Package redirection scam

Last updated

A package redirection scam is a form of e-commerce fraud, where a malicious actor manipulates a shipping label, to trick the mail carrier into delivering the package to the wrong address. This is usually done through product returns to make the merchant believe that they mishandled the return package, and thus provide a refund without the item being returned. It can also be done by the seller, generally by creating fraudulent online stores [1] or creating fake listings on sites such as eBay or Mercari. This makes it very hard to perform a chargeback, as the tracking shows the item has been delivered. [2] This is also known as an FTID scam, standing for Fake Tracking ID. [3] [4] When this scam is successful, the tracking number will show that the package has been delivered to the correct address, when the package was instead delivered to a different address. This package is generally empty or filled with garbage. However, this scam has mostly been “patched” via new technology provided by the various couriers globally.[ citation needed ] It is estimated the scam cost retailers £18,000,000,000 in lost revenue.[ citation needed ]

Contents

An example of a successful FTID scam on Facebook Marketplace. Note the order date being after the "delivery" date. FTID scam success.jpg
An example of a successful FTID scam on Facebook Marketplace. Note the order date being after the "delivery" date.

Methods

Multiple methods are used to trick the carrier into misdelivering the package. Usually, the scammer will edit the label. Various edits are possible, for example, changing the shipping address, removing barcodes, removing any indication that the package is a return, or printing certain parts of the label in disappearing ink. The scammer would then contact the company some weeks after the package is delivered, and demand a refund. As the company has no record of the return, a refund may be provided without the items being returned, as the company believes they mishandled the return. However, an edited label, if recovered, can prove that a package redirection scam occurred.

Some scammers may put the return label on an advertisement and remove all shipping information except for the barcode. This may cause the company to throw out the 'return', thinking it is junk mail. This serves the same purpose as a package redirection scam; the company believes they mismanaged the return and refunds the scammer's money.

It is also possible to remove the label after shipping the item. In February of 2021, a Canadian man was arrested for a return fraud scheme, where he would place devices that would remove the label after shipping the return. This resulted in the package being delivered to the wrong address, or lost entirely. Police recovered $20,000 in stolen merchandise and $25,000 in cash. 28 year old Christopher Lim was charged with 23 counts of public mischief, 12 counts of fraud under $5,000, and 18 counts of possession of property obtained through a crime. [5]

There is also a similar scam where a low value item is ordered on a site such as AliExpress, and shipped to a different address in the seller's ZIP code in place of a return. Some merchants may provide a refund upon seeing the item delivered to the same ZIP code; however this is generally used by fake online stores when selling items. This scam exploits a flaw in the tracking system; online tracking will usually only show the ZIP code the package was delivered to, instead of the full address. [6]

Lost in transit scam

The lost in transit scam is similar to the FTID scam, but instead of the package being redirected, it is intentionally lost in transit. As the package is lost, the shipping insurance will pay out, and the scammer will get their refund. Methods used to accomplish this can range from disappearing ink, thin paper, corrosive substances used to destroy the box after shipping, or even package bombs. [7]

"Refunding" fraud

On the internet, there are illegal services that allow you to receive a fraudulent refund, and keep the item you ordered. These are known as "Refunders". When hired, refunders will impersonate you and socially engineer the company into providing a refund. The "refunders" will then take a cut of the refund, usually 10-40%. The main method used by these Refunders is the package redirection scam. [8] [9]

Prevention

This scam is particularly difficult to prevent. While the merchant may know the package was never delivered, the return tracking may allow the fraudster to win a chargeback claim. In the case of marketplaces such as eBay, the site is programmed to automatically refund the money within 2 days of return package delivery. This can be very hard to reverse, especially if the scammer closes their account or cancels the card used to purchase the item. [10]

