Teacher tenure reform (United States)

Last updated

Teacher tenure is a policy that restricts the ability to fire teachers, requiring a "just cause" rationale for firing. [1] The individual states each have established their own tenure systems. [2] Tenure provides teachers with protections by making it difficult to fire teachers who earn tenure. Some states are focusing on revisions so that the tenure system no longer functions the same way as currently. [3]

Contents

Overview

While each state has its own specifics for how teacher tenure works, most hold a similar form. Each new teacher is given a probationary period (probation periods vary among states). During this probation period, teachers must prove they are worthy of receiving tenure. They must prove that they are having a positive effect on their students using a teacher evaluation system, which includes information from several facets of a teacher's responsibilities. Some common facets are classroom observations, student growth, and self-reflection (see, for example, New Haven [4] and the state of Virginia [5] ).

For example, currently under New Jersey's tenure system, a teacher is placed on probation for three years during which time the teacher is evaluated using a system called AchieveNJ. [6] During or after these three years, the principal must decide if the school will grant tenure to this teacher. If so, the teacher will be asked to work there for a fourth year and will be granted tenure. The principal is able to fire a teacher at any time during the probation period. However, once a teacher is tenured, the principal can no longer fire a teacher without just cause. The teacher is then protected by tenure. There are four reasons a teacher may be fired in New Jersey once they are tenured. The reasons include: incapacity, inefficiency, unbecoming conduct and just cause. A teacher being fired for any of these reasons is given a chance to defend their case. [2]

History

Tenure was created to provide teachers with due process protections. Some say the fight for these protections started around the 1920s as an outgrowth of the women's rights movement at a time when most teachers were women and most principals were men. [7] But a historical survey of indefinite teacher tenure activities and legislation in the United States found that indefinite tenure is a direct outgrowth of the civil service reform movement of the nineteenth century and that the line of historical development extends continuously from 1880. [8]

The debate

Proposals to change or eliminate tenure

Several states are looking into changing (in the name of reforming) and even eliminating their teacher tenure system. Some of the states leading the movement include Florida, New Jersey, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, New York and Pennsylvania. [9] Many would also like to see teachers being evaluated based on their performance and their students' academic achievement. [3] In eight states in America, tenure is given to teachers after just two years of teaching during the probation period. In two states, tenure is awarded after only one year of teaching during the probation period. Washington DC does not require a set time for awarding tenure. [10] Supporters of this notion feel that one or two years is too short a time to tell if a teacher is having a positive effect on their students. Before these teachers are granted lifetime job protection, they would like to see them perform on probation for a longer period of time. Changes have been created in all forms. Some proposals call for longer probation periods while others call for stricter teacher evaluations. Other proposals wish to end the tenure system completely and replace this system with renewable contracts. [3]

Key actors

Former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie proposed to (as he called it) reform the tenure system in New Jersey. He wished to eliminate the current tenure system and replace it with a new one. [11] Currently in New Jersey, after a teacher proves themselves efficient for 3 years, they gain lifetime protection under tenure. [2] Christie's proposal would also see teachers prove themselves for three years to gain tenure. However, after one year of being deemed "ineffective", teachers could easily be fired under his scheme. Christie wanted to judge whether a teacher is ineffective or not on a two part assessment. One part of the score will be based on student achievement. The second part of the score will be based on teacher performance. [11] Christie believes the answer to making schools more effective is to place more accountability on teachers. [12] Christie stated, "Let New Jersey lead the way again,", "The time to eliminate teacher tenure is now." [13]

Former chancellor of DC public schools, Michelle Rhee, had made plans to eliminate teacher tenure altogether. Rhee designed a pay plan which would compensate teachers by giving them big pay raises in exchange for their tenure protection rights. She gave existing tenured teachers the choice to accept this proposal. New hires would be forced to accept this new pay plan. New hires would be paid on the basis of their students' achievement. While teachers would prospectively be able to make more money under this pay plan, they would not be granted any tenure protections. Rhee's plan was unsuccessful. Teachers did not want to give up their tenure protections for a higher salary. After this plan failed she continued to devise plans. She offered a buyout plan for existing teachers with tenure. In 2009, she created a plan called IMPACT. This plan tied students performance on state tests to teachers evaluation. While this plan gained the support of many, there were still many others who opposed it. [3]

