Venetic theory

Last updated

The Venetic theory (Slovene : venetska teorija) is a pseudohistorical interpretation of the origin of the Slovenes that denies the Slavic settlement of the Eastern Alps in the 6th century, claiming that proto-Slovenes (also regarded as the Veneti people by the proponents of the Venetic theory) have inhabited the region since ancient times. During the 1980s and 1990s, it gained wide attention in Slovenia and the former Yugoslavia. The Venetic theory has been rejected by scholars. [1] [2] [3]

Contents

A version of the Venetic theory states that most of Central Europe and portions of today's northern Turkey were originally inhabited by a single people—the Veneti—a people that were subsequently dispersed by several invasions from the North in the form of Celtic and Germanic migrations and by the push northwards of the Roman Empire. According to this variant, the Armorican Veneti, the Adriatic Veneti, the Vistula Veneti as well as portion of the Illyrians and the Veneti of northern Turkey were all related people who spoke the same or similar language. The Venetic theory also counts among the Veneti several peoples of northern Spain and northern coastal France, as well as portions of Denmark, Wales, and Ireland. In this version, most of the northern Slavs as well as the Slovenes and some Croats are the last remnant of the original European Veneti.

Background

The Venetic theory was advanced in the mid-1980s by a group of Slovenian authors, notably Jožko Šavli, Matej Bor and Ivan Tomažič. In a book published in 1984, the three authors proposed an alternative view on the ethnogenesis of the Slovene people: they rejected the notion that the Slovenes were descended from Slavs that settled the area in the 6th century, claiming that the ancestors of the modern Slovenes were in fact a pre-Roman people they call Veneti (which would include the Adriatic Veneti, the Baltic Veneti, the Pannonians, the Noricans and some other peoples that traditional historiography identified either as Celts or Illyrians). According to the Venetic theory, the ancient Veneti spoke a proto-Slavic language from which modern Slovene and West Slavic languages emerged.

There were several similar antecedents to the Venetic theory. The priest Davorin Trstenjak (1817–1890) claimed that the Slovenes were ancient indigenous inhabitants of Slovenia and that Slavs had ruled Europe, Africa, and Asia in antiquity; however, he gave up these claims after he found they were scientifically untenable. The lawyer Henrik Tuma (1858–1935) declared that the Slovenes had been the first humans to settle Europe. The writer and journalist Franc Jeza (1916–1984) asserted that the Slovenes had Swedish origins. [4] :142

Premises

The Venetic theory is based on several different arguments. One is the traditional Germanic denomination of several Slavic peoples as Wends (Old High German : Winida > German : Wenden, Winden, Old High German : windisc > German : windisch, generally accepted to be a loan from Latin : Veneti [5] ); this tradition has remained in the archaic German name for the Sorbs (Wenden) and Slovenes (Windischen or Winden). Some medieval chroniclers also equated ancient Veneti with Slavs. The second argument on which the Venetic theory is based are supposed Slavic (proto-Slovene) toponyms found throughout Central Europe and Northern Italy; these toponyms have been studied by Šavli. The third argument is based on the ancient Venetic inscriptions found in North-Eastern Italy and in the Slovenian Littoral, which Bor interpreted as being Slavic.

Reception

The Venetic theory created a great controversy in the Slovenian and Yugoslav public in the late 1980s. Several of the most prominent Slovenian historians, such as Bogo Grafenauer and Peter Štih, entered into open polemics with the creators of the Venetic theory. On the other hand, many prominent public figures publicly supported the claims advanced by the Venetic theory, among them the designer Oskar Kogoj, the poet Zorko Simčič, the mechanical engineer Lucijan Vuga, and the nationalist politician Zmago Jelinčič Plemeniti. In the 1990s, the Venetic theory gained institutional support of the so-called World Slovenian Congress, publishing much of the literature advocating the Venetic theory and organizing international symposiums. The Venetic theory has also gained support in some nationalist circles. However, the Venetic theory has been challenged by certain writers, [4] :145 and it has been rejected by both mainstream linguists [1] [2] and historians. [6]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wends</span> Historical term for Slavs

