Martha's Rule

Last updated

Martha's Rule is a patient safety initiative being implemented in English NHS hospitals from April 2024. It gives patients, families, carers and staff in hospitals who have concerns about a patient's deteriorating condition access to a rapid review from a critical care outreach team. [1] Similar measures have been instituted in Australia, Denmark and the United States, and a programme called "Call 4 Concern" was previously trialled in the United Kingdom. [2] Martha's Rule is also a 'cultural intervention', which will help to flatten hierarchies within medicine, improve listening and openness on the part of clinicians and give patients and their families greater agency. [3]

Contents

Background

Martha Mills (2007-2021) Martha-mills-daughter-of-merope-and-paul.jpg
Martha Mills (2007–2021)

In the summer of 2021, 13-year-old Martha Mills fell off her bike, injuring her pancreas. [4] She was admitted to King's College Hospital (KCH) in London, where she was under the care of the paediatric liver team. [5] She remained on the ward as her condition deteriorated. She died on 31 August 2021, a few days before her 14th birthday. [4]

KCH's Serious Incident Investigation Report found that there were five occasions when it would have been appropriate to involve the paediatric intensive care unit (PICU). [6] Had she been moved to PICU, where a bed was available, observation and treatment would have been different. [7] In 2022, a coroner ruled that Martha would most likely have survived if KCH's liver team had transferred her to PICU. [7] KCH admitted a breach of its duty of care [6] and apologised for mistakes made. [8]

Development of Martha's rule

Martha Mills's mother, Merope Mills, is a journalist, editor of The Guardian Saturday magazine and a Guardian executive editor. In September 2022, Mills wrote about Martha and her treatment at KCH in an article for the Guardian. [9] The article was widely read [4] and has been studied in medical schools. [10] A year later, in September 2023, Mills gave an interview on the BBC Radio 4 Today programme, telling the story of Martha's treatment and making the case for Martha's Rule. [11] Within a day of the broadcast, Martha's Rule was discussed in the House of Commons. Within two weeks both the Conservative [12] and Labour [13] parties supported the initiative. The Shadow Secretary of State for Health, Wes Streeting, said that he was moved to tears by the BBC interview. [13] Within two weeks, The Times, [14] Daily Telegraph, [15] Guardian [16] and Daily Mail [17] had backed the campaign. The BMJ ran several pieces on Martha's Rule and the editor-in-chief wrote in support of the initiative. [18]

Mills wrote that she and Martha's father, Paul Laity, had raised concerns about Martha's deterioration, but their opinions were ignored or dismissed by the consultants and junior doctors on Rays of Sunshine Ward at KCH. [9] She recounted that Martha developed severe sepsis six days before she died, one symptom of which was that she bled copiously from the tubes in her arms and stomach. [19] Mills had expressly voiced her fear that Martha would die of septic shock over the bank holiday weekend, when the consultants 'weren't around'. [9] Mills and Laity were never told Martha had sepsis, and other symptoms were kept from them and left untreated. [9] In attempting to explain the resistance to involving PICU in Martha's care, independent investigators commissioned by KCH said that it was 'ingrained in the culture' of the paediatric liver consultants that inviting an ICU doctor to look at Martha would have been 'a sign of weakness'. [10] Henrietta Hughes, the Patient Safety Commissioner, has written that the 'tragic death of Martha is a clear example of epistemic injustice, where the views and voices of patients are not heard and acted on. The information and insights from Martha's parents were not believed, were undervalued, or were not understood – but it is not an isolated case.' [3]

Following the significant public response to the Guardian article, Mills and Laity were asked by the think-tank Demos to work jointly on a patient safety initiative designed to learn from Martha's death. [20] After research and a meeting with NHS representatives and other health stakeholders, the decision was taken to concentrate on Martha's Rule. Mills had been approached by health workers in Australia, who told her about Ryan's Rule, a similar patient safety process in Queensland, Australia, [21] which provided the inspiration for the name Martha's Rule. [22] Martha's Rule also draws on Call 4 Concern, an initiative introduced in a number of British hospitals. [1]

