Affordable Housing and Groceries Act, Bill C-56

Last updated
Affordable Housing and Groceries Act
Parliament-Ottawa.jpg
Parliament of Canada
  • An Act to amend the Excise Tax Act and the Competition Act
Legislative history
Bill titleC-56
Introduced byDeputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance Chrystia Freeland
First reading 21 September 2023

The Affordable Housing and Groceries Act, Bill C-56, was tabled in the House of Commons of Canada on 21 September 2023. [1] [2] The legislation has two parts. The first will temporarily remove the goods and services tax (GST) on new residential rental developments. [3] The second part consists of three competition-related changes.

Contents

Bill C-56's amendments will expand the role of the Minister of Industry, which is expected to politicize the competition policy enforcement process. [4] [5] Critics of the bill note that competition policy is unlikely to be helpful in reducing price inflation in the grocery sector, as studies indicate it is a low-margin industry that has been hit by recent adverse macroeconomic shocks. [6] The Business Council of Canada says there has been inadequate consultation to consider the proposed amendments' possibly wide-ranging consequences. [7] [4]

Purpose

A press release from Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's office on 14 September 2023 said the government "will incentivize the construction of much-needed rental homes". [8] Also, "to address the escalating price of groceries" the government "will take immediate steps to enhance competition across the Canadian economy, with a focus on the grocery sector, which would help drive down costs for middle-class Canadians." [8] Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland said the bill includes "historic" changes to the way competition law works in Canada which, she argued, could have a meaningful impact on grocery prices. [2]

Proposed changes

Bill C-56 has two parts. First, a removal of GST charges on new residential rental developments until the end of 2030. [3] Second, the bill proposes three competition-related changes:

(1) the Competition Bureau would be able to seek a court order to compel parties to produce information (such as business records or sworn testimony) for a market study. (At present, participation in market studies is voluntary, although the Bureau already has such powers when investigating Competition Act violations. [5] [9] ) However, the Competition Bureau is permitted to seek such a court order only if the Minister of Industry has directed the Bureau to conduct the market study. [10] The Bureau must also seek the Minister's approval for the terms of reference for its market study. [10] Further, the Minister may demand a market study regardless of whether the Competition Commissioner believes that actionable anti-competitive conduct is occurring or has occurred. [11] As a consequence, the legislation introduces a political decision-maker into the day-to-day administration of the Competition Act . [10]

(2) remove the "efficiencies defence," a provision that allows companies to argue a merger is warranted because it will create efficiency gains. [8] [11]

(3) permit the Competition Tribunal to make orders against anti-competitive behaviour even if none of the parties to an agreement are competitors. This move is particularly aimed at situations where large grocers form agreements with landlords (who are not competitors of grocers) that prevent smaller grocers from establishing operations nearby. [8]

Reception: Removal of the GST on new rental construction

Bill C-56 will remove GST charges on new rental developments until the end of 2030. [3] The rebate percentage of the GST will rise from the current 36% to 100%, and there will no limit on the amount (currently there is no rebate for units valued at $450,000 or more.) [12] The rebate will apply to any building with at least 90% of its units designated for long-term rental. Projects must have at least four private units to qualify, or 10 individual units for student or senior living residences. [2] The change is expected to cost $4.6 billion over six years. [13] [14]

New Democratic Party MP Lindsay Mathyssen said her party has long called for the GST to be waived for new apartments, while Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre said his party would remove the GST from new rental construction only when the average rent on the property is below the market rate. [7] Ontario, British Columbia and Newfoundland and Labrador said they will eliminate provincial sales tax on new rental construction, but Quebec will not, saying it would be too costly. [14]

The president of the GTA's Building Industry and Land Development Association said the tax was "a barrier for purpose-built rentals" and its removal "is a really significant step." [15] Rob Gillezeau, assistant professor of economic analysis and policy at the University of Toronto said the GST rebate proposal is a "meaningful" move, but "you would need many, many more policy changes at this level or larger to really start to shift the dial on housing." [7]

Reception: Competition policy changes

Politicization of competition policy

The government's proposal to allow the Minister of Industry to direct the Commissioner of Competition to conduct a market inquiry adds to the Minister's power. It thereby raises questions with respect to the optics of the Competition Bureau's independence and "may give the government leverage in discussions with market participants regarding competition, or possibly other matters." [5] Goldy Hyder, the president and CEO of the Business Council of Canada, says this change is an "outright and overt politicization" of the competition regime. [4]

An inability to compel documents from subjects as part of its market studies was cited as a barrier to the Competition Bureau's investigation of concentration in the grocery sector earlier in 2023. [2] However, mandatory participation in market studies has raised concerns about "politically-motivated fishing expeditions" against parties who would not be alleged to have contravened the Competition Act (although the requirement of a court order to compel information may mitigate this risk). [9] While the use of market studies may seem unobjectionable, "there is a very real danger that the subjects of such studies will be participants in industries caught in the political spotlight at any given time – such as the grocery industry now – whether or not there is a legitimate competition law concern." [5] Further, there is a risk that, following an extensive and expensive market study, the Competition Bureau may feel some pressure to follow up with enforcement action. Competition practitioners at McMillan LLP note that in the distant past, when Canadian competition authorities had such powers, "it led them, on a number of occasions, down expensive blind alleys." [5]

Impact on grocery prices

Competition law practitioner Michael Osborne argues recent grocery price inflation is likely driven by macroeconomic factors, rather than a lack of competition. [6] In June 2023 the Competition Bureau found the grocery industry was a low-margin business and a modest increase to low margins cannot explain the double-digit food price inflation in Canada. [6] Similarly, an August 2023 Bank of Canada study found no support for the view that inflation is driven by firms exercising market power to increase prices through higher markups. [6] Osborne notes that if grocery store chains enjoyed enough market power to drive prices higher they would not have waited for the pandemic or the war in Ukraine. [6]

Amendments proposed in bill C-56 are very broad and are not expected to directly affect grocery prices other than, by increasing competition they could, eventually, reduce food prices. [14] In a technical briefing, senior government officials said that efforts related specifically to grocery prices are "being executed through a separate process." [14]

Impact on economic growth: (a) Efficiency

Professor Jeffrey Church of the University of Calgary opposes bill C-56's elimination of the efficiency defence because, while competitive markets are desirable because they usually provide the most efficient outcome, a merger may sometimes lead to a more efficient result. [16] This can happen if a merger generates economies of scale, improves productivity, or enhances innovation. [5] [17] Church argues that if efficient resource allocation does produce exceptional harm for some people, the response should be not to forego the efficiency gains, but to introduce offsetting income transfers, as governments have already done for many decades. [16]

Impact on economic growth: (b) Uncertainty and investment

Bill C-56's amendment to prevent anti-competitive agreements between parties that do not compete is aimed at the practice of grocery retailers requiring restrictive covenants that prevent renting retail space to a competitor in their agreements with landlords (landlords are not competitors of grocers). [11] While bill C-56 will apply to grocery store agreements, all industries and all types of agreements that reference a competitor (e.g. exclusivity agreements) have as their purpose an effect on competition. [10] [11] The proposed amendment therefore introduces potential uncertainty for parties considering ordinary commercial protections for their investments. [11] Growth may therefore be impacted to the extent that greater uncertainty hampers investment.

The Business Council of Canada President and CEO, Goldy Hyder, said officials had promised that any changes to the Competition Act would be done only after comprehensive consultations with all impacted stakeholders, but the amendments "came as an ambush" without adequate consultation or parliamentary debate. [4] Hyder notes "Few companies, foreign or domestic, will want to make significant investments in a country that changes its corporate laws so capriciously." He concludes that if the goal is to increase competition by attracting new entrants to the Canadian market, "it is difficult to conceive of a worse way for us to achieve it." [4]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Supermarket</span> Large format of grocery store

A supermarket is a self-service shop offering a wide variety of food, beverages and household products, organized into sections. This kind of store is larger and has a wider selection than earlier grocery stores, but is smaller and more limited in the range of merchandise than a hypermarket or big-box market. In everyday U.S. usage, however, "grocery store" is often used to mean "supermarket".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Grocery store</span> Retail store that primarily sells food and other household supplies

A grocery store (AE), grocery shop (BE) or simply grocery is a foodservice retail store that primarily retails a general range of food products, which may be fresh or packaged. In everyday U.S. usage, however, "grocery store" is a synonym for supermarket, and is not used to refer to other types of stores that sell groceries. In the UK, shops that sell food are distinguished as grocers or grocery shops.

The goods and services tax is a value added tax introduced in Canada on January 1, 1991, by the government of Prime Minister Brian Mulroney. The GST, which is administered by Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), replaced a previous hidden 13.5% manufacturers' sales tax (MST).

Sobeys Inc. is the second largest supermarket chain in Canada after Loblaw Companies Limited, with over 1,500 stores operating across Canada under a variety of banners. Headquartered in Stellarton, Nova Scotia, it operates stores in all ten provinces and accumulated sales of more than C$25.1 billion in the fiscal 2019 operating year. It is a wholly owned subsidiary of Empire Company Limited, a Canadian business conglomerate.

The harmonized sales tax (HST) is a consumption tax in Canada. It is used in provinces where both the federal goods and services tax (GST) and the regional provincial sales tax (PST) have been combined into a single value-added tax.

Goods and Services Tax (GST) is a value-added tax or consumption tax for goods and services consumed in New Zealand.

In the United States, a group purchasing organization (GPO) is an entity that is created to leverage the purchasing power of a group of businesses to obtain discounts from vendors based on the collective buying power of the GPO members.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">C&S Wholesale Grocers</span> American wholesale distributor

C&S Wholesale Grocers is a national wholesale grocery supply company in the United States, based in Keene, New Hampshire. In 2021 it was the eighth-largest privately held company in the United States, as listed by Forbes. C&S owns the Piggly Wiggly grocery brand, which is independently franchised to store operators, the Grand Union supermarkets brand, as well as several private label brands, including Best Yet.

The Commerce Commission is a New Zealand government agency with responsibility for enforcing legislation that relates to competition in the country's markets, fair trading and consumer credit contracts, and regulatory responsibility for areas such as electricity and gas, telecommunications, dairy products and airports. It is an independent Crown entity established under the Commerce Act 1986. Although responsible to the Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs and the Minister of Broadcasting, Communications and Digital Media, the Commission is run independently from the government, and is intended to be an impartial promotor and enforcer of the law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Feed-in tariffs in Australia</span> Overview of feed-in tariffs in Australia

Feed-in tariffs in Australia are the feed-in tariffs (FITs) paid under various State schemes to non-commercial producers of electricity generated by solar photovoltaic (PV) systems using solar panels. They are a way of subsidising and encouraging uptake of renewable energy and in Australia have been enacted at the State level, in conjunction with a federal mandatory renewable energy target.

Public housing policies in Canada includes rent controls, as well as subsidized interest rates and grants. Early public housing policy in Canada consisted of public-private lending schemes which focused on expanding home ownership among the middle class. The first major housing initiative in Canada was the Dominion Housing Act of 1935, which increased the amount of credit available for mortgage loans.

<i>Competition Act</i>

The Competition Act is a Canadian federal law governing competition in Canada. The Act contains both criminal and civil provisions aimed at preventing anti-competitive practices in the marketplace.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">39th Parliament of British Columbia</span>

The 39th Parliament of British Columbia sat from 2009 to 2013, replacing the 38th parliament and being succeeded by the 40th parliament. It was composed of two elements: the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia, as elected by the general election of May 12, 2009, and The Queen represented by the Lieutenant-Governor. That election resulted in a majority government for the BC Liberal Party led by Gordon Campbell, and a BC New Democratic Party official opposition.

Consumption taxes have been levied in the Canadian province of British Columbia since the introduction of the Provincial Sales Tax (PST) on 1 July 1948, as part of the Social Service Tax Act. Sales in the province have also been subject to the federal Goods and Services Tax (GST) since its introduction on 1 January 1991.

The Goods and Services Tax (GST) is an abolished value-added tax in Malaysia. GST is levied on most transactions in the production process, but is refunded with exception of Blocked Input Tax, to all parties in the chain of production other than the final consumer.

Rent regulation is a system of laws, administered by a court or a public authority, which aims to ensure the affordability of housing and tenancies on the rental market for dwellings. Generally, a system of rent regulation involves:

<span class="mw-page-title-main">42nd Canadian Parliament</span> Parliamentary term of the Parliament of Canada

The 42nd Canadian Parliament was in session from December 3, 2015, to September 11, 2019, with the membership of its lower chamber, the House of Commons of Canada, having been determined by the results of the 2015 federal election held on October 19, 2015, and thirty new appointees to its Upper House, the Senate of Canada. Parliament officially resumed on December 3, 2015, with the election of a new Speaker, Geoff Regan, followed by a Speech from the Throne the following day. The Speaker of the Senate of Canada was George Furey, who was appointed Speaker of the Canadian Senate on the advice of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, to replace Leo Housakos, on December 3, 2015. On September 11, 2019, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau advised Governor General Julie Payette to dissolve Parliament and issue the writ of election, leading to a 5-week election campaign period for the 2019 federal election. Significant legislation adopted during the 42nd Parliament included the Cannabis Act, the Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act, the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement Implementation Act, the Trans-Pacific Partnership Implementation Act, the Canada Infrastructure Bank Act, the Impact Assessment Act and Canadian Energy Regulator Act, as well as the legalizing of medical assistance in dying and adding gender identity and expression to the list of prohibited grounds of discrimination in the Canadian Human Rights Act.

The Competition Tribunal is the federal adjudicative body in Canada responsible for cases regarding competition laws under the Competition Act.

Carbon pricing in Canada is implemented either as a regulatory fee or tax levied on the carbon content of fuels at the Canadian provincial, territorial or federal level. Provinces and territories of Canada are allowed to create their own system of carbon pricing as long as they comply with the minimum requirements set by the federal government; individual provinces and territories thus may have a higher tax than the federally mandated one but not a lower one. Currently, all provinces and territories are subject to a carbon pricing mechanism, either by an in-province program or by one of two federal programs. As of April 2023 the federal minimum tax is set at CA$65 per tonne of CO2 equivalent, set to increase to CA$170 in 2030.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Inflation Reduction Act</span> American budget reconciliation bill

The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA) is a landmark United States federal law which aims to curb inflation by possibly reducing the federal government budget deficit, lowering prescription drug prices, and investing into domestic energy production while promoting clean energy. It was passed by the 117th United States Congress and signed into law by President Joe Biden on August 16, 2022.

References

  1. ↑ Parliament of Canada. "Bill C-56".
  2. 1 2 3 4 Lord, Craig (21 September 2023). "Can Ottawa make a dent in housing grocery prices? What a new bill would do". Globalnews.ca.
  3. 1 2 3 Al Mallees, Nojoud (21 September 2023). "Freeland introduces bill to remove GST off rental developments, amend competition law". BNN Bloomberg.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 Hyder, Goldy (26 September 2023). "The Liberal bill to bolster competition is a Trojan horse of bad policy". Globe and Mail.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Musgrove, James; Tougas, François; Riley, Beth; Chad, Joshua; Johnson, Hannah (18 September 2023). "A Shopping Cart of Competition Law Changes". McMillan LLP: Competition & Antitrust Bulletin.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 Osborne, Michael (3 October 2023). "Bill C-56: the good, the bad, and the useless of the federal affordability legislation". Globe and Mail.
  7. 1 2 3 Curry, Bill; Walsh, Marieke (22 September 2023). "Parties spar over housing after government tables bill to waive GST on new rental construction". Globe and Mail.
  8. 1 2 3 4 "Fighting for the middle class". Office of the Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau. 14 September 2023.
  9. 1 2 Goodman, Adam; Kupi, Simon; Walker, Sandy; Zalmanowitz, Barry; Maldi, Camila (2 October 2023). "Bill C-56 proposes new amendments to the Competition Act". Dentons.
  10. 1 2 3 4 Rosner, David; Koch, Michael; Persaud, Devin; Wall, Jon; Zelikovitz, Josh (22 September 2023). "UPDATE: Government of Canada Introduces Legislation to Amend the Competition Act, end of the "Efficiencies Defence"". Goodmans LLP.
  11. 1 2 3 4 5 Rodal, Shuli; Lally, Michelle; Kuzma, Kaeleigh; Pannu, Alysha; Rubin, Chelsea; Nauth, Reba; Rudge, Zach (28 September 2023). "Bill to amend the Competition Act introduced in Parliament". Osler.
  12. ↑ "Canada introduces legislation on enhanced GST rental rebate for new rental units". Ernst & Young LLP. 27 September 2023.
  13. ↑ The Editorial Board (11 October 2023). "A fairer way to share the costs of ending the housing crisis". Globe and Mail.
  14. 1 2 3 4 Lévesque, Catherine (21 September 2023). "What the Liberals' affordability bill means for Canadians, and how it will affect housing and food prices". National Post.
  15. ↑ Warren, May (15 September 2023). "Will Justin Trudeau's plan to end GST on new rental buildings help tenants?". Toronto Star.
  16. 1 2 Church, Jeffrey (28 September 2023). "Opinion: Keep the efficiencies defence in merger cases. It's good for growth". National Post.
  17. ↑ Future of Canada's Competition Policy Consultation – What We Heard Report (Report). Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada: Government of Canada. 20 September 2023.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.