Vipeholm experiments

Last updated
Main building of Vipeholm hospital, now a secondary school Gymnasieskolan Vipan.jpg
Main building of Vipeholm hospital, now a secondary school

The Vipeholm experiments or Vipeholm Study (Swedish: Vipeholmsexperimenten) were a series of human experiments where patients of Vipeholm Hospital for the intellectually disabled in Lund, Sweden, were fed large amounts of sweets, including "extra sticky toffee"[ clarification needed ] to provoke dental caries (1945–1955). The experiments were sponsored both by the sugar industry and the dentist community, in an effort to determine whether carbohydrates affected the formation of cavities.

Contents

The experiments provided extensive knowledge about dental health and resulted in enough empirical data to link the intake of sugar to dental caries. [1] However, today they are considered to have violated multiple principles of medical ethics. [2] [3]

History

The National Dental Service of Sweden was established in 1938. [4] The state of dental health was not well-studied at the time, and cavities were widespread. It was suspected high sugar diets caused tooth decay, but there was no scientific proof. In 1945, the Medical Board commissioned a study on the subject, which would then become the Vipeholm experiments. [5]

Vipeholm was Sweden's largest facility for people with "severe intellectual and developmental disabilities" [6] and was chosen to be the site of the largest experiment ever run on humans in Sweden at the time. [7] Initially, Vipeholm employees were also a part of the experiment. [8]

What began in 1945 as government-sanctioned vitamin trials were converted in 1947 without the knowledge of the government. In consultation with the Medical Board, the researchers decided to substitute sugar for the vitamins. [8]

From 1947 to 1949, a group of patients were used as subjects in a full-scale experiment designed to bring about tooth decay. They were fed copious amounts of sweets, including toffee and chocolate. [9]

The sugar experiment lasted for two years. In 1949, the trials were revised again, now to test a more "normal" carbohydrate-rich diet. By then, the teeth of about fifty of the 660 subjects in the experiment had been completely damaged. [8] Nonetheless, the researchers felt that, scientifically speaking, the experiment was a success. [2]

One of the practical results of the study was the recommendation that it was better for children's teeth to eat sweets once per week, compared to a smaller total amount spread out over most of the week. This practice established itself in Swedish society, and still today many parents only allow their children sweets on Saturdays, known as lördagsgodis (Saturday candy). [10]

Delayed results

The confectionery industry supported the experiments [11] through donations of money and sweets. [12] Because the experiments had shown a clear link between sugar intake and dental cavities, the industry was not pleased with the results, and researchers delayed publication. When the study was finally made public in 1953, public debate arose over why the results had not been published earlier. [12]

The scientists were accused of having been bought by the industry. However, at the time there was not any public debate about the ethics of the experiments themselves. Modern attitudes in the dental profession are very different: a participant in the Vipeholm study, Bo Krasse, writes "It is obvious that a research ethics committee would not accept a project like the Vipeholm Study today." He explains "The need for the study was obvious to us as dentists" and states that the Swedish Parliament and then the news media debated the ethics of the study as early as 1953. [2]

Revelations

It was not until the 1990s that studies appeared about the ethical aspects of the Vipeholm experiments. [13] In 2000, the Swedish ombudsman for the disabled reported that the "excesses" of the study were not justified by the results. [14]

Elin Bommenel, a historian and doctoral student at Linköping University, performed a thorough study of the Vipeholm experiments in her dissertation, published in 2006. [15] She was the first researcher to gain access to the original documents from the experimental period at Vipeholm. Her research describes how the scientists found themselves caught between the divergent goals of research and patient care as well as being under immense pressure from both political and economic interests. [16]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dentistry</span> Branch of medicine

Dentistry, also known as dental medicine and oral medicine, is the branch of medicine focused on the teeth, gums, and mouth. It consists of the study, diagnosis, prevention, management, and treatment of diseases, disorders, and conditions of the mouth, most commonly focused on dentition as well as the oral mucosa. Dentistry may also encompass other aspects of the craniofacial complex including the temporomandibular joint. The practitioner is called a dentist.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Candy</span> Sweet confection

