2006 Lebanon War photographs controversies

Last updated

The 2006 Lebanon War photographs controversies (also referred to as "Hizbollywood" or "Hezbollywood") [1] refers to instances of photojournalism from the 2006 Lebanon War that misrepresented scenes of death and destruction in Lebanon caused by Israeli air attacks.

Contents

CAMERA, a pro-Israel media watch organization, said that the alleged photographic manipulations were used by the mainstream media in an attempt to sway public opinion and paint Israel as an aggressor, and suggesting that Israel was guilty of targeting civilians. [2]

Photo manipulation

Adnan Hajj, a freelance photographer, was fired by Reuters after he admitted to using Photoshop to add and darken smoke spirals in a photograph of Beirut, in order to make the damage appear worse. [3] Reuters stated that Hajj had edited a second photo, and critics raised further questions about Hajj's work. [4] Reuters announced that they had withdrawn "all of Hajj's photos, about 920 images, from its archives". [3]

Allegations of staging by press photographers

A photo of a burning Qur'an amid a pile of rubble, also taken by Hajj, seemed suspicious to Los Angeles Times media critic Tim Rutten, since the building it was in had been destroyed in an Israeli airstrike hours beforehand, and everything else in the photo was already ash. [5] A number of photographs were taken from Lebanon showing various children's toys in the foreground, each surrounded by a pile of rubble. Rutten also wrote about this set, saying that "Reuters might want to check its freelancers' expenses for unexplained Toys R Us purchases." [5]

Similarly, CAMERA questioned the authenticity of seemingly pristine photographs and photo albums lying on the top of the rubble of buildings destroyed by Israeli missiles, asking "how often does one find intact photographs sitting alone and undisturbed on top of the ruins of a building levelled by a missile? But coincidentally or not, photographers from various news organizations have been finding just that in rubble all over Lebanon" ... "with the only common denominator that all purport to depict Israel's destruction of Lebanese civilian life". [2]

Allegations of photo staging by others

Salam Daher, the head of the South Lebanon civil defense organisation, was accused by bloggers and websites of being a Hezbollah member and of using the bodies of children for propaganda purposes in photographs taken at the scene of the 2006 Qana airstrike. [6]

On 8 August, CNN anchor Anderson Cooper reported about a Hezbollah press tour of a bombed-out area in southern Beirut on 23 July 2006, during which Hezbollah operatives asked a group of empty ambulances to switch on their sirens and flashing lights for the benefit of the waiting press photographers, to give the impression that they were responding to casualties. Senior Producer Charlie Moore described the same tour as a "dog-and-pony show". [7]

The same day, Richard Landes and The Wall Street Journal editorial writer James Taranto challenged the validity of a photograph taken by Associated Press worker Lefteris Pitarakis. The picture in question depicted several Lebanese residents who were reportedly killed in an Israeli air strike. Upon close examination of a single still image, Taranto concluded that one man in particular was pretending to be dead. [8]

"Plainly this scene was staged for the benefit of the cameras, though it is important to note we know of no evidence that the photographer was complicit in the staging. It is, however, a clear example of how terrorist groups use journalists to spread their propaganda."

A cursory examination of several other stills in the photographic sequence established that the man first assumed to be feigning his own death was in fact dead. Consequently, both Richard Landes and James Taranto acknowledged they were "mistaken." [8]

Ambulance controversy

After the International Committee of the Red Cross issued a statement saying that "two of its ambulances were struck by [Israeli] munitions, although both vehicles were clearly marked" on 23 July 2006, wounding nine people, [9] the Associated Press reported that "Israeli jets blasted two ambulances with rockets" according to "Ali Deebe, a Red Cross spokesman in Tyre". [10] The Boston Globe quoted Kasim Shaalan as saying "A big fire came toward me, like in a dream" after a "rocket or missile had made a direct hit through the roof". [11]

A controversy developed when "zombie", the pseudonymous owner of the zombietime website, posted a long essay arguing (among other things) that the damage to the ambulances was far too light for a missile strike. [12] Zombie said that the ambulances were rusted out in the photographs, that explosive damage would not have left a rusted-out shell, and that the photos showed no blast damage but instead a perfectly round hole that coincided precisely with where the roof vent would be. On 28 August Australian Foreign Minister Alexander Downer said that "after closer study of the images of the damage to the ambulance, it is beyond serious dispute that this episode has all the makings of a hoax," [13] a conclusion he later said he drew from initial reports. [14] On 30 August, the ICRC "rebuked" Foreign Minister Alexander Downer "for relying on an unverified internet blog" and said that "there was no evidence to support" the hoax claim. [15] [16]

