President of the Supreme Court of Israel

Last updated
President of Supreme Court of Israel
נשיא בית המשפט העליון
Uzi Vogelman (158313395).jpg
Incumbent
Uzi Vogelman (acting)
since 17 October 2023
Precursor Esther Hayut

The President of the Supreme Court of Israel is one of the judges of the Supreme Court of Israel, who serves as head of the body, and as result has a significant impact on the judiciary system in Israel.

Contents

The previous president, Esther Hayut, retired on 15 October 2023. [1] As a successor was not selected, Deputy President Uzi Vogelman is serving as acting President of the Supreme Court.

Selection Process

In accordance with section 4(a) of the Basic Law: The Judiciary, the president of the Supreme Court is appointed by the President of Israel, according to the recommendation of the Judicial Selection Committee. By convention, the selection is made in order of seniority, by which the longest-serving judge is designated when the outgoing president completes his or her term. Accordingly, judges appointed at a young age have a relatively higher likelihood of eventually serving as president. Several justice ministers, including Haim Ramon, [2] Daniel Friedmann, [3] Ayelet Shaked, [4] and Yariv Levin [5] have attempted to end the seniority discipline but the practice has remained unchanged.

The length of tenure as a judge in Israel is limited: section 13 of the Courts Law mandates that a judge's term concludes at the mandatory retirement age of 70. In an amendment to the courts law, approved in 2007, it was determined that the tenure of a Supreme Court president is seven years from the date of appointment, with no possibility of reappointment.

Also in the amendment to the Courts Law approved in July 2007, passed at the initiative of Justice Minister Daniel Friedmann, it was enacted that a Supreme Court president should not be appointed within three years of retirement age. However, in January 2012, the Knesset amended the law and annulled that limitation, at the initiative of MK Ya'akov Katz. The decision was known as the "Grunis Law," as it made possible for the appointment of Asher Grunis to Supreme Court president soon after its passage. [6]

Powers

The Courts Law of 1984 designates the following unique powers to the President of the Supreme Court:

  1. Various appointments of judges, such as appointment of a judge to preside in a higher position, are taken under the authority of the Justice Minister, but with the approval of the President of the Supreme Court. In some other cases it is also required for the minister to consult with the president of the court.
  2. The President of the Supreme Court determines the size and composition of the Disciplinary Tribunal of Judges.
  3. The Supreme Court typically hears cases as a panel of three judges, however, at the discretion of the President in specific cases the court may sit as a panel of a larger uneven number of Judges.
  4. The judge or judges presiding over a specific matter brought to the court are determined by the President of the Supreme Court.
  5. The President of the Supreme Court can disqualify a judge from ruling on a particular case, if the president believes there may exist a conflict of interest.

Other powers were established in the Basic Law: The Judiciary: [7]

In accordance with the Commissions of Inquiry Law of 1968, after the decision is made to form a State Commission of Inquiry, the President of the Supreme Court determines its composition. [8]

List of presidents

No.NameDates of termLength of service
Start dateEnd date
1 Moshe Smoira

(1948–1954)

14 September 19481 August 1954

(Retired)

5 years, 321 days
2 Yitzhak Olshan

(1954–1965)

1 August 195419 February 196510 years, 202 days
3 Shimon Agranat

(1965–1976)

18 March 19655 September 197611 years, 171 days
4 Yoel Zussman

(1976–1980)

8 September 197629 February 1980

(Retired)

3 years, 174 days
5 Moshe Landau

(1980–1982)

5 March 198029 April 19822 years, 55 days
6 Yitzhak Kahan

(1982–1983)

30 April 198215 November 19831 year, 199 days
7 Meir Shamgar

(1983–1995)

27 November 198313 August 199511 years, 259 days
8 Aharon Barak

(1995–2006)

13 August 199516 September 200611 years, 34 days
9 Dorit Beinisch

(2006–2012)

17 September 200628 February 20125 years, 164 days
10 Asher Grunis

(2012–2015)

28 February 201217 January 20152 years, 323 days
11 Miriam Naor

(2015–2017)

17 January 201526 October 20172 years, 282 days
12 Esther Hayut

(2017–2023)

26 October 201715 October 20235 years, 355 days

In accordance with the seniority rule, the next Supreme Court presidents are expected to be:

#JudgeStart of TermEnd of Term
13 Yitzhak Amit 16 October 202320 October 2028
14 Noam Sohlberg 20 October 202822 January 2032
15 Daphne Barak-Erez 22 January 20322 January 2035
16 Ofer Grosskopf 2 January 203512 October 2039

Deputy president

In 1953, President of the Supreme Court Moshe Smoira fell ill, and Justice Minister Pinchas Rosen initiated the position of a permanent Acting President of the Supreme Court who could step in should Judge Smoira's condition prevent him from discharging his duties. Indeed, in December 1953, when Smoira ceased working, Yitzhak Olshan was appointed the first Acting President by the Selection Committee.

