Redshift quantization

Last updated

Redshift quantization, also referred to as redshift periodicity, [1] redshift discretization, [2] preferred redshifts [3] and redshift-magnitude bands, [4] [5] is the hypothesis that the redshifts of cosmologically distant objects (in particular galaxies and quasars) tend to cluster around multiples of some particular value.

Contents

In standard inflationary cosmological models, the redshift of cosmological bodies is ascribed to the expansion of the universe, with greater redshift indicating greater cosmic distance from the Earth (see Hubble's Law). This is referred to as cosmological redshift and is one of the main pieces of evidence for the Big Bang. Quantized redshifts of objects would indicate, under Hubble's Law, that astronomical objects are arranged in a quantized pattern around the Earth. It is more widely posited that the redshift is unrelated to cosmic expansion and is the outcome of some other physical mechanism, referred to as "intrinsic redshift" or "non-cosmological redshift".

In 1973, astronomer William G. Tifft was the first to report evidence of this pattern. Subsequent discourse focused upon whether redshift surveys of quasars (QSOs) have produced evidence of quantization in excess of what is expected due to selection effect or galactic clustering. [6] [7] [8] [9] The idea has been on the fringes of astronomy since the mid-1990s and is now discounted by the vast majority of astronomers, but a few scientists who espouse nonstandard cosmological models, including those who reject the Big Bang theory, have referred to evidence of redshift quantization as reason to reject conventional accounts of the origin and evolution of the universe. [10] [11] [12]

Original investigation by William G. Tifft

György Paál (for QSOs, 1971 [13] ) and William G. Tifft (for galaxies) were the first to investigate possible redshift quantization, referring to it as "redshift-magnitude banding correlation". [14] In 1973, he wrote:

"Using more than 200 redshifts in Coma, Perseus, and A2199, the presence of a distinct band-related periodicity in redshifts is indicated. Finally, a new sample of accurate redshifts of bright Coma galaxies on a single band is presented, which shows a strong redshift periodicity of 220 km s−1. An upper limit of 20 km s−1 is placed on the internal Doppler redshift component of motion in the Coma cluster". [15]

Tifft suggested that this observation conflicted with standard cosmological scenarios. He states in summary:

"Throughout the development of the program it has seemed increasingly clear that the redshift has properties inconsistent with a simple velocity and/or cosmic scale change interpretation. Various implications have been pointed out from time to time, but basically the work is observationally driven." [16]

Early research - focused on galaxies rather than quasars

In 1971 from redshift quantization G. Paál came up with the idea that the Universe might have nontrivial topological structure. [17]

Studies performed in the 1980s and early 1990s produced confirmatory results:

  1. In 1989, Martin R. Croasdale reported finding a quantization of redshifts using a different sample of galaxies in increments of 72 km/s or Δz = 2.4×10−4 (where Δz denotes shift in frequency expressed as a proportion of initial frequency). [18]
  2. In 1990, Bruce Guthrie and William Napier reported finding a "possible periodicity" of the same magnitude for a slightly larger data set limited to bright spiral galaxies and excluding other types. [19]
  3. In 1992, Guthrie and Napier proposed the observation of a different periodicity in increments of Δz = 1.24×10−4 in a sample of 89 galaxies. [20]
  4. In 1992, Paal et al. and Holba et al. concluded that there was an unexplained periodicity of redshifts in a reanalysis of a large sample of galaxies. [21] [22]
  5. In 1997, Guthrie and Napier concluded the same:
"So far the redshifts of over 250 galaxies with high-precision HI profiles have been used in the study. In consistently selected sub-samples of the datasets of sufficient precision examined so far, the redshift distribution has been found to be strongly quantized in the galactocentric frame of reference. ... The formal confidence levels associated with these results are extremely high." [23]

Quasar redshifts

Most recent discourse has focused upon whether redshift surveys of quasars (QSOs) produce evidence of quantization beyond that explainable by selection effect. This has been assisted by advances in cataloging in the late 1990s that have increased substantially the sample sizes involved in astronomical measurements.

