Aberlemno Sculptured Stones

Last updated

Angus UK location map.svg
Red pog.svg
Location of the stones in Scotland

The Aberlemno Sculptured Stones are a series of Pictish standing stones originating in and around the village of Aberlemno, Angus, Scotland. Three are located in the village and a fourth, found in 1962, is on display in The McManus in Dundee. They date from the Early Medieval period. A fifth stone standing in the village has signs of carving, but is of unknown authenticity as a Pictish artefact.

Contents

Location

Aberlemno 1, 3 and 5 are located in recesses in the dry stone wall at the side of the road in Aberlemno (grid reference NO522559 ). Aberlemno 2 is found in the Kirkyard, 300 yards south of the roadside stones.(grid reference NO5223955554 ) In recent years, bids have been made to move the stones to an indoor location to protect them from weathering, but this has met with local resistance and the stones are currently covered in the winter. [1] The stones are covered with wooden boxes from the last working day of September until the first working day of April.

Aberlemno 4, the Flemington Farm Stone was found 30 yards from the church (grid reference NO524556 ), [2] and is now on display in The McManus, Dundee.

Description

Aberlemno 1

Aberlemno 1 Serpent stone.JPG
Aberlemno 1

Aberlemno 1 is the northern roadside stone. It is an unshaped standing stone, bearing incised Pictish symbols, defining it under J Romilly Allen and Joseph Anderson's classification system as a Class I stone. [3] The symbols on one face: the serpent, the double disc and Z-rod and the mirror and comb. [4] The meaning of these symbols is unknown. They are deeply incised in a bold, confident line, and this stone is considered to be one of the finest and best-preserved Pictish symbol stones still standing in or near its original position. The other face of the stone exhibits prehistoric cup marks, showing that it has been re-used. [5]

Aberlemno II: Kirkyard Stone, Class II Pictish Stone Aberlemnokirkyardcropped.jpg
Aberlemno II: Kirkyard Stone, Class II Pictish Stone

Aberlemno 2

Aberlemno II, found in Aberlemno kirkyard, is a shaped cross-slab, bearing Pictish symbols as well as Christian symbols in relief, defining it as a Class II stone. [6] The stone, carved from Old Red Sandstone, stands 2.3 metres (7.5 ft) tall, 1.3 metres (4.3 ft) wide at the base, tapering to 0.9 metres (3.0 ft) wide at the top, and is 0.2 metres (7.9 in) thick. [7]

The west face is inscribed with a quadrilobate Celtic Cross. The cross bears several styles of Celtic pattern designs. The vertical arms are inscribed with three separate knotwork designs, the horizontal arms with keywork designs. [8] The central roundel has a spiral design composed of three interconnecting triskeles. Bordering the cross are a number of Celtic zoomorphic designs, reminiscent of Northumbrian designs and designs from the Book of Kells. [9] A hole has been bored through the upper part of the stone some time after its sculpting.

The rear face features two Pictish symbols, a notched rectangle with z-rod and a triple disc. Below this are nine figures which have been interpreted as a narrative account of a battle.

Until recently, it was thought to date to the mid-8th century, [10] but subsequent art-historical analysis has suggested a mid-9th century date. [11]

Aberlemno 3

Aberlemno 3 Ecosse2009106.JPG
Aberlemno 3

The western road-side stone is another Class II stone. It has an elaborately decorated ringed cross flanked by adoring angels on one side, and a hunting scene on the reverse, below two large Pictish symbols. This stone is known as Aberlemno 3. [5] This stone has until recently been thought to date from the late eighth century. More recent comparative analyses have suggested that it may be of a later, mid-ninth-century origin. [12]

Aberlemno 3 has different proportions to the Kirkyard Cross-slab, being relatively tall and thin, with parallel sides which have incised decoration (those of the other cross-slab are plain). The monument's height and decoration on four faces both suggest it is later in date than Aberlemno 2. Its nearest artistic analogies appear to be sculptures from Easter Ross in northern Scotland, notable the Hilton of Cadboll stone (now in the Museum of Scotland), which has a closely similar hunting scene.

