State Library Victoria Teen Writing Bootcamp controversy

Last updated

The State Library Victoria, pictured in 2005. State Library of Victoria - right side.jpg
The State Library Victoria, pictured in 2005.

Six writers - Alison Evans, Amie Kaufman, Jinghua Qian, Ariel Slamet Ries, Morgan Rose and Omar Sakr - were scheduled to appear at a series of online Teen Writing Bootcamp events for young people run by the State Library Victoria in March 2024. On 28 February 2024, the entire program was cancelled and indefinitely postponed by the library who cited that a "child and cultural safety" review was necessary at a time of "heightened sensitivities."

Contents

Public speculation in the Australian media followed that the actual reason was four of the authors' public support of Palestine in the context of the Israel-Hamas war, and that the cancellation was an attempt at censorship. Accounts of numerous Library staff and internal Library emails obtained under the Freedom of Information Act have since confirmed that the writers' political views and religious backgrounds were scrutinised at length by Library staff in the leadup to the cancellation.

Background

Protest opposing the bombing of Gaza, Melbourne, Australia, 15 October Palestine Rally End The Siege, Stop the War on Gaza (53264916738).jpg
Protest opposing the bombing of Gaza, Melbourne, Australia, 15 October

On 15 September 2023, an official Library press release for International Democracy Day affirmed the institution's commitment to "taking a stand against increasing challenges to intellectual freedom faced by public libraries across Australia, in the form of demands for book challenges, book theft, intimidating protests and threats against public programs, including rainbow and drag queen story times." Library CEO Paul Duldig was quoted as saying: “State Library Victoria, like all public libraries, collects without political, moral or religious bias. One group in the community doesn’t get to decide what others can and can’t access, or what is included in the State Collection... We are providing public library staff with the training, skills and information they need to deliver community programming while managing diverse perspectives." [1]

The Israel-Hamas war began on 7 October 2023. Large protests supporting Palestine were and continue to be widespread across Australia, including a large rally that gathers outside the Library as a meeting place every Sunday. [2]

In January 2024, it was publicly disclosed that the dismissal of pro-Palestinian journalist Antoinette Lattouf from the ABC had been coordinated by a WhatsApp chat named "Lawyers for Israel". [3] The following month, the contents of another WhatsApp group supportive of Israel were publicly leaked by one of its members. [4] Conversations in the group included numerous attempts to silence local artists who had spoken in favour of Palestine, including Clementine Ford. [5] The resulting controversy led to the Federal Government proposing new legislation to legally define and forbid "doxxing." [6]

Numerous Australian writers festivals were also the subject of controversy relating to various writers and academics and their support of either Israel or Palestine in early 2024. [7]

Cancellation of the workshops

The Teen Writing Bootcamps were originally scheduled to take place online in March 2024, with each of the authors given a specialised area of education such as poetry and young adult fiction. On 28 February 2024, the entire series of workshops was cancelled in an email that claimed a "child and cultural safety review" was necessary:

We have a duty of care to ensure the highest levels of child and cultural safety are in place for all participants, artists and facilitators in our programs, and we take this very seriously. At a time of heightened sensitivities, we believe it is important to conduct this review carefully and thoroughly and take the time needed to make sure that the design and implementation guidelines for programs remain appropriate. [8]

While the library publicly insisted that the program had been postponed and not cancelled, they also sent a "termination agreement" to Sakr and the other writers involved in the program. This claimed that they were being terminated "due to circumstances which were not apparent at the time of entering into the contract" and offered immediate full payment on condition that the writers agree they must not "make any claim or demand that the library must do something, or must not do something, in connection with the contract or the program." Neither Sakr, Evans, Ries or Qian have signed this agreement. [9]

Responses

Response from authors

When the cancellation was made public, speculation followed in The Age and The Guardian that public support of Palestine by Evans, Qian, Ries and Sakr was the actual reason for the postponement, and that the Israel-Hamas war was the "heightened sensitivities" referred to. [10] [11]

Evans told The Guardian:

I think it’s very easy to speculate, but I just don’t know. It’s very unclear why they’ve made this decision. I can say that I don’t think the cancellations are due to child safety issues. It’s a program that’s been running at least three years.” [12]

Sakr told The Age:

Who was unsafe? What does it mean? You have to clearly articulate if you decided on your own that your processes are insufficient, that you are unsafe. You can say that out loud. But I won’t allow the inference to remain that we are unsafe... I’m more than willing to have a conversation around the safety of children with anyone. I would love, in fact, to see the safety of Palestinian children foregrounded in this country given our government’s role in what’s happening in Palestine and that they have cut funding to the principal aid organisation on the ground there as we are seeing Palestinian children starve to death. [13]

