Bontoc Eulogy

Last updated
Bontoc Eulogy
Directed byMarlon Fuentes
Written byMarlon Fuentes
Screenplay by
  • Marlon Fuentes
Story by
  • Marlon Fuentes
Produced by
  • Marlon Fuentes
Starring
  • Marlon Fuentes
  • Michael Porter
  • Eliseo Bacolod
  • Enrico Obusan
  • Fermina Bagwan
Distributed by Corporation for Public Broadcasting
Release date
  • 1995 (1995)
Running time
56 minutes
Countries
  • United States
  • Philippines
Language
  • English

Bontoc Eulogy is a 1995 docudrama directed by Marlon Fuentes and distributed by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting. It was produced, written, directed, edited by, and stars Marlon Fuentes in the main role of a screen narrator going through an excruciating internal conflict regarding his heritage and following his thoughts as he recounts his grandfather's journey to the St. Louis World's Fair. It is the fifth film produced by Marlon Fuentes, following Arm in 1994.

Contents

Despite a limited audience view worldwide, this experimental documentary offered a deep and critical insight into Filipino history, and is considered a pioneering work in autoethnography. As a photographer, filmmaker, and conceptual artist, Marlon Fuentes' work has been shown in over 60 separate exhibitions in the past 20+ years alone and has been represented in collections such as Smithsonian Institution’s National Museum of American Art, the National Museum of American History, the Houston Museum of Fine Arts, the Library of Congress, the Corcoran Gallery of Art, and the Santa Barbara Museum of Art. Furthermore, his work has been nominated for the International Documentary Association’s Distinguished Achievement Award and has received many awards from the international community. [1]

Controversy surrounds the film even decades after its release. Some questioned the film for making audiences believe that this seemingly personal account was "real," because the piece combined fictional and factual content as a seamless historically based personal narrative. However, it can be soundly argued that the film's meaning would have been altered had this cinematic device been revealed in the beginning. Some critics have argued that the declaration of its fictional conceit via the film credits is actually the meta-denouement of the film, part of the multiple layers of interrogation conducted by the filmmaker/narrator in trying to ascertain the relationship between form and narrative. The location of the filmmaker (as "narrator") within the commingled streams of fiction and historical facts raises critical questions about the porosity of diegetic, extra-diegetic, and non-diegetic space in cinematic representations of culture and identity formation/s. The film balances its multi-layered critical objectives and formal devices without sacrificing accessibility to an audience. As an experimental, post-ethnographic film that uses/extends (albeit in stealth) the devices of structuralist/materialist cinematic conventions, the film still passes the test of "eminent watchability" despite its rigorous art-historical/theoretical agendas and lineage.

Plot

The unnamed narrator, a serious Filipino-American immigrant, muses about his days in the Philippines and continues on to speculate on the mysterious disappearance of both of his grandfathers. His curiosity leads him to research his past and urges him to discover the whereabouts of his kin. He offers the audience an inside look to his internal conflict regarding his family history by narrating throughout the film. Much of the movie consists of snapshots and footage of the World's Fair and some of the "real" footage has been, in fact, just a reenactment of what is thought to be the past.

The film begins with the narrator thinking of his children and subsequently thinking of his days as a child in the Philippines. He expresses his sadness of belonging to neither country (America or Philippines) and his desire to gain a foundation for his personal history. With this said, the narrator recounts the story of both of his grandfathers' lives. One of the grandfathers' (Emiliano) had fought in the revolution against Spain in 1896 and the Philippine–American War in 1899, only to be killed in the trenches and never have his body found. The narrator speculates that his grandfather is probably buried in one of the several mass graves on the outskirts of Manila.

While Emiliano had an interesting death by fighting in the war, the other's story was far more interesting. The other grandfather, named Markod, had been an Igorot warrior in the Philippines. When the Americans had first came to the village, the tribal members were afraid. But, they soon realized that the Americans wanted to become friends and take them to America to showcase their culture. Markod was, at first, hesitant since his wife was expecting a child. In 1904, Markod and several families of his village decided to go America as participants in the St. Louis World's Fair. At the time, Markod had been a young chief, known for his skills as a hunter and warrior.

