Luxury tax (sports)

Last updated

A luxury tax in professional sports is a surcharge put on the aggregate payroll of a team to the extent to which it exceeds a predetermined guideline level set by the league. The ostensible purpose of this "tax" is to prevent teams in major markets with high incomes from signing almost all of the more talented players and hence destroying the competitive balance necessary for a sport to maintain fan interest. The money derived from the "tax" is either divided among the teams that play in the smaller markets, presumably to allow them to have more revenue to devote toward the contracts of high-quality players, [1] or in the case of Major League Baseball, used by the league for other pre-defined purposes.

Contents

In North America, Major League Baseball has implemented the luxury tax system. The National Basketball Association also has a luxury tax provision; its utility is somewhat limited by the fact that the league also has a salary cap provision. The "hard" salary cap of the National Football League and the National Hockey League has prevented any need for a luxury tax arrangement. [2]

Methods for limiting payroll

In the Big 4 North American sports leagues (Major League Baseball (MLB), National Basketball Association (NBA), National Football League (NFL), and National Hockey League (NHL)), there are three different methods employed to limit individual teams payroll: hard salary cap, soft salary cap with luxury tax, and luxury tax.

Hard salary cap

A hard salary cap is where the league sets a maximum amount of money allowed for player salaries, and no team can exceed that limit.

Soft salary cap

A soft salary cap has a set limit to player salaries, but there are several major exceptions that allow teams to exceed the salary cap. For example, in the case of the NBA, teams can exceed the salary cap when keeping players that are already on the team.

Luxury tax

A luxury tax system does not have a limit to how much money can be spent on player salaries. However, there is a tax levied on money spent above a threshold set by the Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) between the players union and the owners. For every dollar a team spends above the tax threshold, they must also pay some fraction to the league. This system is used to discourage teams from greatly exceeding the tax threshold, with the goal of ensuring parity between large and small market teams.

Luxury tax rules by league

Major League Baseball
Luxury tax
National Basketball Association
Soft salary cap + luxury tax
National Football League
Hard salary cap
National Hockey League
Hard salary cap
Major League Soccer
Hard salary cap + Designated Player Rule exception (making it effectively a soft cap)
Major League Rugby
Hard salary cap
Major League Lacrosse
Hard salary cap
National Lacrosse League
Soft salary cap

Major League Baseball (MLB)

As explained by Fangraphs: "Technically called the 'Competitive Balance Tax', the Luxury Tax is the punishment that large market teams get for spending too much money. While MLB does not have a set salary cap, the luxury tax charges teams with high payrolls a considerable amount of money, giving teams ample reason to want to keep their payrolls below that level." [3]

The threshold level for the luxury tax will be $189MM in 2014 (up from $178MM from 2011-2013) and will remain at $189MM through 2016. From 2012 through 2016, teams who exceed the threshold for the first time must pay 17.5% of the amount they are over, 30% for the second consecutive year over, 40% for the third consecutive year over, and 50% for four or more consecutive years over the cap. [4]

Only eight teams have ever exceeded the luxury tax threshold: the San Francisco Giants, the Boston Red Sox, the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim, the Detroit Tigers, the Los Angeles Dodgers, the New York Yankees, the Chicago Cubs for the first time in 2016 and the Washington Nationals for the first time in 2018. Only the Red Sox, Dodgers and Yankees have exceeded it more than once. The LA Dodgers have exceeded it four times. Boston has exceeded it six times. New York has exceeded it fourteen times, or, every year since it has been in enforcement. In aggregate, the Yankees have paid out some $325.00 MM, 73.78% of the total fines assessed since the luxury tax began.

In 2016 a record six teams were issued the luxury tax by the MLB. The Los Angeles Dodgers ($31.8 million), the New York Yankees ($27.4 million), the Boston Red Sox ($4.5 million), the Detroit Tigers ($4 million), the San Francisco Giants ($3.4 million) and the Chicago Cubs ($2.96 million). [5]

In 2017 the same six teams from 2016 were issued the luxury tax by the MLB. Against the $195 million threshold + $13 million for player benefits, payrolls for the Los Angeles Dodgers ($244 million), New York Yankees ($209.3 million ), Boston Red Sox ($187.9 million), Detroit Tigers ($190.4 million), San Francisco Giants ($186.4 million) and Chicago Cubs ($199.5 million) were in excess. This was the 15th straight year the New York Yankees paid the luxury tax. [6]

