WHO SMART guidelines

Last updated

The WHO Smart Guidelines is a framework developed by the World Health Organization (WHO) to streamline the implementation of evidence-based health recommendations using digital technologies. The acronym "SMART" stands for Standards-based, Machine-readable, Adaptive, Requirements-based, and Testable, which outlines the structured approach used to translate traditional health guidelines into formats suitable for digital health systems.: [1] The objective of SMART guidelines is to promote adaptation of WHO guidelines while preserving fidelity of the evidence. [2]

Contents

Background

The WHO publishes numerous health guidelines that aim to improve healthcare delivery across different countries, especially in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). However, the adoption of these guidelines has been hindered by several challenges. Some key issues include difficulties in adapting global recommendations to local contexts, limited experience with integrating guidelines into digital health systems, and insufficient healthcare infrastructure. These obstacles have led to delays in the adoption of WHO guidelines by national health systems, sometimes taking several years to implement. [3] [2]

WHO SMART Guidelines attempt to address these issues by providing a transparent, and testable systematic pathway for countries to work through. Based on this approach, "Digital Adaptation Kits" that translate WHO guidelines into a common language that helps implementation. They are software-neutral, meaning they can be adapted into whichever software platform a country has elected to use, encouraging adoption. [4]

Components

The SMART guidelines framework is composed of five key layers, which systematically transition guidelines from traditional, human-readable formats to executable, machine-readable algorithms: [3]

SMART guideline layers
LayerContent TypeDescription
L1NarrativeEvidence-based recommendations in descriptive format primarily intended for human readability
L2OperationalSoftware-neutral documentation of requirements.
L3Machine-readableStructured software-neutral specifications with coding, terminology and interoperability standards
L4ExecutableSoftware that deliver the requirements through execution of static algorithms
L5DynamicExecutable dynamic algorithms that are optimized with advanced analytics and training.

Barriers to adoption

While the Smart Guidelines have been piloted in several countries with positive initial outcomes, there are significant challenges to their widespread adoption. A 2022 scoping review highlighted several barriers including [5]

Additionally, governance issues within member states have compounded these challenges, with a lack of accountability and transparency mechanisms further hindering the uptake of WHO guidelines. In some cases, WHO guidelines were considered technically unclear or difficult to implement, particularly for certain health conditions. [5]

To mitigate these issues, WHO has emphasized the need for global and local investments in capacity building, particularly in the areas of digital health expertise and infrastructure development. The use of the HL7 FHIR standard in the Smart Guidelines has also been a point of debate, as some argue that the scarcity of trained professionals in LMICs could initially limit its adoption. However, proponents note that the widespread adoption of global standards like FHIR can ultimately benefit all countries by encouraging shared investments and resources. [6]

Other global initiatives

The WHO Smart Guidelines are part of a broader global trend of digitizing clinical guidelines to make them more actionable in healthcare systems. For example, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in the United States developed the "Adapting Clinical Guidelines for the Digital Age" (ACG) initiative, which promotes a holistic approach to digital health guideline implementation. The CDC approach includes a 12-phase process for creating and implementing both written and computable guidelines. While the CDC's initiative took a comprehensive approach, the WHO initially focused its Smart Guidelines on specific domains, such as antenatal care, before expanding to other health areas. [6]

The WHO's top-down approach, which involves transitioning global narrative guidelines to digital formats and then adapting them locally, contrasts with the more decentralized, middle-out approaches seen in other contexts. [6] Some experts have suggested that including a SMART Guidelines statement on all current WHO guidelines might help broaden their adoption by promoting long-term alignment with the global digital health community.

Related Research Articles

The International Classification of Diseases (ICD) is a globally used medical classification used in epidemiology, health management and for clinical purposes. The ICD is maintained by the World Health Organization (WHO), which is the directing and coordinating authority for health within the United Nations System. The ICD is originally designed as a health care classification system, providing a system of diagnostic codes for classifying diseases, including nuanced classifications of a wide variety of signs, symptoms, abnormal findings, complaints, social circumstances, and external causes of injury or disease. This system is designed to map health conditions to corresponding generic categories together with specific variations, assigning for these a designated code, up to six characters long. Thus, major categories are designed to include a set of similar diseases.