Aberlemno 4

This stone, found in 1961 is approximately 1.5 metres tall, 0.5 m wide and 0.3 m thick. It has incised symbols on an unworked stone, defining it under J Romilly Allen and Joseph Anderson's classification system as a Class I stone. There are two symbols, a horseshoe and a Pictish Beast. [13] The anterior portion of the beast symbol (facing right) has suffered some damage due to ploughing, but is still easily visible.

Aberlemno 5

The central roadside stone bears only traces of incised marks. This stone is thought to be unfinished or a later fake. This stone is known as Aberlemno 5. [5]

2022 stone

A stone was found in 2022 by a group led by archaeologist Gordon Noble of Aberdeen University. This would fit within Allen and Anderson's Class I group of stones. The carvings on this stone include a double disk and z-rod, crescent and v-rod, mirror and comb, and a possible large v-rod without associated symbol encompassing all symbols.

Woodwrae stone

The Woodwrae Stone was recovered from a ruined castle that occupied a position 1 kilometre (0.62 mi) north of Aberlemno. [14] It was one of two carved stones used as floor slabs at the castle and was removed in 1819 to the collection of Sir Walter Scott at Abbotsford House, the other stone being lost at some point. The extant stone was donated to the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland in 1924 and can be seen at the National Museum of Scotland in Edinburgh. [15]

The battle scene on Aberlemno 2

Pictish Stone at Aberlemno Church Yard - battle scene detail Pictish Stone at Aberlemno Church Yard - Battle Scene Detail.jpg
Pictish Stone at Aberlemno Church Yard – battle scene detail

On the rear of Aberlemno 2 is a scene showing human figures bearing weapons, apparently engaged in battle. The figures appear in three rows. The top row has an unhelmeted figure on horseback riding behind a helmeted rider, possibly in pursuit. The helmeted rider is armed with a spear and appears to have dropped his sword and shield. The middle row has a helmeted rider armed with a spear and shield facing three unhelmeted infantry soldiers armed with spears, swords and shields. The bottom row shows a mounted and unhelmeted figure and mounted helmeted figure facing each other, both armed with spears. Behind the helmeted rider lies a helmeted casualty, with a bird to his right.

The battle scene has been interpreted in numerous ways. The earliest record of the stone by Hector Boece, from the 16th century, links the scene with the Battle of Barry (now known to be historically inauthentic):

82. Parem cladem nobilissimus Danorum manipulus est sortitus ad Aberlemnonem vicum vix a Bretheno, nunc civitate episcopali sede honestata, quatuor passuum millibus, qui a Scotis interceptus ibidem ferro occubuit. Quo loco ingens lapis est erectus. Huic animantium effigies nonnullis cum characteribus artificiose, ut tum fiebat, quae rem gestam posteritati annunciarent, sunt insculptae.

82. A noble company of Danes suffered a similar slaughter near the village of Aberlemno, a village four miles distant from Brechin (nowadays a city possessing the honour of an episcopal see), which was intercepted by the Scots and put to the sword. Here a great stone was erected, carved with lifelike figures and an artfully-engraved inscription (according to the lights of those days) to record this achievement for posterity. [16]

This interpretation persisted well into the mid-19th century, [17] some time after antiquarian George Chalmers identified Dunnichen as a possible site of the Battle of Dun Nechtain. [18]

While it was noted in 1955 by Robert Stevenson, keeper of the Museum of Antiquities of Scotland, that the helmets depicted on the stone were of a general sub-Roman design and the helmeted figures were likely to be Picts, [19] the superficial similarity of the helmets with their long nasal, with the Anglo-Saxon Coppergate Helmet found at York in 1982 has led to the notion that the helmeted figures are Northumbrians. This, coupled with the stone's proximity to Dunnichen (3 miles (5 km) to the south) led to the interpretation made by historian Graeme Cruickshank that the scene was a depiction of the Battle of Dun Nechtain. [20]

Cruickshank's interpretation, published in 1985, 1300 years after the Battle of Dun Nechtain, received general acceptance, [21] although he has been criticised for his suggestions that the stone was created soon after the battle in 685, when the conventional view at the time was that it was sculpted a century later. [22]