Candy, alternatively called sweets or lollies, is a confection that features sugar as a principal ingredient. The category, also called sugar confectionery, encompasses any sweet confection, including chocolate, chewing gum, and sugar candy. Vegetables, fruit, or nuts which have been glazed and coated with sugar are said to be candied.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Xylitol</span> Synthetic sweetener

Xylitol is a chemical compound with the formula C
5H
12O
5, or HO(CH2)(CHOH)3(CH2)OH; specifically, one particular stereoisomer with that structural formula. It is a colorless or white crystalline solid that is freely soluble in water. It can be classified as a polyalcohol and a sugar alcohol, specifically an alditol. The name derives from Ancient Greek: ξύλον, xyl[on] 'wood', with the suffix -itol used to denote sugar alcohols.

Teeth cleaning is part of oral hygiene and involves the removal of dental plaque from teeth with the intention of preventing cavities, gingivitis, and periodontal disease. People routinely clean their own teeth by brushing and interdental cleaning, and dental hygienists can remove hardened deposits (tartar) not removed by routine cleaning. Those with dentures and natural teeth may supplement their cleaning with a denture cleaner.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tooth decay</span> Deformation of teeth due to acids produced by bacteria

Tooth decay, also known as cavities or caries, is the breakdown of teeth due to acids produced by bacteria. The cavities may be a number of different colors from yellow to black. Symptoms may include pain and difficulty with eating. Complications may include inflammation of the tissue around the tooth, tooth loss and infection or abscess formation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Water fluoridation</span> Addition of fluoride to a water supply to reduce tooth decay

Water fluoridation is the controlled adjustment of fluoride to a public water supply solely to reduce tooth decay. Fluoridated water contains fluoride at a level that is effective for preventing cavities; this can occur naturally or by adding fluoride. Fluoridated water operates on tooth surfaces: in the mouth, it creates low levels of fluoride in saliva, which reduces the rate at which tooth enamel demineralizes and increases the rate at which it remineralizes in the early stages of cavities. Typically a fluoridated compound is added to drinking water, a process that in the U.S. costs an average of about $1.26 per person-year. Defluoridation is needed when the naturally occurring fluoride level exceeds recommended limits. In 2011, the World Health Organization suggested a level of fluoride from 0.5 to 1.5 mg/L, depending on climate, local environment, and other sources of fluoride. Bottled water typically has unknown fluoride levels.

<i>Streptococcus mutans</i> Species of bacterium

Streptococcus mutans is a facultatively anaerobic, gram-positive coccus commonly found in the human oral cavity and is a significant contributor to tooth decay. It is part of the "streptococci", an informal general name for all species in the genus Streptococcus. The microbe was first described by James Kilian Clarke in 1924.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pierre Fauchard</span> French dentist (1679–1761)

Pierre Fauchard was a French physician, credited as being the "father of modern dentistry". He is widely known for writing the first complete scientific description of dentistry, Le Chirurgien Dentiste, published in 1728. The book described basic oral anatomy and function, signs and symptoms of oral pathology, operative methods for removing decay and restoring teeth, periodontal disease (pyorrhea), orthodontics, replacement of missing teeth, and tooth transplantation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Early childhood caries</span> Dental disease of young children

Early childhood caries (ECC), formerly known as nursing bottle caries, baby bottle tooth decay, night bottle mouth and night bottle caries, is a disease that affects teeth in children aged between birth and 71 months. ECC is characterized by the presence of 1 or more decayed, missing, or filled tooth surfaces in any primary tooth. ECC has been shown to be a very common, transmissible bacterial infection, usually passed from the primary caregiver to the child.The main bacteria responsible for dental cavities are Streptococcus mutans (S.mutans) and Lactobacillus. There is also evidence that supports that those who are in lower socioeconomic populations are at greater risk of developing ECC.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dental public health</span>