Health Level Seven, abbreviated to HL7, is a range of global standards for the transfer of clinical and administrative health data between applications with the aim to improve patient outcomes and health system performance. The HL7 standards focus on the application layer, which is "layer 7" in the Open Systems Interconnection model. The standards are produced by Health Level Seven International, an international standards organization, and are adopted by other standards issuing bodies such as American National Standards Institute and International Organization for Standardization. There are a range of primary standards that are commonly used across the industry, as well as secondary standards which are less frequently adopted.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Electronic health record</span> Digital collection of patient and population electronically stored health information

An electronic health record (EHR) also known as an electronic medical record (EMR) or personal health record (PHR) is the systematized collection of patient and population electronically stored health information in a digital format. These records can be shared across different health care settings. Records are shared through network-connected, enterprise-wide information systems or other information networks and exchanges. EHRs may include a range of data, including demographics, medical history, medication and allergies, immunization status, laboratory test results, radiology images, vital signs, personal statistics like age and weight, and billing information.

The Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society (HIMSS) is an American not-for-profit organization dedicated to improving health care in quality, safety, cost-effectiveness and access through the best use of information technology and management systems. It was founded in 1961 as the Hospital Management Systems Society. It is now headquartered in Chicago, Illinois. The society has more than 100,000 individuals, 480 provider organizations, 470 non-profit partners and 650 health services organizations. HIMSS is a US 501(c)6 organization.

A personal health record (PHR) is a health record where health data and other information related to the care of a patient is maintained by the patient. This stands in contrast to the more widely used electronic medical record, which is operated by institutions and contains data entered by clinicians to support insurance claims. The intention of a PHR is to provide a complete and accurate summary of an individual's medical history which is accessible online. The health data on a PHR might include patient-reported outcome data, lab results, and data from devices such as wireless electronic weighing scales or from a smartphone.

Public health informatics has been defined as the systematic application of information and computer science and technology to public health practice, research, and learning. It is one of the subdomains of health informatics, data management applied to medical systems.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">European Institute for Health Records</span>

The European Institute for Health Records or EuroRec Institute is a non-profit organization founded in 2002 as part of the ProRec initiative. On 13 May 2003, the institute was established as a non-profit organization under French law. Current President of EuroRec is Prof. Dipak Kalra. The institute is involved in the promotion of high quality Electronic Health Record systems in the European Union. One of the main missions of the institute is to support, as the European authorised certification body, EHRs certification development, testing and assessment by defining functional and other criteria.

DHIS2 is a free and open-source software platform for the collection, reporting, analysis and dissemination of aggregate and individual-level data.

Imaging informatics, also known as radiology informatics or medical imaging informatics, is a subspecialty of biomedical informatics that aims to improve the efficiency, accuracy, usability and reliability of medical imaging services within the healthcare enterprise. It is devoted to the study of how information about and contained within medical images is retrieved, analyzed, enhanced, and exchanged throughout the medical enterprise.

mHealth Medicine and public health supported by mobile devices

mHealth is an abbreviation for mobile health, a term used for the practice of medicine and public health supported by mobile devices. The term is most commonly used in reference to using mobile communication devices, such as mobile phones, tablet computers and personal digital assistants (PDAs), and wearable devices such as smart watches, for health services, information, and data collection. The mHealth field has emerged as a sub-segment of eHealth, the use of information and communication technology (ICT), such as computers, mobile phones, communications satellite, patient monitors, etc., for health services and information. mHealth applications include the use of mobile devices in collecting community and clinical health data, delivery/sharing of healthcare information for practitioners, researchers and patients, real-time monitoring of patient vital signs, the direct provision of care as well as training and collaboration of health workers.

Health information technology (HIT) is health technology, particularly information technology, applied to health and health care. It supports health information management across computerized systems and the secure exchange of health information between consumers, providers, payers, and quality monitors. Based on a 2008 report on a small series of studies conducted at four sites that provide ambulatory care – three U.S. medical centers and one in the Netherlands, the use of electronic health records (EHRs) was viewed as the most promising tool for improving the overall quality, safety and efficiency of the health delivery system.

The Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources standard is a set of rules and specifications for the secure exchange of electronic health care data. It is designed to be flexible and adaptable, so that it can be used in a wide range of settings and with different health care information systems. The standard describes data formats and elements and an application programming interface (API) for exchanging electronic health records (EHR). The standard was created by the Health Level Seven International (HL7) health-care standards organization.

Digital health is a discipline that includes digital care programs, technologies with health, healthcare, living, and society to enhance the efficiency of healthcare delivery and to make medicine more personalized and precise. It uses information and communication technologies to facilitate understanding of health problems and challenges faced by people receiving medical treatment and social prescribing in more personalised and precise ways. The definitions of digital health and its remits overlap in many ways with those of health and medical informatics.

InterSystems HealthShare is a comprehensive healthcare informatics platform designed to serve hospitals, Integrated Delivery Networks (IDNs), and regional and national Health Information Exchanges (HIEs).

Health Level Seven International (HL7) is a non-profit ANSI-accredited standards development organization that develops standards that provide for global health data interoperability.

The Global Digital Exemplar (GDE) programme is an NHS England initiative to achieve digital transformation in selected exemplar organisations and to create a knowledge sharing ecosystem to spread learning from these exemplars. The programme is to enable "digitally advanced" NHS trusts to share knowledge with other NHS trusts, specifically knowledge gained during the implementation of IT systems, and especially experience from introducing electronic health record (EHR) systems. The GDE project is expected to last two to three and a half years; with the most digitally advanced trusts on the shorter time scale.

Ecosystem-based adaptation encompasses a broad set of approaches to adapt to climate change. They all involve the management of ecosystems and their services to reduce the vulnerability of human communities to the impacts of climate change. The Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) defines EBA as "the use of biodiversity and ecosystem services as part of an overall adaptation strategy to help people to adapt to the adverse effects of climate change".

Clinical data standards are used to store and communicate information related to healthcare so that its meaning is unambiguous. They are used in clinical practice, in activity analysis and finding, and in research and development.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">SMART Health Card</span> Vaccine passport framework

The SMART Health Card framework is an open source immunity passport program designed to store and share medical information in paper or digital form. It was initially launched as a vaccine passport during the COVID-19 pandemic, but is envisioned for use for other infectious diseases. SMART Health Cards include a QR code which can be scanned and verified using the official SMART Health Card Verifier mobile app, supported by Apple and Android. It was rolled out by the Vaccination Credential Initiative (VCI) based on technology developed at Boston Children's Hospital, and standards set by Health Level Seven International (HL7) and the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C). It is recognized by the International Organization for Standardization.

References

  1. "From paper to digital pathway: WHO launches first 'SMART Guidelines'".
  2. 1 2 "SMART Guidelines".
  3. 1 2 https://www.thelancet.com/journals/landig/article/PIIS2589-7500(21)00038-8/fulltext
  4. "Making WHO guidelines practical and actionable through digital adaptation kits". 30 November 2021.
  5. 1 2 Saluja, K.; Reddy, K. S.; Wang, Q.; Zhu, Y.; Li, Y.; Chu, X.; Li, R.; Hou, L.; Horsley, T.; Carden, F.; Bartolomeos, K.; Hatcher Roberts, J. (2022). "Improving WHO's understanding of WHO guideline uptake and use in Member States: A scoping review". Health Research Policy and Systems. 20 (1): 98. doi: 10.1186/s12961-022-00899-y . PMC   9449928 . PMID   36071468.
  6. 1 2 3 Saban, Martin; Zavala, Denise; Lopez Osornio, Alejandro; Kaminker, Diego; Díaz, Martin; Rubinstein, Adolfo; Esteban, Santiago; Rizzato Lede, Daniel A. (2024). "Understanding WHO SMART Guidelines: Narrative Review of an Innovative Global Digital Health Approach". Digital Health and Informatics Innovations for Sustainable Health Care Systems. Studies in Health Technology and Informatics. Vol. 316. pp. 1994–1998. doi:10.3233/SHTI240825. ISBN   978-1-64368-533-5. PMID   39176884.