In an interview with Jacobin , Qian stated:

(The cancellation) struck me as very odd, given that the library has been running this program since 2021 and there were already robust child safety protocols in place. My understanding now is that the library cancelled the program as an act of self-censorship, to preempt the backlash they expected for giving a platform to pro-Palestine writers. I only know this because of whistleblowers; the library continues to deny it. To this day management hasn’t said what prompted its decision... I think there has been a deliberate campaign to frame all criticism of Israel as antisemitic, to justify all Israeli aggression as self-defense, and to paint all scrutiny of Israel’s actions as aggression. It inverts and exploits the language of anti-racism to censor, silence, intimidate, and punish. [14]

Official responses from the Library

Library president Christine Christian told The Australian that "the deferment was made to ensure the safety of its program participants (as) the unique community service carried with it a duty to provide a safe environment." [15] Another SLV spokesperson told The Guardian that the workshop had been deferred “due to changes in the external environment (to ensure) the highest levels of child and cultural safety are in place”, but would not give further details. [16] [17] Later, the Library further clarified that this had occurred solely "to protect children attending without a parent" [18] and that they "don’t comment on the interpretation of an individual’s views or backgrounds. Their personal views are their own and the Library is apolitical." [19]

Claims by Library staff

On 14 March 2024, The Age published claims attributed to anonymous Library employees that Duldig told a meeting attended by 30 staff that the writers' public support of Palestine was the actual reason for the postponement. [20] He was quoted as having said:

You call it profiling. I call it risk management. [21]

113 of the library's 300 staff signed an internal letter in support of Sakr and the other writers that accused the library of "censorship and discrimination." It was also revealed that the library's former head of engagement, Angharad Wynne-Jones, had resigned in the aftermath of the scandal. [22]

On 12 July 2024, The Age reported that the Library had begun forbidding its staff from wearing any items that "support or promote a particular political viewpoint”, including the watermelon symbol, the Palestinian flag and the Australian Aboriginal flag. In a statement, the library claimed that staff members are "encouraged to wear badges or pins on their lanyards that support diversity and inclusion, including badges with the Aboriginal flag” but did not explain why pro-Palestinian symbols were considered inappropriate. [23]

Motion raised in Victorian Parliament

On 20 March 2024, Gabrielle de Vietri of the Victorian Greens introduced a motion in Victorian Parliament that acknowledged the Library had "terminated the contracts of four writers who have spoken in support of Palestine", and that as political censorship is "indefensible" and public institutions are expected to hold "high ethical and transparency standards", the Library should now fully account for its decision. The motion was not passed. [24]

Boycott of the Library by other authors

On 29 April 2024, The Age reported that numerous well-known Australian authors, including Tony Birch, Michelle de Kretser and Grace Yee, are boycotting the Library indefinitely until the matter is resolved. [25]

Internal emails

Content of the emails

On 16 and 17 July 2024, The Age and The Guardian published numerous internal emails from the Library relating to the incident that had been obtained under the Freedom of Information Act. These emails, while heavily redacted, confirmed that the Library had indeed scrutinised the political and religious views of the authors on various topics and especially Palestine when making the decision to cancel the workshops. In one email, former Labor MP and then-Library board member Maxine McKew discussed a Substack article by Sakr about Palestine at length, adding:

Do we have a clear read on everything Omar Sakr has posted since then? If not, we should know and soon... It doesn’t mean we vet everyone for their social and political views, but it does mean on a subject such as Gaza/Israel we have a duty to be absolutely thorough and super careful about the way language is used by the people we engage. We need to be alert to what’s said and what’s not said.

This was followed by a request to do "a quick scan" of the social media of the other authors. A list was then prepared of posts they had made on various issues, including Qian's support of Lattouf and Yang Hengjun, Evans' posts about the war in Sudan and "First Nations solidarity around Change the Date", as well as "pro-Palestinian content" posted by Evans, Qian, Ries and Sakr. Creative Victoria were also consulted for advice. [26]

Another email from an unnamed staff member openly stated that a Muslim should not be paired with a Jew:

I wanted to flag with you two authors who are paired together for one of the teen writing boot camp information sessions on 15 Feb. The reason I’m flagging it is because one is of Muslim heritage (Omar Sakr) and the other I believe is of Jewish heritage and it’s just clicked that this might need some additional risk management. [27]

