This article needs additional citations for verification .(February 2023) |
The Twentieth Century Encyclopedia of Catholicism is a series of 150 volumes examining topics pertaining to Catholicism, many of them originally published in France. It was published in English in the United States by Hawthorn Books from 1958 to 1971. The series editor was Henri Daniel-Rops. The series was divided into 16 sections. In the United States, volumes were published individually over a number of years and made available for sale separately.
The Twentieth Century Encyclopedia of Catholicism was intended to cover every aspect of the Catholic faith. Most of the authors occupied major posts in Catholic universities. Because most of the participating authors were European, the books were translated into English under the supervision of Lancelot Sheppard. The resulting works were approved by separate editorial boards in the United States and England. The individual books were also reviewed by officials of the Catholic Church, who granted the Church's imprimatur to each volume. [1]
This series of books was originally planned to comprise 150 volumes organized into 15 sections encompassing general topics such as belief, faith, the nature of man, the Bible, etc. However, when completed, the series consisted of 16 sections; this was accomplished by reducing the size of the planned section covering Catholicism and the Arts from 13 volumes [2] to 6 volumes, and creating an additional section for Catholicism and Science that consisted of 8 volumes. [3] Ultimately the series consisted of 148 works of scholarship, as well as a "double-sized" index that was assigned two volume numbers.
The contemporary reaction to The Twentieth Century Encyclopedia of Catholicism was quite favorable. Besides the Catholic press and academics praising the series, the secular Saturday Review proclaimed it, "An enterprise of great scope in the intellectual and spiritual life of contemporary Catholicism." [4] The series was awarded the Thomas More Association Medal[ citation needed ] "for the most distinguished contribution to Catholic publishing in 1958." [5]
Hawthorn Books made an announcement in January 1958 that it was preparing to publish a new Catholic encyclopedia. The firm advised that it was planning on releasing the English language version of a French Catholic encyclopedia currently being published; at that time, 40 volumes of the French version were already in print. [6] Instead of using the large folio format typically used in encyclopedias, the individual volumes were published in the much smaller octavo format, each about 125-150 pages in length. Each volume, while germane to the topic of its section, was meant to be self-contained with its own citations and bibliography. [7]
The production was intended to be an international effort: with the books published in the U.S. by Hawthorn Books, in Canada by McClelland & Stewart Ltd, in Great Britain by Burnes Oates and Washbourne, in France by Librairie Arthème Fayard, and in Germany by Paul Pattlock Verlag. [8] However, it is unknown if the publishing ventures besides those in the United States and France occurred.[ citation needed ]
The books within the series were planned to be published over a period of 75 months. Subscribers could purchase them at a rate of two-books-a-month for $5.00. If purchased individually, the books were sold for $3.50 each. [9] The order in which the volumes were published did not coincide with the volume numbers within the series; for example, the first book published, What is the Bible?, was actually assigned volume #60 within the structure of the encyclopedia.
Publication of The Twentieth Century Encyclopedia of Catholicism started in September 1958 and by December 1964, 128 of the volumes had been published. However, production of the series took longer than planned and not all of the initially projected books were published. The final volume, the index, was not published until 1971. Also, while most of the volumes of the encyclopedia (94 by September 1962) were published before the beginning of the Second Vatican Council, some were published after the conclusion of that ecumenical council and reflect its influence.
All four of the men that formed the senior editorial team were well-established Catholic authors, academics, and editors. [10]
The Twentieth Century Encyclopedia of Catholicism was divided into sixteen sections, each of which was intended to explore a topic within the Catholic faith more deeply. The table below lists the sections and their topics.
