Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought

Last updated

Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought: Kepler to Einstein
Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought Revised Cover.jpg
Cover of the revised edition, published in 1988
Author Gerald James Holton
Country United States
LanguageEnglish
Subject
Publisher Harvard University Press
Publication date
  • 1973 (original ed.)
  • 1988 (revised ed.)
Pages
  • 495 (original ed.)
  • 500 (revised ed.)
ISBN 978-0-674-87747-4
OCLC 17299125
509
LC Class Q125
Identifiers refer to the 1988 revised hardcover edition version unless otherwise noted

Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought: Kepler to Einstein is a collection of essays on themes in the history of physics by Gerald Holton. It was originally published in 1973 by Harvard University Press, who issued multiple reprints of the book leading up to the publication of a revised edition in 1988. The book has been translated into several languages and has received many reviews.

Contents

Background

Holton was a well-known professor of physics at Harvard and a historian of science. [1] In the book, Holton draws on "themata" that tie breakthroughs together in the history of physics; one reviewer noted that he may be the first person to draw a clear line between the philosophy book Either/Or and the complementarity principle of quantum mechanics that was formulated by Niels Bohr in the early twentieth century. [1] After the release of the first edition, Holton released two sequels to the work, The Scientific Imagination and The Advancement of Science and its Burdens in 1978 and 1986, respectively. [2]

Content

The original book, published in 1973 by Harvard University Press, was a collection of fifteen of Holton's essays that were published between 1953 and 1971. [3] The University Press released a revised edition of the book in 1988 in which Holton removed some essays and added new ones in their place. [2] The revised edition and added new papers published as late as 1986. [4]

Table of contents
SectionFirst ed.Revised ed.Chapter
I. On the Thematic Analysis of Science11The Thematic Imagination in Science
22Johannes Kepler's Universe: Its Physics and Metaphysics
33Thematic and Stylistic Interdependence
44The Roots of Complementarity
N/A5On the Hesitant Rise of Quantum Physics Research in the United States
II. On Relativity Theory56On the Origins of the Special Theory of Relativity
67Poincare and Relativity
78Influences on Einstein's Early Work
89Mach, Einstein, and the Search for Reality
910Einstein, Michelson, and the "Crucial" Experiment
1011On Trying to Understand Scientific Genius
III. On the Growth of Physical Science1112The Duality and Growth of Physical Science
1213Models for Understanding the Growth of Research
13N/AThe Changing Allegory of Motion
N/A14Niels Bohr and the Integrity of Science
IV. On Education14N/AModern Science and the Intellectual Tradition
15N/APhysics and Culture: Criteria for Curriculum Design

Reception

The original version of the book, published in 1973 with several reprints thereafter, was reviewed by Stephen Toulmin, [1] [5] Gary Gutting, [6] and James L. Park [3] in 1974, Thomas F. Gieryn in 1976, [7] [8] and several others. [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] In his review of the book, Gutting wrote that the "essays are of high quality" before analyzing the contents and going on to state: "To my mind, the one major defect of this fine book is Holton's failure to come to grips with the central problem of the rationality of science." [6] In his reviews of the book, which was published twice in two different months, Gieryn wrote that the book is "outstanding" and serves as a "Wegweiser" [trail sign] by "pointing out new areas of fruitful ignorance to scholars in many disciplines". [8] In his 1974 review, Park wrote: "The entire book is written with great eloquence and style; and its scholarly content is substantial, cogent, and provocative." [3] Park singled out the series of six lectures in part two on the history of relativity as "singularly outstanding". [3] Toulmin closed his review of the book in Physics World by writing: "His book deserves to have a permanent influence on the work of historians, philosophers and sociologists of science, as well as on educationists and intellectual historians, but it can also be most strongly recommended to the general reader." [1]

The 1988 revised edition also received several reviews. [2] [16] [4] One of the reviews for the 1988 revised edition of the book noted that the book had been used as "a source of insight to many students of science history" since its publication and that the new essay on Niels Bohr "should be required reading for science students in graduate school". [2] Another review of the revised edition stated that the "book is highly recommended" due to its discussions of the themes and philosophies that make scientific breakthroughs possible. [4] A third, critical, review of the revised edition noted the original was a "landmark study" but said the update "sheds little light" because the book "sticks so strictly to the concrete realities of physics" [16] and goes on to state: "Although links between these histories and the larger implications for organized science are promised, they are not delivered." [16]

Publication history

Original editions

Reprints

Translations

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Johannes Kepler</span> German astronomer and mathematician (1571–1630)

Johannes Kepler was a German astronomer, mathematician, astrologer, natural philosopher and writer on music. He is a key figure in the 17th-century Scientific Revolution, best known for his laws of planetary motion, and his books Astronomia nova, Harmonice Mundi, and Epitome Astronomiae Copernicanae, influencing among others Isaac Newton, providing one of the foundations for his theory of universal gravitation. The variety and impact of his work made Kepler one of the founders and fathers of modern astronomy, the scientific method, natural and modern science.

