Michael Neary (surgeon)

Last updated

Michael Neary is a former Irish consultant obstetrician/gynaecologist who carried out unnecessary surgical removal of the wombs of 129 women, many immediately following delivery of a baby. This happened while he worked at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda, County Louth. He was placed on administrative leave in 1998 and suspended by the Irish Medical Council in 1999 pending investigation. [1] In 2003 he was found guilty of professional misconduct by the Irish Medical Council and struck off the Irish Register of Medical Practitioners. [2]

Contents

The national scandal eventually led to state compensation for some of the victims. On 18 April 2007, Minister of Health Mary Harney announced a 45 million Euro compensation scheme, to cover up to 172 of the patients who had surgery between 1974 and 1998. [3]

Initial Enquiry

in 1998, three consultant obstetrician and gynaecologists from Dublin were asked by the Irish Hospital Consultants Association to review a number of cesarean hysterectomies carried out by Michael Neary. After examining nine case files presented by Dr Neary they found that he should continue working in the Lourdes Hospital, without sanction, pending any further inquiry. The three were subsequently named by the Irish Times as Professor Walter Prendiville and Dr Bernard Stewart of the Coombe Women's Hospital, and Dr John Murphy of the National Maternity Hospital in Holles St. [4]

Harding-Clarke inquiry

A judicial inquiry was set up in April 2004 by the then Minister for Health and Children, Micheál Martin to investigate the matter. [5] The Lourdes Hospital Inquiry was led by Judge Maureen Harding-Clarke, a prominent Irish judge, and began hearing evidence and examining 30 years of medical records in June 2004. She and her team interviewed Neary himself, hospital staff in Drogheda and various action groups and patients.

After an almost two-year investigation, the 250-page report was completed in January 2006 [6] and made public by the Tánaiste, and Minister for Health Mary Harney in February 2006. Harding-Clarke's report repeated many findings of the Medical Council's investigation (which she criticised for taking too long). The Inquiry found that Neary carried out 129 of 188 peripartum hysterectomies carried out in the hospital over a 25-year period, some on very young women of low parity. The average consultant obstetrician would carry out 5 or 6 of these operations in their entire career.

The report criticises the 'Catholic ethos' of the hospital at the time. Sterilisation was forbidden, contraception was unavailable, but 'secondary' sterilisations were commonly and sympathetically carried out on women who did not want more children but were forbidden to use contraception by the Church.

The report states that there was a "culture of respect and fear" in the unit so that even when questions were raised, people did not have the opportunity or the courage to speak out. The Inquiry came to the conclusion that Neary had a "heightened sense of danger" and that his fear of losing a patient approached "phobic dimensions" and led him to practice defensive medicine and carry out hysterectomies when he feared losing a patient. Judge Harding-Clarke wrote that questions should have been asked in the hospital long before 1998, when things first came to light. "The unplanned sterilisation of a young woman, as some of Dr. Neary's patients were, is too high a price to pay for a surgeon's phobias," states the inquiry report. One anaesthetist appointed to Lourdes in the 90s told the Inquiry that while people who worked with Neary come out and criticise him now, they "all thought he was wonderful" in 1996. Neary was seen as a hard-working consultant and was much respected in the area.

The Inquiry found how a senior consultant colleague of Mr. Neary's in the 70s and 80s, now deceased, told a Matron who was questioning the high number of hysterectomies that Neary was "afraid of haemorrhage". A junior consultant pathologist at the hospital in the early 80s asked his senior colleague why a perinatal uterus specimen he received seemed to have nothing wrong with it. The senior consultant replied "that's Michael Neary for you". Neary himself told the inquiry that he would have welcomed the opportunity to retrain and to observe other obstetricians at work. During the inquiry, he was asked about the frequent media claims that he hated women, and he replied that this was untrue, that "women were intuitive" and knew when men did not like them.

Judge Harding-Clarke notes in the report "It was difficult not to have some sympathy for Neary...his health is no longer strong. He is pilloried in the media and referred to as a 'monster' and a 'mutilator of women'. The effect on his life is profound. He will never practice medicine again, and he will never be given the opportunity to see how and where he got it wrong".

The Lourdes Hospital Inquiry Report uses the pseudonyms 'Ann' and 'Bridget' to refer to the two midwives who raised their concerns about Neary and notes on page 289 that "when the Health Board solicitor acted immediately on concerns expressed to him by two midwives on the 22nd day of October 1998, instead of general relief that finally these concerns had been aired, there was resentment towards the whistleblowers. We heard of comments to the effect that the whistle blowers would "never get a job in Ireland", that they would be sued for defamation and would generally come to a bad end. It would be difficult to say that there was general support for their criticisms of some of Dr. Neary's practices."