Section | Topic | Section | Topic | |
---|---|---|---|---|
I | Knowledge and Faith | IX | The Church and the Modern World | |
II | The Basic Truths | X | The Worship of the Church | |
III | The Nature of Man | XI | Catholicism and Literature | |
IV | The Means of Redemption | XII | Catholicism and the Arts | |
V | The Life of Faith | XIII | Catholicism and Science | |
VI | The Word of God | XIV | Outside the Church | |
VII | The History of the Church | XV | Non-Christian Beliefs | |
VIII | The Organization of the Church | XVI | General and Supplementary Volumes | |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | The Achievements of Vatican II | Hollis, Christopher | Feb-67 | 141 |
2 | Is Theology a Science? | Chenu, Marie-Dominique; Green-Armytage; Adrian Howell North | 1959 | 23 |
3 | The Meaning of Tradition | Congar, Yves | 1964 | 126 |
4 | What is Dogma? | Journet, Charles | Jul-64 | 121 |
5 | Do Dogmas Change? | Rondet, Henri | May-61 | 65 |
6 | What is Faith? | Joly, Eugène | Sep-58 | 2 |
7 | The Debate on Birth Control | Bauer, Andrew (ed) | 1969 | 148 |
8 | Myth or Mystery? | Daniélou, Jean | Jun-68 | 145 |
9 | Revelation and Reason | Broglie, Guy de | 1965 | 131 |
10 | Is There a Christian Philosophy? | Nédoncelle, Maurice | Apr-60 | 39 |
11 | The Origins of Christian Philosophy | Tresmontant, Claude | Jan-63 | 99 |
12 | Medieval Christian Philosophy | Delhaye, Philippe | 1960 | 45 |
13 | The Basis of Belief | Trethowan, Illtyd | Feb-61 | 59 |
14 | Christianity and Science | Abelé, Jean | Oct-61 | 76 |
15 | The God of Reason | Jolivet, Régis | Nov-58 | 6 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
16 | The Worship of God | Philippe, M.-D. (Marie-Dominique) | Sep-59 | 26 |
17 | What is the Trinity? | Piault, Bernard. | Feb-59 | 11 |
18 | The Holy Spirit | Henry, Antonin Marcel | Oct-60 | 51 |
19 | The Creation | Mouiren, Trophime | Dec-62 | 98 |
20 | The Problem of Evil | Petit, François, O. Praem | Sep-59 | 25 |
21 | Who is the Devil? | Cristiani, Léon | Oct-58 | 4 |
22 | Freedom and Providence | Pontifex, Mark | Sep-60 | 49 |
23 | The Theology of Grace | Daujat, Jean | May-59 | 18 |
24 | What is the Incarnation? | Ferrier, Francis, | Jul-62 | 90 |
25 | What is Redemption? | Philippe de la Trinité, Father | Sep-61 | 72 |
26 | The Communion of Saints | Lamirande, Émilien | Jan-63 | 100 |
27 | Faith, Hope and Charity | Bars, Henry | May-61 | 66 |
28 | Life After Death | Becqué, Maurice, and Becqué, Louis | Aug-60 | 48 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
29 | The Origins of Man | Cristiani, Léon | Nov-58 | 5 |
30 | Evolution | Collin, Rémy | Nov-59 | 29 |
31 | What is Man? | Le Trocquer, René | Feb-61 | 60 |
32 | What is Life? | Biot, René | Mar-59 | 13 |
33 | Personal Responsibility | Lawlor, Monica Mary | Nov-63 | 111 |
34 | Man in His Environment | Folliet, Joseph | Sep-63 | 108 |
35 | Man and Metaphysics | Jolivet, Régis | Aug-61 | 71 |
36 | Psychical Phenomena | Omez, Réginald | Dec-58 | 7 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
37 | Prayer | Daujat, Jean | Dec-64 | 127 |
38 | The Nature of Mysticism | Knowles, David | Oct-66 | 138 |
39 | Spiritual Writers of the Early Church | Cayré, Fulbert | Jan-59 | 10 |
40 | Spiritual Writers of the Middle Ages | Sitwell, Gerard, O.S.B. | Sep-61 | 71 |
41 | Post-Reformation Spirituality | Cognet, Louis | Oct-59 | 28 |
42 | Spiritual Writers in Modern Times | Sheppard, Lancelot C. (Lancelot Capel) | 1967 | 143 |
43 | True and False Possession | Lhermitte, Jean | Mar-63 | 101 |
44 | Mary The Mother of God | Suenens, Léon Joseph | Oct-59 | 27 |
45 | The Devotion to Our Lady | Graef, Hilda C. | Aug-63 | 106 |
