Sami Ullah Baloch v. Abdul Karim Nousherwani

Last updated

Hussein Baloch v. Abdul shoaib Nousherwani
Emblem of the Supreme Court of Pakistan.svg
Court Supreme Court of Pakistan
Full case nameSami Ullah Baloch Vs. Abdul Karim Nousherwani & others
DecidedApril 13, 2018;5 years ago (2018-04-13)
Citation(s) C.A. No. 233 of 2015
Ruling
Failing to meet qualifications under Article 62(1)(f) of the Constitution imposes a permanent bar which remains in effect as long as the declaratory judgment supporting the conclusion of lack of qualification remains in effect.
Court membership
Judges sittingChief Justice
Mian Saqib Nisar Justices
Sh. Azmat Saeed
Umar Ata Bandial
Ijaz ul Ahsan
Sajjad Ali Shah
Case opinions
Majority Umar Ata Bandial, joined by Mian Saqib Nisar, Ijaz-ul-Ahsan, Sajjad Ali Shah
ConcurrenceSh. Azmat Saeed
Laws applied
Article 62(1)(f) of the Constitution of Pakistan

Sami Ullah Baloch v. Abdul Karim Nousherwani is an overturned decision of the Supreme Court of Pakistan in which the Court unanimously held that electoral disqualification under Article 62(1)(f) of the Constitution of Pakistan was for life. The ruling barred former Prime Minister of Pakistan Nawaz Sharif from holding public office indefinitely, following his disqualification in the Panama Papers case in 2017. [1] It is also noted as the last case conducted by human rights lawyer Asma Jahangir before her death. [2]

Contents

The decision was controversial when announced, and remains the subject of widespread discussion. [3]

Background

The Supreme Court had previously disqualified the incumbent Prime Minister of Pakistan, Nawaz Sharif, from holding public office in the Panama Papers case in 2017, citing Article 62(1)(f) of the Constitution. [1] It subsequently removed Sharif as president of the ruling Pakistan Muslim League (N) in a separate decision, wherein the Court ruled that a person disqualified under Article 62 and 63 could not head a political party. All decisions taken by Sharif as PML-N's president resultantly stood null and void. [4]

The Court had also disqualified Jahangir Khan Tareen, general secretary of the opposition Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf, under the same article.

Before the Supreme Court of Pakistan

17 appeals and petitions by former officeholders challenging the length of disqualification under Article 62(1)(f) were fixed before the Supreme Court, which appointed senior counsels Munir A. Malik and Ali Zafar as amicii curiae .

It would be the last Supreme Court case argued by human rights lawyer Asma Jahangir, who appeared for former Member of the National Assembly Rai Hassan Nawaz. Jahangir argued that there should not be a constant period of disqualification, but courts should decide the question according to the conduct of individuals. She said the Supreme Court had held Nawaz Sharif eligible to contest elections in 2009 by deeming him sadiq and ameen, but now it was difficult to understand whether the court had increased the bar of honesty or reduced it. [5] Jahangir died of cardiac arrest a week after her arguments concluded. [2]

Attorney-General for Pakistan Ashtar Ausaf Ali told the bench that it was not the function of the courts to provide a timeline for disqualification under Article 62(1)(f), and that the question should be best left for parliament to decide.

Majority opinion

The majority opinion was authored by Justice Umar Ata Bandial, and was joined by Chief Justice Mian Saqib Nisar and Justices Ijazul Ahsan and Sajjad Ali Shah. Justice Bandial held that the judicial mechanism in Article 62(1)(f) granted a fair opportunity for relief to a candidate under challenge to vindicate himself, ruling, '"In the result, we are inclined to hold that the incapacity created for failing to meet the qualifications under Article 62 (1)(f) of the Constitution imposes a permanent bar which remains in effect so long as the declaratory judgment supporting the conclusion of one of the delinquent kinds of conduct under Article 62 (1)(f) of the Constitution remains in effect." [6]

The judgment noted that the prescription by the Eighteenth Amendment of an adverse judicial declaration to precipitate the ineligibility of a candidate for election provided a lawful, transparent and fair mechanism to a candidate under challenge both for contesting and for avoiding the onset of an embargo on his eligibility to contest elections. [7] The Court directed that all 17 appeals and petitions challenging the length of disqualification under Article 62(1)(f) for possessing fake degrees be fixed before appropriate benches "for decision in accordance with the law laid down in this judgment, keeping in view the respective facts and circumstances of each case."