When the postal carrier marks an item as delivered, the GPS coordinates of the delivery are recorded. If these coordinates do not match the intended delivery address, this can serve as evidence of fraud. [11] The person who received the fraudulent return may also choose to retain the package and hand it to the authorities. The weight of the package can also be used to prove fraud, as scammers generally use an empty envelope. [12] However, some scammers may place garbage in the package to match the weight of the item, complicating the process. [13]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Advance-fee scam</span> Type of confidence trick fraud

An advance-fee scam is a form of fraud and is one of the most common types of confidence tricks. The scam typically involves promising the victim a significant share of a large sum of money, in return for a small up-front payment, which the fraudster claims will be used to obtain the large sum. If a victim makes the payment, the fraudster either invents a series of further fees for the victim to pay or simply disappears.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scam</span> Attempt to defraud a person or group

A scam, or a confidence trick, is an attempt to defraud a person or group after first gaining their trust. Confidence tricks exploit victims using a combination of the victim's credulity, naïveté, compassion, vanity, confidence, irresponsibility, and greed. Researchers have defined confidence tricks as "a distinctive species of fraudulent conduct ... intending to further voluntary exchanges that are not mutually beneficial", as they "benefit con operators at the expense of their victims ". Some people consider a pyramid scheme to be a type of scam.

Scam baiting is a form of internet vigilantism primarily used towards advance-fee fraud, IRS impersonation scams, technical support scams, pension scams, and consumer financial fraud.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Internet fraud</span> Fraud or deception using the Internet

Internet fraud is a type of cybercrime fraud or deception which makes use of the Internet and could involve hiding of information or providing incorrect information for the purpose of tricking victims out of money, property, and inheritance. Internet fraud is not considered a single, distinctive crime but covers a range of illegal and illicit actions that are committed in cyberspace. It is, however, differentiated from theft since, in this case, the victim voluntarily and knowingly provides the information, money or property to the perpetrator. It is also distinguished by the way it involves temporally and spatially separated offenders.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Online auction</span> Auction held over the internet

An online auction is an auction held over the internet and accessed by internet connected devices. Similar to in-person auctions, online auctions come in a variety of types, with different bidding and selling rules.

Email fraud is intentional deception for either personal gain or to damage another individual using email as the vehicle. Almost as soon as email became widely used, it began to be used as a means to defraud people, just as telephony and paper mail were used by previous generations.

The bogus escrow scam is a straightforward confidence trick in which a scammer operates a bogus escrow service.

A chargeback is a return of money to a payer of a transaction, especially a credit card transaction. Most commonly the payer is a consumer. The chargeback reverses a money transfer from the consumer's bank account, line of credit, or credit card. The chargeback is ordered by the bank that issued the consumer's payment card. In the distribution industry, a chargeback occurs when the supplier sells a product at a higher price to the distributor than the price they have set with the end user. The distributor submits a chargeback to the supplier so they can recover the money lost in the transaction.

Chargeback fraud, also known as friendly fraud, cyber shoplifting, or liar-buyer fraud, occurs when a consumer makes an online shopping purchase with their own credit card, and then requests a chargeback from the issuing bank after receiving the purchased goods or services. Once approved, the chargeback cancels the financial transaction, and the consumer receives a refund of the money they spent. Dependent on the payment method used, the merchant can be accountable when a chargeback occurs.

Telemarketing fraud is fraudulent selling conducted over the telephone. The term is also used for telephone fraud not involving selling.

Internet fraud prevention is the act of stopping various types of internet fraud. Due to the many different ways of committing fraud over the Internet, such as stolen credit cards, identity theft, phishing, and chargebacks, users of the Internet, including online merchants, financial institutions and consumers who make online purchases, must make sure to avoid or minimize the risk of falling prey to such scams.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Credit card fraud</span> Financial crime

Credit card fraud is an inclusive term for fraud committed using a payment card, such as a credit card or debit card. The purpose may be to obtain goods or services or to make payment to another account, which is controlled by a criminal. The Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard is the data security standard created to help financial institutions process card payments securely and reduce card fraud.

eBay has faced controversy, including failure to combat fraud committed by buyers and sellers, concerns over its rating systems, and concerns over sales of controversial or illegal items.