In 2018 only two teams met the luxury tax by the MLB: The Boston Red Sox ($9.4 million) and The Washington Nationals ($1.2 million). Several teams came just under the $197 million tax threshold: The San Francisco Giants ($196.66 million), The Chicago Cubs ($183.9 million), Houston Astros ($182.4 million), Los Angeles Dodgers ($181.99 million) and New York Yankees ($178.8 million). [7]

The luxury tax is separate from revenue sharing, which is a system to balance out the income distribution between large and small market teams by dividing money from merchandise sales and media contracts. The money generated from the luxury tax is not distributed to the rest of the league, as is the case with the NBA, but rather is used for other purposes. The first $2,375,400 and 50% of the remaining total are used to fund player benefits, 25% goes to the Industry Growth Fund, and the remaining 25% is used to defray teams' funding obligations from player benefits. [8]

Luxury tax paid per year by team (in millions of $) [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19]
Team2003200420052006200720082009201020112012201320142015201620172018201920202021Total
Luxury tax threshold117120.5128136.5148155162170178178178189189189195197206208210-
Yankees11.8025.9634.0526.0123.8826.8625.6918.0313.9018.9228.1118.3326.127.4-----325.04
Dodgers----------11.4226.6243.631.8-----113.44
Red Sox-3.154.150.506.06--1.493.43---1.84.5-9.4---34.48
Tigers-----1.31-------4-----5.31
Giants------------1.33.4-----4.7
Angels-0.93-----------------0.93
Cubs-------------2.96-----2.96
Nationals---------------1.2---1.2

National Basketball Association (NBA)

The NBA utilizes a soft salary cap, meaning there is a salary cap but there are a variety of exceptions that allow teams to exceed that cap. For example, teams can re-sign players already on the team to an amount up to the maximum salary allowed by the league for up to five years regardless of where their payroll is relative to the cap. This provision is known as the "Larry Bird" exception, named after the former Boston Celtics player who was retained by that team until his retirement under the provisions of this rule. The result is that the majority of teams are over the cap at any given time.

In addition to the soft cap, the NBA utilizes a luxury tax system that is applied if the team payroll exceeds a separate threshold higher than the salary cap. These teams pay a penalty for each dollar their team salary exceeds the tax level. From 2002 to 2013, if a team exceeded the luxury tax threshold, they must pay one dollar to the league for every dollar that they are over the limit. For the 2013-14 season and onward, teams paid an incremental rate based on their team salary. They also have to pay a repeat offender rate, which is an additional dollar for every dollar over. For 2014-15 teams pay the repeater rate if they also were taxpayers in all of the previous three seasons. For 2015-16 and all subsequent seasons, teams pay the repeater rate if they were taxpayers in at least three of the four previous seasons. The table of rates is shown below.

Current tax levels

Amount over tax thresholdStandard tax per excess dollarRepeat offender tax per excess dollar
$4,999,999 or less$1.50$2.50
$5 million to $9,999,999$1.75$2.75
$10 million to $14,999,999$2.50$3.50
$15 million to $19,999,999$3.25$4.25
Over $20 million$3.75 + $0.50 per $5 million$4.75 + $0.50 per $5 million

The resulting total is then distributed to the remaining teams that are under the tax threshold.

There was no luxury tax implemented in the 2004-2005 season due to insufficient basketball-related income. [ citation needed ]

