Cube root law

Last updated

The cube root law is an observation in political science that the number of members of a unicameral legislature, or of the lower house of a bicameral legislature, is about the cube root of the population being represented. [1] The rule was devised by Estonian political scientist Rein Taagepera in his 1972 paper "The size of national assemblies". [2]

Contents

The law has led to a proposal to increase the size of the United States House of Representatives so that the number of representatives would be the cube root of the US population as calculated in the most recent census. [3] The House of Representatives has had 435 members since the Reapportionment Act of 1929 was passed; if the US followed the cube root rule, there would be 693 members of the House of Representatives based on the population at the 2020 Census.

This proposal was endorsed by the New York Times editorial board in 2018. [4]

Subsequent analysis

It has been claimed by Giorgio Margaritondo that the experimental data, including the dataset originally used by Taagepera in 1972, actually fits better to a function with a higher exponent, and that there is sufficient deviation from the cube root rule to question its usefulness. [5] In this regard, analysis by Margaritondo gives an optimal formula of: , where A is the size of the assembly, P is the population, and E = 0.45±0.03.

Applying this formula to the U.S. House of Representatives as of the 2020 Census would give a House of between 379 and 1231 members, while using an exponent of 0.4507 gives 693 (the same result using the cube root rule).

Table comparing OECD nations in 2019 with EIU Democracy Index ranking

Out of the countries listed, Lithuania is the only one to exactly match the cube root rule. Moreover, Denmark, Canada, and Mexico come close to matching the rule.

Some of these countries (eg Germany) have overhang seats in a mixed member proportional system, as a result the size of their parliaments can vary significantly between elections.

CountryLower or unicameral housePopulation (2019) [6] Lower house size (2019)Cube root of population (nearest person)Difference between lower house and cube root of populationDifference between lower house and cube root of population (%)People per representativePeople per representative (cube root lower house)Democracy Index Ranking (2022) [7]
Australia House of Representatives 25,364,307151294−143−49%167,97686,32715
Austria National Council 8,877,067183207−24−12%48,50942,87320
Belgium Chamber of Representatives 11,484,055150226−76−34%76,56050,90136
Canada House of Commons 37,589,262338335+3+1%111,211112,21312
Chile Chamber of Deputies 18,952,038155267−112−42%122,27171,08419
Colombia Chamber of Representatives 50,339,443172363−191−53%303,250136,33453
Czech Republic Chamber of Deputies 10,669,709200220−20−9%53,34948,46625
Denmark Folketing 5,818,553179180−1−1%32,50632,3506
Estonia Riigikogu 1,326,590101110−9−8%13,13512,07327
Finland Parliament 5,520,314200177+23+13%27,60231,2355
France National Assembly 67,059,887577406+171+42%116,222165,06022
Germany Bundestag 83,132,799734436+298+68%113,260190,48014
Greece Parliament 10,716,322300220+80+36%35,72148,60725
Hungary National Assembly 9,769,949199214−15−7%49,09545,70156
Iceland Althing 361,3136371−8−11%5,7355,0733
Ireland Dáil 5,100,000160173−13−8%31,87529,0118
Israel Knesset 9,053,300120208−88−42%75,44443,43829
Italy Chamber of Deputies 60,297,396400392+8+2%150,743153,76834
Japan House of Representatives 126,264,931465502−37−7%271,537251,68416
Korea, Republic of National Assembly 51,709,098300373−73−20%172,384138,79624
Latvia Saeima 1,912,789100124−24−19%19,21815,40938
Lithuania Seimas 2,786,84414114100%19,76519,80339
Luxembourg Chamber of Deputies 619,8966085−25−29%10,3327,27013
Mexico Chamber of Deputies 127,575,529500503−3−1%255,151253,42289
Netherlands House of Representatives 17,332,850150259−109−42%115,55266,9759
New Zealand House of Representatives 4,917,000120170−50−29%40,97528,9162
Norway Storting 5,347,896169175−6−3%31,64430,5811
Poland Sejm 37,970,874460336+124+37%82,545112,97146
Portugal Assembly of the Republic 10,269,417230217+13+6%44,65047,24628
Slovakia National Council 5,454,073150176−26−15%36,36030,98543
Slovenia National Assembly 2,087,94690128−38−30%23,19916,33631
Spain Congress of Deputies 47,076,781350361−11−3%134,505130,37822
Sweden Riksdag 10,285,453349217+132+61%29,47147,2954
Switzerland National Council 8,574,832200205−5−2%42,87441,8947
Turkey Grand National Assembly 83,429,615600437+163+37%139,049190,933103
United Kingdom House of Commons 66,834,405650406+244+60%102,822164,69018
United States House of Representatives 328,239,523435690−255−37%754,574475,84030

