Muckle Hart of Benmore

Last updated March 18, 2023

The Muckle Hart of Benmore^{[lower-alpha 1]} was the name given to a red deer stag that was stalked (hunted) by the 19th-century naturalist and hunter Charles William George St John.^[1] In his book Short Sketches of the Wild Sports and Natural History of the Highlands, he described the continuous hunt of the stag for six days and five nights, culminating in its dramatic demise on 1 October 1833.^[2] St John's account of the stalk was widely republished, and the deer has been described as "the most famous red stag to be recorded in the annals of British sport".^[3]

Background and publication history

Charles St John was an aristocratic Englishman with a lifelong interest in natural history who settled in Scotland as a young man, initially at Rosehall in Sutherland in about 1833. He spent the rest of his life fishing, shooting and observing wildlife. On 1 October 1833 he killed a large red deer stag named the Muckle Hart of Benmore.

St John’s account of his pursuit of the Muckle Hart was first published in 1845, incorporated into a book review written by his friend Cosmo Innes.^[4]^[5] St John later wrote an account of the pursuit in the 1846 book The Wild Sports and Natural History of the Scottish Highlands,^[2] in which he described his encounter with the Muckle Hart in more detail. The story was re-published and anthologized widely.^[6]

St John's account of the stalk

On a Sunday, Malcolm, the shepherd, reports to St John that he has seen the track of a hart of extraordinary size which he guesses must be the "muckle hart of Benmore" notorious for its "wonderful size and cunning".^[2]

The next day, St John sets off with his trusty servant, Donald, and Bran the dog. They shoot a wildcat but see no sign of the stag. They stay the night with Malcolm at his shieling (in Scottish dialect, a shepherd's hut used during summer grazing), and the next morning they spy the stag but, when they attempt to stalk him, he winds them. They return to the shieling.^[2]

On the Wednesday, St John helps Malcolm by hiding in a hole beside a dead sheep and shooting two golden eagles which had been killing his sheep. They resume the hunt but see no sign of the stag and sleep in a "niche in the rocks".^[2]

On Thursday, they see a footprint but dark falls amid heavy rain. In the darkness they hear a fiddle and wade a burn (small river) waist deep to enter a bothy (basic shelter) occupied by illicit whisky distillers, where they spend the night and Donald becomes drunk.^[2]

On Friday, St John resumes the hunt alone but becomes lost in the mist. He shoots and eats two grouse and bivouacs in the heather.^[2]

Saturday breaks fresh and sunny. St John spies the stag and stalks him but can only take a frontal shot which nevertheless appears to kill the hart. St John lays down his rifle and approaches the prone stag with his knife. When he grabs an antler to bleed the animal it springs up and throws him to the ground. Cornered against a bank, St John throws his plaid over the stag’s head and stabs him with his knife. The stag stands at bay in a loch while St John finds he has to pare a bullet with his knife to fit it into the rifle before he can shoot the hart in the head.^[2]

The trophy

In his accounts, St John does not describe the antlers other than to comment on first seeing the hart: "What a stretch of antler!"^[2] St John’s descendants reported that the Muckle Hart was a very heavy stag weighing 30 stone (420 lb; 190 kg).^[7] Years after the stalk, Lionel Edwards and Harold Frank Wallace examined the mounted antlers of the Muckle Hart, which they described as "a well shaped head with thick horn, and very good brow points 13 inches long".^[7] Their photograph of the mounted head appears in their 1927 book Hunting and Stalking the Deer.