In 1984, at the initiative of Meir Shamgar, who had been appointed a judge a year earlier, the Judges Law was amended and the title "Permanent Acting President of the Supreme Court" was replaced by "Deputy President of the Supreme Court." The first person to hold the new title was Miriam Ben-Porat.

The Deputy President of the Supreme Court is subject to similar restrictions to those that fall on the appointment of the President of the Supreme Court: the term ends at the mandatory retirement age of 70; and in accordance with Amendment 45 to the Courts Law in 2007, the length of term as Deputy President is seven years without possibility of reappointment.

While the position of President of the Supreme Court is vacant and until the new president begins to serve, or if the President is out of the country, or if the President is temporarily incapacitated from fulfilling his or her duty, the Deputy President carries out the functions of the President.

The President of the Supreme Court is permitted to delegate his or her responsibilities to the Deputy President.

List of Deputy Presidents and Acting Presidents of the Supreme Court

President of Israel Reuven Rivlin swears in President of the Supreme Court Esther Hayut. Seated, left-right: Esther Hayut, Reuven Rivlin, Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked, and retired president Meir Shamgar. Standing, left-right, past presidents Asher Gronus, Dorit Beinisch, Miriam Naor, and Aharon Barak Reuven Rivlin is swearing in incoming Supreme Court President Esther Hayut at Beit HaNassi, October 2017 (5054).jpg
President of Israel Reuven Rivlin swears in President of the Supreme Court Esther Hayut. Seated, left-right: Esther Hayut, Reuven Rivlin, Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked, and retired president Meir Shamgar. Standing, left-right, past presidents Asher Gronus, Dorit Beinisch, Miriam Naor, and Aharon Barak
#NameStart of termEnd of termPresidents served under
1 Yitzhak Olshan 11 December 19531 August 1954

(Became president)

Moshe Smoira
2Shneur Zalman Cheshin1 August 195429 December 1959

(Died in office)

Yitzhak Olshan
3 Shimon Agranat 29 February 196018 March 1965

(Became president)

4 Moshe Zilberg 18 March 196516 September 1970 Shimon Agranat
5 Yoel Zussman 7 October 19708 September 1976

(Became president)

6 Moshe Landau 14 September 19765 March 1980

(Became president)

Yoel Zussman
7 Haim Cohen 5 March 198011 March 1981 Moshe Landau
8 Yitzhak Kahan 26 March 198130 April 1982

(Became president)

9 Meir Shamgar 30 April 198227 November 1983

(Became president)

Yitzhak Kahan
10 Miriam Ben-Porat 28 November 198325 April 1988 Meir Shamgar
11 Menachem Elon 26 April 19881 November 1993
12 Aharon Barak 1 November 199312 August 1995

(Became president)

13 Shlomo Levin 13 August 199520 February 2003 Aharon Barak
14Theodor Or20 February 200318 March 2004
15 Eliyahu Matza 23 April 20044 January 2005
16 Mishael Cheshin 4 January 200516 February 2006
17 Eliezer Rivlin 17 September 200628 May 2012 Dorit Beinisch,

Asher Grunis

18 Miriam Naor 31 May 201215 January 2015

(Became president)

Asher Grunis
19 Elyakim Rubinstein 15 January 201513 June 2017 Miriam Naor
20 Salim Joubran 12 June 20174 August 2017
21 Hanan Melcer 30 October 201712 April 2021 Esther Hayut
22 Neal Hendel 18 August 202127 April 2022
23 Uzi Vogelman 9 May 2022Incumbent

After the retirement of Judge Salim Joubran on 4 August 2017, there was no judge serving as Deputy President until the appointment of Hanan Melcer on 30 October 2017. In accordance with the seniority rule, it was expected for Esther Hayut to be appointed Deputy President on 4 August 2017 (after Judge Joubran's retirement), but she declined and on 5 September she presented her candidacy for president as did Melcer for Deputy President.