<i>The Structure of Scientific Revolutions</i> 1962 book by Thomas S. Kuhn

The Structure of Scientific Revolutions is a book about the history of science by philosopher Thomas S. Kuhn. Its publication was a landmark event in the history, philosophy, and sociology of science. Kuhn challenged the then prevailing view of progress in science in which scientific progress was viewed as "development-by-accumulation" of accepted facts and theories. Kuhn argued for an episodic model in which periods of conceptual continuity where there is cumulative progress, which Kuhn referred to as periods of "normal science", were interrupted by periods of revolutionary science. The discovery of "anomalies" during revolutions in science leads to new paradigms. New paradigms then ask new questions of old data, move beyond the mere "puzzle-solving" of the previous paradigm, change the rules of the game and the "map" directing new research.

Philipp Frank was a physicist, mathematician and philosopher of the early-to-mid 20th century. He was a logical positivist, and a member of the Vienna Circle. He was influenced by Mach and was one of the Machists criticised by Lenin in Materialism and Empirio-criticism.

Gerald James Holton is an American physicist, historian of science, and educator, whose professional interests also include philosophy of science and the fostering of careers of young men and women. He is Mallinckrodt Professor of Physics and professor of the history of science, emeritus, at Harvard University. His contributions range from physical science and its history to their professional and public understanding, from studies on gender problems and ethics in science careers to those on the role of immigrants. These have been acknowledged by an unusually wide spectrum of appointments and honors, from physics to initiatives in education and other national, societal issues, to contributions for which he was selected, as the first scientist, to give the tenth annual Jefferson Lecture that the National Endowment for the Humanities describes as, “the highest honor the federal government confers for distinguished achievement in the humanities”.

I. Bernard Cohen was the Victor S. Thomas Professor of the history of science at Harvard University and the author of many books on the history of science and, in particular, Isaac Newton and Benjamin Franklin.

David Berlinski is an American author who has written books about mathematics and the history of science as well as fiction. An opponent of evolution, he is a senior fellow of the Discovery Institute's Center for Science and Culture, an organization which promotes the pseudoscience of intelligent design.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Relativity of simultaneity</span> Concept that distant simultaneity is not absolute, but depends on the observers reference frame

In physics, the relativity of simultaneity is the concept that distant simultaneity – whether two spatially separated events occur at the same time – is not absolute, but depends on the observer's reference frame. This possibility was raised by mathematician Henri Poincaré in 1900, and thereafter became a central idea in the special theory of relativity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Relativity priority dispute</span> Debate about priority credit for the theory of special relativity

Albert Einstein presented the theories of special relativity and general relativity in publications that either contained no formal references to previous literature, or referred only to a small number of his predecessors for fundamental results on which he based his theories, most notably to the work of Henri Poincaré and Hendrik Lorentz for special relativity, and to the work of David Hilbert, Carl F. Gauss, Bernhard Riemann, and Ernst Mach for general relativity. Subsequently, claims have been put forward about both theories, asserting that they were formulated, either wholly or in part, by others before Einstein. At issue is the extent to which Einstein and various other individuals should be credited for the formulation of these theories, based on priority considerations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">August Föppl</span> Professor of engineering

August Otto Föppl was a professor of Technical Mechanics and Graphical Statics at the Technical University of Munich, Germany. He is credited with introducing the Föppl–Klammer theory and the Föppl–von Kármán equations.

Einstein and Religion: Physics and Theology (1999) is a book on the religious views of Nobel prize-winning physicist Albert Einstein by Max Jammer, published by Princeton University Press.

Lewis Samuel Feuer was an American sociologist. Initially a committed Marxist, he became a neo-conservative.

Jeremy Bernstein is an American theoretical physicist and popular science writer.

Jagdish Mehra was an Indian-American historian of science.