Implementation

In September 2023, the then Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, Steve Barclay, asked Henrietta Hughes, the Patient Safety Commissioner, to work on an implementation plan for Martha's Rule. After four 'sprint' meetings involving NHS Trusts, the Health Ombudsman, the Care Quality Commission, the General Medical Council, the Patients Association and other bodies, Hughes submitted her recommendations to the Secretary of State on 20 October 2023. [23] On 21 February 2024, NHS England and the Department of Health announced that the roll-out of Martha's Rule would begin with 100 hospitals from April 2024 to March 2025. [1] These are hospitals that provide acute care and that already have round-the-clock critical care outreach capability. According to Victoria Atkins, the Secretary of State for Health, the 'introduction of Martha's Rule from April will put families at the heart of the patient's own care, recognising the critical role they have in the treatment of loved ones'. [24] The work completed at the initial sites will inform the development of wider national policy proposals for Martha's Rule. [1]

The 3 proposed components of Martha’s Rule are:

  1. All staff in NHS trusts must have 24/7 access to a rapid review from a critical care outreach team, who they can contact should they have concerns about a patient.
  2. All patients, their families, carers, and advocates must also have access to the same 24/7 rapid review from a critical care outreach team, which they can contact via mechanisms advertised around the hospital, and more widely if they are worried about the patient’s condition.
  3. The NHS must implement a structured approach to obtain information relating to a patient’s condition directly from patients and their families at least daily. In the first instance, this will cover all inpatients in acute and specialist trusts. [1]

Response

On 2 April the General Medical Council, Nursing and Midwifery Council, and Care Quality Commission issued a joint statement expressing their support for the implementation of Martha's Rule by NHS England. [25] The organisations stated that 'Martha's Rule reinforces the fundamental principles of listening to people who use health and care services and their families, and acting on what they say.' [25]

Mills has argued that Martha's Rule will not only save lives but bring about a significant shift in the culture within hospitals towards patient power. [26] Mills said of her experience at Martha's bedside: 'I was "managed", I hadn't been listened to and I felt powerless ... If a patient and family escalation system such as Martha’s rule had existed – and had been clearly advertised around the hospital with posters and stickers – I’m sure I would have used it and it could well have saved Martha's life.' [27] Mills called for an increase in patient and family agency in a hospital environment – something long supported in principle by the NHS. [28] NHS England chief executive Amanda Pritchard said the programme would undoubtedly 'save lives in the future'. [24]

Some doubts were expressed in advance of the implementation of Martha's Rule regarding any attempt to frame it as the 'right' to a second opinion, which would be 'practically and conceptually fraught'. [29] It was also argued in the context of the initiative's aim to change medical culture that 'not all power imbalances' within the medical world 'are automatically and uniformly problematic'. [29] In addition, 'requesting a second opinion exemplifies a lack of trust, and perhaps even distrust, in the clinical team'. [29] In March 2024, the Royal College of Physicians and the British Medical Association (BMA) welcomed Martha's Rule. But Dr Vishal Sharma, chair of the BMA's consultants committee, argued that significant resource implications arose from its roll-out, given a perceived crisis in the NHS and existing staff shortages: 'For this to result in improvements for patients, it is essential that the current workforce crisis is addressed so that critical care outreach teams have the necessary staff they need to deliver this initiative. More must also be done to embed a supportive culture across the NHS where staff know they can speak up about problems and have time to listen to families and others when issues arise.' [30]

Evaluation of similar rules in other countries suggested that most uses were not related to patient safety. Calls to "Condition Help" in Pittsburgh were mostly regarding inadequate pain control, and most calls under Ryan's Rule in Australia did not lead to any change in clinical management. [2] A broad survey of evidence shows that initiatives such as Martha's Rule are not overused or abused by patients or families, and can result in necessary escalations which would otherwise not have occurred. [31]

The initial implementation target was to enrol at least 100 sites, but due to significant interest from frontline clinicians this has been expanded, so that the first phase of the Martha's Rule programme will be in place at 143 locations across England by March 2025. [32]

Related Research Articles

Patient rights consist of enforceable duties that healthcare professionals and healthcare business persons owe to patients to provide them with certain services or benefits. When such services or benefits become rights instead of simply privileges, then a patient can expect to receive them and can expect the support of people who enforce organization policies or legal codes to intervene on the patient's behalf if the patient does not receive them. A patient's bill of rights is a list of guarantees for those receiving medical care. It may take the form of a law or a non-binding declaration. Typically a patient's bill of rights guarantees patients information, fair treatment, and autonomy over medical decisions, among other rights.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Department of Health and Social Care</span> Ministerial department of the UK Government

The Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) is a ministerial department of the Government of the United Kingdom. It is responsible for government policy on health and adult social care matters in England, along with a few elements of the same matters which are not otherwise devolved to the Scottish Government, Welsh Government or Northern Ireland Executive. It oversees the English National Health Service (NHS). The department is led by the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care with three ministers of state and three parliamentary under-secretaries of state.