Concurrence

"None of the learned counsels refuted the aforesaid obvious interpretation but only sidestepped the issue. However, at the very end, the learned Attorney General for Pakistan addressed the Court and in no uncertain terms stated that once declaration has been made by a Court of Law that a person is not sagacious or righteous or non-profligate or honest and ameen, such a person is not qualified to be a Member of Majlis-e-Shoora (Parliament)...The stand taken by the learned Attorney General for Pakistan is not only fair but is also in accordance with the obvious and self-evident intent of Article 62(1)(f) of the Constitution."

Justice Azmat [8]

Justice Sheikh Azmat Saeed authored a concurrence to the majority opinion, but disagreed with its reasoning. [9] He observed that while a period of disqualification was specified in certain sub-articles of Article 63 of the Constitution, no such sunset clause was found in Article 62(1)(f), as the framers of the Constitution chose not to do so.

Addressing the concern by some counsels of the petitioners that the lifetime ban resulting from Article 62 (1)(f) "may be disproportionate and a little harsh", Justice Saeed maintained that such arguments were more suitable to be made in parliament, rather than before the Court. "This aspect of the matter is rather ironic as several persons before us were or had been the Members of Majlis-e-Shoora (Parliament) at some point of time and may have passed the amendments, which now stand in their way," he wrote. "We [...] can only interpret the Constitution, not amend or change it."

He agreed with the Attorney-General's view that it was for the legislature to prescribe a time limit for electoral disqualification.

Reactions

Minister of State for Information and Broadcasting Marriyum Aurangzeb addressed a press conference shortly after the verdict, saying, "As long as Nawaz Sharif lives in the hearts of the people, this disqualification will hold no meaning. Pakistan's civil society, public and media is now awake and everyone can see what is happening, and the reasons behind it. The slogan of 'minus-one' is being raised once again." She termed the decision a "joke" and "conspiracy". [10]

PTI leader Jahangir Tareen distinguished his fate from Sharif's, stating that the review he filed against his disqualification was still pending before the Supreme Court.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pakistan Muslim League (N)</span> Conservative political party in Pakistan

The Pakistan Muslim League (Nawaz) (Urdu: پاکستان مسلم لیگ (ن), abbr.PML(N) or PML-N) is a centre-right, conservative liberal political party in Pakistan. It is currently the third-largest party in the Senate. The party was founded in 1993, when a number of prominent conservative politicians in the country joined hands after the dissolution of Islamic Democratic Alliance, under the leadership of former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif. The party's platform is generally conservative, which involves supporting free markets, deregulation, lower taxes and private ownership. Although the party historically supported social conservatism, in recent years, the party's political ideology and platform has become more liberal on social and cultural issues; however, members have been accused of using Islamist populist rhetoric. Alongside the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) and Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), it is one of the three major political parties of the country.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prime Minister of Pakistan</span> Leader of the executive branch of the Government of Pakistan

The prime minister of Pakistan is the head of government of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. Executive authority is vested in the prime minister and his chosen cabinet, despite the president of Pakistan serving as the nominal head of executive. The prime minister is often the leader of the party or the coalition with a majority in the lower house of the Parliament of Pakistan, the National Assembly where he serves as Leader of the House. Prime minister holds office by virtue of their ability to command the confidence of the National Assembly. The prime minister is designated as the "Chief Executive of the Islamic Republic".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Supreme Court of Pakistan</span> Highest authority court of Pakistan

The Supreme Court of Pakistan is the apex court in the judicial hierarchy of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Asma Jahangir</span> Pakistani human rights activist and lawyer

Asma Jilani Jahangir was a Pakistani human rights lawyer and social activist who co-founded and chaired the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan and AGHS Legal Aid Cell. Jahangir was known for playing a prominent role in the Lawyers' Movement and served as the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief and as a trustee at the International Crisis Group.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1999 Pakistani coup d'état</span> 1999 military takeover of government in Pakistan

The 1999 military takeover in Pakistan was a bloodless coup d'état initiated by the military staff at the Joint Staff HQ working under the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee and Chief of Army Staff General Pervez Musharraf. The instigators seized control of the civilian government of the publicly elected Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif on 12 October 1999. On 14 October, General Musharraf, acting as the country's Chief Executive, issued a controversial provisional order that suspended the Constitution of Pakistan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2007 Pakistani state of emergency</span> 2007 political crisis in Pakistan

A state of emergency was declared by President of Pakistan Pervez Musharraf on 3 November 2007 which lasted until 15 December 2007, during which the Constitution of Pakistan of was suspended. When the state of emergency was declared, Musharraf controversially held both positions of President and Chief of Army Staff. He later resigned as army chief 25 days into the emergency on 28 November. The state of emergency and its responses are generally attributed to the controversies surrounding the re-election of Musharraf during the presidential election on 6 October 2007, including his holding of both offices of President and Chief of Army Staff at the time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Khawaja Asif</span> Pakistani politician

Khawaja Muhammad Asif is a Pakistani politician who served as the Defence Minister of Pakistan from April 2022 till August 2023. He had also been a member of the National Assembly of Pakistan from August 2018 till August 2023. Previously, he was a member of the National Assembly from 1993 to 1999 and again from 2002 to 2018 and till date. In May, 2019 he took the charge and became the Parliamentary Leader of PML-N in the National Assembly of Pakistan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rai Hassan Nawaz</span> Pakistani politician

Rai Hassan Nawaz is a Pakistani politician who was a member of the National Assembly of Pakistan between 2013 and 2015. Previously, he served three terms on the Punjab Assembly, from 1988 to 1990, 1990 to 1993, and 1997 to 1999.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lawyers' Movement</span> 2007 mass protest movement in Pakistan

The Lawyers' Movement, also known as the Movement for the Restoration of Judiciary or the Black Coat Protests, was the popular mass protest movement initiated by the lawyers of Pakistan in response to the former president and army chief Pervez Musharraf's actions of 9 March 2007 when he unconstitutionally suspended Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry as the chief justice of Pakistan's Supreme Court. Following the suspension of the chief justice, the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) declared the judge's removal as an "assault on the independence of judiciary" and was backed by several political parties.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">PCO Judges case</span>

The Provisional Constitutional Order Judges case, refers to cases heard and decided by the Pakistan Supreme Court pertaining to the High Court and Supreme Court judges who took their oath of offices under the Provisional Constitutional Order in 2007. On 3 November 2007, then-President Pervez Musharraf declared a Provisional Constitutional Order, which declared a state of emergency and suspends the Constitution of Pakistan. Under this emergency law, all High court judges, including the Supreme Court justices, were asked to take oath under this Provisional Constitutional Order. Those who didn't were placed under effective house arrest. A seven-member bench issued a restraining order on the same day, barring the government from implementing emergency rule and urging other government officials to not help do so.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jahangir Tareen</span> Pakistani politician

Jahangir Khan Tareen is a Pakistani businessman and former politician who is the majority shareholder and CEO of JDW Group, a conglomerate specializing in the manufacturing and sale of sugar and associated products, power generation, transmission and sales, sugar cane farms, and aircraft operations and maintenance services. Jahangir Tareen is also the chairman and owner of JK Group, a conglomerate specializing in manufacturing and sale of sugar and associated products, milk production, processing and sales, power generation, transmission and sales, production and sales of fruits and agricultural produce, granite mining and sales, PepsiCo Multan franchise and PSL Multan Sultans' franchise. Khan has been a member of the National Assembly of Pakistan thrice between 2002 and 2017. Born in Comilla, Tareen was educated at the Forman Christian College in Lahore, and later attended the University of North Carolina. Prior to entering politics, he had been a lecturer and banker.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Maryam Nawaz</span> Pakistani politician (born 1973)

Maryam Nawaz Sharif is a Pakistani politician, currently serving as the Chief Minister of Punjab. She is the first woman to become Chief Minister of any province of Pakistan. She is the daughter of former Prime Minister of Pakistan Nawaz Sharif and was initially involved in the family's philanthropic organisations. However, in 2012, she entered politics and was put in charge of the election campaign during the 2013 general elections. In 2013, she was appointed the Chairperson of the Prime Minister's Youth Programme. However, she resigned in 2014 after her appointment was challenged in the Lahore High Court.

Qazi Faez Isa is a Pakistani jurist who is currently serving as the 29th Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) since 17 September 2023. He was appointed as a justice of the Supreme Court in 2014, having previously served as the chief justice of Balochistan High Court from 2009 to 2014.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2018 Pakistani general election</span>

General elections were held in Pakistan on 25 July 2018 to elect the members of the 15th National Assembly and the four Provincial Assemblies. The three major parties were Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), led by Imran Khan, the Pakistan Muslim League, led by Shehbaz Sharif, and the Pakistan People's Party, led by Bilawal Bhutto. The PTI won the most seats in the National Assembly but fell short of a majority; the party subsequently formed a coalition government with several smaller parties. At the provincial level, the PTI remained the largest party in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP); the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) retained its dominance in Sindh; and the newly formed Balochistan Awami Party (BAP) emerged as the largest party in Balochistan. In Punjab, the result was a hung parliament, with the Pakistan Muslim League (N) winning the most seats. However, after several independent MPAs joined the PTI, the latter became the largest party and was able to form a government.

<i>Said Zaman Khan v. Federation of Pakistan</i>

Said Zaman Khan v. Federation of Pakistan is a landmark decision in which the Supreme Court of Pakistan upheld death sentences against sixteen terrorists convicted by military courts in 2016. The accused included members of militant groups Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan and al-Qaeda, as well as suspects involved in the Peshawar school massacre in 2014, the Bannu jailbreak in 2012, and the Rawalpindi Parade Lane bombing in 2009. The decision marked the first time the Court ruled on the legality of military trials, legalized for civilian terror suspects after the school massacre.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Asif Saeed Khosa</span> 26th Chief Justice of Pakistan in 2019 (born 1954)

Asif Saeed Khan Khosa is a Pakistani jurist who served as the 26th Chief Justice of Pakistan from 18 January 2019 to 20 December 2019. He joined the Supreme Court as a judge on 18 February 2010 and prior to that served as judge of the Lahore High Court.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Panama Papers case</span> 2017 Pakistan Supreme Court case

The Panama Papers case, or the Panamagate case, was a 2017 landmark decision by the Supreme Court of Pakistan that disqualified Nawaz Sharif, the prime minister of Pakistan, from holding public office for life.

Umar Ata Bandial is a Pakistani jurist who served as the 28th Chief Justice of Pakistan from February 2022 to September 2023. He was appointed as the Chief Justice after the approval by President Arif Alvi on 13 January 2022, after which he assumed his office on 2 February 2022 and retired on 16 September 2023.

The Federation of Pakistan v. General (R) Pervez Musharraf, informally known as the Musharraf high treason case, was a court case, in which General Pervez Musharraf who acted in the capacity as chief of army staff, tried for high treason stemming from his imposing of unconstitutional state of emergency on 3 November 2007. In this act, Gen. Musharraf, who was also elected as President of Pakistan, subverted and suspended the writ of the Constitution of Pakistan, dismissing the fifteen justices of the Supreme Court of Pakistan and the fifty-six judges of the provincial High Courts while issuing arrest orders to Chief Justice of Pakistan.

References

  1. 1 2 Bhatti, Haseeb. "Nawaz Sharif steps down as PM after SC's disqualification verdict". Dawn. Dawn Group. Retrieved 18 April 2018.
  2. 1 2 Malik, Hasnaat (11 February 2018). "Heart of Gold: the Asma Jahangir Few Knew". Express Tribune. Express Group. Retrieved 18 April 2018.
  3. ↑ Bhatti, Haseeb (13 April 2018). "Disqualification under Article 62 (1)(f) is for life, SC rules in historic verdict". Daqn. Retrieved 19 April 2018.
  4. ↑ Web Desk. "SC to announce verdict in disqualification duration case". Dunya News. Retrieved 18 April 2018.
  5. ↑ Staff Reporter. "SC must not hear cases involving political questions: Asma". Dawn. Dawn Group. Retrieved 18 April 2018.
  6. ↑ Bandial, Umar Ata. "Detailed verdict in Sami Ullah case" (PDF). Supreme Court of Pakistan. Retrieved 18 April 2018.
  7. ↑ Malik, Hasnaat (13 April 2018). "Disqualification for life". Express Tribune. Express Group. Retrieved 19 April 2018.
  8. ↑ Bandial, Umar Ata. "Detailed verdict in Sami Ullah case" (PDF). Supreme Court of Pakistan. Retrieved 18 April 2018.
  9. ↑ Web Desk (13 April 2018). "Additional note of Justice Sh Azmat Saeed in disqualification verdict". The News. Jang Group. Retrieved 19 April 2018.
  10. ↑ Dawn.com (13 April 2018). "PML-N terms SC verdict on lifetime disqualification a 'joke, conspiracy'". Dawn. Dawn Group. Retrieved 19 April 2018.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.