Stephen George Brush is a scholar in the field of history of science whose career spanned the late twentieth and early twenty-first century. His research resulted in hundreds of journal articles and over a dozen books.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">C. Doris Hellman</span> American historian of science (1910–1973)

Clarisse Doris Hellman Pepper was an American historian of science, "one of the first professional historians of science in the United States". She specialized in 16th- and 17th-century astronomy, wrote a book on the Great Comet of 1577, and was the translator of another book, a biography of Johannes Kepler. She became a professor at the Pratt Institute and later at the Queens College, City University of New York, and was recognized by membership in several selective academic societies.

<i>A History of the Theories of Aether and Electricity</i> Series of three books by E. T. Whittaker on the history of electromagnetic theory

A History of the Theories of Aether and Electricity is any of three books written by British mathematician Sir Edmund Taylor Whittaker FRS FRSE on the history of electromagnetic theory, covering the development of classical electromagnetism, optics, and aether theories. The book's first edition, subtitled from the Age of Descartes to the Close of the Nineteenth Century, was published in 1910 by Longmans, Green. The book covers the history of aether theories and the development of electromagnetic theory up to the 20th century. A second, extended and revised, edition consisting of two volumes was released in the early 1950s by Thomas Nelson, expanding the book's scope to include the first quarter of the 20th century. The first volume, subtitled The Classical Theories, was published in 1951 and served as a revised and updated edition to the first book. The second volume, subtitled The Modern Theories (1900–1926), was published two years later in 1953, extended this work covering the years 1900 to 1926. Notwithstanding a notorious controversy on Whittaker's views on the history of special relativity, covered in volume two of the second edition, the books are considered authoritative references on the history of electricity and magnetism as well as classics in the history of physics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bibliography of E. T. Whittaker</span>

Sir Edmund Taylor Whittaker was a British mathematician, physicist, historian of science, and philosopher who authored three titles that remain in circulation over a century after their initial publications. His bibliography includes several books and over one hundred published papers on a variety of subjects, including mathematics, astronomy, mathematical physics, theoretical physics, philosophy, and theism. Whittaker's bibliography in the Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society categorises his publications into three categories: books and monographs, maths and physics articles, and biographical articles; the bibliography excludes works published in popular magazines like Scientific American. The bibliography includes eleven total books and monographs, fifty-six maths and physics articles, thirty-five philosophy and history articles, and twenty-one biographical articles. In the bibliography compiled by William Hunter McCrea in 1957, there are thirteen books and monographs and the same journal articles; McCrea counts all three volumes of A History of the Theories of Aether and Electricity as separate books and excludes the same papers. Whittaker's contributions to Scientific American include two book reviews and a popular article on mathematics.

<i>Subtle is the Lord</i> Biography of Albert Einstein by Abraham Pais

Subtle is the Lord: The Science and the Life of Albert Einstein is a biography of Albert Einstein written by Abraham Pais. First published in 1982 by Oxford University Press, the book is one of the most acclaimed biographies of the scientist. This was not the first popular biography of Einstein, but it was the first to focus on his scientific research as opposed to his life as a popular figure. Pais, renowned for his work in theoretical particle physics, was a friend of Einstein's at the Institute for Advanced Study in his early career. Originally published in English in the United States and the United Kingdom, the book has translations in over a dozen languages. Pais later released a sequel to the book in 1994 titled Einstein Lived Here and, after his death in 2000, the University Press released a posthumous reprint of the biography in 2005, with a new foreword by Roger Penrose. Considered very popular for a science book, the biography sold tens of thousands of copies of both paperback and hardcover versions in its first year. The book has received many reviews and, the year after its initial publication, it won both the 1983 National Book Award for Nonfiction, in Science (Hardcover), and the 1983 Science Writing Award.

<i>The Meaning of Relativity</i> Book by Albert Einstein

The Meaning of Relativity: Four Lectures Delivered at Princeton University, May 1921 is a book published by Princeton University Press in 1922 that compiled the 1921 Stafford Little Lectures at Princeton University, given by Albert Einstein. The lectures were translated into English by Edwin Plimpton Adams. The lectures and the subsequent book were Einstein's last attempt to provide a comprehensive overview of his theory of relativity and is his only book that provides an accessible overview of the physics and mathematics of general relativity. Einstein explained his goal in the preface of the book's German edition by stating he "wanted to summarize the principal thoughts and mathematical methods of relativity theory" and that his "principal aim was to let the fundamentals in the entire train of thought of the theory emerge clearly". Among other reviews, the lectures were the subject of the 2017 book The Formative Years of Relativity: The History and Meaning of Einstein's Princeton Lectures by Hanoch Gutfreund and Jürgen Renn.

