Telling Right From Wrong

Last updated
Telling Right From Wrong
TWFWCooney.jpg
Timothy J. Cooney
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
SubjectPhilosophy, morality
PublisherPrometheus
Publication date
1985
Media typeHardback
Pages158 pages
ISBN 0879752971 First edition
OCLC 300578530

Telling Right From Wrong is a book by Timothy J. Cooney. [1] In an attempt to get the book published Cooney submitted a falsified letter to Random House. This was detected prior to release and the publication offer was rescinded. Telling Right From Wrong was later published by Prometheus Books.

Contents

Synopsis

The book's synopsis describes the work as an "analysis and discussion of moral language and the assumptions underlying its use. This book contends that much of our prescriptive language pertaining to issues such as gambling, abortion, capitol punishment, homosexuality, prostitution, divorce, freedom of speech and expression, pornography, and others, is devoid of moral content." [2]

Release

Cooney's prior attempts at locating a publisher for his first two books had been unsuccessful and per the New York Times , he "assumed no academic press would look at a manuscript by a philosophical autodidact." [3] His former wife, Joan Ganz Cooney, [4] recommended that Cooney solicit philosophy academics for a recommendation letter. [5] Assuming that no academic would read the book as he was not in academics himself, Cooney forged a recommendation letter from Harvard professor Robert Nozick and submitted it to Random House, which then extended him a publication offer. [6] Nozick and Random House learned of the fraud after a journal editor contacted Nozick to let him know that they had received a copy of the book, as a copy of the letter was sent out with each galley. [7] Upon learning of the fraud, Random House withdrew their offer. [3]

In an unsuccessful attempt to persuade Random House to continue with publication of Telling Right From Wrong Cooney issued a formal apology and also added a new chapter based on the event. [3] The book was later published via Prometheus Books in summer 1985. [6] The publisher condemned Cooney's actions but chose to publish the work after it was praised by two philosophers. [3] Prior to Prometheus Books picking up the book philosophy professor David L. Norton called for a boycott of Telling Right from Wrong if it were to be published. [8]

Sidney Hook criticized Cooney's apology to Random House in his review for the New York Times , stating that there was "something disingenuous about this explanation, since he did not explore obvious ways to get a reputable philosopher to read his manuscript and recommend it on its merits." The newspaper also noted that Cooney had not attempted to self-publish the work. [3] Hook's review was itself later criticized as the philosopher had been included in the acknowledgements page in the Prometheus Books galley; this acknowledgement was not present in the published version or mentioned in Hook's review. He also did not mention his possible involvement in the book's publication after it was dropped by Random House. [8]

In September 1985 Cooney reported that he had was unable to get speaking engagements on college campuses. [5] After Cooney's death Tim Madigan noted that Cooney had "never tried to justify his act of forgery, admitting that by his own standards he had committed a wrongful act, and he ruefully pointed out that he understood better than anyone how the deception put the nail in the coffin of his reputation as a spokesperson for ethical reflection." [4]

Reception

Sidney Hook reviewed Telling Right from Wrong for The New York Times, writing that "To my surprise (and without subscribing to his main thesis), I found it an uncommonly good book, far superior to scores of volumes on the subject tumbling from both university and commercial presses." [3] This review was questioned by Carlin Romano, who pointed out that Hook had been previously credited in the acknowledgements in the book's galley as having "championed its publication after the book was dropped" and that this acknowledgement was possibly removed in the publication copy order to ensure that Hook could review the book for the New York Times. Romano further noted that the New York Times' deputy editor of the book reviews responded to questions about the acknowledgement by stating that the staff editor responsible for reading galleys and catching any potential conflict of interest "simply 'missed' it". [8] In his own review for the book Romano criticized the text, writing "Cooney's approach, unfortunately, depends on unrealistic assumptions about our agreement on fundamental values and the likelihood of particular actions' causing destruction." [9]

Seymour J. Mandelbaum also reviewed the work, calling it a "brash tract". [10]

Related Research Articles

A. J. Ayer English philosopher

Sir Alfred Jules "Freddie" Ayer, usually cited as A. J. Ayer, was an English philosopher known for his promotion of logical positivism, particularly in his books Language, Truth, and Logic (1936) and The Problem of Knowledge (1956).