Against changes in the tenure system

In some states, schools are required to pay more to teachers who have earned higher degrees, and tenure allows teachers to secure a job, go back to school, and return to their jobs, not fearing dismissal because of their higher pay grade. Supporters liken tenure to the concept of seniority in other jobs. Teachers are often forced into uncomfortable situations (such as failing students, choosing certain students). An employee who makes decisions of a difficult and confrontational nature would thus require job protection. [14] Many who are against the motion of reforming/eliminating tenure argue that tenure allows teaching to become a profession rather than just a job. Presumably, teachers would not have as much job stability and would be forced to transfer from school to school. Giving teachers permanent positions would allow them to form bonds and relationships with students, parents, and other faculty. [15]

Recent activity

Several jurisdictions have considered changes in their tenure system since the 1990s. Some of these states include:

See also

Related Research Articles

Education reform is the name given to the goal of changing public education. The meaning and education methods have changed through debates over what content or experiences result in an educated individual or an educated society. Historically, the motivations for reform have not reflected the current needs of society. A consistent theme of reform includes the idea that large systematic changes to educational standards will produce social returns in citizens' health, wealth, and well-being.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fire drill</span> Method of practicing orderly evacuation in case of a fire

A fire drill is a method of practicing how a building would be evacuated in the event of a fire or other emergencies. In most cases, the building's existing fire alarm system is activated and the building is evacuated by means of the nearest available exits, as if an emergency had actually occurred. Fire drill procedures may vary depending on the building type, such as hospitals or high rise buildings, where occupants may be relocated within the building as opposed to evacuating the building. Generally, the evacuation interval is measured to ensure that it is fast enough, and problems with the emergency system or evacuation procedures are identified to be remedied.

Academic tenure in the United States and Canada is a contractual right that grants a teacher or professor a permanent position of employment at an academic institution such as a university or school. Tenure is intended to protect teachers from dismissal without just cause, and to allow development of thoughts or ideas considered unpopular or controversial among the community. In North America, tenure is granted only to educators whose work is considered to be exceptionally productive and beneficial in their careers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bayonne School District</span> School district in Hudson County, New Jersey, US

The Bayonne School District is a comprehensive public school district serving students from pre-kindergarten through twelfth grade from Bayonne in Hudson County, New Jersey, United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Randi Weingarten</span> American lawyer

Randi Weingarten is an American labor leader, attorney, and educator. She is president of the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) and a member of the AFL–CIO. She is the former president of the United Federation of Teachers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2005 California Proposition 74</span> Ballot proposition in the 2005 California special election

Proposition 74 (2005) was a ballot proposition in the 2005 California special election that intended to extend probationary periods for the state's public school teachers from two years to five before attaining tenure. It failed at the polls, with 55% of voters rejecting it.

Tenure is a category of academic appointment existing in some countries. A tenured post is an indefinite academic appointment that can be terminated only for cause or under extraordinary circumstances, such as financial exigency or program discontinuation. Tenure is a means of defending the principle of academic freedom, which holds that it is beneficial for society in the long run if scholars are free to hold and examine a variety of views.

Merit pay, merit increase or pay for performance, is performance-related pay, most frequently in the context of educational reform or government civil service reform. It provides bonuses for workers who perform their jobs effectively, according to easily measurable criteria. In the United States, policy makers are divided on whether merit pay should be offered to public school teachers, and other public employees, as is commonly the case in the United Kingdom.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chris Christie</span> 55th governor of New Jersey

Christopher James Christie is an American politician, lawyer, political commentator, lobbyist, and former federal prosecutor who served as the 55th governor of New Jersey from 2010 to 2018.

Thomas Luna is an American politician who served as Idaho superintendent of public instruction from 2006 to 2014. Luna was the chair of Idaho Republican Party from June 2020 to July 2022.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Michelle Rhee</span> American educational reformer

Michelle Ann Rhee is an American educator and advocate for education reform. She was Chancellor of District of Columbia Public Schools from 2007 to 2010. In late 2010, she founded StudentsFirst, a non-profit organization that works on education reform.

Absent Teacher Reserve is a term referring to teachers who are no longer appointed to a specific school, but are reassigned to a school or number of schools within a school district or school system throughout the school year. It may also refer to assistant principals who are rotated from school to school in a similar fashion and there are also AGRs, a guidance counterpart.

