Yacovelli v. Moeser

Last updated

The Yacovelli v. Moeser case was a result of a summer reading program for new students implemented by the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in 2002 that was objected to by several groups and was referred to by the media as the UNC-Qur'an Controversy.

Contents

Controversy

Professor Carl W. Ernst of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (UNC) was asked if there was a good translation of the Qur'an that would be suitable for its Summer reading program of 2002. [1] The program amounts to reading a short book, writing a short paper, and participating in small group discussion for two hours. [2] He suggested Michael Sells (1999). Approaching the Qur'an. White Cloud Press. Ernst noted that if it were not available he couldn't recommend one for the program. [1] The book was adopted and the program set. [2]

On May 21, 2002, conservative commentator Brit Hume of Fox News released the first known news story on the forthcoming program [3] followed by NPR on May 29. [4] Early responses from parents directly to the university were generally negative though others said it was a courageous choice. Initially the ACLU and conservative commentators were concerned that a favoritism in religion was being shown. The then Chancellor of UNC, James Moeser, began to appear in various news outlets reporting some of the negative feedback his office had received but supporting the program noting most of the incoming students were assumed to be Christian or Jewish with a comparative lack of understanding Islam and that part of the mission of the university, its "great function", was to help expand understanding of other cultures. [4] In July The O'Reilly Factor covered the controversy [3] [5] followed in August the television shows Good Morning America and Nightline [3] as the time of the reading program approached.

Public talking points included whether the effort respected the suffering in light of September 11 attacks or that was an initial approach to the subject of Islam, a natural subject for review in light of 9-11. [6]

Under pressure, the university changed the implementation of the program for the incoming class of 4,200 freshmen and transfer students by asking those who objected to reading the book to write a one-page essay explaining their reasons. [7] Ultimately 2,260 freshmen took part on August 19 (after a court case ruled in favor of the university) [8] in some 160 small group discussions led by one or more of 178 faculty and staff. [3]

Significant news coverage began in July and continued through November 2002, [3] [9] while further analysis and recall of the experience continue to be published. [6] [10] [11] [12]

A conservative-Christian activist group, the Family Policy Network, filed suit in the U.S. District Court, Middle District of North Carolina, on July 22, 2002, representing several students who were allowed to remain anonymous seeking a preliminary injunction to keep UNC from conducting its summer program, alleging that it violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment and abridged students' rights to free exercise of religion by obliging them to study Islam against their will. [6] The case was entitled Yacovelli v. Moeser (after James Yacovelli, a Family Policy Network spokesman, and James Moeser, the UNC Chancellor). The plaintiffs also asserted that the university through choosing Michael Sells book had misrepresented Islam by not by focusing on its more controversial elements. The university countered that the implementation of allowing students who objected to the reading to submit a single page report with their reasoning and thereby opt out of reading the book, but still participate in the discussions, insured that there was no violation of the Constitution and sought to continue with the program.

The court ruled in favor of UNC, [6] and Family Policy Network appealed to the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals, [Yacovelli v. Moeser, Aff'd, Case No. 02-1889, (4th Cir., Aug. 19, 2002)] but lost again.

Between the case and its first appeal North Carolina state government representative J. Sam Ellis was among those that sought to limit funding for the summer reading program when on August 7 the House Appropriations Committee voted to bar public funds for use in UNC's 2002 summer reading program, unless "all known religions are given equal treatment." [6] This proviso was removed when the state budget finally passed in mid-September.

The overall conclusion of Chief Judge N. Carlton Tilley, Jr., was that the book was strictly academic, not religious in nature, and therefore did not amount to a religious activity despite claims that listening to the CD exposes students to "the spell cast by a holy man of Islam" for example. [6] The judge ended his analysis with an application of the "Lemon test" deriving from the Lemon vs. Kurtzman court case. Chief Judge Tilley said:

Approaching the Qur'an" simply cannot be compared to religious practices that have been deemed violative of the "Establishment Clause", such as posting the Ten Commandments, reading the Lord's Prayer, or reciting prayers in school. The book does include surahs, which are similar to Christian Psalms. However, by his own words, the author endeavors only to explain Islam and not to endorse it. Furthermore, listening to Islamic prayers in an effort to understand the artistic nature of the readings and its connection to a historical religious text does not have the primary effect of advancing religion. [6]