Official response from the Library

McKew told The Guardian that her decisions were informed by "the policy of political neutrality which covers all the major Victorian cultural institutions" that the library had been "entirely consistent" in applying. Duldig continued to insist that the Bootcamp sessions had not been "postponed" because of the political views of the authors: "Concerns were raised with the library about the blogs of one writer, Mr Sakr, and these blogs were found not to require further action. In reviewing those concerns, the library did however find that its policies and procedures were not sufficiently robust, and therefore decided to undertake a program-wide duty of care review." Another Library spokesperson stated that the emails affirm their position that a duty of care review was underway, and that "(upholding) the core value of respectful conduct... has come into sharp focus in the current geopolitical environment." [28]

Response from authors

Sakr stated that the emails proved that the Library's "invocation of child safety as the reason for cancelling the program was disingenuous." Evans called them "shameful", adding that the way the Library had "continued to assert that our views had nothing to do with the cancellations (was) appalling." Qian called them proof of "a blatant act of censorship." [29]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">UNRWA</span> United Nations agency supporting Palestinian refugees

The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East is a UN agency that supports the relief and human development of Palestinian refugees. UNRWA's mandate encompasses Palestinians who fled or were expelled during the Nakba, the 1948 Palestine War, and subsequent conflicts, as well as their descendants, including legally adopted children. As of 2019, more than 5.6 million Palestinians are registered with UNRWA as refugees.

The Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council (AIJAC), represents the interests of the Australian Jewish community to government, politicians, media and other community groups and organisations through research, commentary and analysis. The organisation is directed by Colin Rubenstein, who was previously a political science lecturer at Monash University. AIJAC has office locations in Melbourne and Sydney. AIJAC is formally associated with the American Jewish Committee.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">State Library Victoria</span> State library in Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

State Library Victoria (SLV) is the state library of Victoria, Australia. Located in Melbourne, it was established in 1854 as the Melbourne Public Library, making it Australia's oldest public library and one of the first free libraries in the world. It is also Australia's busiest public library and, as of 2023, the third busiest library globally.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Melbourne Symphony Orchestra</span> Australian orchestra

The Melbourne Symphony Orchestra (MSO) is an Australian orchestra based in Melbourne. The MSO is resident at Hamer Hall. The MSO has its own choir, the MSO Chorus, following integration with the Melbourne Chorale in 2008.

Solidarity for Palestinian Human Rights (SPHR) is a non-profit, student-based organization based in Montreal, Quebec, Canada. It gained a wide profile after instigating a protest in Concordia University, that forced the Israeli ex-Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to cancel a speech that was to take place on 9 September 2002. Rama Al-Malah serves as its spokesperson.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Maxine McKew</span> Australian politician

Maxine Margaret McKew is a former Australian Labor politician and journalist; she was the Parliamentary Secretary for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government in the First Rudd Ministry and the First Gillard Ministry.

<i>My Name Is Rachel Corrie</i> British play

My Name Is Rachel Corrie is a play based on the diaries and emails of activist Rachel Corrie, who was killed by an Israeli soldier when she was aged 23. It was jointly edited by journalist Katharine Viner and actor Alan Rickman, who also directed it.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Israel–United Kingdom relations</span> Bilateral relations

Israel–United Kingdom relations, or Anglo-Israeli relations, are the diplomatic and commercial ties between the United Kingdom and Israel. The British embassy to Israel is located in Tel Aviv. The UK has an honorary consul in Eilat and a non-accredited consulate-general in Jerusalem, that represents the United Kingdom in that city and the Palestinian territories. Israel has three representative offices in the United Kingdom: an Embassy located in London and consulates in Cardiff and Glasgow. As of 2023 trade exceeded 6.1 billion British pounds. Israel and the UK engage together in scientific research, defence and the development of new technologies, with the UK seeking to tap into Israel's considerable High technology sector through local British initatives. The UK since 2011 has sought to partner British companies with Israeli advanced technology companies. The UK Israeli cooperation has generated £1.2 billion as well as 16,000 British jobs of 250 such partnerships. The United Kingdom and Israel are currently negotiating renewing a free trade agreement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Communications in the State of Palestine</span>

Communications in the State of Palestine lags behind the world, though it still has telephone, radio, television, and internet. The communications sector in the Palestinian West Bank and Gaza Strip faces many obstacles, such as the Oslo Accords that were signed with the Israeli authorities, which prevented the use of spectrum frequencies for the wireless communications sector except with the approval of the Israeli side, and other obstacles, all of which led to the prevention of bringing modern technology to Palestine. After an effort, Palestine obtained third generation wireless communications frequencies or 3G. The Oslo Accords signed with the Israeli side are not the only ones that control the telecommunications sector in Palestine. There are many other matters that control this sector, such as the Palestinian Telecommunications Law and international agreements in this regard. The table shows the extent of Palestine’s lag behind neighboring countries due to the Oslo Accords, the impact of the Israeli occupation on the Palestinian territories, and many obstacles to obtaining technology from countries around the world and their control over Palestine’s spectrum frequencies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Palestine–United Kingdom relations</span> Bilateral relations