Andrew Bolt, a conservative Australian columnist who had written a column arguing that media photographs contradicted the ICRC's claims and that reporters were "passing on as fact the propaganda of terrorists", [17] defended Downer, [18] and noted that later reports claiming that the ambulances were hit by small arms fire contradicted the original reports. [19] Bolt cited an unnamed military source as stating that "there is no weapon that would deliver terminal effects consistent with the pictures, the alleged story and the reputed damage done to ambulance and people." [20]

In December 2006, Human Rights Watch released a report on forensic investigations they conducted in Qana. The group concluded that there was no hoax. [21] HRW had "originally reported that the ambulances had been struck by missiles fired from an Israeli airplane, but that conclusion was incorrect". The December 2006 report speculated that the ambulances were hit by a "smaller type of missile", possibly a "SPIKE anti-armor missile" or "the still experimental DIME (dense inert metal explosive) missile." [21] Both missiles have a relatively small blast radius, with DIME being specifically designed to limit collateral damage. [21]

Professor Avi Bell, a reservist in the Israel Defense Forces, criticized the Human Rights Watch report, writing that "the report contains no evidence whatsoever of any other Israeli presence in the area that could have attacked the ambulances. ... The report presents nothing more than its conjecture that Israel possesses and used unspecified new 'limited impact missiles designed to cause low collateral damage' fired from drones. ... Human Rights Watch assumes Israeli guilt without proof, viewing its mission as constructing a scenario, however implausible, in which it might be right." [22]

Allegations of improper captioning

Photographs submitted to Reuters and Associated Press showed a Lebanese woman mourning in front of destroyed buildings, said to be her home, on two different pictures taken by two photographers, published and captioned two weeks apart, which BBC editors replaced on their website after comments pointing to the inconsistency. [23] Guardian features writer Patrick Barkham offered the following explanation for other reported time-stamp inconsistencies between different news agencies: [24]

[B]loggers in Britain and the US want to prove that the mainstream media are swallowing Hizbullah propaganda. [...] At first, they suggested victims of the Israeli bombings were being carried around and posed for pictures because of different time-stamps on photographs reproduced on news websites. An AP photo was time-stamped 7.21 am, showing a dead girl in an ambulance. Another AP picture by a different photographer, stamped 10.25 am, showed the same girl being loaded on to the ambulance. A third, with the time 10.44 am, showed a rescue worker carrying the girl with no ambulance nearby. Three agencies – AP, AFP and Reuters – denied staging pictures at Qana. And the explanation for the different times was simple. Different news websites, such as Yahoo, put their own time-stamps on photos they receive from feeds; and AP does not distribute photos sequentially but on their news value and how quickly they are sent in.

The New York Times improperly captioned a photo taken in the city of Tyre in its online edition; an injured rescue worker being lifted from the rubble was implied to have been a bombing victim when in fact the worker had slipped and fallen. The newspaper subsequently issued a correction, saying that the photo had appeared in the printed edition with the correct caption. [25]

Bruno Stevens photos

A set of photos taken by press photographer Bruno Stevens show a Lebanese gunman with a raging fire in the background. One such photo appeared on the cover of the 31 July issue of U.S. News & World Report , with the inside caption, "Hezbollah guerilla poses at the site of an Israeli attack near Beirut". Another one was published in the 31 July issue of Time , with a caption saying the fire came from the "wreckage of a downed Israeli jet." Michelle Malkin and anonymous blogger Allahpundit stated that the fire in the background appeared to be a large pile of burning tires. [26] [27]

On 11 November 2006 Stevens, on the online forum "Lightstalkers", gave his explanation for the discrepancy. [28] He wrote that he had originally given one of the photos the following caption:

"Kfar Chima, near Beirut, 17 July 2006 An Israeli Air Force F16 has allegedly been shot down while bombing a group of Hezbollah owned trucks, at least one of these trucks contained a medium range ground to ground missile launcher."[ citation needed ]