Luxury tax paid per year by team (in millions of $) [20] (NBA Champ)
Team2002-032003-042004-052005-062006-072007-082008-092009-102010-112011-122012-132013-142014-152015-16 [21] Total Paid
Luxury Tax Threshold52.8854.56N/A61.765.4267.8671.1569.9270.3170.3170.3171.7576.8384.74N/A
Knicks24.3739.87-37.2545.1419.7223.745.20--9.9636.356.95-248.54
Mavericks19.525.03-17.337.2019.6123.6117.5818.922.74----150.53
Nets5.739.39--------12.8890.5719.78-138.55
Lakers9.756.44---5.137.1921.4319.9212.5629.268.96--122.64
Trail Blazers51.9728.85----5.899-------89.05
Heat5.18----8.32-3.04-6.1313.3514.43--50.44
Cavaliers-----14.0113.7115.41----6.9654104.09
Celtics-1.60---8.228.2914.935.697.371.18---47.28
Magic---7.76---11.0520.18-----38.95
Kings17.3813.14------------30.52
Timberwolves6.0317.63--1.00---------24.66
Nuggets----2.0213.57-5.56------21.16
Sixers12.765.10------------17.86
Suns1.89----3.874.924.96------15.63
Spurs0.19--0.900.20--8.81-2.52---4.917.5
Grizzlies7.55--3.74----------11.30
Pacers0.893.32-4.67----------8.89
Jazz-------3.115.00-----8.10
Raptors2.684.09------------6.77
Clippers-----------1.334.8019.926.03
Bucks4.73-------------4.73
Hawks3.72--------0.67----4.38
Bulls----------3.93--4.28.13
Thunder------------2.7914.517.29
Rockets--------0.76----4.55.26
Pistons-0.76------------0.76
Warriors-------------14.814.8
Hornets--------------0
Pelicans--------------0
Wizards--------------0

Canadian Football League

The Canadian Football League has a luxury tax. Penalties for teams that breach the salary cap regulations are:

Amount involved in breachPenalty for each $1Draft picks forfeited
First $100,000$1None
$100,000 to $300,000$2First Round
More than $300,000$3First and Second Round

[22]

Other leagues

The National Football League (NFL) and the National Hockey League (NHL) both have hard salary caps, making it unnecessary to utilize the luxury tax.

Several other leagues in the United States and abroad use salary caps, but the luxury tax is uncommon.

See also

Sports icon.png  Sportsportal

Related Research Articles

Commissioner of Baseball Chief executive of Major League Baseball

The Commissioner of Baseball is the chief executive officer of Major League Baseball (MLB) and the associated Minor League Baseball (MiLB) – a constellation of leagues and clubs known as "organized baseball". Under the direction of the Commissioner, the Office of the Commissioner of Baseball hires and maintains the sport's umpiring crews, and negotiates marketing, labor, and television contracts. The commissioner is chosen by a vote of the owners of the teams. The incumbent MLB commissioner is Rob Manfred, who assumed office on January 25, 2015.

In professional sports, a salary cap is an agreement or rule that places a limit on the amount of money that a team can spend on players' salaries. It exists as a per-player limit or a total limit for the team's roster, or both. Several sports leagues have implemented salary caps, using it to keep overall costs down, and also to maintain a competitive balance by restricting richer clubs from entrenching dominance by signing many more top players than their rivals. Salary caps can be a major issue in negotiations between league management and players' unions because they limit players' and teams' ability to negotiate higher salaries even if a team is operating at significant profits, and have been the focal point of several strikes by players and lockouts by owners and administrators.

<i>Moneyball</i> 2003 book by Michael Lewis

Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game is a book by Michael Lewis, published in 2003, about the Oakland Athletics baseball team and its general manager Billy Beane. Its focus is the team's analytical, evidence-based, sabermetric approach to assembling a competitive baseball team despite Oakland's small budget. A film based on Lewis' book, starring Brad Pitt and Jonah Hill, was released in 2011.

Jerry Michael Reinsdorf is an American billionaire businessman, and the owner of the NBA's Chicago Bulls and MLB's Chicago White Sox. He started his professional life as a tax attorney with the Internal Revenue Service. He has been the owner of the White Sox and Bulls for over 35 years. As of November 2021, his net worth was estimated at US$1.7 billion.

Scott Boras American sports agent

Scott Dean Boras is an American sports agent, specializing in baseball. He is the founder, owner and president of the Boras Corporation, a sports agency based in Newport Beach, California, that represents roughly 175 professional baseball clients. Since 2013, Forbes magazine has named Boras the "Most Powerful Sports Agent in the World." In 2019, contracts signed by his clients totaled more than $1 billion in the month of December.

Manny Ramirez Dominican-American baseball player

Manuel Arístides Ramírez Onelcida is a Dominican-American retired professional baseball outfielder. He played in Major League Baseball (MLB) for parts of 19 seasons. He played with the Cleveland Indians, Boston Red Sox, Los Angeles Dodgers, Chicago White Sox, and Tampa Bay Rays before playing one season at the Chinese Professional Baseball League in Taiwan. Ramirez is recognized for having great batting skill and power. He was a nine-time Silver Slugger and was one of 28 players to hit 500 career home runs. His 21 grand slams are third all-time, and his 29 postseason home runs are the most in MLB history. He appeared in 12 All-Star Games, with a streak of eleven consecutive games beginning in 1998 that included every season that he played with the Red Sox.