The parcel mule scam, also known as the reshipping scam, involves scammers and unsuspecting victims handling goods to other countries. In some ways it is similar to the money mule scam. Scammers use fake advertising to hire mules. Items are bought with stolen cards, and since the goods are typically re-sold once shipped, this scam can be viewed as an indirect form of money laundering.

A card-not-present transaction is a payment card transaction made where the cardholder does not or cannot physically present the card for a merchant's visual examination at the time that an order is given and payment effected. It is most commonly used for payments made over the Internet, but can also be used with mail-order transactions by mail or fax, or over the telephone.

An exit scam, is a confidence trick, con job or fraud, perpetuated under the guise of a legitimate business, that ends when the originator absconds with the funds contributed by participants. When a business entity rug-pulls and stops shipping orders while receiving payment for new orders, it could take some time before it is widely recognized that orders are not shipping. The entity can then make off with the money paid for unshipped orders. Customers who trusted the business do not realize that orders are not being fulfilled until the business has already disappeared. Exit scams are commonly associated with the rise of cryptocurrency projects due to the lack of regulation and decentralized ecosystem.

The locksmith scam is a scam involving fake business listings for cheap locksmith services that, once called out, overcharge the customer. The scam targets people who call a locksmith out of desperation, usually because of being locked out of their car or premises. Locksmith scams have been reported in the U.S., the U.K., and New Zealand.

An overpayment scam, also known as a refund scam, is a type of confidence trick designed to prey upon victims' good faith. In the most basic form, an overpayment scam consists of a scammer claiming, falsely, to have sent a victim an excess amount of money. The scammer then attempts to convince the victim to return the difference between the sent amount and the intended amount. This scam can take a number of forms, including check overpayment scams and online refund scams.

A pig butchering scam is a type of confidence trick and investment fraud in which the victim is gradually lured into making increasing contributions, in the form of cryptocurrency, to a seemingly sound investment before the scammer disappears. The name alludes to the practice of fattening a hog before slaughter. These scams have evolved into a global concern, impacting victims worldwide with substantial financial losses.

References

  1. "PayPal loophole makes it easier for scammers to trick you into fake goods". Detroit Free Press.
  2. Meyer, Bernard (October 29, 2020). "We helped a retiree win back her money from a PayPal-UPS scam - and uncovered a network of 39 scam sites". Cybernews. Retrieved April 2, 2022.
  3. "How to identify and stop e-commerce refund fraud and return fraud". Kount. Retrieved April 1, 2022.
  4. Brignall, Miles (January 28, 2019). "Seller beware! A new eBay scam using its own return label". The Guardian . Retrieved April 1, 2022.
  5. "Toronto man charged after alleged fraud involving online shopping returns". Global News.
  6. "BBB Scam Alert: Tracking code trick costs online shoppers". Better Business Bureau . December 3, 2021. Retrieved April 1, 2022.
  7. "Ex-worker posted exploding parcels in Amazon fraud". The Sunday Times.
  8. "REFUNDING FRAUD FAQ: THE NEW FRAUD TACTIC THAT COULD BE COSTING YOUR BUSINESS MILLIONS" (PDF). Squarespace .
  9. Karisse Hendrick (April 22, 2021). "Refund Fraud: An Update". Card Not Present.
  10. "Return an item for a refund". eBay . Retrieved April 1, 2022.
  11. "Package Delivery Scanning- Nationwide". United States Postal Service . Retrieved April 4, 2022.
  12. Jeff Weiner (Aug 19, 2019). "Lake Mary mother and son convicted in eBay scam get probation, ordered to pay back $63K". Orlando Sentinel.
  13. Diane Wilson (October 22, 2021). "Tracking number scam: Online shopper says eBay seller sent worthless fake package to wrong address". ABC11 News. Retrieved April 2, 2022.