<i>Intellectual Mastery of Nature</i> Book by Christa Jungnickel and Russell McCormmach

Intellectual Mastery of Nature: Theoretical Physics from Ohm to Einstein is a two-volume reference work on the history of theoretical physics by Christa Jungnickel and Russell McCormmach that was initially published in 1986 by the University of Chicago Press. The book was well received and it won the 1987 Pfizer Award, given annually by the History of Science Society. In 2017, the duo released a revised and condensed version of the book through Springer International Publishing titled The Second Physicist: On the History of Theoretical Physics in Germany. The authors also wrote the 1996 and updated 1999 biography of Henry Cavendish, originally titled Cavendish, the book was given the subtitle The Experimental Life in the revised version of 1999.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Toulmin, Stephen (February 1974). "Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought, Kepler to Einstein". Physics Today. 27 (2): 47–48. Bibcode:1974PhT....27b..47H. doi:10.1063/1.3128445. ISSN   0031-9228.
  2. 1 2 3 4 Topper, David (1989). "Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought: Kepler to Einstein". Leonardo. 22 (2): 267. doi:10.2307/1575244. JSTOR   1575244. S2CID   124151494.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Park, James L. (April 1974). "Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought: Kepler to Einstein". American Journal of Physics. 42 (4): 346–347. Bibcode:1974AmJPh..42..346H. doi:10.1119/1.1987695. ISSN   0002-9505.
  4. 1 2 3 Faucher, Guy (May 1990). "Thematic origins of scientific thought: Kepler to Einstein". The Physics Teacher. 28 (5): 345. doi:10.1119/1.2343059. ISSN   0031-921X.
  5. Toulmin, Stephen (October 1974). Holton, Gerald (ed.). "Science and Scientists: The Problem of Objectivity". Minerva. 12 (4): 522–529. doi:10.1007/BF01557644. ISSN   0026-4695. JSTOR   41806228. S2CID   189793219.
  6. 1 2 Gutting, Gary (October 1974). "Review of Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought". Technology and Culture. 15 (4): 657–659. doi:10.2307/3102263. ISSN   0040-165X. JSTOR   3102263.
  7. Gieryn, Thomas F. (May 1976). "Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought: Kepler to Einstein". Contemporary Sociology. 5 (3): 368. doi:10.2307/2064149. JSTOR   2064149.
  8. 1 2 Gieryn, Thomas F. (July 1976). "Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought: Kepler to Einstein". Contemporary Sociology. 5 (4): 513. doi:10.2307/2063863. JSTOR   2063863.
  9. De Benedetti, Sergio (1979). "Gerald Holton, Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought. Kepler to Einstein, Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press, 1973, in-8, pp. 495". Annali dell'Istituto e Museo di Storia della Scienza di Firenze. 4 (2): 91–92. doi:10.1163/221058779X00126. ISSN   0391-3341.
  10. Trenn, Thaddeus J. (December 1974). "Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought: Kepler to Einstein . Gerald Holton". Philosophy of Science. 41 (4): 415–418. doi:10.1086/288604. ISSN   0031-8248. JSTOR   187010.
  11. Wall, Charles A. (April 1974). "Review of Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought". The Science Teacher. 41 (4): 55. ISSN   0036-8555. JSTOR   24123526.
  12. de Buzon, Catherine (1977). "Review of Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought. Kepler to Einstein". Revue d'histoire des sciences. 30 (3): 275–276. ISSN   0151-4105. JSTOR   23631874.
  13. Schubert, Leo (May 1974). "Review of Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought: Kepler to Einstein. First Edition". Journal of College Science Teaching. 3 (5): 362. ISSN   0047-231X. JSTOR   42965382.
  14. Goldman, James A. (1976). "Scientific Themata". Journal of College Science Teaching. 5 (4): 265. ISSN   0047-231X. JSTOR   42984363.
  15. Tilling, Laura (1 February 1974). "Intuitive cience". Nature. 247 (5439): 317. Bibcode:1974Natur.247..317T. doi: 10.1038/247317a0 . ISSN   1476-4687. S2CID   4217212.
  16. 1 2 3 Shubin, Daryl E.; Davies, Richard; Heinz, LISA C. (Winter 1988). "Review of Farewell to Reason, ; Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought: Kepler to Einstein, ; Science, Philosophy, and Human Behavior in the Soviet Union, ; The Ends of Science: An Essay in Scientific Authority, ; Science Under Siege: The Myth of Objectivity in Scientific Research". Issues in Science and Technology. 5 (2): 110–112. ISSN   0748-5492. JSTOR   43309365.