Karlsson's formula

Historically, K. G. Karlsson and G. R. Burbidge were first to note that quasar redshifts were quantized in accordance with the empirical formula [24] [25]

where:

This predicts periodic redshift peaks at = 0.061, 0.30, 0.60, 0.96, 1.41, and 1.9, observed originally in a sample of 600 quasars, [26] verified in later early studies. [27]

Modern discourse

A 2001 study by Burbidge and Napier found the pattern of periodicity predicted by Karlsson's formula to be present at a high confidence level in three new samples of quasars, concluding that their findings are inexplicable by spectroscopic or similar selection effects. [28]

In 2002, Hawkins et al. found no evidence for redshift quantization in a sample of 1647 galaxy-quasar pairs from the 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey:

"Given that there are almost eight times as many data points in this sample as in the previous analysis by Burbidge & Napier (2001), we must conclude that the previous detection of a periodic signal arose from the combination of noise and the effects of the window function." [29]

In response, Napier and Burbidge (2003) argue that the methods employed by Hawkins et al. to remove noise from their samples amount to "excessive data smoothing" which could hide a true periodicity. They publish an alternate methodology for this that preserves the periodicity observed in earlier studies. [30]

In 2005, Tang and Zhang found no evidence for redshift quantization of quasars in samples from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey and 2dF redshift survey. [9]

Arp et al. (2005) examined sample areas in the 2dF and SDSS surveys in detail, noting that quasar redshifts:

"... fit very closely the long standing Karlsson formula and strongly suggest the existence of preferred values in the distribution of quasar redshifts." [31]

A 2006 study of 46,400 quasars in the SDSS by Bell and McDiarmid discovered 6 peaks in the redshift distribution consistent with the decreasing intrinsic redshift (DIR) model. [7] However, Schneider et al. (2007) and Richards et al. (2006) reported that the periodicity reported by Bell and McDiarmid disappears after correcting for selection effects. [32] [33] Bell and Comeau (2010) concur that selection effects give rise to the apparent redshift peaks, but argue that the correction process removes a large fraction of the data. The authors argue that the "filter gap footprint" renders it impossible to verify or falsify the presence of a true redshift peak at Δz = 0.60. [34]

A 2006 review by Bajan et al. discovered weak effects of redshift periodization in data from the Local Group of galaxies and the Hercules Supercluster. They conclude that "galaxy redshift periodization is an effect which can really exist", but that the evidence is not well established pending study of larger databases. [35]

A 2007 absorption spectroscopic analysis of quasars by Ryabinkov et al. observed a pattern of statistically significant alternating peaks and dips in the redshift range Δz = 0.0 − 3.7, though they noted no statistical correlation between their findings and Karlsson's formula. [36]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quasar</span> Active galactic nucleus containing a supermassive black hole

A quasar is an extremely luminous active galactic nucleus (AGN). It is sometimes known as a quasi-stellar object, abbreviated QSO. The emission from an AGN is powered by a supermassive black hole with a mass ranging from millions to tens of billions of solar masses, surrounded by a gaseous accretion disc. Gas in the disc falling towards the black hole heats up and releases energy in the form of electromagnetic radiation. The radiant energy of quasars is enormous; the most powerful quasars have luminosities thousands of times greater than that of a galaxy such as the Milky Way. Quasars are usually categorized as a subclass of the more general category of AGN. The redshifts of quasars are of cosmological origin.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Redshift</span> Change of wavelength in photons during travel

In physics, a redshift is an increase in the wavelength, and corresponding decrease in the frequency and photon energy, of electromagnetic radiation. The opposite change, a decrease in wavelength and increase in frequency and energy, is known as a blueshift, or negative redshift. The terms derive from the colours red and blue which form the extremes of the visible light spectrum. The main causes of electromagnetic redshift in astronomy and cosmology are the relative motions of radiation sources, which give rise to the relativistic Doppler effect, and gravitational potentials, which gravitationally redshift escaping radiation. All sufficiently distant light sources show cosmological redshift corresponding to recession speeds proportional to their distances from Earth, a fact known as Hubble's law that implies the universe is expanding.