Historical US House sizes

The following table describes how the US House of Representatives would have looked historically under the cube root rule according to the Huntington–Hill method.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Legislature</span> Deliberative assembly that makes laws

A legislature is a deliberative assembly with the legal authority to make laws for a political entity such as a country, nation or city. They are often contrasted with the executive and judicial powers of government. Legislatures can exist at different levels of government–national, state/provincial/regional, local, even supranational. Countries differ as to what extent they grant deliberative assemblies at the subnational law-making power, as opposed to purely administrative responsibilities.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Delaware General Assembly</span> Legislative branch of the state government of Delaware

The Delaware General Assembly is the legislature of the U.S. state of Delaware. It is a bicameral legislature composed of the Delaware Senate with 21 senators and the Delaware House of Representatives with 41 representatives. It meets at Legislative Hall in Dover, convening on the second Tuesday of January of odd-numbered years, with a second session of the same Assembly convening likewise in even-numbered years. Normally the sessions are required to adjourn by the last day of June of the same calendar year. However the Governor can call a special session of the legislature at any time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ohio General Assembly</span> Legislative branch of the state government of Ohio

The Ohio General Assembly is the state legislature of the U.S. state of Ohio. It consists of the 99-member Ohio House of Representatives and the 33-member Ohio Senate. Both houses of the General Assembly meet at the Ohio Statehouse in Columbus.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">United States congressional apportionment</span> How 435 seats are distributed to 50 states

United States congressional apportionment is the process by which seats in the United States House of Representatives are distributed among the 50 states according to the most recent decennial census mandated by the United States Constitution. After each state is assigned one seat in the House, most states are then apportioned a number of additional seats which roughly corresponds to its share of the aggregate population of the 50 states. Every state is constitutionally guaranteed at least one seat in the House and two seats in the Senate, regardless of population.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wisconsin Senate</span> Upper house of the Wisconsin Legislature

The Wisconsin Senate is the upper house of the Wisconsin State Legislature. Together with the Wisconsin State Assembly they constitute the legislative branch of the state of Wisconsin. The powers of the Wisconsin Senate are modeled after those of the U.S. Senate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wisconsin State Assembly</span> Lower house of the Wisconsin Legislature

The Wisconsin State Assembly is the lower house of the Wisconsin Legislature. Together with the smaller Wisconsin Senate, the two constitute the legislative branch of the U.S. state of Wisconsin.

Redistricting in the United States is the process of drawing electoral district boundaries. For the United States House of Representatives, and state legislatures, redistricting occurs after each decennial census.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Electoral district (Canada)</span> Federal or provincial electoral district in Canada

An electoral district in Canada is a geographical constituency upon which Canada's representative democracy is based. It is officially known in Canadian French as a circonscription but frequently called a comté (county). In Canadian English it is also colloquially and more commonly known as a riding or constituency.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Illinois General Assembly</span> Legislative branch of the state government of Illinois

The Illinois General Assembly is the legislature of the U.S. state of Illinois. It has two chambers, the Illinois House of Representatives and the Illinois Senate. The General Assembly was created by the first state constitution adopted in 1818. As of 2023, the current General Assembly is the 103rd; the term of an assembly lasts two years.

Congressional districts, also known as electoral districts in other nations, are divisions of a larger administrative region that represent the population of a region in the larger congressional body. Countries with congressional districts include the United States, the Philippines, and Japan.

<i>Federalist No. 55</i> Federalist Paper by James Madison

Federalist No. 55 is an essay by James Madison, the fifty-fifth of The Federalist Papers. It was first published by The New York Packet on February 13, 1788 under the pseudonym Publius, the name under which all The Federalist Papers were published. It is titled "The Total Number of House of Representatives". It is the first of four papers defending the number of members in the House of Representatives against the critics who believe the number of members to be inadequate. The critics presume that there aren't enough representatives to defend the country against the small group of legislators who are violating the rights of the people. In this paper, Madison examines the size of the United States House of Representatives.