Markod was first taken to San Francisco on a boat and then taken to St. Louis on a train, where 2 of his companions froze to death in a boxcar. Once at St. Louis, the Igorots built an entire village out of the "traditional" elements of the Philippines. The St. Louis World's Fair was set to begin.

At the World's Fair, many people came to see the men and women on display at the Philippine reservation. These people wanted to catch a glimpse of the Filipino in flesh and blood, in their "natural habitat". Over 1,000 "natives" of various heritages were on display simultaneously at the fair. Native tribes which had not known of each other's existence were placed next to each other on the reservation. The aim of this was to show to the American people the various stages of social progress, from "barbaric" to "civilized" and Christian. Markod admired the skills of the different tribes and he marveled at the various animals on display at the fair.

One day, a sick baby girl born to an African couple was taken away and never seen again. The father of the child talked about the incident and the authorities of the World's Fair became wary of an uprising. Extra scouts were posted in the village. Markod thought about how the Western people say that their God is strong, but their medicines are weak. The death of the child deeply disturbed Markod and he became fearful that evil things would begin to happen. Markod became homesick and missed his wife and home in the mountains. He became disturbed at the noise and brightness of the fair and longed for the quietness of his home. Two Igarot men also disappeared and the whole village mourned at their death. They mourned for days while the American public watched, unaware of their grief.

Markod tried to escape after this incident. He escaped into the woods and relished the music of the sounds of nature he knew so well. He hoped to get by unnoticed and would be able to escape from the fair. When reaching the edge of the forest, he fell into a deep sleep, only to awaken surrounded by unknown American faces. He was then placed in a solitary confinement to keep him from escaping.

When the World's Fair ended, Markod mysteriously disappeared. The narrator comes back into the plot here and he discovers through archives, that there had been an unusual incident just before the closing of the fair, which involved the death of an Igorot male. The remains had been mangled beyond recognition, but authorities had determined that he was Filipino by the color of his skin. This man could have been Markod, or he could have been put on display at other fairs around the country. Still, Markod's remains could currently be displayed at the Smithsonian Museum where the brains of two Filipinos had been removed immediately after their death.

At the end of the film, the location of Markod's body was still unknown and the narrator still wonders on the whereabouts of his ancestor.

Cast

Director

Marlon Fuentes is a Philippine born, Los Angeles based artist. He is an alumnus of the prestigious Philippine Science High School. His undergraduate study focused on behavioral science and anthropology, graduating with a Bachelor of Arts, Summa cum laude, from De La Salle University's Liberal Arts Honors Program, in Manila, Philippines. He studied photography with Mark Power at The Corcoran School of Art in Washington D.C., and was awarded a Presidential Fellowship at Temple University's MFA program in Philadelphia, PA.

Fuentes has created numerous works in film, photography, conceptual, and text-based art. His work has been displayed in over 60 exhibits in the past 20+ years. He has received international awards and praise and is known for his many professional works, such as, B.E.A.T., Sleep With Open Eyes, Tantalus, Arm, and Crikee. [1] Furthermore, his work has been acclaimed worldwide and has been shown in museums, including the Netherlands Filmmuseum, the Museum of Modern Art in New York and the Guggenheim Museum in New York. In the past, Fuentes has been a visiting artist at New York University, Antioch College, along with other educational institutions.

Soundtrack

Various "tribal" and "Western" music was played throughout the film. It served the purpose of signaling the transition between the two cultures within the movie and to create an exaggeration of the cultures. The Western music was much more upbeat and contained various complex instrument (example: the piano). The "traditional Filipino music" showcased the basic stereotype of "tribal" music with the use of the drum. The soundtrack in this film included "Music and Dance from the Hill Peoples of Northern Philippines" and also utilized music from Ramon Obusan.