46 | What is a Saint? | Douillet, Jacques | Oct-58 | 3 |
47 | What is an Angel? | Régamey, P.-R. (Pie-Raymond) | Jan-60 | 33 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
48 | What is the Church? | Bovis, André de | Nov-61 | 77 |
49 | What is a Sacrament? | Piault, Bernard | Oct-63 | 110 |
50 | Christian Initiation | McCormack, Arthur | 1969 | 147 |
51 | Penance and Absolution | Barton, John M. T. (John Mackintosh Tilney) | Apr-61 | 63 |
52 | What is the Eucharist? | Nicolas, Maria Iosephus | Aug-60 | 47 |
53 | What is a Priest? | Lécuyer, Joseph | Jul-59 | 21 |
54 | Christian Marriage | Fabrègues, Jean de | Dec-59 | 31 |
55 | Death and the Christian | Didier, Jean-Charles | Mar-61 | 61 |
56 | What is Christian Life? | Liégé, Pierre André | Nov-61 | 78 |
57 | The Enigma of the Stigmata | Biot, René | Dec-62 | 97 |
58 | Christian Ethics | Hawkins, D. J. B. (Denis John Bernard) | Dec-63 | 113 |
59 | Christianity and Money | Leclercq, Jacques | May-59 | 17 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
60 | What is the Bible? | Daniel-Rops, Henri | Sep-58 | 1 |
61 | The Promised Land | Blanchard, Raoul; Du Buit, F. M. (François Michel) | Sep-66 | 137 |
62 | Biblical Archaeology | Du Buit, F. M. (François Michel) | Dec-60 | 55 |
63 | Biblical Criticism | Steinmann, Jean | Dec-58 | 8 |
64 | God's Word At Mass | Koenig, John H. | Jan-67 | 139 |
65 | The Religion of Israel | Gelin, Albert | 1959 | 16 |
66 | The Prophets | Dheilly, Joseph | 1960 | 56 |
67 | The Sources for the Life of Christ | Amiot, F. (François), P.S.S. ; Danielou, Jean, S.J.; Brunot, Amedee, S.C.J.; Daniel-Rops, Henri | Aug-62 | 92 |
68 | The Life of Our Lord | Daniel-Rops, Henri | Nov-64 | 125 |
69 | What is the Gospel? | Paupert, Jean-Marie | Oct-62 | 95 |
70 | St. Paul and His Message | Brunot, Amédée | Jul-59 | 22 |
71 | The Old Testament Apocrypha | Dimier, Catherine | Jun-64 | 120 |
72 | The New Testament Apocrypha | Hervieux, Jacques | Nov-60 | 53 |
73 | Judaism | Démann, Paul | Aug-61 | 72 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
74 | Christian Beginnings | Zeiller, Jacques | Nov-60 | 54 |
75 | The Dawn of the Middle Ages | Palanque, Jean-Rémy | Sep-60 | 50 |
76 | The Early Middle Ages | Guillemain, Bernard | Jul-60 | 46 |
77 | The Later Middle Ages | Guillemain, Bernard | Jun-60 | 44 |
78 | The Revolt against the Church | Cristiani, Léon | Jun-62 | 88 |
79 | The Age of Absolutism | Braure, Maurice | Dec-63 | 114 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
80 | What is Canon Law? | Metz, Rene | Jan-60 | 34 |
81 | The Papacy | Ormesson, Wladimir, comte d' | Feb-59 | 12 |
82 | The Ecumenical Councils | Dvornik, Francis | Jan-61 | 57 |
83 | What is a Bishop? | Urtasun, Joseph | Aug-62 | 91 |
84 | What is a Cardinal? | Lierde, Petrus Canisius van, Bp., and Giraud, Alexandre | Jul-64 | 122 |
85 | Religions Orders of Men | Canu, Jean | Feb-60 | 36 |
86 | Religions Orders of Women | Malard, Suzanne | Oct-64 | 123 |
87 | Secular Institutes | Reidy, Gabriel | May-62 | 85 |
88 | The Catholic Spirit | Rétif, André | Jun-59 | 19 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
89 | Church and State | Woodruff, Douglas | Dec-61 | 79 |
90 | Christianity and Economics | Hollis, Christopher | Jan-61 | 58 |
91 | Atheism | Borne, Etienne | Jul-61 | 69 |
92 | Catholicism in English-Speaking Lands | Carthy, M. P. (Mary Peter) | Feb-64 | 116 |
93 | Psychiatry and the Christian | Dominian, Jack | Sep-62 | 93 |
94 | Technology and Religion | Queffélec, Henri | Feb-64 | 115 |
95 | The Christian and World Integration | Leclercq, Jacques | Apr-63 | 103 |