The university's lawyers observed that the U.S. Supreme Court endorsed the academic study of religion in public schools and universities when Justice Tom C. Clark in 1963 declared, "one's education is not complete without a study of comparative religion or the history of religion and its relationship to the advancement of civilization." [6] Based on this as it applies to the Qur'an specifically, university officials then argued that, in addition to being constitutionally permissible, one's education is not complete without a study of the Qur'an (as well as the history of Islam) and its relationship to the advancement of civilization.

A revised challenge by the American Family Association's Center for Law and Policy, who had represented FPN all along, was filed in 2004, [Yacovelli v. Moeser, 2004 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 9152, (M.D.N.C. May 20, 2004)] which also lost on appeal, [Motion granted by, dismissed by Yacovelli v. Moeser, 324 F. Supp. 2d 760, 2004 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 12815 (M.D.N.C., July 7, 2004)] addressed various challenges of presenting material online related to the program by ruling it was in fact just focused on presenting the program rather than religious instruction. [6]

Media

UNC's own count of news coverage includes some 41 days, [3] [9] with some days having many news stories – for example, August 28 has 31 instances of coverage. [13] On August 27, C-SPAN covered Chancellor Moeser's speech at the National Press Club. [14] He noted many of the objections his office had received. [15] In addition to those already mentioned, many other news outlets covered the controversy, [16] including The Daily Show with Jon Stewart . [17]

Further reading

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quran</span> Foundational Islamic religious text

The Quran, also romanized Qur'an or Koran, is the central religious text of Islam, believed by Muslims to be a revelation from God. It is organized in 114 chapters, which consist of verses. In addition to its religious significance, it is widely regarded as the finest work in Arabic literature, and has significantly influenced the Arabic language.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill</span> Public university in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, U.S.

The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill is a public research university in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. It is the flagship of the University of North Carolina system. After being chartered in 1789, the university first began enrolling students in 1795, making it one of the oldest public universities in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ibn Warraq</span> Pen name of an author critical of Islam

Ibn Warraq is the pen name of an anonymous author critical of Islam. He is the founder of the Institute for the Secularisation of Islamic Society and used to be a senior research fellow at the Center for Inquiry, focusing on Quranic criticism. Warraq is the vice-president of the World Encounter Institute.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nasr Abu Zayd</span> Egyptian Quranic thinker, author, and academic (1943-2010)

Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd was an Egyptian Quranic thinker, author, academic and one of the leading liberal theologians in Islam. He is famous for his project of a humanistic Quranic hermeneutics, which "challenged mainstream views" on the Quran, sparking "controversy and debate." While not denying that the Quran was of divine origin, Zayd argued that it was a "cultural product" that had to be read in the context of the language and culture of seventh century Arabs, and could be interpreted in more than one way. He also criticized the use of religion to exert political power. In 1995 an Egyptian Sharia court declared him an apostate, this led to threats of death and his fleeing Egypt several weeks later. He later quietly returned to Egypt where he died.

An-Naml is the 27th chapter (sūrah) of the Qur'an with 93 verses (āyāt).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Moeser</span>

James Charles Moeser is a musician and university administrator who served as the ninth chancellor of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. He is a trained concert organist. A native of Colorado City, Texas, Moeser earned bachelor's and master's degrees in music from the University of Texas at Austin and a doctorate from the University of Michigan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jaringan Islam Liberal</span>

Jaringan Islam Liberal(JIL) or the Liberal Islam Network is a loose forum for discussing and disseminating the concept of Islamic liberalism in Indonesia. One reason for its establishment is to counter the growing influence and activism of militant and Islamic extremism in Indonesia. The "official" description of JIL is "a community which is studying and bringing forth a discourse on Islamic vision that is tolerant, open and supportive for the strengthening of Indonesian democratization."