He wrote that sometime later, after having done more investigation, he had modified his caption to:

"Kfar Chima, near Beirut, 17 July 2006 The Israeli Air Force bombed a group of Hezbollah chartered trucks parked on the back of large Lebanese Army barracks, at least one of these trucks contained a medium range ground to ground missile launcher, at least one missile was hit, misfiring high into the sky before falling down and starting a huge fire in the barracks' parking lot."[ citation needed ]

In his post, he wrote that he had had no say in the magazines' captions. He also reaffirmed the validity of his second caption, stating that the fire did not come from a garbage dump and was indeed the result of an Israeli attack; though he considered the site "a very legitimate target for the Israeli Air Force."[ citation needed ]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Qana massacre</span> 1996 attack on civilians by the Israeli Defense Forces in Qana, Lebanon

The Qana massacre took place on April 18, 1996, near Qana, a village in Southern Lebanon, when the Israel Defense Forces fired artillery shells at a United Nations compound. The artillery barrage had been launched to cover an Israeli special forces unit after it had come under mortar fire launched from the vicinity of the compound and radioed a request for support. Of 800 Lebanese civilians who had taken refuge in the compound, 106 were killed and around 116 injured. Four Fijian United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon soldiers were also seriously injured.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Operation Grapes of Wrath</span> Israeli military operation in Lebanon against Hezbolah in 1996

Operation Grapes of Wrath, known in Lebanon as the April Aggression, was a seventeen-day campaign of the Israeli Defense Forces against Hezbollah in 1996 which attempted to end rocket attacks on Northern Israel by the organisation. Israel conducted more than 1,100 air raids and extensive shelling. A UNIFIL compound at Qana was hit when Israeli artillery fired on Hezbollah forces operating nearby. 639 Hezbollah cross-border rocket attacks targeted northern Israel, particularly the town of Kiryat Shemona. Hezbollah forces also participated in numerous engagements with Israeli and South Lebanon Army forces. The conflict was de-escalated on 27 April by a ceasefire agreement banning attacks on civilians.

This is a timeline of events related to the 2006 Lebanon War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Israeli–Lebanese conflict</span> Clashes involving Israel, Lebanon, Syria, Hezbollah and the PLO

The Israeli–Lebanese conflict, or the South Lebanon conflict, is a series of military clashes involving Israel, Lebanon and Syria, the Palestine Liberation Organization, as well as various militias and Militants acting from within Lebanon. The conflict peaked in the 1980s, during the Lebanese Civil War, and has abated since.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">International incidents during the 2006 Lebanon War</span>

During the 2006 July War, a number of international incidents occurred in Lebanon, largely involving United Nations personnel who have come under a number of attacks by Israeli forces.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2006 Qana airstrike</span> Israeli airstrike on a Lebanese village

The 2006 Qana airstrike was an airstrike carried out by the Israeli Air Force (IAF) on a three-story building in the small community of al-Khuraybah near the South Lebanese village of Qana on July 30, 2006, during the 2006 Lebanon War. The strike killed 28 civilians, 16 of whom were children. Israel halted airstrikes for 48 hours following the attack, amid increasing calls for a ceasefire in the conflict between Israel and Lebanon's Hezbollah guerrillas.

There have been many casualties in the 2006 Lebanon War, leading to condemnation of both sides, however the exact distribution of casualties has been disputed. The Lebanese Higher Relief Council (HRC), UNICEF, and various press agencies and news organizations have stated that most of those killed were Lebanese civilians, however the Lebanese government does not differentiate between civilians and combatants in death toll figures. The Israeli government identified 43 Israeli civilians killed by Hezbollah rocket attacks, including four who died of heart attacks during rocket attacks. The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) death toll ranges from 118 to 121, depending on the source and whether or not casualties that occurred after the ceasefire are included. The figures for the Hezbollah fighters killed are the most varying, with Hezbollah claiming 250 of its fighters killed, while Israel claimed to have identified 530 dead Hezbollah fighters. The IDF estimates 600–700 dead Hezbollah fighters. Sources can be conflicting.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">International reactions to the Qana airstrike</span>