Mickey Owen American baseball player

Arnold Malcolm "Mickey" Owen was an American professional baseball player, coach and scout. He played as a catcher for 13 seasons in Major League Baseball (MLB) between 1937 and 1954 for the St. Louis Cardinals, Brooklyn Dodgers, Chicago Cubs and Boston Red Sox. Considered an outstanding defensive catcher, his career was nonetheless marred by a crucial error that he committed during the 1941 World Series. He also was one of the better-known MLB players who defected to the insurgent Mexican League in 1946, which resulted in a suspension that cost him over three prime seasons of his big-league career.

In the National Basketball Association (NBA), a sign-and-trade deal is a type of transaction allowed by the collective bargaining agreement (CBA) where one franchise/team signs an unrestricted free agent or restricted free agent player to a new contract, only to then immediately trade him to another team of the player's choosing. This is typically done to enable the player to obtain a higher salary and/or greater number of years on their contract than NBA salary cap rules would ordinarily allow a destination team that signs him directly to a contract.

The NBA salary cap is the limit to the total amount of money that National Basketball Association teams are allowed to pay their players. Like many professional sports leagues, the NBA has a salary cap to control costs and benefit parity, defined by the league's collective bargaining agreement (CBA). This limit is subject to a complex system of rules and exceptions and is calculated as a percentage of the league's revenue from the previous season. Under the CBA ratified in July 2017, the cap will continue to vary in future seasons based on league revenues. For the 2022–23 season, the cap is set at $123.655 million.

Posting system Baseball player transfers between Japan and the United States

The posting system is a baseball player transfer system that operates between Nippon Professional Baseball (NPB) and Major League Baseball (MLB). Despite the drafting of the United States – Japanese Player Contract Agreement, unveiled in 1967 to regulate NPB players moving to MLB, problems began to arise in the late 1990s. Some NPB teams lost star players without compensation, an issue highlighted when NPB stars Hideo Nomo and Alfonso Soriano left to play in MLB after using loopholes to void their existing contracts. A further problem was that NPB players had very little negotiating power if their teams decided to deal them to MLB, as when pitcher Hideki Irabu was traded to an MLB team for which he had no desire to play. In 1998, the Agreement was rewritten to address both problems; the result was dubbed the "posting system".

Andrew Friedman American baseball executive

Andrew Friedman is an American baseball executive. He is currently the President of Baseball Operations of the Los Angeles Dodgers of Major League Baseball (MLB). He previously served as the general manager for MLB’s Tampa Bay Rays, where Sporting News named him Executive of the Year in 2008. That year, for the first time in franchise history, the Rays both qualified for the playoffs and played in the World Series. In Los Angeles, as of 2020, Friedman and the Dodgers have won a World Series, three pennants, and six division titles since he took the job after the 2014 season. Baseball America called the Dodgers the model franchise in the sport under Friedman’s tenure as President.

Major League Baseball collusion refers to owners working together to avoid competitive bidding for player services or players jointly negotiating with team owners.

Major professional sports leagues in the United States and Canada Informal group of sports leagues

The major professional sports leagues in the United States and Canada are the highest professional competitions of team sports in those countries. The four leagues traditionally included in the definition are Major League Baseball (MLB), the National Basketball Association (NBA), the National Football League (NFL), and the National Hockey League (NHL). Other prominent leagues include Major League Soccer (MLS) and the Canadian Football League (CFL).

In professional sports within the United States and Canada, a trade is a sports league transaction between sports clubs involving the exchange of player rights from one team to another. Though player rights are the primary trading assets, draft picks and cash are other assets that may be supplemented to consummate a trade, either packaged alongside player rights to be transferred to another team, or as standalone assets in exchange for player rights and/or draft picks in return. Typically, trades are completed between two clubs, but there are instances where trades are consummated between three or more clubs.

