Loaded: A Disarming History of the Second Amendment

Last updated

Loaded: A Disarming History of the Second Amendment
LoadedBookCover.jpg
Author Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz
Cover artistHerb Thornby
LanguageEnglish
Genre History
Publisher City Lights Books, San Francisco
Publication date
2018-01-23
Publication placeUnited States
Media typePrint (paperback, Kindle & audio)
Pages236
OCLC 1035450533

Loaded: A Disarming History of the Second Amendment is a book written by the historian Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz and published by City Lights Books. It takes a close and unexpected look at the historical origins of the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution. Despite being no fan of guns, Dunbar approaches the subject from neither the liberal nor the conservative side of the usual debate, instead digging deeply into the subject as a historian to unearth surprising facts.

Contents

Synopsis

Loaded begins with Dunbar-Ortiz writing about her own experience with guns as a member of a radical left-wing "women’s action-study group" in 1970. She uses her own history of falling in, and then out of, love with guns to begin an exploration of the larger U.S. love-fest with guns, and where this comes from. In nine chapters she describes the historical development of what she calls "a dangerous gun culture" intimately connected to the Second Amendment, that "has entitled white nationalism, racialized dominance, and social control through violence."

Chapters One and Two describe how the Second Amendment allowed and legalized the "total war" settlers were already "waging against Indigenous Peoples to dispossess them of their land", as well as permitting settler control of "Black populations - enslaved and free". This was an important part of U.S. expansion "throughout the continent and into the Caribbean and Pacific." [1] :p.25 In these chapters, Dunbar-Ortiz refutes an argument popular among gun-control advocates demonstrating that the Second Amendment "specifically gave individuals and families the right to form volunteer militias to attack Indians and take their land." [1] :p.18

Chapter Three examines little discussed provisions of the Second Amendment which required every citizen "to capture and return people caught escaping from slavery" and empowered slavers to organize "militias to help enforce slavery." [1] :pp.25–6

Chapters Four and Five explore the celebration of gun culture that led "generations" of American children to play "cowboys and Indians", and lionized "pro-slavery guerrillas" and "ruthless mass murderers" like Quantrill's Raiders, Jesse and Frank James, and the Younger brothers who became Robin Hood-like "iconic national celebrities". It also explores the national mythology surrounding "the hunter" which romanticised figures like Daniel Boone and gun use during the period when the U.S. was "committing genocide against Native Americans." [1] :p.26

Chapter Six looks into the ways that the Second Amendment, especially the right to bear arms, is treated like a "God-given covenant" in the U.S. [1] :p.109

Chapters Seven and Eight trace the rising numbers of mass shootings in the U.S. with the parallel increase of "organized gun-rights advocacy" and the "revival and rise of white nationalist groups and militias." [1] :p.26

Chapter Nine digs into the national resistance, among both pro and anti-gun advocates, to understand this history of the "connections between the Second Amendment and white nationalism." [1] :p.27

Overall, the book attempts to "confront fundamental aspects of U.S. history" embedded within "the original meaning and intention of the Second Amendment" that are "too often overlooked or denied". [1] :p.27

Reception

Loaded has received an overall favorable reception. It rates 4 out of 5 stars on Goodreads, the readers' book review website which has over 90 million members. [2] Adam Hochschild, writing in The New York Review of Books , described it as "like a blast of fresh air." [3] Mark Trecka in the Los Angeles Review of Books writes, "Dunbar-Ortiz constructs a vivid outline of the genocidal colonization of the United States.... her thesis here is certainly as compelling as — and perhaps even more shattering than — any she has proposed in previous works." [4] The New Republic reviewer, Patrick Blanchfield, praised the book as "brilliant" and said the book's "analysis, erudite and unrelenting, exposes blind spots not just among conservatives, but, crucially, among liberals as well". He continued, "Throughout, and even when uneven, her narrative is devastating ... As a portrait of the deepest structures of American violence, Loaded is an indispensable book." [5] The San Francisco Chronicle's review finds a few questionable arguments, but notes that at a time when "many Americans...have lost their patience with feckless lawmakers and AR-15 fetishists" the moment may demand "unambiguous language" which Dunbar-Ortiz "is well-positioned to meet". [6] Jonah Raskin, writing in the HuffPost gave the book a scathing review, calling it a screed and saying "Dunbar-Ortiz selects those incidents that support her argument and ignores those that don’t support her argument." along with saying she has an in issue with "white men". [7]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Second Amendment to the United States Constitution</span> 1791 amendment protecting the right to keep and bear arms

The Second Amendment to the United States Constitution protects the right to keep and bear arms. It was ratified on December 15, 1791, along with nine other articles of the Bill of Rights. In District of Columbia v. Heller (2008), the Supreme Court affirmed for the first time that the right belongs to individuals, for self-defense in the home, while also including, as dicta, that the right is not unlimited and does not preclude the existence of certain long-standing prohibitions such as those forbidding "the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill" or restrictions on "the carrying of dangerous and unusual weapons". In McDonald v. City of Chicago (2010) the Supreme Court ruled that state and local governments are limited to the same extent as the federal government from infringing upon this right. New York State Rifle & Pistol Association, Inc. v. Bruen (2022) assured the right to carry weapons in public spaces with reasonable exceptions.