Creighton Lee Lovelace is an American Christian minister, currently the pastor of Danieltown Baptist Church in Forest City, North Carolina. Lovelace and his church received brief international attention in May 2005 over a controversial sign on the Danieltown church's grounds that read, "The Koran needs to be flushed!"

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2006 UNC SUV attack</span>

On March 3, 2006, Mohammed Reza Taheri-azar intentionally hit people with a sport utility vehicle on the campus of the University of North Carolina (UNC) at Chapel Hill to "avenge the deaths of Muslims worldwide" and to "punish" the United States government. While no one was killed in the vehicle-ramming attack, nine people were injured.

<i>The Syro-Aramaic Reading of the Koran</i> Book by Christoph Luxenberg

The Syro-Aramaic Reading of the Koran: A Contribution to the Decoding of the Language of the Koran is an English-language edition (2007) of Die syro-aramäische Lesart des Koran: Ein Beitrag zur Entschlüsselung der Koransprache (2000) by Christoph Luxenberg.

Michael Anthony Sells is John Henry Barrows Professor of Islamic History and Literature in the Divinity School and in the Department of Comparative Literature at the University of Chicago. Michael Sells studies and teaches in the areas of Qur'anic studies, Sufism, Arabic and Islamic love poetry, mysticism, and religion and violence.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carl W. Ernst</span> American academic

Carl W. Ernst is the William R. Kenan, Jr., Distinguished Professor Emeritus of Islamic studies at the Department of Religious Studies at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. He was also the founding director (2003-2022) of the UNC Center for Islamic and Middle East Studies.

Omid Safi is a Shia, Iranian-American Professor of Asian and Middle Eastern Studies at Duke University. He served as the Director of Duke Islamic Studies Center from July 2014 to June 2019 and was a columnist for On Being. Safi specializes in Islamic mysticism (Sufism), contemporary Islamic thought and medieval Islamic history. He has served on the board of the Pluralism project at Harvard University and served as the co-chair of the steering committee for the Study of Islam and the Islamic Mysticism Group at the American Academy of Religion. Before joining Duke University, Safi was a professor at the University of North Carolina Chapel Hill. Prior to joining the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, he was on faculty at Colgate University as an Assistant Professor of Philosophy and Religion from 1999 - 2004.

<i>American Civil Liberties Union of North Carolina v. North Carolina</i>

American Civil Liberties Union of North Carolina & Syidah Mateen v. State of North Carolina, 181 N.C. App. 430, 639 S.E.2d 136 (2007), was a court case in the state of North Carolina within the United States of America. One of the main plaintiffs was Syidah Mateen an American-Muslim of Greensboro, North Carolina. She and the North Carolina chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union called for the state courts of North Carolina to rule that it is acceptable under the laws of the state for non-Christians to swear on religious texts of their own faith rather than the Bible of Christianity.

Herbert Holden Thorp is an American chemist, professor and entrepreneur. He is a professor of chemistry at George Washington University. He was the tenth chancellor of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, assuming the position on July 1, 2008, succeeding James Moeser, and, at age 43, was noted as being among the youngest leaders of a university in the United States. At the time of his selection as chancellor, Thorp was the dean of the College of Arts and Sciences and a Kenan Professor of chemistry at the university. Thorp is a 1986 graduate of UNC; he later earned a Ph.D. in chemistry from California Institute of Technology, and was a postdoctoral associate at Yale University.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Eve Carson</span> 2008 crime in Chapel Hill, North Carolina

On the morning of March 5, 2008, Eve Marie Carson was shot and killed in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, United States where she was a student at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dove World Outreach Center</span> Church in Florida, United States

Dove World Outreach Center is a 50-member non-denominational charismatic Christian church led by pastor Terry Jones and his wife, Sylvia. After spending more than 25 years in Gainesville, Florida, the church sold its 20 acres of property in July 2013 and plans to relocate to Tampa. The church first gained notice during the late 2000s for its public displays and criticism of Islam and gay people, and was designated as a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center. It became widely known for its pastor's controversial plan to burn Qur'ans on the ninth anniversary of the September 11 attacks.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Unsung Founders Memorial</span> Historic site in Chapel Hill, North Carolina