96 | Christianity and Communism | Chambre, Henri | Apr-60 | 40 |
97 | Christianity and Colonialism | Delavignette, Robert Louis | Jun-64 | 119 |
98 | Holiness in Action | Cluny, Roland | Apr-63 | 104 |
99 | History of the Missions | Vaulx, Bernard de | Apr-61 | 64 |
100 | Missions in the World Today | Millot, René Pierre | Jul-61 | 70 |
101 | The Contribution of German Catholicism | Dru, Alexander | Oct-63 | 109 |
102 | The Church's Mission in the World | Rétif, Louis and Rétif, André Rétif | Apr-62 | 84 |
103 | The Church and Sex | Trevett, Reginald Frederick | Mar-60 | 37 |
104 | The Church and the Workingman | Cronin, John F. (John Francis); Flannery, Harry W. | Nov-65 | 134 |
105 | Christian Charity in Action | Riquet, Michel | Dec-61 | 80 |
106 | International Morality | Soras, Alfred de | Aug-63 | 105 |
107 | Why We Believe | Cristiani, Léon | Apr-59 | 15 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
108 | The Spirit of Worship | Lefebvre, Gaspar, O.S.B | Nov-59 | 30 |
109 | The Liturgical Books | Sheppard, Lancelot C. (Lancelot Capel) | Oct-62 | 96 |
110 | History of the Mass | Amiot, F. (François) | Jan-59 | 9 |
111 | The Mass in the West | Sheppard, Lancelot C. (Lancelot Capel) | Jan-62 | 82 |
112 | Eastern Liturgies | Dalmais, Irénée Henri | May-60 | 42 |
113 | The Christian Calendar | Denis-Boulet, Noële M. | Jun-60 | 43 |
114 | Vestments and Church Furniture | Lesage, Robert | Mar-60 | 38 |
115 | The Liturgical Movement | By the sacerdotal communities of Saint-Sev́erin of Paris and Saint-Joseph of Nice | Apr-64 | 118 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
116 | Sacred Languages | Auvray, Paul; Poulain, Pierrre; Blaise, Albert, | Feb-60 | 35 |
117 | Contemporary Christian Writers | Foster, Joseph R. | Nov-63 | 112 |
118 | Christian Poetry | Jennings, Elizabeth | Apr-65 | 130 |
119 | Modern Christian Literature | Kranz, Gisbert | Mar-61 | 62 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
120 | Church Building | Rykwert, Joseph | Jan-66 | 136 |
121 | Early Christian Art | Syndicus, Eduard | Jan-62 | 81 |
122 | Christian Sculpture | Debidour, Victor-Henry | 1968 | 146 |
123 | Modern Christian Art | Wilson, Winefride. | Nov-65 | 133 |
124 | Christian Theatre | Speaight, Robert | May-60 | 41 |
125 | Christian Music | Robertson, Alec | Oct-61 | 75 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
126 | Linguistics, Language and Religion | Crystal, David | Apr-65 | 129 |
127 | Cosmology and Christianity | Peach, John Vincent | Aug-65 | 132 |
128 | Nuclear Physics in Peace and War | Hodgson, P. E. (Peter Edward) | Jun-61 | 67 |
129 | Medicine and Morals | Marshall, John | Oct-60 | 52 |
130 | Science and Religion | Chauchard, Paul | Jul-62 | 89 |
131 | Cybernetics | Moray, Neville | Sep-63 | 107 |
132 | World Poverty and the Christian | McCormack, Arthur | Mar-63 | 102 |
133 | Man's Intervention in Nature | Garrigan, Owen | Sep-67 | 144 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
134 | The Contemporary Christian | Corbishley, Thomas | Jan-67 | 140 |
135 | The Spirit of Eastern Orthodoxy | Le Guillou, M.-J. (Marie-Joseph) | Apr-62 | 83 |
136 | Heresies and Heretics | Cristiani, Léon | Jun-59 | 20 |
137 | Protestantism | Tavard, George H. (George Henry) | Dec-59 | 32 |
138 | Christian Unity | Boyer, Charles | May-62 | 86 |
139 | Christian Sects | Algermissen, Konrad | Jun-62 | 87 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order |
---|---|---|---|---|
140 | Primitive and Prehistoric Religions | Bergounioux, F.-M. (Frédéric-Marie); Goetz, Joseph | Jan-66 | 135 |
141 | Religions of the Ancient East | Drioton, Étienne | 1965 | 134 |