In the United Kingdom, junior doctors are qualified medical practitioners working whilst engaged in postgraduate training. The period of being a junior doctor starts when they qualify as a medical practitioner following graduation with a Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery degree and start the UK Foundation Programme. It culminates in a post as a consultant, a general practitioner (GP), or becoming a SAS Doctor, such as a specialty doctor or Specialist post.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ashworth Hospital</span> Hospital in Maghull, England

Ashworth Hospital is a high-security psychiatric hospital in Maghull, 10 miles (16 km) northeast of Liverpool. It is a part of Mersey Care NHS Foundation Trust, catering to patients with psychiatric health needs that require treatment in conditions of high security.

Polyclinics in England were intended to offer a greater range of services than were offered by current general practitioner (GP) practices and local health centres. In addition to traditional GP services they would offer extended urgent care, healthy living services, community mental health services and social care, whilst being more accessible and less medicalised than hospitals. A variety of models were proposed, ranging from networks of existing clinics to larger premises with several colocated general practitioner (GP) practices, more extensive facilities and additional services provided by allied healthcare professionals.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Priory Group</span> Provider of mental health care facilities in the United Kingdom

The Priory Group is a provider of mental health care facilities in the United Kingdom. The group operates at more than 500 sites with over 7,000 beds. Its flagship hospital is the Priory Hospital, Roehampton, which is best known for treating celebrities particularly for drug addiction. The Priory Group also manages schools, some for students with autism spectrum disorders through Priory Education and Children’s Services. Some of its facilities are run by its subsidiary Partnerships in Care. In January 2019 it opened its first overseas school in partnership with the Abu Dhabi Department of Education and Knowledge.

Health and Social Care is the publicly funded healthcare system in Northern Ireland. Although having been created separately to the National Health Service (NHS), it is nonetheless considered a part of the overall national health service in the United Kingdom. The Northern Ireland Executive through its Department of Health is responsible for its funding, while the Public Health Agency is the executive agency responsible for the provision of public health and social care services across Northern Ireland. It is free of charge to all citizens of Northern Ireland and the rest of the United Kingdom.

A patient safety organization (PSO) is a group, institution, or association that improves medical care by reducing medical errors. Common functions of patient safety organizations are data collection, analysis, reporting, education, funding, and advocacy. A PSO differs from a Federally designed Patient Safety Organization (PSO), which provides health care providers in the U.S. privilege and confidentiality protections for efforts to improve patient safety and the quality of patient care delivery

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Health Service (England)</span> Publicly-funded healthcare system in England

The National Health Service (NHS) is the publicly funded healthcare system in England, and one of the four National Health Service systems in the United Kingdom. It is the second largest single-payer healthcare system in the world after the Brazilian Sistema Único de Saúde. Primarily funded by the government from general taxation, and overseen by the Department of Health and Social Care, the NHS provides healthcare to all legal English residents and residents from other regions of the UK, with most services free at the point of use for most people. The NHS also conducts research through the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Health Service</span> Publicly-funded healthcare systems in the United Kingdom

The National Health Service (NHS) is the umbrella term for the publicly funded healthcare systems of the United Kingdom, comprising the NHS in England, NHS Scotland and NHS Wales. Health and Social Care in Northern Ireland was created separately and is often locally referred to as "the NHS". The original three systems were established in 1948 as part of major social reforms following the Second World War. The founding principles were that services should be comprehensive, universal and free at the point of delivery—a health service based on clinical need, not ability to pay. Each service provides a comprehensive range of health services, provided without charge for people ordinarily resident in the United Kingdom apart from dental treatment and optical care. In England, NHS patients have to pay prescription charges; some, such as those aged over 60, or those on certain state benefits, are exempt.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Children's Acute Transport Service</span>