Legacy and analysis

The Muckle Hart became legendary and was influential in the development of Scottish red deer stalking.^[7]^[8] The Muckle Hart has been described as "the most famous Scottish head which has ever been killed, probably the most famous head ever killed, at any rate to the English speaking world."^[7] St John's account of the stalk has been described as a "classic for all time" among deer-stalkers.^[9]

In the 21st century, St John's account has been taken as an exemplar of the romanticised 19th-century combat between the hardy English stalker alone in the wild Scottish Highlands and the massive, noble, native Scottish antlered red deer stag.^[10] It is an example of the often embellished accounts of deer-stalking in "florid prose" characteristic of the era; Hayden Lorimer describes St John's account as "scarcely credible".^[11]

St John’s account of the stalk of the Muckle Hart has been retold by many authors.^[12]

Notes

↑ Muckle is a Scottish dialect word meaning much or large, hart is an archaic word for a mature male red deer or stag and Benmore is a mountain in Sutherland, northern Scotland.

Related Research Articles

The Scottish Deerhound, or simply the Deerhound, is a large breed of sighthound, once bred to hunt the red deer by coursing. In outward appearance, the Scottish Deerhound is similar to the Greyhound, but larger and more heavily boned with a rough-coat.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Deer</span> Family of mammals

Deer or true deer are hoofed ruminant mammals forming the family Cervidae. The two main groups of deer are the Cervinae, including muntjac, elk (wapiti), red deer, and fallow deer; and the Capreolinae, including reindeer (caribou), white-tailed deer, roe deer, and moose. Male deer of all species, as well as female reindeer, grow and shed new antlers each year. In this, they differ from permanently horned antelope, which are part of a different family (Bovidae) within the same order of even-toed ungulates (Artiodactyla).

The sika deer, also known as the Northernspotted deer or the Japanese deer, is a species of deer native to much of East Asia and introduced to other parts of the world. Previously found from northern Vietnam in the south to the Russian Far East in the north, it is now uncommon except in Japan, where the species is overabundant.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Deer in mythology</span> Deer

Deer have significant roles in the mythology of various peoples located all over the world, such as object of worship, the incarnation of deities, the object of heroic quests and deeds, or as magical disguise or enchantment/curse for princesses and princes in many folk and fairy tales.

The red deer is one of the largest deer species. A male red deer is called a stag or hart, and a female is called a hind. The red deer inhabits most of Europe, the Caucasus Mountains region, Anatolia, Iran, and parts of western Asia. It also inhabits the Atlas Mountains of Northern Africa; its early ancestors are thought to have crossed over to Morocco, then to Algeria, Libya and Tunisia via the Strait of Gibraltar, becoming the only species of true deer (Cervidae) to inhabit Africa. Red deer have been introduced to other areas, including Australia, New Zealand, the United States, Canada, Peru, Uruguay, Chile and Argentina. In many parts of the world, the meat (venison) from red deer is used as a food source.

The sambar is a large deer native to the Indian subcontinent, South China and Southeast Asia that is listed as a vulnerable species on the IUCN Red List since 2008. Populations have declined substantially due to severe hunting, local insurgency, and industrial exploitation of habitat.

Throughout Western Europe in the Middle Ages, humans hunted wild animals. While game was at times an important source of food, it was rarely the principal source of nutrition. All classes engaged in hunting, but by the High Middle Ages, the necessity of hunting was transformed into a stylized pastime of the aristocracy. More than a pastime, it was an important arena for social interaction, essential training for war, and a privilege and measurement of nobility.

Charles William George St. John, English naturalist and sportsman, son of General the Hon. Frederick St John, second son of Frederick St John, 2nd Viscount Bolingbroke, was born on 3 December 1809 at Chailey, Sussex.

Gillie or ghillie is an ancient Gaelic term for a person who acts as a servant or attendant on a fishing, hunting, deer stalking or hawking expedition, primarily in the Scottish Highlands or on a river such as the River Spey. In origin it referred especially to someone who attended on his male employer or guests.

Deer hunting is hunting for deer for meat and sport, an activity which dates back tens of thousands of years. Venison, the name for deer meat, is a nutritious and natural food source of animal protein that can be obtained through deer hunting. There are many different types of deer around the world that are hunted for their meat. For sport, often hunters try to kill deer with the largest and most antlers to score them using inches. There are two different categories of antlers. They are typical and nontypical. They measure tine length, beam length, and beam mass by each tine. They will add all these measurements up to get a score. This score is the score without deductions. Deductions occur when the opposite tine is not the same length as it is opposite. That score is the deducted score.