Dental Public Health (DPH) is a para-clinical specialty of dentistry that deals with the prevention of oral disease and promotion of oral health. Dental public health is involved in the assessment of key dental health needs and coming up with effective solutions to improve the dental health of populations rather than individuals.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Oral hygiene</span> Cleaning the mouth by brushing the teeth and cleaning in between the teeth

Oral hygiene is the practice of keeping one's oral cavity clean and free of disease and other problems by regular brushing of the teeth and adopting good hygiene habits. It is important that oral hygiene be carried out on a regular basis to enable prevention of dental disease and bad breath. The most common types of dental disease are tooth decay and gum diseases, including gingivitis, and periodontitis.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Remineralisation of teeth</span>

Tooth remineralization is the natural repair process for non-cavitated tooth lesions, in which calcium, phosphate and sometimes fluoride ions are deposited into crystal voids in demineralised enamel. Remineralization can contribute towards restoring strength and function within tooth structure.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Willoughby D. Miller</span>

Willoughby Dayton Miller (1853–1907) was an American dentist and the first oral microbiologist.

Special needs dentistry, also known as special care dentistry, is a dental specialty that deals with the oral health problems of geriatric patients, patients with intellectual disabilities, and patients with other medical, physical, or psychiatric issues.

Evidence-based dentistry (EBD) is the dental part of the more general movement toward evidence-based medicine and other evidence-based practices. The pervasive access to information on the internet includes different aspects of dentistry for both the dentists and patients. This has created a need to ensure that evidence referenced to are valid, reliable and of good quality.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sweetened beverage</span> Type of beverage

A sweetened beverage is any beverage with added sugar. It has been described as "liquid candy". Consumption of sweetened beverages has been linked to weight gain, obesity, and associated health risks. According to the CDC, consumption of sweetened beverages is also associated with unhealthy behaviors like smoking, not getting enough sleep and exercise, and eating fast food often and not enough fruits regularly.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tooth pathology</span> Medical condition

Tooth pathology is any condition of the teeth that can be congenital or acquired. Sometimes a congenital tooth disease is called a tooth abnormality. These are among the most common diseases in humans The prevention, diagnosis, treatment and rehabilitation of these diseases are the base to the dentistry profession, in which are dentists and dental hygienists, and its sub-specialties, such as oral medicine, oral and maxillofacial surgery, and endodontics. Tooth pathology is usually separated from other types of dental issues, including enamel hypoplasia and tooth wear.

Unethical human experimentation is human experimentation that violates the principles of medical ethics. Such practices have included denying patients the right to informed consent, using pseudoscientific frameworks such as race science, and torturing people under the guise of research. Around World War II, Imperial Japan and Nazi Germany carried out brutal experiments on prisoners and civilians through groups like Unit 731 or individuals like Josef Mengele; the Nuremberg Code was developed after the war in response to the Nazi experiments. Countries have carried out brutal experiments on marginalized populations. Examples include American abuses during Project MKUltra and the Tuskegee syphilis experiments, and the mistreatment of indigenous populations in Canada and Australia. The Declaration of Helsinki, developed by the World Medical Association (WMA), is widely regarded as the cornerstone document on human research ethics.

Atraumatic restorative treatment (ART) is a method for cleaning out tooth decay from teeth using only hand instruments and placing a filling. It does not use rotary dental instruments to prepare the tooth and can be performed in settings with no access to dental equipment. No drilling or local anaesthetic injections are required. ART is considered a conservative approach, not only because it removes the decayed tissue with hand instruments, avoiding removing more tissue necessary which preserves as much tooth structure as possible, but also because it avoids pulp irritation and minimises patient discomfort. ART can be used for small, medium and deep cavities caused by dental caries.

Marita Rohr Inglehart is a psychologist, academic, and author. She is a Professor at the Department of Periodontics and Oral Medicine at the School of Dentistry, an Adjunct Professor at the Department of Psychology at the College of Literature, Arts and Sciences at the University of Michigan. Additionally, she also holds the position of Inaugural University Diversity and Social Transformation Professor at the University of Michigan.