The Children's Acute Transport Service (CATS) is a publicly funded specialised regional intensive care transport service for critically ill children. CATS is the busiest Paediatric Intensive Care Transport Service in the UK and covers the 50 District General Hospitals in the North Thames and East Anglia regions of England. CATS is part of the Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children NHS Foundation Trust.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Health and Social Care Act 2012</span> United Kingdom legislation

The Health and Social Care Act 2012 is an act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom. It provided for the most extensive reorganisation of the structure of the National Health Service in England to date. It removed responsibility for the health of citizens from the Secretary of State for Health, which the post had carried since the inception of the NHS in 1948. It abolished primary care trusts (PCTs) and strategic health authorities (SHAs) and transferred between £60 billion and £80 billion of "commissioning", or healthcare funds, from the abolished PCTs to several hundred clinical commissioning groups, partly run by the general practitioners (GPs) in England. A new executive agency of the Department of Health, Public Health England, was established under the act on 1 April 2013.

A rapid response system (RRS) is a system implemented in many hospitals designed to identify and respond to patients with early signs of clinical deterioration on non-intensive care units with the goal of preventing respiratory or cardiac arrest. A rapid response system consists of two clinical components, an afferent component, an efferent component, and two organizational components – process improvement and administrative.

Patient choice is a concept introduced into the NHS in England. Most patients are supposed to be able to choose the clinician whom they want to provide them with healthcare and that money to pay for the service should follow their choice. Before the advent of the internal market, in principle, a GP could refer a patient to any specialist in the UK. When contracts were introduced in 1990 these were called extracontractual referrals. From 1999 the concept of Out of Area Treatments was developed. These referrals were not necessarily related to choice made by a patient. Specialised treatments were not, and are not, available in every area.

Patient record access in the United Kingdom has developed most fully in respect of the GP record, because computerisation in that field is almost universal. British hospitals were slower to move into electronic records. From 1 April 2015 all GP practices in England have to provide online services to patients, including access to summary electronic medical records.

Hilary Dawn Cass is a British honorary physician in paediatric disability at the Evelina Hospital, part of Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust, and former president of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health. She is known for establishing the UK's Rett Clinic for children with the neurodevelopmental disorder Rett syndrome, developing palliative care for children, and leading the Cass Review, completed in 2024.

Professor Nick Harding OBE BSc FRCGP FRCP HonMFPH DRCOG DOccMed PGDIP (Cardiology) SFFLM, born 21 December 1969, is a British general practitioner and Chief Medical Officer at Operose Health.

In 2005 the National Health Service (NHS) in the United Kingdom began deployment of electronic health record systems in NHS Trusts. The goal was to have all patients with a centralized electronic health record by 2010. Lorenzo patient record systems were adopted in a number of NHS trusts. While many hospitals acquired electronic patient records systems in this process, there was no national healthcare information exchange. Ultimately, the program was dismantled after a cost to the UK taxpayer was over $24 billion, and is considered one of the most expensive healthcare IT failures.

Exercise Cygnus was a three-day simulation exercise carried out by the UK Government, in October 2016, to estimate the impact of a hypothetical H2N2 influenza pandemic on the United Kingdom. It was aimed at identifying strengths and weaknesses within the United Kingdom health system and emergency response chain by putting it under significant strain, providing insight on the country's resilience and any future ameliorations required. It was conducted by Public Health England representing the Department of Health and Social Care, as part of a project led by the "Emergency Preparedness, Resilience and Response Partnership Group". Twelve government departments across Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, as well as local resilience forums (LRFs) participated. More than 950 workers from those organisations, prisons and local or central government were involved during the three-day simulation, and their ability to cope under situations of high medical stress was tested.