Robert Nozick American political philosopher (1938-2002)

Robert Nozick was an American philosopher. He held the Joseph Pellegrino University Professorship at Harvard University, and was president of the American Philosophical Association. He is best known for his books Philosophical Explanations (1981), which included his counterfactual theory of knowledge, and Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974), a libertarian answer to John Rawls' A Theory of Justice (1971), in which Nozick also presented his own theory of utopia as one in which people can freely choose the rules of the society they enter into. His other work involved ethics, decision theory, philosophy of mind, metaphysics and epistemology. His final work before his death, Invariances (2001), introduced his theory of evolutionary cosmology, by which he argues invariances, and hence objectivity itself, emerged through evolution across possible worlds.

John Rawls American political philosopher

John Bordley Rawls was an American moral and political philosopher in the liberal tradition. Rawls received both the Schock Prize for Logic and Philosophy and the National Humanities Medal in 1999, the latter presented by President Bill Clinton, in recognition of how Rawls' work "helped a whole generation of learned Americans revive their faith in democracy itself."

J. L. Mackie Australian philosopher

John Leslie Mackie was an Australian philosopher. He made significant contributions to the philosophy of religion, metaphysics, and the philosophy of language, and is perhaps best known for his views on metaethics, especially his defence of moral scepticism. He wrote six books. His most widely known, Ethics: Inventing Right and Wrong (1977), opens by boldly stating, "There are no objective values." It goes on to argue that because of this ethics must be invented rather than discovered. He posthumously published The Miracle of Theism: Arguments For and Against the Existence of God (1983), which has been called "atour de force" in contemporary analytic philosophy. Many considered Mackie one of the best defenders of philosophical atheism. In the 1980s, Time magazine called him the "ablest of today's atheistic philosophers", and he regularly debated Christian philosophers such as Richard Swinburne and Alvin Plantinga.

<i>A Theory of Justice</i> 1971 book by John Rawls

A Theory of Justice is a 1971 work of political philosophy and ethics by the philosopher John Rawls, in which the author attempts to provide a moral theory alternative to utilitarianism and that addresses the problem of distributive justice. The theory uses an updated form of Kantian philosophy and a variant form of conventional social contract theory. Rawls's theory of justice is fully a political theory of justice as opposed to other forms of justice discussed in other disciplines and contexts.

Ted Honderich

Ted Honderich is a Canadian-born British professor of philosophy, who was Grote Professor Emeritus of the Philosophy of Mind and Logic, University College London.

Sidney Hook 20th-Century American philosopher

Sidney Hook was an American philosopher of the pragmatist school known for his contributions to the philosophy of history, the philosophy of education, political theory, and ethics. After embracing communism in his youth, Hook was later known for his criticisms of totalitarianism, both fascism and Marxism–Leninism. A pragmatic social democrat, Hook sometimes cooperated with conservatives, particularly in opposing Marxism–Leninism. After World War II, he argued that members of such groups as the Communist Party USA and Leninists like democratic centralists could ethically be barred from holding the offices of public trust because they called for the violent overthrow of democratic governments.

Prometheus Books is a publishing company founded in August 1969 by the philosopher Paul Kurtz. The publisher's name was derived from Prometheus, the Titan from Greek mythology who stole fire from Zeus and gave it to man. This act is often used as a metaphor for bringing knowledge or enlightenment.

"Instrumental" and "value rationality" are terms scholars use to identify two ways humans reason when coordinating group behaviour to maintain social life. Instrumental rationality recognizes means that "work" efficiently to achieve ends. Value rationality recognizes ends that are "right," legitimate in themselves.

James Rachels

James Webster Rachels was an American philosopher who specialized in ethics and animal rights.

<i>Philosophical Explanations</i> 1981 book by Robert Nozick

Philosophical Explanations is a 1981 metaphysical, epistemological, and ethical treatise by the philosopher Robert Nozick.

<i>For a New Liberty</i> 1973 book by Murray Rothbard

For a New Liberty: The Libertarian Manifesto is a book by American economist and historian Murray Rothbard, in which the author promotes anarcho-capitalism. The work has been credited as an influence on modern libertarian thought and on part of the New Right.

Denise Spellberg American scholar of Islamic history (born c. 1958)

Denise A. Spellberg is an American scholar of Islamic history. She is professor of history and Middle Eastern Studies at the University of Texas at Austin. Spellberg holds an A.B. in History from Smith College (1980) and an M.A., M. Phil., and a PhD (1989) in Middle Eastern History from Columbia University.

