Plymale 1903 , p. 15): "there were no legally authorized courts"
  4. ↑ ( Plymale 1903 , p. 15): "a man who was called Brown by his comrades, but whose right name was Jackson Maynard"
  5. ↑ ( The Oregon Statesman 1852 , p. 2): "Robert Maynard, who went by the name of Brown"
  6. 1 2 "XLIII — Jacksonville". History of Southern Oregon. A. G. Walling. 1884. p. 360. LCCN   a14001444 . Retrieved February 26, 2024. Potts was shot dead, without provocation, by a gambler named Brown
  7. 1 2 3 4 "Lynching on Rogue River". The Daily Alta California . No. 166, Vol III. San Francisco: E. Gilbert & Co. June 15, 1852. Retrieved February 26, 2024. Brown, of Illinois, who killed John D. Platt [...] has been hung [...] trial at the hands of a committee appointed by the miners
  8. 1 2 David Newsom (August 9, 1852). "From Oregon". Sangamo Journal / Illinois State Journal. Illinois Digital Newspaper Collections. p. 2. Retrieved February 26, 2024. a gambler shot a man [...] and at the expiration of a week the man pulled hemp!
  9. ↑ ( Plymale 1903 , p. 15): "Jackson Maynard, a gambler"
  10. ↑ Sacramento Daily Union 1852, p. 37: "John Brown, of Illinois"
  11. ↑ ( Reinhart 1962 , p. 2): "John Brown from Pike County, Illinois"
  12. ↑ ( Plymale 1903 , p. 15): "the mines on Rich Gulch within the limits of Jacksonville were discovered [...] late in the fall of 1851."
  13. ↑ ( The Oregon Statesman 1852 , p. 2): "Jacksonville, a small mining village on Rogue River"
  14. 1 2 3 "Oregon". Illinois Daily Journal. No. 360, Vol IV. S. & A. Francis. July 31, 1852. p. 2. OCLC   8821623. Robt. S. Maynard, from Illinois, shot a man by the name of J. C. Platt, at Jacksonville, because he had been insulted by him [...] executed in three days after
  15. ↑ ( Plymale 1903 , p. 15): "killed Samuel Potts"
  16. ↑ ( The Oregon Statesman 1852 , p. 2): "Brown said he was insulted, and that he would shoot Platt. He borrowed a revolver"
  17. ↑ ( Sacramento Daily Union 1852 , p. 2): "Upon being called a liar he shot his antagonist"
  18. ↑ ( Plymale 1903 , p. 15): "Potts made no attempt to assault Maynard"
  19. ↑ ( The Oregon Statesman 1852 , p. 2): "He said [...] buried in that grave (pointing to a grave nearby, which had been dug), and that the traveler would point to it and say there lies a man who would not be insulted"
  20. ↑ ( Plymale 1903 , p. 15): "at this time there were no county organizations, no courts"
  21. ↑ "The Territory of Oregon". The Ovid Bee. No. 24, Vol 15. Ovid, New York: David Fairchild and Son. September 22, 1852. p. 1. LCCN   sn83031494. OCLC   9887516 . Retrieved February 26, 2024. May 29 [...] This may be called "mob law," but it is a government that seems to be necessary in these new settlements, where courts are not organized [...] A white man was [..] hung, for the diabolical murder of a white man
  22. ↑ ( History of Southern Oregon 1884 , p. 360): "there was a law higher, stronger, more effective than written codes--the stern necessity of mutual protection--and a strong element had the courage and will to enforce it. Justice was administered by the people's court"
  23. ↑ ( Reinhart 1962 , pp. 37–39): "Brown was called of that class, then very obnoxious to the miners, who had lost money with them, and were mad at them for beating them out of their money [...] The miners were for lynching Brown right off [...] A guard of fifty men (Vigilantes)"
  24. ↑ ( Plymale 1903 , p. 15): "they had a wholesome dread of the swift and unerring justice of the miners"

Bibliography

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.