During the inquiry, Judge Harding-Clarke said that her offices were subject to three criminal forced entries. [7] The judge also disclosed that 44 patient charts, 41 corresponding birth registers listing their babies' details, and a maternity theatre register, were stolen. Another theatre register was tampered with. Only the gynaecological register turned up - inexplicably - months after it was reported missing. [8] They were "deliberately and unlawfully" removed, she wrote, "with a view to concealing the details of the operation performed and the treatment given. "Despite exhaustive research, judge Hardin-Clark never exposed the "miscreant/s" but she did suggest the involvement of women - at least two, one of whom wore nail varnish - and a possible motive of "misplaced loyalty" to Dr Neary. The bulk of the sabotage of patient files and medical records began in October 1998 when Dr Neary's alarming rate of hysterectomies first came to light. [9] The Gardai launched an investigation into the missing files and in August 2005, the Director of Public Prosecutions directed that no prosecutions would be made. [10]

On 9 March 2006 Tom O'Malley, The Minister of State at the Department of Health and Children, launched the report in the Seanad and said 'I want to express my deepest regret and to apologise to these women and their families for what happened. I assure the women involved that many lessons will be learned from this report, and I equally assure them that the Government will respond fully to the report's findings. [11]

Aftermath

Michael Neary's actions caused national outrage. The idea that a well-known and liked (as he was at the time) consultant obstetrician could needlessly remove women's wombs, and get away with it for so long, was shocking in itself, but the delay in discovery and investigation, and numerous other incidents that emerged following the publication of the Lourdes Inquiry, created a media storm and resulted in pages of coverage in newspapers.The hospital's 25 year culture of silence was noted. [12]

The women harmed by Neary came forward and spoke of their distress and how they still wonder why he did it. Represented by the group Patient Focus, some patients - though not all [13] - received compensation for what happened to them at the Lourdes Hospital Drogheda. As a result of the outcry following the publication of the report, the Irish Medical Council pressed to introduce new legislation that would allow them more power to find and stop any doctor who is performing poorly. They also introduced stricter Competence Assurance rules for doctors.

The three Dublin obstetricians who wrote the two initial reports appearing to clear Neary of any wrongdoing and defending his treatment of nine women whose wombs he removed later expressed serious regrets. [14] Dr John Murphy resigned in Feb 2007 as President of the Royal College of Physicians in Ireland following Medical Council criticism of his role in the case. [15] All three were found guilty of professional misconduct by the Irish Medical Council in 2007 [16] Subsequently, Professor Prendiville and Dr Murphy took a High Court case seeking to have the council's decision overturned. On 14 December 2007 the court found in favour of the two men and the Irish Medical council decided not to appeal the ruling. [17]

Whistleblower was a two-part Irish television IFTA-winning fact-based drama, broadcast on RTÉ One for two consecutive nights in 2008. The story followed a young midwife who became concerned over the high number of caesarean hysterectomies carried out by consultant surgeon Dr. Neary at the Lourdes Hospital, Drogheda. Her blowing the whistle on Dr Neary sets in train a series of events which resulted in a full investigation which attracted high media coverage throughout the country. [18] The true identity of the whistleblower remains shrouded in mystery, with Sheila O'Connor from Patient Focus collecting awards on their behalf.

In May 2008, the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) directed that there was insufficient evidence to bring a case against Neary, which angered the affected women. At the time, it was reported that Neary was living in his 500,000 Euro villa in the grounds of Isla Canela golf club in Southern Spain and that Neary had transferred ownership of his property in Spain as well as his five-bedroomed house in Monasterboice to his three children. [19] The Irish Hospital Consultants Association were involved in his negotiations to retire on a full pension. Since then, he has returned to live in Ireland.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Drogheda</span> Town in County Louth, Ireland, with suburbs in County Meath

Drogheda is an industrial and port town in County Louth on the east coast of Ireland, 42 km (26 mi) north of Dublin city centre. It is located on the Dublin–Belfast corridor on the east coast of Ireland, mostly in County Louth but with the south fringes of the town in County Meath, 40 km (25 mi) north of Dublin city centre. Drogheda had a population of 44,135 inhabitants in 2022, making it the eleventh largest settlement by population in all of Ireland, and the largest town in the Republic of Ireland, by both population and area. It is the last bridging point on the River Boyne before it enters the Irish Sea. The UNESCO World Heritage Site of Newgrange is located 8 km (5.0 mi) west of the town.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jayant Patel</span> Indian-born American surgeon (born 1950)