142 | Greek and Roman Religion | Hus, Alain | Sep-62 | 94 |
143 | Mohammedanism | Gardet, Louis | Jun-61 | 68 |
144 | Hinduism | Lemaître, Solange | Aug-59 | 24 |
145 | Buddhism | Berry, Thomas | Feb-67 | 142 |
146 | Christianity and Other Religions | Zaehner, R. C. (Robert Charles) | Apr-64 | 117 |
Volume | Title | Author(s) | Date | Publication Order | Note |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
147 | What is Society? | Zahn, Gordon C. (Gordon Charles) | Dec-64 | 128 | |
148 | Law and Morals | St. John-Stevas, Norman | Oct-64 | 124 | |
149 & 150 | Index | Sprug, Joseph W. | 1971 | one book assigned two volume numbers |
Mortimer Jerome Adler was an American philosopher, educator, encyclopedist, and popular author. As a philosopher he worked within the Aristotelian and Thomistic traditions. He lived for long stretches in New York City, Chicago, San Francisco, and San Mateo, California. He taught at Columbia University and the University of Chicago, served as chairman of the Encyclopædia Britannica board of editors, and founded the Institute for Philosophical Research.
The Encyclopædia Britannica Eleventh Edition (1910–1911) is a 29-volume reference work, an edition of the Encyclopædia Britannica. It was developed during the encyclopaedia's transition from a British to an American publication. Some of its articles were written by the best-known scholars of the time. This edition of the encyclopaedia, containing 40,000 entries, has entered the public domain and is easily available on the Internet. Its use in modern scholarship and as a reliable source has been deemed problematic due to the outdated nature of some of its content. Modern scholars have deemed some articles as cultural artifacts of the 19th and early 20th centuries.
The Dictionary of National Biography (DNB) is a standard work of reference on notable figures from British history, published since 1885. The updated Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (ODNB) was published on 23 September 2004 in 60 volumes and online, with 50,113 biographical articles covering 54,922 lives.
The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians is an encyclopedic dictionary of music and musicians. Along with the German-language Die Musik in Geschichte und Gegenwart, it is one of the largest reference works on the history and theory of music. Earlier editions were published under the titles A Dictionary of Music and Musicians, and Grove's Dictionary of Music and Musicians; the work has gone through several editions since the 19th century and is widely used. In recent years it has been made available as an electronic resource called Grove Music Online, which is now an important part of Oxford Music Online.
The Great Soviet Encyclopedia is one of the largest Russian-language encyclopedias, published in the Soviet Union from 1926 to 1990. After 2002, the encyclopedia's data was partially included into the later Bolshaya rossiyskaya entsiklopediya in an updated and revised form. The GSE claimed to be "the first Marxist–Leninist general-purpose encyclopedia".
The Catholic Encyclopedia: An International Work of Reference on the Constitution, Doctrine, Discipline, and History of the Catholic Church is an English-language encyclopedia published in the United States and designed to serve the Catholic Church. The first volume appeared in March 1907 and the last three volumes appeared in 1912, followed by a master index volume in 1914 and later supplementary volumes. It was designed "to give its readers full and authoritative information on the entire cycle of Catholic interests, action and doctrine".