Three Aspects of the Rhetorical Triangle

Rhetor

The screen narrator in Bontoc Eulogy can be thought of as the rhetor. This narrator is an ever-present voice in the film and guides the viewer through the plot and story line. Although we never learn the name of this narrator, it is (at first) speculated that this is indeed Marlon Fuentes (the director). But, at the end of the film, the audience realizes that this film is indeed fictional and the rhetor is a nameless narrator only played by Marlon Fuentes. This twist and mystery which surrounds the rhetor is, in itself, an aid for the audience to inadvertently understand the narrator's (and the Filipino-American population's) personal struggle to piece together his past and find a sense of belonging and stability in life. The anonymous narrator also remains ambiguous to allow every Filipino-American Immigrant to relate to this story and struggle. Through this film the narrator explores his own relationship with his Filipino culture and ancestry.

Message

Marlon Fuentes unfolds the events of the St. Louis World's Fair in 1904. He does this by fabricating a story about the search for a grandfather who mysteriously vanished during the events of the fair. [2] The story was simply created to help the mockumentary attract and keep the attention of the audience. This film not only shows the awful history of the St. Louis World Fair but also the reactions of many Americans to the Filipino people at the fair. The Filipinos were treated like animals with absolutely no respect. Viewers of this film can be compared to the spectators at the World's Fair. We are so quick to believe that many Filipinos were “barbaric” and “savage” at this time, but the truth is they were just portrayed this way at the World Fair to show how “uncivilized” non-white races are.[ citation needed ]

Audience

Bontoc Eulogy is meant for both a general audience and also specifically for the Filipino audience, although it also targets audiences interested in American history, ethnographic film, and experimental documentary. Fuentes chooses to "mislead" his audience at the beginning of the film by fabricating a story that will intrigue audiences. He says that his grandfather was a victim of the St. Louis Worlds Fair, but in reality, this may never have happened. Instead, it was a narrative device used to focus attention on traditions of displaying indigenous tribal culture in Western civilization. Although the audience may feel "cheated" at the end of the movie, they are still left with the realization that there is a logical possibility someone else could have faced a similar tragic predicament. Fuentes, in an interview, explains that he did not want to reveal the truth within the film because it was essential for him to retain the audience’s attention through the “raw material” ethnography and emotions generated by the story. Furthermore, to break the façade too early would have distracted the audience and drawn away from his message. Not much is known of the first audience’s original reception of Bontoc Eulogy, but current viewers suggest that it is a film that all Filipino and Philippine diaspora audiences must watch. New viewers are continually promoting Bontoc Eulogy in order to keep the Filipino history alive and to create awareness of what western civilization did to early Filipino immigrants. [3] Overall, Bontoc Eulogy continues to receive critical acclaim from general and academic audiences for its portrayal of the St. Louis World's Fair, at the same time interrogating the relationships between the formal issues of documentary form and the presentation historical "truth."

Genre

Bontoc Eulogy is a film often mistaken as a nonfiction, documentary. Although this film employs many of the techniques commonly used in a traditional documentary, it is, more precisely, a unique fusion of autoethnographic and Brechtian cinema. The elements used to create this feel are: a narrative voiceover through the entire film, black and white images, foreign languages used and then (re)translated, and blending a "personal" voice that foreshadows the possibility of an unreliable narrator dissecting the colonial narratives embedded in the 1904 World's Fair.

This experimental/brechtian film is targeted towards an interrogation of the colonial metanarrative in a historical moment at the turn of the century. It uses avant-garde techniques such as distantiation, bricolage, metafiction, the interplay of diegetic and non-diegetic sound, and appropriation/recontextualization strategies used in the visual arts. As such, the film highlights the fetishization (and the "fetish infrastructure") by dominant Western societies towards "other" indigenous/colonized cultures. The "West" here is shown to take the culture of the Filipino people and other indigenous societies, completely change and misconstrue it (recasting the cultural narrative to fit sociopolitical and economic objectives of Empire), and then to exhibit this tableau/facade/platform in front of millions, who believe that it is real, all to support and perpetuate the rubric of U.S. Manifest Destiny.