Jayant Mukundray Patel is an Indian-born American surgeon who was accused of gross negligence whilst working at Bundaberg Base Hospital in Queensland, Australia. Deaths of some of Patel's patients led to widespread publicity in 2005. In June 2010, he was convicted of three counts of manslaughter and one case of grievous bodily harm, and sentenced to seven years' imprisonment. In August 2012, all convictions were quashed by the full bench of the High Court of Australia and a retrial was ordered due to "highly emotive and prejudicial evidence that was irrelevant to the case" laid before the jury. A retrial for one of the manslaughter counts resulted in acquittal and led to a plea deal where Patel pleaded guilty to fraud and the remaining charges were dropped. On May 15, 2015, he was barred from practising medicine in Australia.

The Cartwright Inquiry was a committee of inquiry held in New Zealand from 1987 to 1988 that was commissioned by the Minister of Health, Michael Bassett, to investigate whether, as alleged in an article in Metro magazine, there had been a failure to treat patients adequately with cervical carcinoma in situ (CIS) at National Women’s Hospital (NWH) by Herbert Green, a specialist obstetrician and gynaecologist and associate professor at the Postgraduate School of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Auckland. The inquiry was headed by District Court Judge Silvia Cartwright, later High Court Justice, Dame and Governor-General of New Zealand. The Report of the Cervical Cancer Inquiry was released on 5 August 1988.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Herb Green</span>

George Herbert Green, B.A., BSc, M.B., Ch.B.,, M.R.C.O.G.(Lond.), was a New Zealand Obstetrician and Gynaecologist who led the National Women's Hospital Cervical Cancer Unit as Professor through the 1960s and 1970s and became notorious for conducting an alleged unethical experiment that was the subject of the Cartwright Inquiry.

Toni Ellen Hoffman is a senior nurse who was made a Member of the Order of Australia and awarded the 2006 Australian of the Year Local Hero Award. She took on the role of whistleblower in informing Queensland Politician Rob Messenger about Jayant Patel, a surgeon who was the subject of the Morris Inquiry and later the Davies Commission. She originally began to raise doubts about the ability of Patel with hospital management and other staff. Both doctors and surgeons who were familiar with his work had also been deeply concerned.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Symphysiotomy</span> Surgical procedure assisting childbirth

Symphysiotomy is an outdated surgical procedure in which the cartilage of the pubic symphysis is divided to widen the pelvis allowing childbirth when there is a mechanical problem. It is also known as pelviotomy and synchondrotomy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stephen Bolsin</span> British anaesthetist (born 1952)

Stephen Nicholas Cluley Bolsin is a British anaesthetist whose actions as a whistleblower exposed incompetent paediatric cardiac surgery at the Bristol Royal Infirmary leading to the implementation of clinical governance reforms in the United Kingdom.

<i>Whistleblower</i> (Irish TV series) Irish TV series or program

Whistleblower is a two-part Irish television IFTA-winning fact-based drama, broadcast on RTÉ One for two consecutive nights in 2008, which focuses on the Michael Neary scandal that first erupted in the 1990s. Neary, a retired Irish consultant obstetrician and gynaecologist, gained notoriety when it was discovered that he had performed what was considered an inordinate number of caesarian hysterectomies during his time at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda, County Louth.

Kathy Rose O'Brien is an actress from Dublin, Ireland, who has appeared in the Irish television drama Whistleblower, which dealt with the controversial events at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda relating to obstetrician/gynecologist Michael Neary, and in theatre productions including Leaves, The Burial at Thebes, The Birthday Party, The Fall of Herodias Hattigan and The Plough and the Stars. She holds a BA (Hons) in Drama and Theatre Studies from The Samuel Beckett Centre, Trinity College Dublin and graduated from the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art in 2006.

Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital is a public hospital located in Drogheda, County Louth, Ireland. It is managed by RCSI Hospitals.

The Health Information and Quality Authority is a statutory, government-funded agency in the Republic of Ireland which monitors the safety and quality of the healthcare and social care systems. Mooted as early as 2001, HIQA received its powers and mandate in May 2007 under the Health Act 2007. The Authority also exercises functions under the Child Care Act 1991 and the Children Act 2001. HIQA does not operate in Northern Ireland, where the equivalent body is the Regulation and Quality Improvement Authority.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fatima Hamroush</span>

Fatima Hamroush is an ophthalmologist and Libyan politician.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Death of Savita Halappanavar</span> Woman who died from sepsis from being denied an abortion in Ireland

Savita Halappanavar was a dentist of Indian origin, living in Ireland, who died from sepsis after her request for an abortion was denied on legal grounds. In the wake of a nationwide outcry over her death, voters passed in a landslide the Thirty-Sixth Amendment of the Constitution, which repealed the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution of Ireland and empowered the Oireachtas to legislate for abortion. It did so through the Health Act 2018, signed into law on 20 December 2018.

