Law of 7 July 1904

Last updated
Law of July 7, 1904
Loi congreganistes JORF 19040708.jpg
DateJuly 7, 1904
LocationFrance

The Law of July 7, 1904, also known as the Combes Law, officially the Law on the Suppression of Congregational Teaching, was a law of the French Republic that banned members of religious congregations and congregations themselves, even those authorized, from teaching in France and mandated the liquidation of their properties.

Contents

This law led to the reorganization of denominational education by the secular clergy and the establishment of numerous private schools staffed by lay or secularized personnel. It significantly altered the educational landscape and strengthened the secularization of education in France.

Context

After the expulsion of religious congregations in 1880, some congregations reconstituted themselves, prompting an anticlerical reaction from the French Third Republic. Under Pierre Waldeck-Rousseau's government (1899–1902), this reaction was relatively moderate but became more militant under Émile Combes (1902–1905). [1] Under Combes, who described his policies as a "secular campaign," the effort to curb the Catholic Church's influence in education reached its peak. [2]

Combes diverged from Waldeck-Rousseau’s approach, which primarily sought state control over congregations. [3] Instead, Combes aimed to exclude them. In November 1903, he announced plans for a law banning members of religious congregations from teaching, even in authorized congregations, and submitted a legislative proposal in December. A commission led by Ferdinand Buisson was established, and animated debates took place between February 29 and March 28, 1904. [4]

Content

The law’s title explicitly outlines its purpose: "Law on the Suppression of Congregational Teaching." [5] It aimed to compel teaching brothers to secularize or cease teaching. [6] Specifically, any application to open a congregational school became inadmissible. [7]

Notable articles include: [8]

Article 1: Teaching of any kind is forbidden in France to congregations. Congregations authorized exclusively as teaching bodies will be suppressed within a maximum of ten years.

Article 5: By judgment of the tribunal in the jurisdiction of the mother house, upon the request of the public prosecutor, the liquidator—appointed immediately after the promulgation of the law—shall inventory the assets of the congregations, which may not be rented or leased without his consent. The liquidator shall also administer the assets of institutions as they close and proceed with the liquidation of the properties and values of dissolved congregations under the conditions set forth by this law.

Implementation

The law was adopted by the Chamber of Deputies on March 28, 1904, by 316 votes to 269, and by the Senate on July 5, 1904. It was promulgated on July 7, 1904. [4]

The law applied to all levels of education—primary, secondary, and higher—and all types of schools, including professional, agricultural, and artistic institutions. It effectively condemned exclusively teaching congregations to dissolution. [9]

However, specific forms of education within hospital-type institutions—such as training apprentices or teaching orphans and students with disabilities—remained permissible. [9] Additionally, an amendment by Georges Leygues allowed congregations to continue operating overseas if they contributed to France's international influence. [10]

Consequences

Despite the ambitions of the law, its implementation was inconsistent. When Combes left office in 1905, only 3015 of the planned 6129 closures had occurred. [11]

The law profoundly altered the educational system and reinforced the secularization of French education. [7]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pierre Waldeck-Rousseau</span> Prime Minister of France from 1899 to 1902

Pierre Marie René Ernest Waldeck-Rousseau was a French Republican politician who served for three years as the Prime Minister of France.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Émile Combes</span> 19th/20th-century French statesman (1835–1921)

Émile Justin Louis Combes was a French politician and freemason who led the Lefts Bloc cabinet from June 1902 to January 1905.

The 1905 French law on the Separation of the Churches and State was passed by the Chamber of Deputies on 3 July 1905. Enacted during the Third Republic, it established state secularism in France. France was then governed by the Bloc des gauches led by Émile Combes. The law was based on three principles: the neutrality of the state, the freedom of religious exercise, and public powers related to the church. This law is seen as the backbone of the French principle of laïcité (secularism). It is however not applicable in Alsace and Moselle, which were part of Germany when it was enacted.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Patrick Cabanel</span> French historian (born 1961)

Patrick Cabanel is a French historian, director of studies at the École pratique des hautes études and holder of the chair in Histoire et sociologie des protestantismes. He mainly writes on the history of religious minorities, the construction of a secularised French Republic and French resistance to the Shoah.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Franca Valeri</span> Italian actress (1920–2020)

Alma Franca Maria Norsa, known professionally as Franca Valeri, was an Italian actress, playwright, screenwriter, author, and theatre director.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shmuel Trigano</span> French sociologist

Shmuel Trigano is a sociologist, philosopher, professor emeritus of sociology at Paris Nanterre University. He was Tikvah Fund Visiting Professor in Jewish Law and Thought at Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law, New York (2009), and Templeton Fellow at the Herzl Institute (Jerusalem) program "Philosophy of the Tanakh, Midrash and Talmud" (2012-2013), (2015-2017). Elia Benamozegh European Chair of Sephardic Studies, Livorno, Italy (2002).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of education in France</span>

The education system in France can be traced back to the Roman Empire. Schools may have operated continuously from the later empire to the early Middle Ages in some towns in southern France. The school system was modernized during the French Revolution, but roughly in the 18th and early 19th century debates ranged on the role of religion.