The subsequent identification of Dunachton in Badenoch as a second candidate for the site of the battle, [23] and the revised dating of the stone to the mid-9th century [24] has weakened Cruickshank's argument somewhat, and alternative interpretations have been made, including that the scene depicts a battle between Picts and Vikings, [25] or that it is a memorial to the 8th-century Pictish king Óengus I, [26] or even that it represents a spiritual struggle. [27]

Notes

  1. "Aberlemno Sculptured Stones". www.historicenvironment.scot. Retrieved 22 February 2021.
  2. Boyd 1962; Henderson 1962
  3. Allen & Anderson 1903 , p. 205
  4. Allen & Anderson 1903 , p. 205; Fraser 2008 , p. 46
  5. 1 2 3 "Re: The Monument known as Aberlemno, cross slab and symbol stones NW of Village Hall", The Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Areas Act 1979: Entry in the Schedule of Monuments, 1998, retrieved 18 December 2009
  6. Allen & Anderson 1903 , pp. 209–214
  7. "Aberlemno: Cross Slab", Canmore: Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland, retrieved 5 August 2010
  8. Allen 1885
  9. Trench-Jellicoe 1999
  10. Cummins 1999 , pp. 98–103
  11. Trench-Jellicoe 1999; Laing 2000; Laing 2001
  12. Trench-Jellicoe 1999
  13. Fraser 2008 , pp. 48–49
  14. "Site details for Woodwrae, Castle Woodwray", Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland, Canmore Database, retrieved 29 November 2010
  15. Jervise 1856; PSAS 1924
  16. Boece, Hector (1575), Scotorum Historia , retrieved 5 August 2010
  17. Mitchel 1792; Crombie 1842; Jervise 1856 , pp. 187–201
  18. Chalmers 1887 , p. 210; Woolf 2006
  19. Stevenson 1955
  20. Cruickshank 1985; Cruickshank 1991
  21. See for example Fraser 2006; Woolf 2006
  22. Ritchie 1991
  23. Woolf 2006
  24. Trench-Jellicoe 1999; Laing 2000; Laing 2001
  25. Trench-Jellicoe 1999
  26. Cummins 1999 , pp. 98–103
  27. Trench-Jellicoe 1999

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Dun Nechtain</span> 685 battle between Picts and Northumbrians

The Battle of Dun Nechtain or Battle of Nechtansmere was fought between the Picts, led by King Bridei Mac Bili, and the Northumbrians, led by King Ecgfrith, on 20 May 685.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brough of Birsay</span> An uninhabited tidal island off the north-west coast of The Mainland of Orkney, Scotland

The Brough of Birsay is an uninhabited tidal island off the north-west coast of The Mainland of Orkney, Scotland, in the parish of Birsay. It is located around 13 miles north of Stromness and features the remains of Pictish and Norse settlements as well as a modern light house.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pictish stone</span> Monuments erected by early Scottish tribes

A Pictish stone is a type of monumental stele, generally carved or incised with symbols or designs. A few have ogham inscriptions. Located in Scotland, mostly north of the Clyde-Forth line and on the Eastern side of the country, these stones are the most visible remaining evidence of the Picts and are thought to date from the 6th to 9th century, a period during which the Picts became Christianized. The earlier stones have no parallels from the rest of the British Isles, but the later forms are variations within a wider Insular tradition of monumental stones such as high crosses. About 350 objects classified as Pictish stones have survived, the earlier examples of which holding by far the greatest number of surviving examples of the mysterious symbols, which have long intrigued scholars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aberlemno</span> Parish and small village in Angus, Scotland

Aberlemno is a parish and small village in the Scottish council area of Angus. It is noted for three large carved Pictish stones dating from the 7th and 8th centuries AD ; the stones can be viewed at any time in spring-autumn, but are covered by wooden boxes in the winter to prevent frost damage. Two stones stand by the B9134 Forfar-Brechin road, the Kirkyard Stone stands in the nearby graveyard of the parish church.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bridei son of Beli</span> King of the Picts from 671 to 692

Bridei son of Beli ; died 692) was king of Fortriu and of the Picts from 671 until 692. His reign marks the start of the period known to historians as the Verturian hegemony, a turning point in the history of Scotland, when the uniting of Pictish provinces under the over-kingship of the kings of Fortriu saw the development of a strong Pictish state and identity encompassing most of the peoples north of the Forth.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Menmuir</span> Human settlement in Scotland