The Unsung Founders Memorial at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill is a memorial located in McCorkle Place, one of the University's quads. It consists of a black granite tabletop supported by 300 bronze figurines and surrounded by 5 black stone seats. The inscription around the edge of the table reads:

The Class Of 2002 Honors The University's Unsung Founders – The People Of Color, Bond And Free – Who Helped Build The Carolina That We Cherish Today.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">University of North Carolina academic-athletic scandal</span>

The University of North Carolina academic-athletic scandal involved alleged fraud and academic dishonesty committed at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (UNC). Following a lesser scandal that began in 2010 involving academic fraud and improper benefits with the university's football program, two hundred questionable classes offered by the university's African and Afro-American Studies department came to light. As a result, the university was placed on probation by its accrediting agency.

Jonathan Howes was an American politician and urban planner. He served as the director of the Center for Urban and Regional Studies at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill from 1970 until 1993. Howes began his political career as an elected member of the Chapel Hill Town Council from 1975 to 1987. He was then elected Mayor of Chapel Hill for two consecutive terms from 1987 to 1991. In 1991, North Carolina Governor Jim Hunt appointed Howes as Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources, a state cabinet position he held from 1992 to 1997.

References

  1. 1 2 Ernst, Carl W. (May 2003). "From the Heart of the Qur'an Belt". Religious Studies News. Retrieved July 2, 2013.
  2. 1 2 "Carolina Summer Reading Program 2002: Approaching the Qur'an, translated and introbduced by Michael Sells". Carolina Summer Reading Program (archives). University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. March 10, 2003.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "Reading story makes news". University Gazette. Office of Internal Communications Division of University Advancement. September 11, 2002. Retrieved July 2, 2013.
  4. 1 2 Adam Hochberg (May 29, 2002). "UNC and the Koran". Morning Edition. Season 2002. 3:33 minutes in. NPR.
  5. ↑ Bill O'Reilly (September 2004). Who's Looking Out for You?. Broadway Books. pp. 132–134. ISBN   978-0-7679-1380-5 . Retrieved 1 July 2013.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Buck, Christopher (2012). "The Constitutionality of Teaching Islam: The University of North Carolina Qur'an Controversy". In Bukhari, Zahid H.; Ahmad, Mumtaz (eds.). Observing the Observer: The State of Islamic Studies in American Universities (PDF). The International Institute of Islamic Thought.
  7. ↑ "Battle over Islam Book Assignment Continues". Ethics Newsline. Institute for Global Ethics. Aug 26, 2002. Retrieved July 2, 2013.
  8. ↑ Ernst, Carl W. (March–April 2003). "Reflection: Assigning the Qur'an at Chapel Hill Proved a Fine Thing to Do". Spirituality and Health. Retrieved July 2, 2013.
  9. 1 2 "references to Koran in 2002 collected by UNC from news outlets (date=mostly July to September 2002, but ultimately May through November plus one mention in 2006)". Carolina in the News. Retrieved July 2, 2013.
  10. ↑ Derewicz, Mark (June 21, 2012). "People of the Book". Endeavors. UNC Research. ISSN   1933-4338 . Retrieved July 2, 2013.
  11. ↑ "Critic Attacks Clemson's Required Reading for Freshmen". The Chronicle of Higher Education. July 17, 2006. Retrieved July 2, 2013.
  12. ↑ "Free Expression at UNC is Subject of Wilson Library Exhibition". University Library at UNC of Chapel Hill. March 11, 2013.
  13. ↑ "Special Summer Reading Program Coverage Summary". Carolina in the News. August 28, 2002. Retrieved July 2, 2013.
  14. ↑ "Academic Freedom and the Koran Controversy". C-SPAN coverage of National Press Club. Aug 27, 2002. Retrieved July 2, 2013.
  15. ↑ Moeser, James (August 27, 2002). "A Tempest in a Textbook: Academic Freedom and the Qur'an Controversy". Office of the Chancellor.
  16. ↑ E.g.:
  17. ↑ Mo Rocca (October 8, 2002). "Terror UNC". The Daily Show with Jon Stewart. Comedy Central, Comedy Partners.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.