References

  1. ↑ Gustafsson, BE; Quensel, CE; Lanke, LS; Lundqvist, C; Grahnen, H; Bonow, BE; Krasse, B (1954). "The Vipeholm dental caries study; the effect of different levels of carbohydrate intake on caries activity in 436 individuals observed for five years". Acta Odontologica Scandinavica. 11 (3–4): 232–64. doi:10.3109/00016355308993925. PMID   13196991.
  2. 1 2 3 Krasse, Bo (September 2009). "The Vipeholm Dental Caries Study: Recollections and Reflections 50 Years Later". Journal of Dental Research. 80 (9): 1785–1788. doi:10.1177/00220345010800090201. ISSN   0022-0345. PMID   11926233. S2CID   6314797.
  3. ↑ Ismail, Amid I.; Hasson, Hana; Sohn, Woosung (October 2001). "Dental Caries in the Second Millennium". Journal of Dental Education. 65 (10): 953–959. doi:10.1002/j.0022-0337.2001.65.10.tb03469.x. ISSN   0022-0337. PMID   11699996. S2CID   28149968.
  4. ↑ Nordenram, Ake; Astrand, Per; Nord, Per-Gunnar; Paulin, Gunnar; Feldmann, Hartmut (2005-01-01). "[Surgical treatment of diseases in the oral cavity and jaws]". Svensk Medicinhistorisk Tidskrift. 9 (1): 155–162. ISSN   1402-9871. PMID   17153182.
  5. ↑ Manley, Maxwell Christopher Graham; Lane, H. L.; Doshi, M. (2021-08-09). "Dental disadvantage for people with disability: a potential solution for a problematic area of care". Disability & Society. 36 (7): 1197–1202. doi: 10.1080/09687599.2021.1927672 . ISSN   0968-7599. S2CID   236362935.
  6. ↑ "The Swedish cavity experiments: How dentists rotted the teeth of the mentally handicapped to study candy's effect".
  7. ↑ Höjer, J. Axel; Maunsrach, Arvid Bernhard (1953-01-01). "Purposes and Organisation". Acta Odontologica Scandinavica. 11 (3–4): 195–206. doi:10.3109/00016355308993923. ISSN   0001-6357.
  8. 1 2 3 Seeman, Mary V. (2006-12-01). "Starvation in Psychiatric Institutions in Sweden". International Journal of Mental Health. 35 (4): 81–87. doi:10.2753/IMH0020-7411350409. ISSN   0020-7411. S2CID   72918681.
  9. ↑ Bommenel, Elin (2006). Sockerförsöket. Kariesexperimenten 1943–1960 på Vipeholms sjukhus för sinnesslöa (Doktorsavhandling (monografi) thesis). Arkiv.
  10. ↑ Lundqvist, Ida. "Vipeholmsexperimenten - P3 Dokumentär". sverigesradio.se (in Swedish). Retrieved 2021-08-07.
  11. ↑ Krasse, Bo (April 1989). "Why was the Vipeholm Study done and why have this symposium?". European Journal of Oral Sciences. 97 (2): 99–102. doi:10.1111/j.1600-0722.1989.tb01436.x. ISSN   0909-8836. PMID   2704980.
  12. 1 2 Bommenel, Elin (2006-03-31). "Sugar experiments at Vipeholm". Expertsvar. Retrieved 2023-03-23.
  13. ↑ Petersson B (1993). The mentally retarded as research subjects. A research ethics study of the Vipeholm investigations of 1945-1955. In: Studies in Research Ethics. No. 3. Hallberg M, editor. Göteborg: Centre for Research Ethics, pp. 1-32.[ verification needed ]
  14. ↑ Lööw, L (2000). "Ombudsman of the disabled: The excesses in Vipeholm are not worthy the result". Läkartidningen. 97 (6): 616, 619. PMID   10707490.
  15. ↑ Sugar experiments of mental patients, Innovations Report 2006-03-31
  16. ↑ Three short lectures on Vipeholm Hospital in Lund, Dr. Elin Bommenel talks about her research
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.