The United Kingdom does not recognise Palestine as a state. The UK has a non-accredited Consulate General in Jerusalem that "represents the UK government in Jerusalem, West Bank, and Gaza", and works on "political, commercial, security and economic interests between the UK and the Palestinian territories". Husam Zomlot became head of the Palestine Mission to the United Kingdom in 2018. The State of Palestine was represented in London by Manuel Hassassian, the Palestinian General Delegate to the United Kingdom between 2005 and 2018. Another former Palestinian General Delegate to the UK was Afif Safieh, who began in that role in 1990. The UK House of Commons voted in favor of recognizing Palestine as a state in 2014, as a contribution towards achieving a negotiated two-state solution. However, the UK government maintained its policy of reserving the right to recognize Palestine bilaterally at a more opportune time for peace efforts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Adania Shibli</span> Palestinian author (born 1974)

Adania Shibli is a Palestinian author and essayist. She is mainly known for the 2020 translation of her novel Minor Detail into English, German and other languages, and for a public controversy in Germany following the cancellation of a literary prize for this book, originally scheduled for the 2023 Frankfurt Book Fair.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Steven Salaita</span> American scholar (born 1975)

Steven Salaita is an American scholar, author and public speaker. He became the center of a controversy when the University of Illinois did not hire him as a professor of American Indian Studies following objections to a series of tweets critical of Israel's bombardment of Gaza in 2014. He also experienced similar controversy during the hiring process at the American University of Beirut in 2016.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Students for Justice in Palestine</span> Pro-Palestinian BDS activism organization

Students for Justice in Palestine is a pro-Palestinian college student activism organization in the United States, Canada and New Zealand. It has campaigned for boycott and divestment against corporations that deal with Israel and organized events about Israel's human rights violations. In 2011, The New York Times reported that "S.J.P., founded in 2001 at the University of California, Berkeley, has become the leading pro-Palestinian voice on campus."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Middle East Monitor</span> Not-for-profit press monitoring organisation

The Middle East Monitor (MEMO) is a not-for-profit press monitoring organisation and lobbying group that emerged in mid 2009. MEMO is largely focused on the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, but writes about other issues in the Middle East as well. MEMO is pro-Palestinian in orientation and supports Islamist causes. MEMO is regarded as an outlet for the Muslim Brotherhood and its website strongly promotes pro-Hamas related content.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Norway–Palestine relations</span> Diplomatic relations between Norway and the State of Palestine

Palestine has a diplomatic mission in Oslo, while Norway has a representative office in Al-Ram. Norway recognized the state of Palestine on May 28, 2024.

Anti-Palestinianism or anti-Palestinian racism refers to prejudice, collective hatred, and discrimination directed at the Palestinian people for any variety of reasons. Since the mid-20th century, the phenomenon has largely overlapped with anti-Arab racism and Islamophobia due to the fact that the overwhelming majority of Palestinians today are Arabs and Muslims. Historically, however, anti-Palestinianism was more closely identified with European antisemitism, as far-right Europeans detested the Jewish people as undesirable foreigners from Palestine. Modern anti-Palestinianism—that is, xenophobia with regard to the Arab people of Palestine—is most common in Israel, the United States, and Lebanon, among other countries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Omar Sakr</span> Australian writer and poet

Omar Sakr is a contemporary Arab Australian poet, novelist and essayist.

The US Campaign for Palestinian Rights (USCPR), formerly known as the US Campaign to End Israeli Occupation, is a pro-Palestinian advocacy group advocating for the rights of Palestinians. The organization was founded in 2001 after the second Intifada and is now made up of more than 300 member groups in the US working for Palestinian advocacy. USCPR was created with the goal to focus on "denied human rights" instead of focusing explicitly on Palestinian statehood.

On April 24, 2024 an occupation protest began at the University of Southern California (USC) in Los Angeles, California. The protest was a part of pro-Palestine protests on university campuses campaigning for divestment from Israel. USC cancelled their main commencement ceremony over safety concerns about protests. The encampment was cleared by the Los Angeles Police Department on the morning of May 5.