An active galactic nucleus (AGN) is a compact region at the center of a galaxy that emits a significant amount of energy across the electromagnetic spectrum, with characteristics indicating that the luminosity is not produced by stars. Such excess, non-stellar emissions have been observed in the radio, microwave, infrared, optical, ultra-violet, X-ray and gamma ray wavebands. A galaxy hosting an AGN is called an active galaxy. The non-stellar radiation from an AGN is theorized to result from the accretion of matter by a supermassive black hole at the center of its host galaxy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reionization</span> Process that caused matter to reionize early in the history of the Universe

In the fields of Big Bang theory and cosmology, reionization is the process that caused electrically neutral atoms in the universe to reionize after the lapse of the "dark ages".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lyman-alpha forest</span> Astronomical spectroscopic term

In astronomical spectroscopy, the Lyman-alpha forest is a series of absorption lines in the spectra of distant galaxies and quasars arising from the Lyman-alpha electron transition of the neutral hydrogen atom. As the light travels through multiple gas clouds with different redshifts, multiple absorption lines are formed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Halton Arp</span> American astronomer

Halton Christian "Chip" Arp was an American astronomer. He was known for his 1966 book Atlas of Peculiar Galaxies, which documented peculiarities among galaxies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">NGC 5548</span> Type I Seyfert galaxy in the constellation Boötes

NGC 5548 is a Type I Seyfert galaxy with a bright, active nucleus. This activity is caused by matter flowing onto a 65 million solar mass (M☉) supermassive black hole at the core. Morphologically, this is an unbarred lenticular galaxy with tightly-wound spiral arms, while shell and tidal tail features suggest that it has undergone a cosmologically-recent merger or interaction event. NGC 5548 is approximately 245 million light years away and appears in the constellation Boötes. The apparent visual magnitude of NGC 5548 is approximately 13.3 in the V band.

William G. Tifft was an astronomer at the University of Arizona. His main interests were in galaxies, superclusters and redshift quantization. He was influential in the development of the first redshift surveys, and was an early proponent of crewed space astronomy, conducted at a proposed Moon base for example. In retirement, he was a principal scientist with The Scientific Association for the Study of Time in Physics and Cosmology (SASTPC).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">APM 08279+5255</span> Quasar

APM 08279+5255 is a very distant, broad absorption line quasar located in the constellation Lynx. It is magnified and split into multiple images by the gravitational lensing effect of a foreground galaxy through which its light passes. It appears to be a giant elliptical galaxy with a supermassive black hole and associated accretion disk. It possesses large regions of hot dust and molecular gas, as well as regions with starburst activity.

CLASS B1359+154 is a quasar, or quasi-stellar object, that has a redshift of 3.235. A group of three foreground galaxies at a redshift of about 1 are behaving as gravitational lenses. The result is a rare example of a sixfold multiply imaged quasar.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Galaxy filament</span> Largest structures in the universe, made of galaxies

In cosmology, galaxy filaments are the largest known structures in the universe, consisting of walls of galactic superclusters. These massive, thread-like formations can commonly reach 50/h to 80/h Megaparsecs — with the largest found to date being the Hercules-Corona Borealis Great Wall at around 3 gigaparsecs (9.8 Gly) in length — and form the boundaries between voids. Due to the accelerating expansion of the universe, the individual clusters of gravitationally bound galaxies that make up galaxy filaments are moving away from each other at an accelerated rate; in the far future they will dissolve.

The Cloverleaf quasar is a bright, gravitationally lensed quasar.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Steady-state model</span> Model of the universe – alternative to the Big Bang model

In cosmology, the steady-state model or steady state theory is an alternative to the Big Bang theory. In the steady-state model, the density of matter in the expanding universe remains unchanged due to a continuous creation of matter, thus adhering to the perfect cosmological principle, a principle that says that the observable universe is always the same at any time and any place.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">TON 618</span> Quasar and Lyman-alpha blob in the constellation Canes Venatici

TON 618 is a hyperluminous, broad-absorption-line, radio-loud quasar and Lyman-alpha blob located near the border of the constellations Canes Venatici and Coma Berenices, with the projected comoving distance of approximately 18.2 billion light-years from Earth. It possesses one of the most massive black holes ever found, at 40.7 billion M☉.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Georges Meylan</span> Swiss astronomer

Georges Meylan is a Swiss astronomer, born on July 31, 1950, in Lausanne, Switzerland. He was the director of the Laboratory of Astrophysics of the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (EPFL) in Lausanne, Switzerland, and now a professor emeritus of astrophysics and cosmology at EPFL. He is still active in both research and teaching.

References

  1. ↑ Tifft, W. G. (2006). "Redshift periodicities, The Galaxy-Quasar Connection". Astrophysics and Space Science . 285 (2): 429–449. Bibcode:2003Ap&SS.285..429T. doi:10.1023/A:1025457030279. S2CID   120143840.
  2. ↑ Karlsson, K. G. (1970). "Possible Discretization of Quasar Redshifts". Astronomy and Astrophysics . 13: 333. Bibcode:1971A&A....13..333K.
  3. ↑ Arp, H.; Russel, D. (2001). "A Possible Relationship between Quasars and Clusters of Galaxies". Astrophysical Journal . 549 (2): 802. Bibcode:2001ApJ...549..802A. doi: 10.1086/319438 . S2CID   120014695. The clusters and the galaxies in them tend to be strong X-ray and radio emitters, and their redshifts occur at preferred redshift values.
  4. ↑ Tifft, W. G. (1973). "Properties of the redshift-magnitude bands in the Coma cluster". Astrophysical Journal . 179: 29. Bibcode:1973ApJ...179...29T. doi:10.1086/151844.
  5. ↑ Nanni, D.; Pittella, G.; Trevese, D.; Vignato, A. (1981). "An analysis of the redshift-magnitude band phenomenon in the Coma Cluster". Astronomy and Astrophysics . 95 (1): 188. Bibcode:1981A&A....95..188N.
  6. ↑ Trimble, V.; Aschwanden, M. J.; Hansen, C. J. (2007). "Astrophysics in 2006". Space Science Reviews . 132 (1): 1–182. arXiv: 0705.1730 . Bibcode:2007SSRv..132....1T. doi:10.1007/s11214-007-9224-0. S2CID   119570960.
  7. 1 2 Bell, M. B.; McDiarmid, D. (2006). "Six Peaks Visible in the Redshift Distribution of 46,400 SDSS Quasars Agree with the Preferred Redshifts Predicted by the Decreasing Intrinsic Redshift Model". Astrophysical Journal . 648 (1): 140–147. arXiv: astro-ph/0603169 . Bibcode:2006ApJ...648..140B. doi:10.1086/503792. S2CID   17057129.
  8. ↑ Godłowski, W.; Bajan, K.; Flin, P. (2006). "Weak redshift discretisation in the Local Group of galaxies?". Astronomische Nachrichten . 387 (1): 103. arXiv: astro-ph/0511260 . Bibcode:2006AN....327..103G. doi:10.1002/asna.200510477. S2CID   119388085.