Wends is a historical name for Slavs who inhabited present-day northeast Germany. It refers not to a homogeneous people, but to various peoples, tribes or groups depending on where and when it was used. In the modern day, communities identifying as Wendish exist in Slovenia, Austria, Lusatia, the United States, and Australia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Istria</span> Peninsula on the Adriatic Sea

Istria is the largest peninsula within the Adriatic Sea. The peninsula is located at the head of the Adriatic between the Gulf of Trieste and the Kvarner Gulf. It is shared by three countries: Croatia, Slovenia, and Italy, with 90% of surface area being part of Croatia. Croatia encapsulates most of the Istrian peninsula within Istria County.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carantania</span> Early medieval Slavic principality

Carantania, also known as Carentania, was a Slavic principality that emerged in the second half of the 7th century, in the territory of present-day southern Austria and north-eastern Slovenia. It was the predecessor of the March of Carinthia, created within the Carolingian Empire in 889.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Slovenes</span> Central European ethnic group living in historical Slovene lands

The Slovenes, also known as Slovenians, are a South Slavic ethnic group native to Slovenia, and adjacent regions in Italy, Austria and Hungary. Slovenes share a common ancestry, culture, history and speak Slovene as their native language. They are closely related to other South Slavic ethnic groups, as well as more distantly to West Slavs.

The Vistula Veneti, also called Baltic Veneti were an Indo-European people that inhabited the lands of central Europe east of the Vistula River and the Bay of Gdańsk. First mentioned in the 1st century AD by ancient Roman geographers who differentiated a group of peoples whose manner and language differed from that of the neighbouring Germanic and Sarmatian tribes. In the 6th century AD, Byzantine historians described the Veneti as the ancestors of the Slavs who during the second phase of the Migration Period crossed the northern frontiers of the Byzantine Empire.

"Naprej, zastava slave" or "Naprej, zastava Slave" is a former national anthem of Slovenia, used from 1860 to 1989. It is now used as the official service song of the Slovenian Armed Forces.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carantanians</span> Slavic people of the Early Middle Ages

Carantanians were a Slavic people of the Early Middle Ages, living in the principality of Carantania, later known as Carinthia, which covered present-day southern Austria and parts of Slovenia. They are considered ancestors of modern Slovenes, particularly Carinthian Slovenes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Venetic language</span> Extinct Indo-European language of northeast Italy

Venetic is an extinct Indo-European language, usually classified into the Italic subgroup, that was spoken by the Veneti people in ancient times in northeast Italy and part of modern Slovenia, between the Po Delta and the southern fringe of the Alps, associated with the Este culture.

Carinthian Slovenes or Carinthian Slovenians are the indigenous minority of Slovene ethnicity, living within borders of the Austrian state of Carinthia, neighboring Slovenia. Their status of the minority group is guaranteed in principle by the Constitution of Austria and under international law, and have seats in the National Ethnic Groups Advisory Council.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Windic March</span> Frontier march of the Holy Roman Empire

The Windic March was a medieval frontier march of the Holy Roman Empire, roughly corresponding to the Lower Carniola region in present-day Slovenia. In Slovenian historiography, it is known as the Slovene March.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Black panther (symbol)</span>

The black panther, also known as the Carantanian panther after the Medieval principality of Carantania, is a Carinthian historical symbol, which represents a stylized heraldic panther. As a heraldic symbol, it appeared on the coat of arms of the Carinthian Duke Herman II as well as of the Styrian Margrave Ottokar III. In this region it was most frequently imaged on various monuments and tombstones. The symbol can still be found in the coat of arms of the Austrian state of Styria, although in a white version on green background, dating back to the 13th century. The symbol is also widely used within structures of the Slovenian security forces; namely by the Slovenian Armed Forces and the Slovenian Police. Since 1991, there have been several proposals to replace the Slovenian coat of arms with the black panther.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Vojnomir</span> Military commander and Duke of the Slavs in Lower Pannonia