A series of protests at Ohio State University by pro-Palestinian demonstrators occurred on-campus in response to the Israel-Palestine conflict beginning on October 7, 2023. A solidarity encampment was constructed on OSU's South Oval on April 25, 2024, during which there were 36 arrests. About 40 protesters have been arrested across multiple non-violent protests, making for the largest en masse arrest on campus since the 1969–1970 Vietnam War protests.

References

  1. ↑ "State Library Victoria stands against challenges to intellectual freedom on International Democracy Day". State Library Victoria. Retrieved 17 July 2024.
  2. ↑ "Six people arrested amid stand-off between pro-Palestinian and pro-Israel rallies in Melbourne". SBS News. 19 May 2024. Retrieved 17 July 2024.
  3. ↑ Michael Bachelard, Calum Jaspan, Messages show push to oust Lattouf, Archived 15 January 2024 at the Wayback Machine The Age 16 January 2024 pp.1-3.
  4. ↑ Le Grand, Chip (17 July 2024). "Hundreds of Jewish creatives have names, details taken in leak, published online". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 17 July 2024.
  5. ↑ Taylor, Josh (9 February 2024). "Publication of Jewish creatives WhatsApp group led to death threats, MP says". The Guardian. Retrieved 17 July 2024.
  6. ↑ Lowrey, Tom (13 February 2024). "Federal government moves to criminalise 'doxxing' after publication of Jewish Australians' WhatsApp messages". ABC. Retrieved 17 July 2024.
  7. ↑ Muller, Denis (17 July 2024). "Australian writers festivals are engulfed in controversy over the war in Gaza. How can they uphold their duty to public debate?". The Conversation. Retrieved 29 February 2024.
  8. ↑ Burke, Kelly (6 March 2024). "Writers puzzled after State Library Victoria cancels workshops for teens citing 'child and cultural safety'". The Guardian. Retrieved 15 March 2024.
  9. ↑ Burke, The Guardian, 6 March 2024.
  10. ↑ O'Brien, Kerrie (7 March 2024). "State Library Victoria cancels workshops hosted by pro-Palestine writers". The Age. Retrieved 15 March 2024.
  11. ↑ Burke, Kelly (6 March 2024). "Writers puzzled after State Library Victoria cancels workshops for teens citing 'child and cultural safety'". The Guardian. Retrieved 15 March 2024.
  12. ↑ Burke, The Guardian, 6 March 2024.
  13. ↑ O'Brien, The Age, 7 March 2024.
  14. ↑ Dite, Chris (28 March 2024). "In Australia, Pro-Palestine Writers Are Defying Censorship". Jacobin. Retrieved 17 July 2024.
  15. ↑ Durie, John (31 May 2024). "Business, government partnerships help library become global leader". The Australian. Retrieved 17 July 2024.
  16. ↑ Burke, The Age, 6 March 2024.
  17. ↑ Beazley, Jordyn (14 March 2024). "State Library Victoria staff accuse management of 'censorship and discrimination' over pro-Palestine authors controversy". The Guardian. Retrieved 15 March 2024.
  18. ↑ Epstein, Rafael (15 March 2024). "Staff members and writers accuse State Library of stifling pro-Palestine voices". ABC Radio Melbourne. Retrieved 17 July 2024.
  19. ↑ Beazley, The Guardian, 6 March 2024
  20. ↑ O'Brien, Kerrie (14 March 2024). "State Library revolt over treatment of pro-Palestine writers". The Age. Retrieved 15 March 2024.
  21. ↑ O'Brien, Kerrie (29 April 2024). "Top writers boycott State Library Victoria over accusations of censorship". The Age. Retrieved 29 April 2024.
  22. ↑ Beazley, The Guardian, 6 March 2024.
  23. ↑ Watson, Meg (12 July 2024). "State Library cracks down on staff wearing "political" items". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 12 July 2024.
  24. ↑ de Vietri, Gabrielle. "Political censorship is indefensible". Twitter. Retrieved 20 March 2024.
  25. ↑ O'Brien, Kerrie (29 April 2024). "Top writers boycott State Library Victoria over accusations of censorship". The Age. Retrieved 29 April 2024.
  26. ↑ Beazley, Jordyn (17 July 2024). "State Library Victoria surveyed presenters' social media for political content before terminating contracts, emails show". The Guardian. Retrieved 18 July 2024.
  27. ↑ O'Brien, Kerrie (16 July 2024). "State Library probed writers' political, religious views before cancellations". The Age. Retrieved 16 July 2024.
  28. ↑ Beazley, The Guardian, 17 July 2024.
  29. ↑ Beazley, The Guardian, 17 July 2024.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.