The following table presents the judges expected to serve as Deputy President of the Supreme Court:

#JudgeStart of TermEnd of Term
24 Noam Sohlberg 6 October 202420 October 2028
25 Daphne Barak-Erez 20 October 202822 January 2032
26 Ofer Grosskopf 22 January 20322 January 2035

See also

Related Research Articles

Chapter 9: Judiciary.Chapter 9 of the 1997 Constitution of Fiji is titled Judiciary. It is divided into twenty-two sections, setting out the composition and functions of the Judicial branch of the Fijian government.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Salim Joubran</span> Israeli judge (1947–2024)

Salim Joubran was a judge of the Supreme Court of Israel. He served as a Supreme Court justice from 2003, and became a permanent member in May 2004. Joubran was of Christian Maronite heritage and affiliated with the Arab Christian community. Joubran was the first Arab to receive a permanent appointment in the Israeli Supreme Court. He was also described as the second Arab judge to hold a Supreme Court appointment, preceded by Abdel Rahman Zuabi, who held a fixed nine-month appointment in 1999.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Supreme Court of Israel</span> Highest court in the State of Israel

The Supreme Court of Israel is the highest court in Israel. It has ultimate appellate jurisdiction over all other courts, and in some cases original jurisdiction.

The Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) is an independent commission that selects candidates for judicial office in courts and tribunals in England and Wales and for some tribunals whose jurisdiction extends to Scotland or Northern Ireland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Supreme Court of Korea</span> Highest ordinary court of South Korea

The Supreme Court of Korea is the highest ordinary court in the judicial branch of South Korea, seated in Seocho, Seoul. Established under Chapter 5 of the Constitution of South Korea, the Court has ultimate and comprehensive jurisdiction over all cases except those cases falling under the jurisdiction of the Constitutional Court of Korea. It consists of fourteen Justices, including the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Korea. The Supreme Court is at the top of the hierarchy of all ordinary courts in South Korea, and traditionally represented the conventional judiciary of South Korea. The Supreme Court has equivalent status as one of the two highest courts in South Korea. The other is the Constitutional Court of Korea.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Judiciary of Pakistan</span> National judicial system

The judiciary of Pakistan is the national system of courts that maintains the law and order in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. Pakistan uses a common law system, which was introduced during the colonial era, influenced by local medieval judicial systems based on religious and cultural practices. The Constitution of Pakistan lays down the fundamentals and working of the Pakistani judiciary.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Israeli law</span>

Israeli law is based mostly on a common law legal system, though it also reflects the diverse history of the territory of the State of Israel throughout the last hundred years, as well as the legal systems of its major religious communities. The Israeli legal system is based on common law, which also incorporates facets of civil law. The Israeli Declaration of Independence asserted that a formal constitution would be written, though it has been continuously postponed since 1950. Instead, the Basic Laws of Israel function as the country's constitutional laws. Statutes enacted by the Knesset, particularly the Basic Laws, provide a framework which is enriched by political precedent and jurisprudence. Foreign and historical influences on modern-day Israeli law are varied and include the Mecelle and German civil law, religious law, and British common law. The Israeli courts have been influenced in recent years by American Law and Canadian Law and to a lesser extent by Continental Law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Judicial officers of the Republic of Singapore</span>

The judicial officers of the Republic of Singapore work in the Supreme Court and the State Courts to hear and determine disputes between litigants in civil cases and, in criminal matters, to determine the liability of accused persons and their sentences if they are convicted.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Justice of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom</span> The judges of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom

Justices of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom are the judges of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom other than the president and the deputy president of the court. The Supreme Court is the highest court of the United Kingdom for all civil cases, and for criminal cases from the jurisdictions of England and Wales and Northern Ireland. Judges are appointed by the British monarch on the advice of the prime minister, who receives recommendations from a selection commission.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hanan Melcer</span> Justice of the Supreme Court of Israel

Hanan Melcer is an Israeli judge who served as a justice on the Supreme Court of Israel and Deputy Chief Justice.

The Israeli Judicial Selection Committee is the body that appoints judges to Israeli courts.