The Penrose method is a method devised in 1946 by Professor Lionel Penrose for allocating the voting weights of delegations in decision-making bodies proportional to the square root of the population represented by this delegation. This is justified by the fact that, due to the square root law of Penrose, the a priori voting power of a member of a voting body is inversely proportional to the square root of its size. Under certain conditions, this allocation achieves equal voting powers for all people represented, independent of the size of their constituency. Proportional allocation would result in excessive voting powers for the electorates of larger constituencies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cube rule</span> Law regarding first-past-the-post elections

The cube rule or cube law is an empirical observation regarding elections under the first-past-the-post system. The rule suggests that the party getting the most votes is over-represented. It was first formulated in a report on British elections in 1909, then extended to elections in other countries. Both in theory and in practice, the cube rule is only applicable in a two-party system. In a multi-party democracy operating under the first-past-the-post system, the cube law invariably fails, often leading to capricious results.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reapportionment Act of 1929</span> United States Law providing for 435 Representatives in the House

The Reapportionment Act of 1929, also known as the Permanent Apportionment Act of 1929, is a combined census and apportionment bill enacted on June 18, 1929, that establishes a permanent method for apportioning a constant 435 seats in the U.S. House of Representatives according to each census. This reapportionment was preceded by the Apportionment Act of 1911, which established the 435-seat size, and followed nearly a decade of debate and gridlock after the 1920 Census. The 1929 Act took effect after the 1932 election, meaning that the House was never reapportioned as a result of the 1920 United States Census, and representation in the lower chamber remained frozen for 95 years as of 2024 .

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Congressional Apportionment Amendment</span> Proposed amendment to the US Constitution pertaining to the number of Representatives in the House

The Congressional Apportionment Amendment is a proposed amendment to the United States Constitution that addresses the number of seats in the House of Representatives. It was proposed by Congress on September 25, 1789, but was never ratified by the requisite number of state legislatures. As Congress did not set a time limit for its ratification, the Congressional Apportionment Amendment is still pending before the states. As of 2024, it is one of six unratified amendments.

The Wyoming Rule is a proposal to increase the size of the United States House of Representatives so that the standard representative-to-population ratio would be that of the smallest state, which is currently Wyoming. Under Article One of the United States Constitution, each state is guaranteed at least one representative. If the disparity between the population of the most and least populous states continues to grow, the disproportionality of the U.S. House of Representatives will continue to increase unless the body, whose size has been fixed at 435 since 1929, is expanded.

Matthew Søberg Shugart is an American political scientist. He is a Distinguished Professor of political science at the University of California, Davis. He is also an Affiliated Professor at the University of Haifa. Shugart specializes in electoral systems, party systems, and the design of political institutions, primarily through empirical studies of political systems across large numbers of countries. Shugart is also an orchardist, and runs the Fruits and Votes blog on electoral systems and fruit growing.

In voting theory, the micromega rule holds that, when political parties choose electoral systems, "the large prefer the small and the small prefer the large". The term "micromega" references Micromégas, a tale by Voltaire in which dwarfs and giants dialogue.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Redistricting in North Carolina</span> USA gerrymandering controversy (2010-)

Redistricting in North Carolina has been a controversial topic due to allegations and admissions of gerrymandering.

References

  1. Lutz, Donald S. (2006). Principles of Constitutional Design. Cambridge University Press. ISBN   9781139460552.
  2. Taagepera, Rein (1972). "The size of national assemblies". Social Science Research. 1 (4): 385–401. doi:10.1016/0049-089X(72)90084-1.
  3. Kane, Caroline; Mascioli, Gianni; McGarry, Michael; Nagel, Meira (January 2020). Why the House of Representatives Must Be Expanded and How Today's Congress Can Make It Happen (PDF) (Report). Fordham University School of Law. Retrieved 17 September 2020.
  4. "America Needs a Bigger House". New York Times. 9 November 2018. Retrieved 17 September 2020.
  5. Margaritondo, Giorgio (2021). "Size of National Assemblies: The Classic Derivation of the Cube-Root Law is Conceptually Flawed". Frontiers in Physics. 8: 606. Bibcode:2021FrP.....8..606M. doi: 10.3389/fphy.2020.614596 . ISSN   2296-424X.
  6. "Population, total - OECD members | Data". data.worldbank.org. Retrieved 2020-09-19.
  7. "EIU Report: Democracy Index 2022". Economist Intelligence Unit. 2023. Retrieved April 24, 2023.