Ledgowan Forest is a deer forest in the Scottish North-West Highlands. It stands in Wester Ross to the southwest of Achnasheen. Ledgowan Forest is the location of Carron Bog, the starting point of the River Carron.

The Lloyd Rifle was the 1950s brainchild of English deer-stalker, rifleman, metallurgist and engineer David Llewellyn Lloyd. His objective was to create a high-quality, scope-sighted, magazine-fed sporting rifle capable of dependably high accuracy at long ranges, of retaining its zero despite rough handling, and of firing modern high-intensity, flat shooting cartridges such as the .244 H&H Magnum and the .264 Winchester Magnum.

The deer forest is a sporting estate which is kept and managed largely or solely for the purposes of maintaining a resident population of red deer for sporting purposes. It is an institution and phenomenon peculiar to the Highlands of Scotland.

Deer stalking, or simply stalking, is a British term for the stealthy pursuit of deer on foot with the intention of hunting for meat, for leisure/trophy, or to control their numbers. As part of wildlife management, just as with rabbiting and boar hunting, the aim of deer stalking is to help reduce crop damage and obtain venison. Also, as with other types of hunting, deer stalking has long been considered a pastime sport.

A white stag is a white-colored red deer, wapiti, sika deer, chital, fallow deer, roe deer, white-tailed deer, black-tailed deer, reindeer, moose, or rusa, explained by a condition known as leucism that causes its hair and skin to lose its natural colour. The white deer has played a prominent role in many cultures' mythology.

Romania has a long history of hunting and remains a remarkable hunting destination, drawing many hunters because of its large numbers of brown bears, wolves, wild boars, red deer, and chamois. The concentration of brown bears in the Carpathian Mountains of central Romania is largest in the world and contains half of all Europe's population, except Russia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hart (deer)</span> Medieval hunting term for a red deer stag more than five years old

A hart is a male red deer, synonymous with stag and used in contrast to the female hind; its use may now be considered mostly poetic or archaic. The word comes from Middle English hert, from Old English heorot; compare Frisian hart, Dutch hert, German Hirsch, and Swedish, Norwegian, and Danish hjort, all meaning "deer". Heorot is given as the name of Hrothgar's mead hall in the Old English epic Beowulf.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Emperor of Exmoor</span>

The Emperor of Exmoor, a red stag, was reportedly killed in October 2010. Its weight has been estimated as over 300 pounds (136 kg) and its height at 9 feet (2.7 m). Red deer on Exmoor National Park are larger than red deer in Scotland owing to their diet.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Devon and Somerset Staghounds</span>

The red deer of Exmoor have been hunted since Norman times, when Exmoor was declared a Royal Forest. Collyns stated the earliest record of a pack of Staghounds on Exmoor was 1598. In 1803, the "North Devon Staghounds" became a subscription pack. In 1824/5 30 couples of hounds, the last of the true staghounds, were sold to a baron in Germany. Today, the Devon and Somerset is one of three staghounds packs in the UK, the others being the Quantock Staghounds and the Tiverton Staghounds. All packs hunt within Devon and Somerset. The Chairman as of 2016 is Tom Yandle, who was previously High Sheriff of Somerset in 1999.