Sarah Catherine Clarke FRCP FESC FACC is a British consultant cardiologist and was the president of the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) of London between September 2022 and June 2024.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 NHS England (21 February 2024). "Martha's Rule". UKOpenGovernmentLicence.svg Text was copied from this source, which is available under an Open Government Licence v3.0. © Crown copyright.
  2. 1 2 Cooksley, Tim; Astbury, Susan; Holland, Mark (2023). "Martha's rule and patients' rights to a second opinion". BMJ. 383: 2221. doi:10.1136/bmj.p2221. PMID   37783488.
  3. 1 2 Hughes, Henrietta (20 October 2023). "Recommendations on Martha's Rule implementation go to government". Patient Safety Commissioner: Listening to Patients.
  4. 1 2 3 Pidd, Helen (11 September 2023). "How the death of Martha Mills sparked a movement for change". Guardian.
  5. ↑ Thomas, Rebecca (21 February 2024). "NHS to roll out 'Martha's rule' following 13-year old's death". The Independent.
  6. 1 2 Today in Focus podcast (21 February 2024). "Why the NHS Needs Martha's Rule". Guardian.
  7. 1 2 Siddique, Haroon (4 March 2022). "Girl, 13, likely to have survived if moved to intensive care, coroner rules". Guardian.
  8. ↑ Kirby, Jane (4 September 2023). "Martha Mills: Parents of girl who died after NHS mistakes call for new right to get second opinion". The Independent.
  9. 1 2 3 4 Mills, Merope (3 September 2022). "'We had such trust, we feel such fools': how shocking hospital mistakes led to our daughter's death". Guardian.
  10. 1 2 Laity, Paul (27 August 2023). "Can I Forgive Myself for My Daughter's Death?". Guardian.
  11. ↑ BBC News (4 September 2023). "Martha's rule: Government to explore bringing in change after tragic teen death". BBC News.
  12. ↑ Davies, Caroline (14 September 2023). "Government backs Martha's rule on right to second medical opinion in England". Guardian.
  13. 1 2 Grierson, Jamie (5 September 2023). "Labour backs call for 'Martha's rule' on right to second medical opinion". Guardian.
  14. ↑ "The Times view on the case of Martha Mills: Martha's Rule". The Times. 5 September 2023.
  15. ↑ "Patients have a right to a second opinion: Medical staff are fallible. Martha's Rule is a necessary intervention". Telegraph. 5 September 2023.
  16. ↑ "The Guardian view on Martha's Rule: boosting patient power could save lives". Guardian. 5 September 2023.
  17. ↑ 'A second opinion', 7 September 2023
  18. ↑ Abbasi, Kamran (12 October 2023). "Martha's rule: an undeniable right to a second medical opinion". BMJ. 383: 2351. doi:10.1136/bmj.p2351.
  19. ↑ Sylvester, Rachel (5 September 2023). "We were powerless, we were told so little — and Martha died". The Times.
  20. ↑ "Martha's Rule: A New Policy to Amplify Patient Voice and Improve Safety in Hospitals" (PDF). Demos. 9 September 2023.
  21. ↑ Hinchliffe, John (8 September 2023). "Ryan's rule: the Australian right to a second medical opinion that may soon be saving lives in England". The Guardian.
  22. ↑ Best of Today. "Martha's Rule to Start in Hospitals". BBC Sounds.
  23. ↑ Hughes, Henrietta (20 October 2023). "Martha's Rule: Recommendations".
  24. 1 2 NHS England (21 February 2024). "NHS to Roll-Out Martha's Rule".
  25. 1 2 Sutcliffe, Andrea; Massey, Charlie; Trenholm, Ian (2 April 2024). "Joint statement on Martha's Rule from the GMC, NMC, and CQC". GMC Online.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  26. ↑ Mundasad, Smitha (4 September 2023). "Martha's rule: Call for right to second opinion after tragic teen death". BBC.
  27. ↑ "Martha's Rule: Challenging culture will make our hospitals safer". BBC. 4 September 2023.
  28. ↑ Sylvester, Rachel (18 November 2023). "Toxic doctors put patients at risk, says NHS watchdog". The Times.
  29. 1 2 3 Graham, Mackenzie (6 January 2024). "Getting rights right: implementing 'Martha's Rule'". Journal of Medical Ethics. doi:10.1136/jme-2023-109650. PMID   38184371.
  30. ↑ Houston, Dr Muiris (17 March 2024). "The challenge of implementing 'Martha's rule'". The Medical Independent.
  31. ↑ "Martha's Rule: A new policy to amplify patient voice and improve safety in hospitals". Demos. 2023-09-04. Retrieved 2023-12-28.
  32. ↑ "NHS England » NHS announces 143 hospitals to roll out 'Martha's Rule' in next step in major patient safety initiative". www.england.nhs.uk. Retrieved 2024-06-26.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.