World Series Championship of Major League Baseball

The World Series is the annual championship series of Major League Baseball (MLB) in the United States and Canada, contested since 1903 between the champion teams of the American League (AL) and the National League (NL). The winner of the World Series championship is determined through a best-of-seven playoff, and the winning team is awarded the Commissioner's Trophy.

Throughout its history, Major League Baseball rivalries have occurred between many teams and cities. Rivalries have arisen for many different reasons, the primary ones including geographic proximity, familiarity with opponents, various incidents, and cultural, linguistic, or national pride.

Trayce Thompson American baseball player (born 1991)

Trayce Nikolas Thompson is an American professional baseball outfielder for the Los Angeles Dodgers of Major League Baseball (MLB). He has also played in MLB for the Chicago White Sox, Oakland Athletics, Chicago Cubs, and the San Diego Padres. He is the son of former National Basketball Association (NBA) player Mychal Thompson and the younger brother of current NBA player Klay Thompson.

Major League Baseball (MLB) has a luxury tax called the "Competitive Balance Tax" (CBT). In place of a salary cap, the competitive balance tax regulates the total sum of money a given team can spend on their roster. Salary caps are common across professional sports leagues in the United States. Without these measures, teams would not be restricted on the amount of money spent on players' salaries. Therefore, teams with greater funding or revenue would possess a competitive advantage in their ability to attract top talent via higher salaries.

2019 Major League Baseball draft Major League Baseball player draft for the 2019 season

The 2019 Major League Baseball (MLB) First-Year Player Draft was held from June 3 to 5, 2019. The draft assigned amateur baseball players to MLB teams. The draft order was set based on the reverse order of the 2018 MLB season standings. In addition, compensation picks were distributed for players who did not sign from the 2018 MLB Draft and for teams that lost qualifying free agents. The first 41 picks, including the first round and compensatory picks, were broadcast by MLB Network on June 3, and the second round was streamed on MLB.com directly following the first round. The remainder of the draft was streamed online from June 4 to 5.

References

  1. Dietl, H., Lang, M. and Werner, S. (2010): "The Effect of Luxury Taxes on Competitive Balance, Club Profits, and Social Welfare in Sports Leagues", forthcoming in International Journal of Sport Finance.
  2. Andreff, Wladimir; Stefan Szymański (2006). Handbook on the economics of sport. Edward Elgar Publishing. p. 656. ISBN   978-1-84376-608-7.
  3. "Luxury Tax | Sabermetrics Library".
  4. Luxury Tax" Fangraphs
  5. "Record 6 MLB teams to pay luxury tax". Metroland News. 6 December 2016. Retrieved 20 December 2016.
  6. "6 teams will pay the luxury tax this year, and yes, of course, one of them is the Yankees". SBnation. 14 November 2017. Retrieved 20 November 2018.
  7. "Red Sox, Nationals only teams on track to pay MLB's luxury tax". ESPN. 23 April 2018. Retrieved 20 November 2018.
  8. "MLB CBA" (PDF). pp. 132–133. Retrieved 18 October 2016.
  9. CHART OF THE DAY: The MLB Luxury Tax Should Really Be Called "The Yankees Tax"." Business Insiders April 6, 2011.
  10. Yankees Assessed Luxury Tax." mlb.com 12/29/2009.
  11. MLB players, owners announce 5-year deal." ESPN.com October 25, 2006.
  12. New York Yankees cut the amount they spend on Major League Baseball luxury tax by over $7 million." NY Daily News December 22, 2010.
  13. Breaking Down MLB's Luxury Tax: 2003-2007." The Biz of Baseball December 25, 2007 Archived June 7, 2013, at the Wayback Machine .
  14. Baseball Luxury Tax." Juliettes Interiors.
  15. Report: Yanks hit with luxury tax:" ESPN December 14, 2012
  16. Yankees, Dodgers hit with luxury tax penalties" sbnation.com September 11, 2013
  17. Dodgers lead MLB with record $43.6 million paid in luxury tax" ESPN December 18 2015
  18. Competitive Balance Tax"
  19. Red Sox, Nationals only teams on track to pay MLB's luxury tax"
  20. "ShamSports | Complete History Of NBA Luxury Tax Payments, 2001-2015".
  21. "NBA luxury tax payments by team 2012-2016 | Statistic". Statista. Retrieved 2017-06-14.
  22. "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 2015-01-21. Retrieved 2014-12-27.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)