One of Hungary's 22 state owned forestry and hunting companies is Gyulaj Forestry and Hunting Private Limited Company. Its online marketing brand name is Gyulaj Hunting Hungary. Besides forest management one of its main business activities is big game management carried out in professional and traditional near- nature way. Its game management branch activities include receiving international hunting clients for purpose of hunting for local big game species. Its business premises are located in Tamási, South- West Hungary in Tolna County. Among the Hungarian state-owned forestries Gyulaj Plc is the leader by its highest rate of incomings from hunting section compared to the total annual incomings of the company. By this performance Gyulaj Forestry and Hunting Plc is a key player of the Hungarian big games management and hunting. Its legal predecessors and different hunting grounds look back at a rich hunting history and performance: a heritage that has been kept alive until today. Gyulaj Forestry and Hunting Plc has been operating in the legal form of a private limited company since November 3, 2005. With its center in Tamási it presently does forest management on nearly 23,500 hectares state forestland and quality game management on nearly 30,000 hectares in South-West Hungary.

References

↑ Watkins, M.G. (2004) 'St John, Charles George William (1809–1856)', Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; online edn, accessed 11 May 2020.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 St John, Charles (1846). "The Muckle Hart of Benmore". Short Sketches of the Wild Sports and Natural History of the Highlands. London: John Murray. pp. 203–213.
↑ Edwards & Wallace 1927 , p. vi
↑ "Days and Nights of Salmon Fishing in the Tweed..." The Quarterly Review . 77 (153): 69–103. December 1845.
↑ Rutland, R. B. (1976). "Some Notes on the Highland Setting of Clough's "Bothie"". Victorian Poetry. 14 (2): 125–133. ISSN 0042-5206. JSTOR 40002379. Much of the article, ostensibly a review of William Scrope's Days and Nights of Salmon Fishing in the Tweed (London, 1843), is taken up by an account of the stalking of the 'Muckle Hart of Benmore,' which Innes drew from notes by the sportsman-naturalist, Charles St. John.
↑
See, for example:
- St John, Charles (1847) ‘The Muckle Hart of Benmore’, Sydney Chronicle (New South Wales), 19 October 1847. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/31753883
- Chalmers, Patrick R. (1931). Mine Eyes To The Hills. London: A&C Black, Ltd. (dedicated to the Muckle Hart)
- Buchan, John (1921). Great Hours in Sport. London: Thomas Nelson and Sons, Limited. pp. 55–70.
- BB (Denys Watkins-Pitchford) (1994) The Shooting Man’s Bedside Book. Cambridge, UK: White Lion Books, pp. 138–148.
- Camp, Raymond R. (1961) Hunting Trails: A Sportsman’s Treasury. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, Inc. pp. 483–491.
- McManus, Peter (2002) One Man’s Scotland. Burton-on-Trent, UK: MEP Publishing, pp. 131–139.
- Hart-Davis, Duff (1978) Monarchs of the Glen—a History of Deer-Stalking in the Scottish Highlands. London: Jonathan Cape.
1 2 3 4 Edwards & Wallace 1927 , p. 105.
↑ Von der Schulenberg, Fritz (1997). Balnagown: Ancestral Home of the Clan Ross : a Scottish Castle Through Five Centuries. Brompton. p. 78. ISBN 978-1-900055-07-9. The romance of deerstalking was spread by such writers as Charles St John who in 1833 stalked the celebrated muckle hart of Benmore...
↑ Cameron, A.G. (1923) The Wild Red Deer of Scotland. Blackwood: London and Edinburgh
↑ Martin, Maureen M. (2009). The Mighty Scot: Nation, Gender, and the Nineteenth-Century Mystique of Scottish Masculinity. SUNY Press. p. 75. ISBN 978-0-7914-7730-4.
↑ Lorimer, Hayden (2000). "Guns, game and the grandee: the cultural politics of deerstalking in the Scottish Highlands". Ecumene. 7 (4): 417. doi:10.1177/096746080000700402. ISSN 0967-4608. JSTOR 44252163. S2CID 143864212.
↑ Whitehead, George Kenneth (1980). Hunting & Stalking Deer in Britain Through the Ages. B.T. Batsford. ISBN 978-0-7134-2083-8.

Works cited

Edwards, Lionel; Wallace, Harold Frank (1927). Hunting and Stalking the Deer. London: Longmans.