<i>Waiting for "Superman"</i> 2010 American film

Waiting for "Superman" is a 2010 American documentary film written and directed by Davis Guggenheim and produced by Lesley Chilcott. The film criticizes the American public education system by following several students as they strive to be accepted into competitive charter schools such as KIPP LA Schools, Harlem Success Academy and Summit Preparatory Charter High School.

TNTP, formerly known as The New Teacher Project, is an organization in the United States with a mission of ensuring that poor and minority students get equal access to effective teachers. It helps urban school districts and states recruit and train new teachers, staff challenged schools, design evaluation systems, and retain teachers who have demonstrated the ability to raise student achievement. TNTP is a non-profit organization that was founded by Michelle Rhee in 1997.

Last in First Out is a policy often used by school districts and other employers to prioritize layoffs by seniority. Under LIFO layoff rules, junior teachers and other employees lose their jobs before senior ones. Laying off junior employees first is not exclusive to the education sector or to the United States, but is perhaps most controversial there. LIFO's proponents claim that it protects teachers with tenure and gives them job stability, and that it is an easily administered way of accomplishing layoffs following a budget cut. LIFO's critics respond that it is bad for students. They prefer that the best teachers remain regardless of how long they have been teaching.

StudentsFirst is a political lobbying organization formed in 2010 by Michelle Rhee, former school chancellor of Washington D.C. public schools, in support of education reform. The organization worked to pass state laws on issues such as expanding charter schools and teacher tenure reform. On March 29, 2016, it announced some of its state chapters would merge with 50CAN, and its Sacramento headquarters would downsize.

Kevin S. Huffman is an American lawyer and education administrator who was the Commissioner of the Tennessee Department of Education. He was appointed to the position by Tennessee Governor Bill Haslam and served from April 2011 to January 2015. Prior to his work at the Tennessee Department of Education, Huffman held a senior management position in Teach for America and had worked as an attorney specializing in education.

Christopher D. Cerf is an American education administrator and attorney who previously served as the state-appointed Superintendent of the Newark Public Schools in New Jersey.

Clifford B. Janey was an American educator who served as superintendent of District of Columbia Public Schools, Newark Public Schools, and Rochester City School District.

Robert Richard "Bud" Spillane was an American school administrator who served as superintendent of Boston Public Schools and Fairfax County Public Schools.

References

  1. "What Is Teacher Tenure?". Education.com. Retrieved 2011-05-05.
  2. 1 2 3 Horn, Brandon. "New Jersey Teacher Tenure". Mrhorn.com. Retrieved 2011-05-05.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "Archived copy" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2011-05-24. Retrieved 2011-05-05.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
  4. "Teacher Evaluation and Development System | NHPS". www.nhps.net. Archived from the original on 2011-10-08.
  5. "VDOE :: Teacher Performance and Evaluation". Doe.virginia.gov. Retrieved 2022-08-18.
  6. "AchieveNJ: Teacher Evaluation: Overview".
  7. "AAV of Tracing the Roots of Teacher Tenure". California Department of Education. Retrieved 2011-05-05.
  8. Scott, Cecil Winfield (1943). "Teacher Tenure, including Teachers' Contracts". Review of Educational Research. 13 (3): 285–291. doi:10.2307/1168413. ISSN   0034-6543. JSTOR   1168413.
  9. Rotherham, Andrew J. (2011-01-27). "Teacher Tenure Debate: How to Modify Due-Process Rules". Time. Archived from the original on January 28, 2011. Retrieved 2011-05-05.
  10. Merrow, John (2011-02-23). "It's Time to Debate Teacher Tenure". Huffington Post. Retrieved 2011-05-05.
  11. 1 2 Mooney, John (2011-04-14). "Gov. Christie Offers First Peek at Education Reform Bills". NJ Spotlight. Retrieved 2011-05-05.
  12. Mooney, John (2011-02-10). "Union City Schools: A Test Case for Christie Reforms?". NJ Spotlight. Retrieved 2011-05-05.
  13. Galioto, Catherine (2011-01-11). "Christie Calls for Eliminating Teacher Tenure and Cutting Spending". Patch.com. Retrieved 2011-05-05.
  14. Stewart E Brekke (2001). "Why Teachers Need Tenure". Teachers.Net. Retrieved 2011-05-05.
  15. Matt Coleman (2011-04-07). "Why teachers need tenure". Gainesville.com. Retrieved 2011-05-05.