Menmuir is a parish in the county of Angus in Scotland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eassie Stone</span>

The Eassie Stone is a Class II Pictish stone of about the mid 8th century AD in the village of Eassie, Angus, Scotland. The stone was found in Eassie burn in the late 18th century and now resides in a purpose-built perspex building in the ruined Eassie church.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Barry</span> Legendary battle in 1010 AD

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dunnichen</span> Village in Angus, Scotland

Dunnichen is a small village in Angus, Scotland, situated between Letham and Forfar. It is close to Dunnichen Hill, at which the Battle of Dun Nechtain is popularly believed to have been fought. The church is part of the parish of Letham, Dunnichen and Kirkden.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Glamis Manse Stone</span>

The Glamis Manse Stone, also known as Glamis 2, is a Class II Pictish stone at the village of Glamis, Angus, Scotland. Dating from the 9th century, it is located outside the Manse, close to the parish church. It is inscribed on one side with a Celtic cross and on the other with a variety of Pictish symbols. It is a scheduled monument.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dunachton</span> Human settlement in Scotland

Dunachton is an estate on the north-west shore of Loch Insh in Badenoch and Strathspey, in the Highlands of Scotland. It occupies land immediately to the north of the A9 road and General Wade's Military Road.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Camus Cross</span> Sculpture in Angus, Scotland, UK

The Camus Cross, otherwise known as the Camuston or Camustane Cross, is an Early Medieval Scottish standing stone on the Panmure Estate near Carnoustie in Angus, Scotland. First recorded in the 15th century in a legal document describing the boundaries between Camuston and the barony of Downie, and described in the 17th century by Robert Maule, it is a freestanding cross, rare in Eastern Scotland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dunnichen Stone</span>

The Dunnichen Stone is a class I Pictish symbol stone that was discovered in 1811 at Dunnichen, Angus. It probably dates to the 7th century AD.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Monifieth Sculptured Stones</span>

The Monifieth Sculptured Stones are a series of five class II and III standing Pictish stones from the early Medieval period found in or around St Regulus' church in Monifieth, Angus, Scotland. Uncovered during the demolition of a pre-Reformation church and its kirkyard wall in the 19th and 20th centuries, the stones are now housed in the collection of the Museum of Scotland.

The double disc is a Pictish symbol of unknown meaning that is frequently found on Class I and Class II Pictish stones, as well as on Pictish metalwork. The symbol can be found with and without an overlaid Z-rod, and in combinations of both.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Woodwrae Stone</span>

The Woodwrae Stone is a Class II Pictish Stone that was found in 1819 when the foundations of the old castle at Woodwrae, Angus, Scotland were cleared. It had been reused as a floor slab in the kitchen of the castle. Following its removal from the castle, it was donated to the collection of Sir Walter Scott at Abbotsford House. It is now on display at the Museum of Scotland in Edinburgh.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">St Orland's Stone</span> Cross slab in Angus, Scotland, UK

St Orland's Stone is a Class II Pictish Cross-Slab at Cossans, near Kirriemuir and Forfar, Angus, Scotland

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hunter's Hill Stone</span>

The Hunter's Hill Stone, otherwise known as the Glamis 1 Stone, is a Class II Pictish standing stone at Hunter's Hill to the south east of Glamis village, Angus, Scotland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kirriemuir Sculptured Stones</span> Pictish stones discovered in Scotland

The Kirriemuir Sculptured Stones are a series of Class II and III Pictish stones found in Kirriemuir, Angus, Scotland. Their existence points to Kirriemuir being an important ecclesiastical centre in the late first millennium AD.

The mirror and comb are Pictish symbols of uncertain function, found on Class I and Class II Pictish stones. The mirror, or mirror and comb, do not belong to the body of main Pictish symbols, but are used as modifiers of a symbol pair. The mirror can occur on its own, or with the comb, although the comb never occurs on its own. The mirror, or mirror and comb, occur either below the symbol pair, or beside the lower symbol.

References

56°41′21″N2°46′53″W / 56.68917°N 2.78139°W / 56.68917; -2.78139