Jean-Pierre Chantin is a French historian of religion and author, associated with the University of Lyon. He specializes in the history of religion in France, including the Catholic Church and the role of new religious movements. He has published and edited several books on the topic of religion and NRMs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henri Charlier</span> French painter and sculptor (1883–1975)

Henri Charlier was a French painter and sculptor, noted for his religious art. He also wrote essays on art and music.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Georges Trouillot</span> French politician (1851–1916)

Georges Marie Denis Gabriel Trouillot was a French Radical politician. He played a central role in developing the law of 1901 that governed associations such as agricultural cooperative. He was Minister of the Colonies in 1898 and again in 1909–10. He was Minister of Industry, Commerce and Posts in 1902–05 and again in 1905–06. He published several books, including both poetry and political subjects.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Xavier de Montclos</span> French historian (1924–2018)

Xavier de Montclos was a 20th–21st-century French historian, a specialist of the history of religions and particularly Christianity.

Nadine-Josette Chaline is a contemporary French historian, specialist in religious history, especially Christians in France.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gaston Méry</span> French journalist and author (1866–1909)

Gaston Méry was a French author, translator and journalist. He was violently antisemitic and was also hostile to the people of the south of France, whom he saw as racially impure and inferior Latin peoples compared to the Celts of the north. He founded a journal L'écho du merveilleux which was largely devoted to proving the reality of a series of visions of the Virgin Mary, Joan of Arc and Jesus reported by Marie Martel in Calvados. From 1900 until his death he was a member of the Paris municipal council.

Marianne Carbonnier-Burkard is a French historian of modern Protestantism and honorary docent at the Faculté de théologie protestante de Paris. She is vice-president of the Société de l'histoire du protestantisme français and a member of the Comité consultatif national d'éthique pour les sciences de la vie et de la santé (2013–2017).

Dominique Gonnet is a Jesuit professor and a researcher at Institut des sources chrétiennes. He is a founding member of the Société d'Études Syriaques and has co-edited, in its collection of studies, Les Pères grecs dans la tradition syriaque.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">First Textbook War</span> Education-related conflict in France between 1882 and 1883

The first Textbook War was an education-related conflict in France between 1882 and 1883, after the secularization of primary education materials by the Ferry law on March 28, 1882.

Catholic congregations in France are institutions, approved by bishops or popes, which have been created over time in response to the needs or crises of the Church, and are an illustration of the Church's evolution. Novices, aspiring to religious life, become monks by making a lifelong commitment to the three Vows of obedience, chastity and poverty.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Expulsion of congregations</span> Political event in France

The expulsion of religious congregations in 1880 was a political event in France during the Third Republic, involving the dispersal of unauthorized, primarily male, religious congregations. These expulsions were enacted after the enactment of two decrees on March 29, 1880, by the government of Charles de Freycinet, specifically by Charles Lepère, Minister of the Interior, and Jules Cazot, Minister of Justice. The initial decree mandated the dissolution of the Society of Jesus (Jesuits) within French territory. At the same time, the subsequent directive required that all other unrecognized religious groups seek legal recognition, with the implicit threat of facing the same fate as the Jesuits.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of secularism in France</span> From 1789 to present day

The history of secularism in France is the birth and development of this principle up to the present day.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Georges Calzant</span>

Georges Calzant was a lawyer, journalist, and royalist activist affiliated with the Action Française movement.

References

  1. Jean Leduc (2014). L'Enracinement de la République : 1879 - 1918. Hachette Éducation. p. 76. ISBN   978-2-01-181875-1.
  2. Pierre Roche; Antoine Léon (2018). Histoire de l'enseignement en France. Que sais-je?. p. 88. ISBN   978-2-13-081238-8.
  3. Guy Laperrière (1996). Les congrégations religieuses de France au Québec, 1880-1914. Vol. II. Presses Université Laval. p. 441. ISBN   978-2-7637-7631-6.{{cite book}}: Unknown parameter |title-volume= ignored (help)
  4. 1 2 Guy Laperrière (1996). Les congrégations religieuses de France au Québec, 1880-1914. Vol. II. Presses Université Laval. p. 440. ISBN   978-2-7637-7631-6.{{cite book}}: Unknown parameter |title-volume= ignored (help)
  5. Patrick Cabanel; Jean-Dominique Durand (2005). Le grand exil des congrégations religieuses françaises, 1901-1914. Cerf. p. 72. ISBN   978-2-204-07469-8.{{cite book}}: Unknown parameter |subtitle= ignored (help)
  6. Gérard Cholvy; Yves-Marie Hilaire (1989). Histoire religieuse de la France contemporaine. Vol. 2. Éditions Privat. p. 104. ISBN   978-2-7089-5330-3.{{cite book}}: Check |isbn= value: checksum (help); Unknown parameter |title-volume= ignored (help)
  7. 1 2 Sophie Hasquenoph (2009). Histoire des ordres et des congrégations religieuses en France, du Moyen Âge à nos jours. Champ Vallon. p. 1114. ISBN   978-2-87673-495-1.
  8. J. Charon-Bordas (1989). "Liquidation des biens des congrégations religieuses: dossiers des établissements (1901-1914)". Archives nationales.
  9. 1 2 Patrick Cabanel; Jean-Dominique Durand (2005). Le grand exil des congrégations religieuses françaises, 1901-1914. Cerf. p. 73. ISBN   978-2-204-07469-8.{{cite book}}: Unknown parameter |subtitle= ignored (help)
  10. Patrick Cabanel; Jean-Dominique Durand (2005). Le grand exil des congrégations religieuses françaises, 1901-1914. Cerf. p. 74. ISBN   978-2-204-07469-8.{{cite book}}: Unknown parameter |subtitle= ignored (help)
  11. Patrick Cabanel; Jean-Dominique Durand (2005). Le grand exil des congrégations religieuses françaises, 1901-1914. Cerf. p. 75. ISBN   978-2-204-07469-8.{{cite book}}: Unknown parameter |subtitle= ignored (help)