University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire NHS Trust runs University Hospital Coventry and the Hospital of St. Cross situated in Rugby, Warwickshire. The trust works in partnership with the University of Warwick's Warwick Medical School.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Catherine Calderwood</span> Scottish doctor

Catherine Jane CalderwoodFRCOG FRCPE is Northern-Irish born Scottish consultant obstetrician and gynaecologist, who has served as the National Clinical Director for Sustainable Delivery at the Golden Jubilee University National Hospital since 2021. She previously served as the Chief Medical Officer for Scotland from 2015 to 2020, having advised the Scottish Government's initial response to the COVID-19 pandemic in Scotland.

Charles Francis Meenan is an Irish judge who has served as a Judge of the Court of Appeal since July 2023. He previously served as a Judge of the High Court from 2017 and 2023.

RCSI Hospitals is one of the hospital groups established by the Health Service Executive in Ireland.

Suzanne Crowe is an Irish anaesthesiologist, intensivist, and current president of the Medical Council of Ireland.

Michael Gerard "Garry" Courtney is an Irish gastroenterologist and professor of medicine.

<i>Gough v Neary & Cronin</i> Irish Supreme Court case

Gough v Neary & Cronin [2003] IESC 39; [2003] IR 92; [2004] 1 ILRM 35 is an Irish Supreme Court case in which the court ruled that a claim against a gynecologist for performing an unnecessary hysterectomy was no longer legally enforceable owing to a prescribed period of limitation having lapsed under the Statute of Limitations (Amendment) Act 1991. However, the claim could still be brought under tort; this case highlighted that the three year limit for personal injury starts when the individual realizes the injury was due to negligence, rather than the date of the occurrence of the injury. Thus, the period that a person could file a claim was, in practical terms, extended.

References

  1. ↑ O'Connor, Sheila (2010). Without Consent. Poolbeg Books Ltd. p. 374. ISBN   978-1-84223-407-5.
  2. ↑ Edwards, Elaine. "Obstetrician is struck off medical register". The Irish Times. Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  3. ↑ "€45m compensation package for Neary victims". The Irish Times. Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  4. ↑ Donnellan, Eithne. "'Serious regrets' of doctors in Neary review". The Irish Times. Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  5. ↑ "Inquiry into Dr Neary to go back 30 years". The Irish Times. Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  6. ↑ Children (DOHC), Department of Health and (2006). "The Lourdes hospital inquiry: An inquiry into peripartum hysterectomy at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, Drogheda. Report of Judge Maureen Harding Clark S.C., / Department of Health & Children".{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  7. ↑ "Judging Consultants | Magill". magill.ie. Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  8. ↑ "'Misplaced loyalty' moved women to cover for Neary". independent. Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  9. ↑ "'Misplaced loyalty' moved women to cover for Neary". independent. Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  10. ↑ O'Brien, Carl. "No prosecution over lost Neary files". The Irish Times. Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  11. ↑ Oireachtais, Tithe an (9 March 2006). "Lourdes Hospital Inquiry: Statements. – Seanad Éireann (22nd Seanad) – Thursday, 9 Mar 2006 – Tithe an Oireachtais". www.oireachtas.ie (in Irish). Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  12. ↑ "Hysterectomy inquiry reveals 25-year scandal of silence". the Guardian. 1 March 2006. Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  13. ↑ Ward, Kathleen (19 September 2015). A Violation Against Women. Ireland: Liberties Press. ISBN   9781910742129 . Retrieved 8 January 2017.
  14. ↑ Donellan, Eithne. "'Serious regrets' of doctors in Neary review". The Irish Times. Retrieved 9 January 2017.
  15. ↑ "RCPI head resigns over Neary scandal". The Irish Times. Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  16. ↑ Editorial (23 June 2007). "Neary's legacy - Prendiville decision is a surprise". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  17. ↑ "Medical Council not to appeal ruling". 16 January 2008.{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  18. ↑ "'Whistleblower' Drama On RTÉ One | The Irish Film & Television Network". www.iftn.ie. Retrieved 22 June 2021.
  19. ↑ Murphy, Cormac (15 September 2008). "Butcher of Lourdes Hospital lives it up on Costa as victims suffer on". Herald Newspaper. Retrieved 14 February 2020.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.