Themes

Repetition

Fuentes repeats many scenes of the grandfather while he is held captive in the World's Fair. He also repeats many scenes of the Igorot, along with other tribes, mock-fighting and playing instruments. Another prominent scene which is repeated is the scene with the paper boats floating in the water.

Fuentes repeats these scenes for the purpose of stressing the fact that the Igorot and Filipino people were, in a sense, held captive in the St. Louis World's Fair and that each day seemed the same to them; performing an act, being watched, and dreaming of their families back in the Philippines. The scene of the paper bloats floating is also crucial although it may appear to be superfluous at first sight. This scene includes the element of water, a symbol of refreshment and rebirth, and puts paper boats in it, which can be interpreted as a symbol of the "West". The boats are paper, so it signifies that the Filipino people had come to the United States in hopes of earning money for their families and creating a better life for themselves, but were only met with the unstable and inhospitable American environment and people.

Children

The narrator continuously talks about his children throughout the film, but most prominently during the beginning of the film when he is reflecting on his own childhood and upbringing. Fuentes also edits clips of two children playing at various points in the film and leaves audiences with a nostalgic feel of childhood. The narrator's own grandfather had left for the World's Fair while his wife was pregnant and about to have a baby. Adding on, there was also a very prominent clip of a child dancing in a "traditional" way. This clip was slowed down for emphasis and played for a prolonged amount of time while the narrator mused of his own childhood in the United States and the cruelty (or ignorance) of the children there towards his culture.

This theme of children in the movie highlights the innocence of the Filipino people when they lived in their personal civilization, before it was touched by Western influence. The stress that Fuentes puts on the simplicity yet complexity of the peaceful Filipino way of living is recognized with the easily seen display of innocence by using small children in many of his scenes.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marlon Brando</span> American actor (1924–2004)

Marlon Brando Jr. was an American actor and activist. Considered one of the greatest actors of the 20th century, he received numerous accolades throughout his career, which spanned six decades, including two Academy Awards, two Golden Globe Awards, one Cannes Film Festival Award, and three British Academy Film Awards. Brando is credited with being one of the first actors to bring the Stanislavski system of acting and method acting to mainstream audiences.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Louisiana Purchase Exposition</span> 1904 Worlds Fair in St. Louis

The Louisiana Purchase Exposition, informally known as the St. Louis World's Fair, was an international exposition held in St. Louis, Missouri, United States, from April 30 to December 1, 1904. Local, state, and federal funds totaling $15 million were used to finance the event. More than 60 countries and 43 of the then-45 American states maintained exhibition spaces at the fair, which was attended by nearly 19.7 million people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Narrative</span> Account that presents connected events

A narrative, story, or tale is any account of a series of related events or experiences, whether nonfictional or fictional. Narratives can be presented through a sequence of written or spoken words, through still or moving images, or through any combination of these. The word derives from the Latin verb narrare, which is derived from the adjective gnarus. The formal and literary process of constructing a narrative—narration—is one of the four traditional rhetorical modes of discourse, along with argumentation, description, and exposition. This is a somewhat distinct usage from narration in the narrower sense of a commentary used to convey any written narrative. Many additional narrative techniques, particularly literary ones, are used to build and enhance any given story.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cordillera Administrative Region</span> Administrative region of the Philippines

The Cordillera Administrative Region, also known as the Cordillera Region and Cordillera, is an administrative region in the Philippines, situated within the island of Luzon. It is the only landlocked region in the insular country, bordered by the Ilocos Region to the west and southwest, and by the Cagayan Valley Region to the north, east, and southeast. It is the least populous region in the Philippines, with a population less than that of the city of Manila.

Diegesis is a style of fiction storytelling which presents an interior view of a world in which the narrator presents the actions of the characters to the readers or audience.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Human zoo</span> Public exhibits of humans

Human zoos, also known as ethnological expositions, were public displays of people, usually in a so-called "natural" or "primitive" state. They were most prominent during the 19th and 20th centuries. These displays sometimes emphasized the supposed inferiority of the exhibits' culture, and implied the superiority of "Western society", through tropes that purported marginalized groups as "savage". The idea of a "savage" derives from Columbus's voyages that deemed European culture remained pure, while other cultures were titled impure or "wild", and this stereotype relies heavily on the idea that different ways of living were "cast out by God", as other cultures do not recognize Christianity in relation to Creation. Throughout their existence such exhibitions garnered controversy over their demeaning, derogatory, and dehumanizing nature. They began as a part of circuses and "freak shows" which displayed exotic humans in a manner akin to a caricature which exaggerated their differences. They then developed into independent displays emphasizing the exhibits' inferiority to western culture and providing further justification for their subjugation. Such displays featured in multiple colonial exhibitions and at temporary exhibitions in animal zoos.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Igorot people</span> Ethnic group in the Philippines

The indigenous peoples of the Cordillera Mountain Range of northern Luzon, Philippines, often referred to by the exonym Igorot people, or more recently, as the Cordilleran peoples, are an ethnic group composed of nine main ethnolinguistic groups whose domains are in the Cordillera Mountain Range, altogether numbering about 1.5 million people in the early 21st century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Willi Ninja</span> American dancer and choreographer (1961–2006)

William Roscoe Leake, better known as Willi Ninja, was an American dancer and choreographer known for his appearance in the documentary film Paris Is Burning.

<i>December 7th</i> (film) 1943 film by John Ford, Gregg Toland

December 7th is a 1943 propaganda documentary film produced by the US Navy and directed by John Ford and Gregg Toland, about the December 7, 1941 attack on Pearl Harbor, the event which sparked the Pacific War and American involvement in World War II. Toland was also the film's cinematographer. The original version of this film, with a running time of 82 minutes, was not released but was retained by the National Archives. An edited version of 32 minutes length, which removed a long introductory segment and a shorter epilogue, was given limited release to specific audiences but won the Academy Award for Best Documentary in 1944. This is the only film Toland ever worked on for which he received a director credit.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fabián de la Rosa</span>

Don Fabián de la Rosa y Cueto was a Filipino painter. He was the uncle and mentor to the Philippines' national artist in painting, Fernando Amorsolo, and to his brother Pablo. He is regarded as a "master of genre" in Philippine art.

The Philippines is home to several folk dances such as Tinikling, Pandanggo, Cariñosa, and Subli. Dance has integrated itself in Philippine society over the course of many years and is imbedded in Philippine culture.

Eduardo Masferré was a Filipino-Catalan photographer who made important documentary reports about the lifestyle of native people in the region of the Cordillera in the Philippines at the middle of 20th century. He is regarded as the Father of Philippine photography.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ghent International Exposition (1913)</span> Worlds fair held in Ghent, Belgium

The Ghent International Exposition of 1913 was a world's fair held in Ghent, Belgium, from 26 April to 3 November 1913.

<i>Voyeurs & Savages</i>

Voyeurs & Savages is a 1998 English-language novel written by Filipino novelist Alfred A. Yuson. The 220-page novel was published in Pasig in the Philippines by Anvil Publishing, Inc. The second edition of the novel was published by Anvil Publishing, Inc. in 2003. The novel is a winner of the Philippines' Centennial Literary Prize. The novel featured the events before, during, and after the St. Louis World Exposition of 1904 in the United States. During the exposition that was held at the St. Louis, Missouri, a group of ethnic minorities from the Mountain Province of the Philippines represented the Philippines. Apart from being representatives from the Philippines, the group of Filipinos were also the "tribal specimens" selected and exhibited by a group of American researchers and presenters during the exposition.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bontoc people</span> Ethnic group of the Philippines

The Bontoc ethnolinguistic group can be found in the central and eastern portions of Mountain Province, in the Philippines. Although some Bontocs of Natonin and Paracelis identify themselves as Balangaos, Gaddangs or Kalingas, the term "Bontoc" is used by linguists and anthropologists to distinguish speakers of the Bontoc language from neighboring ethnolinguistic groups. They formerly practiced head-hunting and had distinctive body tattoos.