<i>The Jewel of Medina</i> Historical novel

The Jewel of Medina is a historical novel by Sherry Jones that recounts the life of Aisha, one of Muhammad's wives, from the age of six, when she was betrothed to Muhammad, to her death.

Anita L. Allen American lawyer

Anita LaFrance Allen is the Henry R. Silverman Professor of Law and professor of philosophy at the University of Pennsylvania Law School. She is also Vice Provost for Faculty. She has been a senior fellow in the former bioethics department of the University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine, a collaborating faculty member in Africana Studies, and an affiliated faculty member in the gender, sexuality and women's studies program. She has been elected to the National Academy of Medicine, the American Law Institute, and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. She served as President of the Eastern Division of the American Philosophical Association in 2018–19. In 2010 President Barack Obama named Allen to the Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues. She is a Hastings Center Fellow.

In philosophy, objectivity is the concept of truth independent from individual subjectivity. A proposition is considered to have objective truth when its truth conditions are met without bias caused by a sentient subject. Scientific objectivity refers to the ability to judge without partiality or external influence. Objectivity in the moral framework calls for moral codes to be assessed based on the well-being of the people in the society that follow it. Moral objectivity also calls for moral codes to be compared to one another through a set of universal facts and not through Subjectivity.

Carlin Romano

Carlin Romano is an American writer and educator. Romano writes for The Chronicle of Higher Education.

Brian Leiter American philosopher and legal scholar

Brian Leiter is an American philosopher and legal scholar who is Karl N. Llewellyn Professor of Jurisprudence at the University of Chicago Law School and founder and Director of Chicago's Center for Law, Philosophy & Human Values. A review in Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews described Leiter as "one of the most influential legal philosophers of our time", while a review in The Journal of Nietzsche Studies described Leiter's book Nietzsche on Morality (2002) as "arguably the most important book on Nietzsche's philosophy in the past twenty years."

<i>Animals, Men and Morals</i>

Animals, Men and Morals: An Inquiry into the Maltreatment of Non-humans (1971) is a collection of essays on animal rights, edited by Oxford philosophers Stanley and Roslind Godlovitch, both from Canada, and John Harris from the UK. The editors were members of the Oxford Group, a group of postgraduate philosophy students and others based at the University of Oxford from 1968, who began raising the idea of animal rights in seminars and campaigning locally against factory farming and otter hunting.

Analytical Marxism

Analytical Marxism is an approach to Marxist theory that was prominent amongst English-speaking philosophers and social scientists during the 1980s. It was mainly associated with the September Group of academics, so called because of their biennial September meetings to discuss common interests. Described by G. A. Cohen as "non-bullshit Marxism", the group was characterized, in the words of David Miller, by "clear and rigorous thinking about questions that are usually blanketed by ideological fog." Members of this school seek to apply the techniques of analytic philosophy, along with tools of modern social science such as rational choice theory, to the elucidation of the theories of Karl Marx and his successors.

References

  1. Timothy J. Cooney (1985). "Telling Right From Wrong, Prometheus Books, 1985, ISBN   0-87975-297-1
  2. Cooney, Timothy J (1985). Telling right from wrong: what is moral, what is immoral, and what is neither one nor the other. Buffalo: Prometheus. ISBN   978-0-87975-297-2. OCLC   300578530.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Hook, Sidney (1985). "WOULD IT DESTROY THE WORLD?". The New York Times . Retrieved 2018-09-01.
  4. 1 2 "How We Got To Sesame Street | Issue 79". Philosophy Now. Retrieved 2021-04-21.
  5. 1 2 "Morality book's author forged praise". Corvallis Gazette. September 27, 1985.
  6. 1 2 McDowell, Edwin (1985). "PUBLISHING: DOING RIGHT BY A BOOK". The New York Times . Retrieved 2018-09-01.
  7. Swanson, Stevenson (October 13, 1984). "Infobits". Hartford Courant.
  8. 1 2 3 Romano, Carlin (June 30, 1985). "A philosophy book that has stirred controversy". The Philadelphia Inquirer.
  9. Romano, Carlin (July 7, 1985). "Facile assertions about right and wrong". Lexington Herald-Reader.
  10. Mandelbaum, Seymour J. (1986). "Review of Telling Right from Wrong: What Is Moral, What Is Immoral, and What Is Neither One nor the Other". Journal of Policy Analysis and Management. 5 (4): 832–834. doi:10.2307/3324892. ISSN   0276-8739.