Part Nine of the Constitution of Albania is the ninth of eighteen parts. Titled The Courts, it consists of 22 articles including the Article 144 which was repealed in 2016. Together with Part Eight (Constitutional Court), and Part Ten (The Office of the Prosecutor) underwent radical changes in 2016 during the so-called Justice Reform, which were the efforts of lawmakers to fight corruption, organized crime, nepotism in the justice system.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Law of the Bahamas</span>

The basis of the Bahamian Law and legal system lies within the English Common Law tradition. Justices of the Supreme Court, Registrars and Magistrates are all appointed by The Governor-General acting on the advice of the Judicial and Legal Service Commission, which is composed of five individuals who are headed by the Chief Justice as their chairman. The Chief Justice and the Justices of the Court of Appeal, including the President, are appointed by the Governor-General on the recommendation of the Prime Minister after consultation with the Leader of the Opposition. Once appointed, the salaries and other terms of appointment of the Chief Justice, Justices of Appeal and Justices of the Supreme Court cannot be altered to their disadvantage. Justices of the Supreme Court can serve until the age of 65 years and, where agreed among the judge, the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition, may serve until the age of 67. Justices of Appeal can serve until the age of 68 years and, where agreed among the judge, the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition, may serve until the age of 70 years. The law of The Bahamas makes provisions for the appointment of 12 Justices to the Bench of the Supreme Court, inclusive of the Chief Justice, and for five Justices of the Court of Appeal, inclusive of the President. The Chief Justice, as Head of the Judiciary, is an ex officio member of the Court of Appeal, but only sits at the invitation of the President.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Uzi Vogelman</span> Israeli jurist (born 1954)

Uzi Fogelman is a justice of the Supreme Court of Israel and the acting president of the Supreme Court of Israel.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Judicial Service Commission (Kenya)</span>

The Judicial Service Commission (JSC) of Kenya is an independent Commission established under Article 171 of the Constitution of Kenya. Its mandate as stipulated in Article 172 of the Constitution is to promote and facilitate the independence and accountability of the Judiciary and the efficient, effective and transparent administration of justice. The commission has 11 members with the initial team appointed in December 2010.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Vivien Rose, Lady Rose of Colmworth</span> British judge)

Vivien Judith Rose, Lady Rose of Colmworth, is a British judge currently serving as a justice of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom.

The Judiciary of Sri Lanka are the civil and criminal courts responsible for the administration of justice in Sri Lanka. The Constitution of Sri Lanka defines courts as independent institutions within the traditional framework of checks and balances. They apply Sri Lankan Law which is an amalgam of English common law, Roman-Dutch civil law and Customary Law; and are established under the Judicature Act No 02 of 1978 of the Parliament of Sri Lanka.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Miriam Naor</span> Israeli judge (1947–2022)

Miriam Naor was an Israeli judge who was President of the Supreme Court of Israel from January 2015 to October 2017. Naor retired at the end of October 2017 upon reaching the mandatory judicial retirement age of 70. She was succeeded by Esther Hayut.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Esther Hayut</span> Israeli jurist (born 1953)

Esther Hayut is an Israeli jurist who served as president of the Supreme Court of Israel from October 2017 to October 2023.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Judiciary of the Dominican Republic</span>

The judiciary is one of the three branches of state that make up the government of the Dominican Republic. Its function is to administer justice, for free, to decide on disputes between individuals or corporations, private or public, in every type of process, judgment and execution of judgment. They exercise for the courts and tribunals established by the Constitution and the law

References

  1. Sharon, Jeremy (16 October 2023). "Supreme Court president Hayut retires, hoping for 'better days'". Times of Israel.
  2. "Justice Minister Ramon May Alter Supreme Court Seniority System". Haaretz. Retrieved 2023-02-20.
  3. Kershner, Isabel (2007-11-22). "Friends' Clash Reflects Battle Over Israeli Court". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved 2023-02-20.
  4. "Supreme Court President Naor says annulling seniority method will 'erode public's trust in the justice system'; Justice Minister Shaked: 'Appoint most professional candidate'". Knessed News. Retrieved 2023-02-20.
  5. ToI Staff. "Levin plans to end seniority system for appointing Supreme Court president – report". www.timesofisrael.com. Retrieved 2023-02-20.
  6. "High Court refuses petition against 'Grunis Law'". The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com. Retrieved 2023-02-20.
  7. State of Israel (June 2017). "Response of the State of Israel – Ministry of Justice: Information requested from States parties in relation to integrity in criminal justice institutions (arts. 7, 8 and 11) and education in schools and universities on anti-corruption (art. 13, para. 1 (c)) (Reference: CU 2017/51/DTA/CEB)" (PDF).
  8. "What's A Commission of Inquiry? Explainer". en.idi.org.il. Retrieved 2023-02-20.