International reactions to the 2006 Qana airstrike, which saw the greatest loss of civilian life in the 2006 Israel-Lebanon conflict, twenty eight deaths with thirteen missing, largely involved the condemnation of Israel by many countries around the globe, bringing about a supposed 48 hours cessation of air operations by the Israeli Air Force. Bombings resumed only a few hours after the start of the cessation of air operations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2006 Lebanon War</span> Armed conflict primarily between Israel and Hezbollah

The 2006 Lebanon War, also called the 2006 Israel–Hezbollah War and known in Lebanon as the July War and in Israel as the Second Lebanon War, was a 34-day military conflict in Lebanon, northern Israel and the Golan Heights. The principal parties were Hezbollah paramilitary forces and the Israel Defense Forces (IDF). The conflict started on 12 July 2006, and continued until a United Nations-brokered ceasefire went into effect in the morning on 14 August 2006, though it formally ended on 8 September 2006 when Israel lifted its naval blockade of Lebanon. Due to unprecedented Iranian military support to Hezbollah before and during the war, some consider it the first round of the Iran–Israel proxy conflict, rather than a continuation of the Arab–Israeli conflict.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Adnan Hajj photographs controversy</span> 2006 media scandal

The Adnan Hajj photographs controversy involves digitally manipulated photographs taken by Adnan Hajj, a Lebanese freelance photographer based in the Middle East, who had worked for Reuters over a period of more than ten years. Hajj's photographs were presented as part of Reuters' news coverage of the 2006 Lebanon War, but Reuters has admitted that at least two were significantly altered before being published.

The Chyah Airstrike was an attack by the Israel Air Force (IAF) on the Shiyyah suburb in the Lebanese capital of Beirut on August 7, 2006, during the 2006 Lebanon War. Two missiles fired from an IDF bomber destroyed three apartment buildings in the suburb. Contemporary news accounts stated that the death toll from the airstrikes rose as recovery efforts continued, with 50 corpses recovered at the time of reportage and 61 anticipated.

The 2006 Ghaziyeh airstrikes also referred to as the 2006 Ghaziyeh massacre were two sequential attacks by the Israel Air Force (IAF) on the city of Ghaziyeh in Lebanon on August 7, and August 8, 2006. The attacks took place during the 2006 Lebanon War. In the first attack on August 7, the IAF bombed a building killing 16 people. In the second attack on August 8, the IAF fired five missiles into three buildings killing a total of 8 to 14 civilians and wounding 33. A total of 26 to 30 civilians died in the attacks.

Salam Daher is a Lebanese civil defense worker who was involved in the aftermath of the Israeli airstrike on Qana on July 30, 2006, where widely published photographs showed him removing dead children from the rubble of a house struck by an Israeli attack.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Attacks on civilian convoys in the 2006 Lebanon war</span>

A number of incidents of attack on civilian and UN convoys have been reported. The Israel Defense Forces has disputed involvement in some cases, and has also alleged that no prior coordination took place before some affected convoys set out. These allegations have in turn been disputed. There have also been reports that fear of aerial attack has prevented drivers from transporting humanitarian aid within Lebanon. One estimate two weeks into the conflict placed the number of Lebanese truck drivers who had died as a result of IDF/IAF air strikes on convoys as "dozens".

This is a timeline of the 2006 Lebanon War during the month of July.

This is a timeline of the 2006 Lebanon War during early August.

During the 2006 Lebanon War, allegations of war crimes were made by various groups and individuals, including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and United Nations officials, who accused both Hezbollah and Israel of violating international humanitarian law. These have included allegations of intentional attacks on civilian populations or infrastructure, disproportionate or indiscriminate attacks, the use of human shields, and the use of prohibited weapons.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Layal Najib</span>

Layal Najib, also Romanized Nagib, Nejib or Najeeb, was a Lebanese photojournalist for Agence France Press and Al Jaras and is the first journalist killed during the 2006 Lebanon War. She was also among several female journalists who were establishing their reputations as reporters during the war, such as Rima Maktabi and Najwa Qassem. Najib is one of seven journalists to have been killed since the end of civil war in 1990. Najib's death follows behind that of female journalist Atwar Bahjat who was killed while covering the Iraq War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nabatieh Fawka attack</span>

The Nabatieh Fawka attack occurred on 16 April 1996, when Israeli warplanes bombed an apartment in the village of Nabatieh Fawka, killing nine people, seven of whom were children.