Vojnomir, Voynomir or Vonomir I was a Slavic military commander in Frankish service, the duke of Slavs in Lower Pannonia, who ruled from c. 790 to c. 800 or from 791 to c. 810 over an area that corresponds to modern-day Slavonia, Croatia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Slovene Lands</span> Areas where the Slovene language is spoken

The Slovene lands or Slovenian lands is the historical denomination for the territories in Central and Southern Europe where people primarily spoke Slovene. The Slovene lands were part of the Illyrian provinces, the Austrian Empire and Austria-Hungary. They encompassed Carniola, southern part of Carinthia, southern part of Styria, Istria, Gorizia and Gradisca, Trieste, and Prekmurje. Their territory more or less corresponds to modern Slovenia and the adjacent territories in Italy, Austria, Hungary, and Croatia, where autochthonous Slovene minorities live. In the areas where present-day Slovenia borders to neighboring countries, they were never homogeneously ethnically Slovene.

The settlement of the Eastern Alps region by early Slavs took place during the 6th to 8th centuries. It is part of the southward expansion of the early Slavs which would result in the characterization of the South Slavic group, and would ultimately result in the ethnogenesis of present-day Slovenes. The Eastern Alpine territories concerned comprise modern-day Slovenia, Eastern Friuli, in modern-day Northeast Italy, and large parts of modern-day Austria.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Matej Bor</span> Slovene writer and poet (1913–1993)

Matej Bor was the pen name of Vladimir Pavšič, who was a Slovene poet, translator, playwright, journalist, and Partisan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Simon Rutar</span> Slovenian historian and geographer (1851–1903)

Simon Rutar was a Slovene historian and geographer. He wrote primarily on the history and geography of the areas that are now part of the Slovenian Littoral, the Italian region of Friuli Venezia Giulia and the Croatian counties of Istria and Primorsko-Goranska.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Davorin Trstenjak</span> Slovene writer (1817-1890)

Davorin Trstenjak was a Slovene writer, historian and Roman Catholic priest.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Peter Štih</span> Slovenian historian

Peter Štih is a Slovenian historian, specialising in medieval history.

Jožko Šavli was a Slovene author, self-declared historian and high school teacher in economic sciences from Italy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bogo Grafenauer</span> Slovenian historian

Bogo Grafenauer was a Slovenian historian, who mostly wrote about medieval history in the Slovene Lands. Together with Milko Kos, Fran Zwitter, and Vasilij Melik, he was one of the founders of the so-called Ljubljana school of historiography.

References

  1. 1 2 Lencek, Rado (1990). "The Linguistic Premises of Matej Bor's Slovene-Venetic Theory". Slovene Studies . 12 (1): 75–86.
  2. 1 2 Priestly, Tom (1997). "Vandals, Veneti, Windischer: The Pitfalls of Amateur Historical Linguistics". Slovene Studies . 12 (1/2): 3–41.
  3. Priestly, Tom (2001). "Vandali, Veneti, Vindišarji: pasti amaterske historične lingvistike" [Vandals, Veneti, Vindishars: pitfalls of amateur historical linguistics]. Slavistična revija (in Slovenian). 49: 275–303.
  4. 1 2 Skrbiš, Zlatko (2008). "'The First Europeans' Fantasy of Slovenian Venetologists". In Svašek, Maruška (ed.). Postsocialism: Politics and Emotion in Central and Eastern Europe. New York: Berghahn Books. pp. 138–158.
  5. Sonderegger, Stefan (1979). Grundzüge deutscher Sprachgeschichte. Diachronie des Sprachsystems. Band I: Einführung – Genealogie – Konstanten [Basics of German language history. Diachrony of the language system. Volume I: Introduction - Genealogy - Constants] (in German). Berlin and New York: Walter de Gruyter. p. 37. ISBN   978-3-11-084200-5.
  6. Plut-Pregelj, Leopoldina; Rogel, Carole (2010). The A to Z of Slovenia. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow Press. p. 481.

Further reading