  9. 1 2 Tang, S. M.; Zhang, S. N. (2005). "Critical Examinations of QSO Redshift Periodicities and Associations with Galaxies in Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data". Astrophysical Journal . 633 (1): 41–51. arXiv: astro-ph/0506366 . Bibcode:2005ApJ...633...41T. doi:10.1086/432754. S2CID   119052857.
  10. ↑ For examples, see references by nonstandard cosmology proponents
  11. ↑ Arp, H. (1998). "Quantization of Redshifts". Seeing Red. ISBN   978-0-9683689-0-9. Archived from the original on 2006-10-20.
  12. ↑ Arp, H. (1987). "Additional members of the Local Group of galaxies and quantized redshifts within the two nearest groups". Journal of Astrophysics and Astronomy. 8 (3): 241–255. Bibcode:1987JApA....8..241A. doi:10.1007/BF02715046. S2CID   119819755.
  13. ↑ Paál, G. (1971). "The global structure of the universe and the distribution of quasi-stellar objects". Acta Physica Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae . 30: 51–54. Bibcode:1971AcPhH..30...51P. doi:10.1007/bf03157173. S2CID   118710050.
  14. ↑ Tifft, W. G. (1980). "Periodicity in the redshift intervals for double galaxies". Astrophysical Journal . 236: 70. Bibcode:1980ApJ...236...70T. doi:10.1086/157719.
  15. ↑ Tifft, W. G. (1974). Shakeshaft, J. R (ed.). "Fine Structure Within the Redshift-Magnitude Correlation for Galaxies". Proceedings of the 58th IAU Symposium: The Formation and Dynamics of Galaxies. 58: 255–256. Bibcode:1974IAUS...58..243T.
  16. ↑ Tifft, W .G. (1995). "Redshift Quantization - A Review". Astrophysics and Space Science . 227 (1–2): 25–39. Bibcode:1995Ap&SS.227...25T. doi:10.1007/BF00678064. S2CID   189849264.
  17. ↑ Paál, G. (1971). "The global structure of the universe and the distribution of quasi-stellar objects". Acta Physica Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae . 30: 51–54. Bibcode:1971AcPhH..30...51P. doi:10.1007/bf03157173. S2CID   118710050.
  18. ↑ Croasdale, Martin R. (1989). "Periodicities in galaxy redshifts". The Astrophysical Journal. 345: 72. Bibcode:1989ApJ...345...72C. doi: 10.1086/167882 .
  19. ↑ Guthrie, B. N. G.; Napier, W. M. (1990). "The Virgo cluster as a test for quantization of extragalactic redshifts". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 243: 431–442. Bibcode:1990MNRAS.243..431G.
  20. ↑ Guthrie, B. N. G.; Napier, W. M. (1991). "Evidence for redshift periodicity in nearby field galaxies". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 253 (3): 533–544. Bibcode:1991MNRAS.253..533G. doi: 10.1093/mnras/253.3.533 .
  21. ↑ Paal, G. (1992). "Inflation and compactification from Galaxy redshifts?". Astrophysics and Space Science. 191 (1): 107–124. Bibcode:1992Ap&SS.191..107P. doi:10.1007/BF00644200. S2CID   116951785.
  22. ↑ Holba, Ágnes (1992). "Cosmological parameters and redshift periodicity". Astrophysics and Space Science. 198 (1): 111–120. Bibcode:1992Ap&SS.198..111H. doi:10.1007/BF00644305. S2CID   118806486. See also reference to Broadhurst, T. J. (1990). "Large-scale distribution of galaxies at the Galactic poles". Nature. 343 (6260): 726–728. Bibcode:1990Natur.343..726B. doi:10.1038/343726a0. S2CID   4356867.