A thought-terminating cliché is a form of loaded language, often passing as folk wisdom, intended to end an argument and quell cognitive dissonance. Its function is to stop an argument from proceeding further, ending the debate with a cliché rather than a point. Some such clichés are not inherently terminating; they only become so when used to intentionally dismiss dissent or justify fallacious logic.

Loaded may refer to:

<i>The Last of the Mohicans</i> 1826 historical novel by James Fenimore Cooper

The Last of the Mohicans: A Narrative of 1757 is a historical romance novel written by James Fenimore Cooper in 1826. It is the second book of the Leatherstocking Tales pentalogy and the best known to contemporary audiences. The Pathfinder, published 14 years later in 1840, is its sequel; its prequel, The Deerslayer, was published a year after The Pathfinder. The Last of the Mohicans is set in 1757, during the French and Indian War, when France and Great Britain battled for control of North America. During this war, both the French and the British used Native American allies, but the French were particularly dependent, as they were outnumbered in the Northeast frontier areas by the British. Specifically, the events of the novel are set immediately before, during, and after the Siege of Fort William Henry.

In American political discourse, states' rights are political powers held for the state governments rather than the federal government according to the United States Constitution, reflecting especially the enumerated powers of Congress and the Tenth Amendment. The enumerated powers that are listed in the Constitution include exclusive federal powers, as well as concurrent powers that are shared with the states, and all of those powers are contrasted with the reserved powers—also called states' rights—that only the states possess. Since the 1940s, the term "states' rights" has often been considered a loaded term or dog whistle because of its use in opposition to federally-mandated racial desegregation and, more recently, same-sex marriage and reproductive rights.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gun politics in the United States</span>

Gun politics is defined in the United States by two primary opposing ideologies concerning the private ownership of firearms. Those who advocate for gun control support increasingly restrictive regulation of gun ownership; those who advocate for gun rights oppose increased restriction, or support the liberalization of gun ownership. These groups typically disagree on the interpretation of the text, history and tradition of the laws and judicial opinions concerning gun ownership in the United States and the meaning of the Second Amendment to the Constitution of the United States. American gun politics involves these groups' further disagreement concerning the role of firearms in public safety, the studied effects of ownership of firearms on public health and safety, and the role of guns in national and state crime.

<i>King Leopolds Ghost</i> Book by Adam Hochschild

King Leopold's Ghost: A Story of Greed, Terror and Heroism in Colonial Africa (1998) is a best-selling popular history book by Adam Hochschild that explores the exploitation of the Congo Free State by King Leopold II of Belgium between 1885 and 1908, as well as the large-scale atrocities committed during that period. The book, also a general biography of the private life of Leopold, succeeded in increasing public awareness of these crimes in recent decades.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz</span> American historian and activist (born 1938)

Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz is an American historian, writer, professor, and activist based in San Francisco. Born in Texas, she grew up in Oklahoma and is a social justice and feminist activist. She has written numerous books including Blood on the Border: A Memoir of the Contra Years (2005), Red Dirt: Growing up Okie (1992), and An Indigenous Peoples' History of the United States (2014). She is professor emeritus in Ethnic Studies at California State University.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Militia (United States)</span> U.S. paramilitary force

The militia of the United States, as defined by the U.S. Congress, has changed over time. During colonial America, all able-bodied men of a certain age range were members of the militia, depending on each colony's rule. Individual towns formed local independent militias for their own defense. The year before the U.S. Constitution was ratified, The Federalist Papers detailed the Founding Fathers' paramount vision of the militia in 1787. The new Constitution empowered Congress to "organize, arm, and discipline" this national military force, leaving significant control in the hands of each state government.

A Taste of Power: A Black Woman's Story is a memoir written by Elaine Brown. The book follows her life from childhood up through her activism with the Black Panther Party. In the early chapters of the book, Brown recalls growing up on York Street in a rough neighborhood of North Philadelphia. Due to her mother's persistence, she is able to attend an experimental elementary school in a nice neighborhood and becomes friends with some Jewish girls. From that point on, Brown describes being a part of two worlds. She'd act "white" while hanging out with her school friends, and "black" when with the girls in her neighborhood.

District of Columbia v. Heller, 554 U.S. 570 (2008), is a landmark decision of the Supreme Court of the United States. It ruled that the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution protects an individual's right to keep and bear arms—unconnected with service in a militia—for traditionally lawful purposes such as self-defense within the home, and that the District of Columbia's handgun ban and requirement that lawfully owned rifles and shotguns be kept "unloaded and disassembled or bound by a trigger lock" violated this guarantee. It also stated that the right to bear arms is not unlimited and that certain restrictions on guns and gun ownership were permissible. It was the first Supreme Court case to decide whether the Second Amendment protects an individual right to keep and bear arms for self-defense or whether the right was only intended for state militias.