Suhel Nafar is currently the Vice President of Strategy & Market Development- WANA at Empire Distribution, the leading independent label, distributor, and publisher in the US and the first label to open a division in the US to help grow the local scene in West Asia & North Africa and its diaspora.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Albert Jenks</span> American anthropologist and professor at the University of Minnesota

Albert Ernest Jenks (1869–1953) was an American anthropologist and a professor at the University of Minnesota. He was known for his work in historical anthropological studies on rice cultivation, the development of hominids, and his identification of the skeletal remains of Minnesota Woman, 8,000-year old human remains found near Pelican Rapids, Minnesota. He joined the United States Bureau of Ethnology in 1901 and served in the U.S. colonial government of the Philippines from 1902 to 1905. In this capacity, he was involved in the exhibition of Bontoc Igorot people at the 1904 Louisiana Universal Exposition in St. Louis. The collection of Bontoc objects that he assembled for the Exposition was purchased by the American Museum of Natural History in New York. He joined the faculty of the University of Minnesota in 1906 as a member of the Department of Sociology. He was promoted to full professor in 1907 and served as chair of the sociology department from 1915 until 1918. In 1918, he was a founder of the Department of Anthropology at the University of Minnesota and he served as the chair of that department until his retirement in 1936.

Personal narrative (PN) is a prose narrative relating personal experience usually told in first person; its content is nontraditional. "Personal" refers to a story from one's life or experiences. "Nontraditional" refers to literature that does not fit the typical criteria of a narrative.

Filipino Americans have a long history of music in the United States. The Philippines have musical context and varied influences due to indigenous traditions and early colonial influences of Spanish and American occupation. During occupation by the United States, many Filipinos were recruited for manual labor along the West Coast. These early laborers commonly would perform Spanish-influenced rondallas as well as choral groups. With many Filipinos living in the United States beginning around the 1900s, Filipinos have contributed towards early Americana staples such as blues and jazz, and continue to influence more modern contemporary genres such as hip hop and rock. American music has also been influential in the Philippines for artists and vice versa. Though contributing to the evolution of American music, large number of Filipino Americans have a strong identity with culture of the Philippines by participating or organizing traditional dances and musical performances, largely in the form of PCNs on university campuses. Traditional dances and musical performances commonly practiced in the US are rondallas, choral groups, and gong chime ensembles. College campuses often organize performances on campuses, but can also have characteristics unique to America, as many Filipino Americans want to share their experiences of living in America and perform a more neo-traditional variation of traditional performances.

Elizabeth Henshaw Metcalf was an American amateur anthropologist who conducted fieldwork among the Bagobo in the Philippines. After meeting and corresponding with Bagobo participants of the 1904 Louisiana Purchase Exposition, Elizabeth and her sister, Sarah Metcalf, amassed one of the best collections of Bagobo textile and clothing in the United States, including rare examples of dua talian cloth and three-panel skirts that show the overdyeing technique called sináke. Elizabeth and Sarah Metcalfs’ collection was donated to the University Museum at the University of Pennsylvania and the National Museum of Natural History at the Smithsonian Institution.

References

  1. 1 2 "Marlon Fuentes - Media Arts Fellow". Mediaartists.org. Archived from the original on 2013-10-20. Retrieved 2013-07-14.
  2. Juhasz, Alexandra; Lerner, Jesse (2006). F Is for Phony: Fake Documentary And Truth's Undoing. U of Minnesota Press. ISBN   978-1-4529-0889-2.[ page needed ]
  3. Rony, Fatimah Tobing (2003). "The Quick and the Dead: Surrealism and the Found Ethnographic Footage Films of Bontoc Eulogy and Mother Dao: The Turtlelike". Camera Obscura. 18 (1): 129–155. doi:10.1215/02705346-18-1_52-129. S2CID   192013062. Project MUSE   42078.