  23. ↑ Napier, W. Μ.; B. N. G. Guthrie (1997). "Quantized Redshifts: A Status Report" (PDF). J. Astrophys. Astron. 18 (4): 455–463. Bibcode:1997JApA...18..455N. doi:10.1007/BF02709337. S2CID   73557034.
  24. ↑ Burbidge, G (1968). "The Distribution of Redshifts in Quasi-Stellar Objects, N-Systems and Some Radio and Compact Galaxies". Astrophysical Journal . 154: L41–L48. Bibcode:1968ApJ...154L..41B. doi: 10.1086/180265 .
  25. ↑ Karlsson, K. G. (1990). "Quasar redshifts and nearby galaxies". Astron Astrophys. 239: 50. Bibcode:1990A&A...239...50K.
  26. ↑ Burbidge, G. (1978). "The line-locking hypothesis, absorption by intervening galaxies, and the Z = 1.95 peak in redshifts". Physica Scripta. 17 (3): 237–241. Bibcode:1978PhyS...17..237B. doi:10.1088/0031-8949/17/3/017. S2CID   250841536.
  27. ↑ Holba, Ágnes (1994). "Once more on quasar periodicities". Astrophysics and Space Science. 222 (1–2): 65–83. Bibcode:1994Ap&SS.222...65H. doi:10.1007/BF00627083. S2CID   118379051.
  28. ↑ Burbidge, G. (2001). "The Distribution of Redshifts in New Samples of Quasi-stellar Objects". Astronomical Journal. 121 (1): 21–30. arXiv: astro-ph/0008026 . Bibcode:2001AJ....121...21B. doi:10.1086/318018. S2CID   15751692.
  29. ↑ Hawkins; Maddox; Merrifield (2002). "No Periodicities in 2dF Redshift Survey Data". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 336 (13): L13–L16. arXiv: astro-ph/0208117 . Bibcode:2002MNRAS.336L..13H. doi:10.1046/j.1365-8711.2002.05940.x. S2CID   6832490.
  30. ↑ Napier, W. M.; Burbidge, G. R. (2003). "The detection of periodicity in QSO data sets". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 342 (2): 601–604. Bibcode:2003MNRAS.342..601N. doi:10.1046/j.1365-8711.2003.06567.x.
  31. ↑ Arp, H.; Fulton, C.; Roscoe, D. (2005). "Periodicities of Quasar Redshifts in Large Area Surveys". arXiv: astro-ph/0501090 . Bibcode:2005astro.ph..1090A.{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  32. ↑ Schneider; et al. (2007). "The Sloan Digital Sky Survey Quasar Catalog. IV. Fifth Data Release". The Astronomical Journal. 134 (1): 102–117. arXiv: 0704.0806 . Bibcode:2007AJ....134..102S. doi:10.1086/518474. S2CID   14359163.
  33. ↑ Richards, G. T.; et al. (2006). "The Sloan Digital Sky Survey Quasar Survey: Quasar Luminosity Function from Data Release 3". The Astronomical Journal. 131 (6): 2766–2787. arXiv: astro-ph/0601434 . Bibcode:2006AJ....131.2766R. doi:10.1086/503559. S2CID   55346862.
  34. ↑ Bell, M. B.; Comeau, S. P. (2010). "Selection Effects in the SDSS Quasar Sample: The Filter Gap Footprint". Astrophys Space Sci. 326 (1): 11–17. arXiv: 0911.5700 . Bibcode:2010Ap&SS.326...11B. doi:10.1007/s10509-009-0232-2. S2CID   118655062.
  35. ↑ Bajan, K.; Flin, P.; Godlowski, W.; Pervushin, V. N. (2007). "On the Investigations of Galaxy Redshift Periodicity". Physics of Particles and Nuclei Letters. 4 (1): 5–10. arXiv: astro-ph/0606294 . Bibcode:2007PPNL....4....5B. doi:10.1134/s1547477107010025. S2CID   15364493.
  36. ↑ Ryabinkov, A. I.; Kaminker, A. D.; Varshalovich, D. A. (2007). "The redshift distribution of absorption-line systems in QSO spectra". Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 376 (4): 1838–18481. arXiv: astro-ph/0703277 . Bibcode:2007MNRAS.376.1838R. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2007.11567.x. S2CID   16270925.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.