Presser v. Illinois, 116 U.S. 252 (1886), was a landmark decision of the Supreme Court of the United States that held, "Unless restrained by their own constitutions, state legislatures may enact statutes to control and regulate all organizations, drilling, and parading of military bodies and associations except those which are authorized by the militia laws of the United States." It states that the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution limited only the power of Congress and the national government to control firearms, not that of the states, and that the right to peaceably assemble in the First Amendment to the United States Constitution was not protected by the clause referred to except to petition the government for a redress of grievances. This decision was overruled in McDonald v. City of Chicago in (2010).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nazi gun control argument</span> 1992 fringe theory about gun regulations

The Nazi gun control argument is the claim that gun regulations in Nazi Germany helped facilitate the rise of the Nazis and the Holocaust. Historians and fact-checkers have characterized the argument as dubious or false, and point out that Jews were under 1% of the population and that it would be unrealistic for such a small population to defend themselves even if they were armed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stephen Halbrook</span> American lawyer and author

Stephen P. Halbrook is a senior fellow at the Independent Institute and an author and lawyer known for his litigation on cases involving laws pertaining to firearms. He has written extensively about the original meanings of the Second Amendment and the Fourteenth Amendment. He has argued and won three cases before the US Supreme Court: Printz v. United States, United States v. Thompson-Center Arms Company, and Castillo v. United States. He has also written briefs in many other cases, including the Supreme Court cases Small v. United States and McDonald v. Chicago. In District of Columbia v. Heller, he wrote a brief on behalf of the majority of both houses of Congress. He has written many books and articles on the topic of gun control, some of which have been cited in Supreme Court opinions. He has testified before congress on multiple occasions. Halbrook's most popular book is That Every Man Be Armed, originally published in 1984. The book is an analysis of the legal history and original intent of the Second Amendment.

In the United States, the right to keep and bear arms is a fundamental right protected by the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution, part of the Bill of Rights, and by the constitutions of most U.S. states. The Second Amendment declares:

A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert J. Cottrol</span>

Robert J. Cottrol is an American legal scholar and legal historian.

<i>Spain in Our Hearts</i> Book by Adam Hochschild

Spain in Our Hearts: Americans in the Spanish Civil War, 1936–1939 is a non-fiction book by Adam Hochschild that was first published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt on March 29, 2016. The book is an account of the American volunteers who participated in the Spanish Civil War from 1936 to 1939. The story centers around several American volunteer fighters and journalists, tracing their motivations for joining the war and their experiences during the war which left many disillusioned. The book explains the involvement of foreign leaders including Adolf Hitler, Benito Mussolini and Joseph Stalin, and explains why the Republican faction ultimately lost.

<i>An Indigenous Peoples History of the United States</i> 2014 book by Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz

An Indigenous Peoples' History of the United States is a non-fiction book written by the historian Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz and published by Beacon Press. It is the third of a series of six ReVisioning books which reconstruct and reinterpret U.S. history from marginalized peoples' perspectives. On July 23, 2019, the same press published An Indigenous Peoples' History of the United States for Young People, an adaptation by Jean Mendoza and Debbie Reese of Dunbar-Ortiz's original volume.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Colonialism and genocide</span> Relationship between colonialism and genocide

The connection between colonialism and genocide has been explored in academic research. According to historian Patrick Wolfe, "[t]he question of genocide is never far from discussions of settler colonialism." Historians have commented that although colonialism does not necessarily directly involve genocide, research suggests that the two share a connection.

Dina Gilio-Whitaker is an American academic, journalist and author, who studies Native Americans in the United States, decolonization and environmental justice. She is a member of the Colville Confederated Tribes. In 2019, she published As Long as Grass Grows.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Dunbar-Ortiz, Roxanne (2018). Loaded: A Disarming History of the Second Amendment. San Francisco, CA: City Lights Books. ISBN   978-0872867239.
  2. "Goodreads review of Loaded" . Retrieved April 12, 2020.
  3. Hochschild, Adam (April 18, 2018). "Bang for the Buck". The New York Review of Books. New York, NY. Retrieved April 12, 2020.
  4. Trecka, Mark (February 15, 2018). "The United States's Sacred Gun Problem". Los Angeles Review of Books. Los Angeles, CA. Retrieved April 12, 2020.
  5. Blanchfield, Patrick (December 11, 2017). "The Brutal Origins of Gun Rights". The New Republic. New York, NY. Retrieved April 12, 2020.
  6. Canfield, Kevin (March 1, 2018). "Loaded: A Disarming History of the Second Amendment by Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz". San Francisco Chronicle. San Francisco, CA. Retrieved April 12, 2020.
  7. Raskin, Jonah (October 31, 2017). "Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz's Screed on Gun Love and Gun Culture". HuffPost. New York, NY. Retrieved April 12, 2020.