Roger's Frigate

Last updated
Roger's Frigate
Roger's Frigate
Restaurant information
Location99 Main St A, Port Jefferson, New York, United States
Coordinates 40°56′49″N73°04′08″W / 40.9469°N 73.0689°W / 40.9469; -73.0689

The Roger's Frigate, also known as the Port Jefferson Frigate, is a candy shop owned by George Wallis that is in Port Jefferson, New York. [1] [2]

History

Sometime in the 1990s, George Wallis bought the Roger's Frigate. [3]

In 2002, Wallis replaced a statue of Thomas Jefferson with a statue of an eagle meant to honor victims of the 9/11 attacks. Jeanne Garant, Felix J. Grucci Jr., Robert J. Gaffney, and Charles Lefkowitz were at the statue's unveiling. [3]

In 2017, the Roger' Frigate was the subject of criticism for hanging a banner that said, "In Trump We Trust". Around two dozen people called to complain. The shop previously hung a banner that just said "Trump", which they were issued a summons for. The shop received a second summons due to the "In Trump We Trust" sign, in which section 250-31D(2)(iv) of the village code was cited. [2] [4] [1] Roger Rutherford, the store's general manager at the time responded by stating that the business's “free speech rights have been targeted.” [4]

In 2020, Roger's Frigate rehung the "In Trump We Trust" sign in support of Trump during his impeachment trial. Rutherford argued that the town was using a double standard when enforcing the regulation, with the store being targeted for its political beliefs. While Margot Garant, Port Jefferson's mayor, argued the reason is apolitical and just about having a uniform look. [5] Rutherford also said that the sign was beneficial to their business, saying, "People are coming by taking pictures, love the sign and all in support of our president." [6] Roger's Frigate eventually conceded and removed the sign, but put it back up 4 years later. [7] [8]

Later in that same year, Roger's Frigate put up a sign that said "Impeach Cuomo", referring to then New York Governor Andrew Cuomo. The shop was protesting Cuomo's orders to shut down businesses. Officials of the city responded by saying the sign was illegal. In response to the officials, Rutherford said Roger's Frigate wasn't going to get a permit because the city objected his political views. [9] Judge Tara Higgins later ruled that Roger Frigate's right to freedom of speech outweighed the village sign ordinance. [10]

References

  1. 1 2 Petroski, Alex (2017-01-24). "Port Jeff candy store in middle of political debate". TBR News Media. Retrieved 2025-09-24.
  2. 1 2 Christian, Carol (January 24, 2017). "Reaction to Trump banner on Long Island candy shop lasts longer than sign". Houston Chronicle. Retrieved 2025-09-26.
  3. 1 2 Fischler, Marcelle (2002-06-30). "Long Island Journal; Tug of War Over a Monument". New York Times. Retrieved 2025-09-26.
  4. 1 2 Uda, Rachel (January 23, 2017). "Port Jefferson ice cream shop's Trump sign stirs residents". Newsday. Archived from the original on October 8, 2017. Retrieved September 26, 2025.
  5. Armus, Teo (2020-01-31). "'In Trump We Trust': Ice cream shop resists town orders to take down its impeachment banner". The Washington Post. ISSN   0190-8286 . Retrieved 2025-09-24.
  6. Sager, Stacey (2020-01-30). "Large Trump banner outside Long Island ice cream shop sparks controversy". ABC7 New York. Retrieved 2025-09-24.
  7. Deese, Kaelan (2020-01-31). "Long Island ice cream shop removes pro-Trump sign after tussle with town". The Hill. Retrieved 2025-09-24.
  8. Hallarman, Lynn (July 29, 2024). "Divisive political banner is back up in Port Jeff, challenging the village's sign code enforcement". TBR News Media. Retrieved 2025-09-24.
  9. Allen, J. D. (2020-06-02). "'Impeach Cuomo' Sign Violates Village Code, Officials Say". WSHU. Retrieved 2025-09-24.
  10. MacGowan, Carl (2022-08-11). "Ruling sides with owner who hung pro-Trump signs at Port Jefferson ice cream shop". Newsday. Retrieved 2025-09-24.