The Cambridge History of English and American Literature is an encyclopedia of literary criticism that was published by Cambridge University Press between 1907 and 1921. Edited and written by an international panel of 171 leading scholars and thinkers of the early twentieth century, its 18 volumes comprise 303 chapters and more than 11,000 pages. The English-literature chapters begin with Old English poetry and end with the late Victorian era. Coverage of American literature ranges from colonial and revolutionary periods through the early twentieth century.
The Lancelot-Grail, also known as the Vulgate Cycle or the Pseudo-Map Cycle, is an early 13th-century French Arthurian literary cycle consisting of interconnected prose episodes of chivalric romance in Old French. The cycle of unknown authorship, presenting itself as a chronicle of actual events, retells the legend of King Arthur by focusing on the love affair between Lancelot and Guinevere as well as the religious quest for the Holy Grail, expanding on the works of Robert de Boron and Chrétien de Troyes.
The New Catholic Encyclopedia (NCE) is a multi-volume reference work on Roman Catholic history and belief edited by the faculty of The Catholic University of America. The NCE was originally published by McGraw-Hill in 1967. A second edition, which gave up the articles more reminiscent of a general encyclopedia, was published in 2002.
The Encyclopædia Britannica has been published continuously since 1768, appearing in fifteen official editions. Several editions have been amended with multi-volume "supplements", consisted of previous editions with added supplements or gone drastic re-organizations (15th). In recent years, digital versions of the Britannica have been developed, both online and on optical media. Since the early 1930s, the Britannica has developed several "spin-off" products to leverage its reputation as a reliable reference work and educational tool.
The Chronicles and Memorials of Great Britain and Ireland during the Middle Ages, widely known as the Rolls Series, is a major collection of British and Irish historical materials and primary sources published as 99 works in 253 volumes between 1858 and 1911. Almost all the great medieval English chronicles were included: most existing editions, published by scholars of the 17th and 18th centuries, were considered to be unsatisfactory. The scope was also extended to include legendary, folklore and hagiographical materials, and archival records and legal tracts. The series was government-funded, and takes its unofficial name from the fact that its volumes were published "by the authority of Her Majesty's Treasury, under the direction of the Master of the Rolls", who was the official custodian of the records of the Court of Chancery and other courts, and nominal head of the Public Record Office.
Henri Daniel-Rops was a French Roman Catholic writer and historian whose real name was Henri Petiot.
Lexikon für Theologie und Kirche is a German-language Catholic theological encyclopedia. Three editions have appeared so far, all published by Herder-Verlag in Freiburg im Breisgau.
The Library of the Fathers, more properly A library of fathers of the holy Catholic church: anterior to the division of the East and West, was a series of around 50 volumes of the Church Fathers, annotated in English translation, published 1838 to 1881 by John Henry Parker. Edited by Edward Bouverie Pusey and others including John Keble and John Henry Newman, this series of editions is closely associated with the origins of the Oxford Movement.
Kim Yong-ik, also known as Yong Ik Kim, was an early Korean–American writer originally from Tongyeong, Korea. His works were primarily in English but also translated into other languages such as German and Korean.
Encyclopedias have progressed from the beginning of history in written form, through medieval and modern times in print, and most recently, displayed on computer and distributed via computer networks.
Knowledge was a British weekly educational magazine for children which was assembled in blue binders into an encyclopedia.
John Douglas Woodruff (1897–1978) was the editor of the Tablet and later chairman of the Catholic publishers Burns & Oates.
Hawthorn Books was an American publishing firm located in New York City that operated from 1952 to 1977. Originally founded as a subsidiary of Prentice-Hall, Hawthorn Books went out of business after its publishing assets were acquired by E. P. Dutton.
As initially planned, The Twentieth Century Encyclopedia of Catholicism was to include 13 books in the section covering Catholicism and the Arts. The original selection of book titles to be encompassed within this section is shown in the table below: