Reviews and critical response
OFF-BROADWAY
“BREATHTAKING! Based on the riveting true story adapted from This American Life, the production’s trip to the stage has only deepened it.” [15]
- The New York Times
“DON’T MISS Stalking the Bogeyman. A dynamic play of sobering substance. Well-written and sensitively acted. Potent stuff that never soft soaps the issues and leaves you stunned. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED." [16]
- Rex Reed, New York Observer
“One of the most powerful and gripping pieces of theatre you will find anywhere in New York. RUN & SEE IT! Given the subject matter and thought-‐provoking performances, STALKING THE BOGEYMAN is going to engage you well beyond the final blackout. This isn’t an easy play to forget.” [17]
‐ BroadwayBox.com
“Potter’s stark, unforgiving staging and matter-‐of-‐fact design.” [18]
‐ Talkin’ Broadway
“The successful dramatization owes as much to Markus Potter’s effective narrative structure as to its thoughtful staging, design and excellent ensemble.” [19]
‐ The Broadway Blog
“Careful and cogent direction by Markus Potter.” [20]
‐ Huffington Post
“Markus Potter has created a production that is impeccable in its stagecraft.” [21]
‐ New York Theater
“A shattering true story – and as adapted and directed by Markus Potter the effect is viscerally powerful.” [22]
‐ Northern Valley Suburbanite / NJ.com
“Consistently precise blocking, effective narrative structure, and thoughtful staging from Markus Potter.” [23]
‐ The Broadway Blog
“This is a fascinating study of human understanding, compassion, and grace. Issues of sexual molestation and abuse have long been topics for movies of the week and television crime dramas, but watching this story unfold on stage brings a visceral permanence to an awkward and uncomfortable topic. Kudos to adaptor and director Markus Potter for handling such a delicate matter with dramatic strength and truth." [24]
‐ Manhattan Digest
“Good theater boils down to one thing: a great story, told well. STALKING THE BOGEYMAN adapted and directed by Markus Potter is a gripping tale based on the true story of David Holthouse.” [25]
‐ Broadway.com
“A successful dramatization with effective narrative, thoughtful staging, and excellent ensemble.” [23]
‐ The Broadway Blog
“Brave storytelling of a delicate subject – something you don’t see often in the theatrical world. Each second of this new play directed by Markus Potter is an exciting revelation.” [26]
‐ NY Theater Now
“A fast-‐paced powerful new play directed by Markus Potter that keeps you on the edge of your seat. Definitely a play I will think above for a long time.” [26]
‐ David Lally, NY Theater Now
“Nakedly honest. Stalking the Bogeyman stands on its own engaging integrity even before you add in that it’s based on a true story. It’s something for everyone to explore – and they will proceed to process it in their minds for a long time.” [27]
‐ Metro
“Could not be better! A highly important play that demands to be seen.” [22]
‐ Northern Valley Suburbanite / NJ.com
“Important theater does more than entertain, and some stories, like this one left me breathless. ..Intimate, Deeply Compelling, & Powerful.” [28]
‐ Flavorpill
LONDON REVIEWS
What's On Stage ★★★★ "Authentic and searing new drama. Skilfully woven together and expertly played." [29]
The Reviews Hub ★★★★ "A taughtly told story of catharsis and revenge." "Unnerving energy with great performances" "Presented excellently with great depth". [30]
London Theatre ★★★★ "Markus Potter and David Holthouse's gripping and harrowing drama Stalking The Bogeyman does just this. Necessary and thought-provoking drama.Markus Potter's careful delivery and spirited direction absorbs the audience and has each of the characters emerge from the auditorium to join the space in the frankest way possible. On a multi-functional playing space, he moves location effortlessly, balancing the realism within the text against an immersive expressionistic set that merges David's childhood bedroom and memories with his efforts to 'stalk' the bogeyman in order to find some solace." [31]
BBC Radio ★★★★ "EXTRAORDINARY. The best piece of theatre I've seen in years. Beautifully constructed, highly recommended."
Sunday Times ★★★★ “Brave and unflinching, Intense and tightly executed. A challenging and thought-provoking piece of theatre that needs to be told."
The upcoming ★★★★ "It keeps the audience on the edge of their seats. It is a play that needs to be seen, a story that needs to be heard." [32]
Evening Standard ★★★★ "An Eloquent production. Potter’s unflinching vision makes for deliberately uncomfortable viewing." [33]
Jonathan Baz Reviews ★★★★ Stalking The Bogeyman - Review "Stalking The Bogeyman is a brave and challenging play. Well-crafted writing and performance, cleverly staged." [34]
Plays to See ★★★★ "A well-written and cleverly paced play…Powerful and precise. Thought provoking and witty piece with superb production values. A redemptive story." [35]
British Theatre Guide ★★★★ "Well constructed and very moving." "Gripping staging" "Stunning performances" [36]
Boyz Magazine ★★★★ "Powerful riveting drama with twists and turns that the audience never sees coming, mainly because they are so staggeringly truthful. One of the most important plays you’re likely to see this year" [37]
London News Online ★★★★ "A play that demands to be seen. Grippingly intense. Astonishing performances…Ultimately this is an incredibly important play – brutal and honest but with a message of hope." [38]
West End Wilma: ★★★★ "This is an intense and heartbreaking production, sensitively directed by Markus Potter, and performed by an outstanding cast." [39]
Survivors Manchester: ★★★★ "The most beautifully inspiring experience In the theatre I have ever had." "Markus Potter and David Holthouse have produced something that is more than a script, more than a play. They have produced an access point for the world to understand the true reality of being a male survivor, and intricacies and complexities of living with the biggest secret one can ever have". [40]
AUSTRALIA
"This is theatre on a knife edge, with infinite micro-decisions by the writers contributing to its urgency as it lifts a scab and allows us to peer at a wound most of us could barely imagine." - Sydney Morning Herald [41]
"Graeme McRae delivers an outstanding performance. It is an incredibly important story that needs to be heard." - BroadwayWorld [42]
"When theatre bites down hard on a subject like this you, too, are caught in its teeth." - The Sydney Morning Herald [41]
“…this is gut punch theatre by stealth…Stalking The Bogeyman is an important, relevant story to tell. Unfortunately, not a rare story….But the truth telling mustn’t stop and at this time, in this intimate space, with this cast, this production bears witness with humanity and authority. – Sydney Arts Guide [43]
A very involving piece of theatre that leaves you thinking and feeling a little raw from the sexual trauma that so many in our society experience. Played with heartfelt naturalism and honesty by Graeme McRae, this is the true story of David Holthouse. Stalking the Bogeyman is told in such a way that you are responding moment by moment to the life of David in his reliving of the experience and him trying to come to terms with his abuse. We the audience feel his horror, his fear, his wanting it to all go away, his awareness of other bogeymen in society, his desire for revenge, his desire to self-destruct, and his secrecy of the rape to the people closest in his life in order to protect them. – The Buzz from Sydney [44]
Holthouse, alongside playwright Markus Potter, has created a complex, compelling piece of storytelling that could so easily have been one-dimensional and all about revenge. But there are so many other important layers to the script. They have managed to articulate all of the conflicting emotions of betrayal, pain, revenge and fear in a distinctly human way. – Theatre Now [45]
It is an engaging production, keeping things concise and clear. Ideas in Stalking The Bogeyman are simple, and powerfully conveyed on this stage. Leading man Graeme McRae’s vulnerability as David is a vital component, that preserves our empathy comprehensively, through every step of the proceedings. The eponymous bogeyman is played by Radek Jonak, whose portrayal of malevolence is as impressive as the electrifying energy he introduces with each appearance. – Suzy Go See [46]
Stalking the Bogeyman is a gripping story that is both stomach-turning and shocking as it is hard to fathom that this not just a playwright's imagination but is a real story. The work retains the truth and honesty without overacting so that the impact of the work is fully felt, and the weight of the content is clear. It is an incredibly important story that needs to be heard so that people protect the innocent.. – Broadway World [42]
What you get in Stalking the Bogeyman is the raw emotion imparted from the victim… It’s a very moving, very personal and powerful account and Graeme McRae as a wounded but empathetic David holds our attention from that opening line to the very last line. The ensemble cast are uniformly excellent and the whole production, is tight and compelling. This is a difficult story and a confronting production with a subtle approach to trauma and masculinity that I haven’t seen on a Sydney stage before. – Night Writes [47]
NORTH CAROLINA
Critical reception for the North Carolina performance was positive and the Citizen-Times praised the play's cast. [48] [49]