References

  1. ↑ 'Im Zweifel für den Zweifel,' Der Tagesspiegel 9 August 2006]
  2. 1 2 "Updated: A Reprise: Media Photo Manipulation", Ricki Hollander, CAMERA, 8 August 2006
  3. 1 2 Reuters Says Freelancer Manipulated Lebanon Photos Archived 30 December 2010 at the Wayback Machine , Photo District News Online, 18 January 2007
  4. ↑ "Reuters admits to more image manipulation", Ynetnews , 7 August 2006
  5. 1 2 "Lebanon photos: Take a closer look", Tim Rutten, Los Angeles Times, 12 August 2006
  6. ↑ zombie (8 August 2006). "The Reuters Photo Scandal". zombietime.com. Archived from the original on 24 June 2008. Retrieved 16 July 2008.
  7. ↑ Charlie Moore (23 July 2006). "Our very strange day with Hezbollah". CNN. Archived from the original on 21 September 2006. Retrieved 30 September 2006.
  8. 1 2 Taranto, James. Jihadis Playing Possum, The Wall Street Journal, 8 August 2006.
  9. ↑ Lebanese Red Cross ambulances suffer new security incidents Archived 2 September 2006 at the Wayback Machine , International Committee of the Red Cross, 24 July 2006
  10. ↑ "Lebanese hospital struggles with wounded" Archived 9 October 2007 at the Wayback Machine , Kathy Gannon, Associated Press, 24 July 2006
  11. ↑ Cambanis, Thanassis (25 July 2006). "Ambulance drivers tell tales of horror". The Boston Globe. Retrieved 28 February 2007.
  12. ↑ zombie (23 August 2006). "The Red Cross Ambulance Incident". zombietime.com. Archived from the original on 13 September 2006. Retrieved 11 September 2006.
  13. ↑ "Foreign Policy Values and the Media" Archived 9 May 2007 at the Wayback Machine , speech by Alexander Downer, 28 August 2006
  14. ↑ Doorstop interview Archived 8 October 2006 at the Wayback Machine , Alexander Downer, 31 August 2006
  15. ↑ "Red Cross slams Downer hoax claim". Archived from the original on 2 September 2006.
  16. ↑ Alexander Downer radio interview Archived 8 October 2006 at the Wayback Machine with Tony Eastley, AM, 30 August 2006
  17. ↑ "Column – Not the whole truth – Andrew Bolt". Archived from the original on 4 February 2008. Retrieved 28 February 2007.
  18. ↑ "Sticking by the hoax – Andrew Bolt". Archived from the original on 4 December 2007. Retrieved 10 October 2006.
  19. ↑ "Fake-but-true: The Age defends the holey ambulance hoax – Andrew Bolt". Archived from the original on 6 February 2008. Retrieved 28 February 2007.
  20. ↑ "The ambulance hoax – why no missile could have done this – Andrew Bolt". Archived from the original on 6 February 2008. Retrieved 28 February 2007.
  21. 1 2 3 The "Hoax" That Wasn’t: The 23 July Qana Ambulance Attack, Human Rights Watch, 19 December 2006
  22. ↑ Bell, Avi (3 January 2007). "Human Rights Watch: Troubling Report". The New York Sun. Archived from the original on 26 February 2011. Retrieved 16 March 2011.
  23. ↑ Steve Herrmann. "BBC NEWS | The Editors". BBC. Retrieved 1 March 2012.
  24. ↑ Barkham, Patrick (14 August 2006). "Spot the difference". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 29 April 2010.
  25. ↑ "Corrections: For the Record". The New York Times. 9 August 2006. Retrieved 15 January 2009.
  26. ↑ "New York Times 'used fraudulent photo'". Ynet. 9 August 2006. Archived from the original on 11 August 2006. Retrieved 11 August 2006.
  27. ↑ "Blog Archive » Another bogus photo? (Update: "The Passion of the Toys") (Update: U.S. News cover staged?) (Update: NYT photo fraud, too?) (Bumped)". Hot Air. Retrieved 1 March 2012.
  28. ↑ "The Lebanon "garbage dump" story: complete explanation". Lightstalkers. Archived from the original on 20 September 2008. Retrieved 1 July 2016.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.