Ethical Oil

Last updated

Ethical Oil: The Case for Canada's Oil Sands
EthicalOil.jpg
Author Ezra Levant
Country Canada
Language English
Publisher McClelland & Stewart [1]
Publication date
2010
Pages261
ISBN 0-7710-4641-3
OCLC 437081482

Ethical Oil: The Case for Canada's Oil Sands is a book written by Canadian talk-show host and political activist Ezra Levant, which makes a case for exploiting the Athabasca oil sands and its sister projects in Alberta. Published in 2010 by McClelland & Stewart in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, [1] the book became a non-fiction best seller [2] and won the National Business Book Award for 2011. [3]

Contents

In the 261 page book, Ezra Levant makes the case that in terms of four criteria (the environment, conflict, economic and social justice and freedom from oppression) the Canadian petroleum industry is "heads above other crude producers like Saudi Arabia, Libya, Nigeria and Venezuela". [4] [5] Highlighting perceived hypocrisy from Western progressive and environmental movements, [6] the author confronts what he sees as unfair and excessive criticism of oil sands, stating that the "oil sands are not perfect, and criticizing them is fair game. But why has criticism of the oil sands been so disproportionately loud compared to criticism of other, larger, more disturbing sources of oil?". [7]

Ethical Oil: The Case for Canada's Oil Sands has popularized the concept of "ethical oil" as a neologism, giving ammunition to the Conservative government of Stephen Harper and providing the inspiration behind Alykhan Velshi's "EthicalOil" campaign in the United States and Canada.

The Economist called Ethical Oil a "polemical defence of the tar sands." [8]

Background

Oil sands in Alberta have a proven reserve of 170 billion barrels (2.7×1010 m3), the second largest proven reserves of crude oil in the world. [9] They have become the largest source of oil imported into the United States. [10] With significant economic development and investment into the oil sands, the industry has been enjoying strong support by both the province's government and the federal government. [11] However, the industry has also been subject to criticism due to the environmental impacts of bitumen exploitation. [12] [13] While the industry has attempted to resolve these issues by developing new techniques, such as in situ extraction, environmental organizations, such as Greenpeace, have launched campaigns to delegitimize the resource, based on its greenhouse gas emission records. [14]

Canada's primary export market, the United States, has been ambivalent to the environmental questions surrounding the exploitation of the oil sands, with Republicans being generally more supportive of the resource, [15] while president Barack Obama, a Democrat, said that "there are some environmental questions about how destructive they are". [16]

In an attempt to refocus the debate, Ezra Levant, a conservative political activist and former publisher of the Western Standard , examines the ethical aspects of importing oil from countries where political oppression and human rights violations are prevalent, and argues that oil sands production from Canada should be considered the only true ethical alternative to OPEC oil exports. [17] His inspiration for the concept of 'ethical oil' came from the neologism 'conflict diamond', and its antonym 'conflict-free diamond'. Levant decided to write the book to change some minds, after realizing at the 2009 Ottawa International Writers Festival in Ottawa that he was the "token Alberta whipping boy" during a panel on the oil sands, and ineffective at convincing the audience of the merits of the oil sands. Ezra Levant stated that he wrote the book from a liberal point of view, in order to appeal to those who reject the traditional conservative point of view. [18]

Content

The book is divided into 12 chapters, with a prologue, an epilogue, acknowledgments and sources. Chapters deal with various topics, including an overview of the biggest oil producing countries, an account of the controversy over Talisman Energy's involvement in Sudan, a critical analysis of some ethical funds, a case about inconsistencies in Greenpeace activism, a rebuke of the cancer controversy in Fort Chipewyan, the implication of Middle-Eastern regimes in the anti-Oil sands movement, and a critical analysis of the green jobs arguments.

A recurring theme throughout Ethical Oil: The Case for Canada's Oil Sands is the perceived hypocrisy of Western environmental movements. In a chapter entitled "Greenpeace's Best Fundraiser Ever", Levant notes the disparities between the harsh criticism of the Canadian energy industry coming from Greenpeace Canada to the seemingly absent criticism of Chinese industrial activity (such as nuclear power) from Greenpeace China, arguing that it is much easier to criticize free and liberal democracies than to criticize controlling regimes, but also raising the question of funding, noting that China, the most populated country on Earth, is a very attractive fundraising market for Greenpeace (which Levant describes as a 'multinational corporation').

Reviews

Andrew Brannan reviewed the book in The Objective Standard , and noted that it provides a "barrage of evidence in moral defense of the oil sands producers", [19] while Peter Foster, a Financial Post columnist, suggested that Levant "not only exposes the lies and hypocrisy of the media-coddled opponents of the vast resource, but raises the uncomfortable question of what alternatives to the oilsands these moralists prefer". [20] On the other hand, David Suzuki, dismissing Levant as an "apologist", argued that "the logic is faulty. Just because a country or society is considered 'ethical' does not mean everything it produces or exports is ethical". [21] In the Winnipeg Free Press , John Collins, a retired union negotiator, criticized some of Levant's sources, noting the presence of the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers in the footnotes, [22] while Patrick Brethour, an editor for The Globe and Mail writing in the Literary Review of Canada , contends that the title of Levant’s book "is a considerable misstatement" and that Levant "fails to make the case for ethical oil". [23]

Reactions

A January 1, 2011 article in The Economist described Ezra Levant as the "author of a recent polemical defence of the tar sands". The article cites Ethical Oil's statement that "Americans would rather buy from Canada than from Venezuela and the Middle East." At that time, The Economist said that the United States would "remain the world's biggest oil buyer for decades" with foreign supplies growing—not decreasing—in importance. [8]

Support

Ezra Levant's work gave ammunition to the Conservative government, which adopted the neologism in a similar rhetoric. Stephen Harper, Prime Minister of Canada from 2006 until 2015, was quoted as saying that it is "critical to develop that resource in a way that’s responsible and environmental and the reality for the United States, which is the biggest consumer of our petroleum products, is that Canada is a very ethical society and a safe source for the United States in comparison to other sources of energy." [24] Danielle Smith, leader of Alberta's Wildrose Alliance, echoed Levant's arguments during a speech at the Fort McMurray Chamber of Commerce. [25]

In 2011, Alykhan Velshi, a former staffer for Minister of Immigration Jason Kenney left government service and founded a website to promote the ideas put forward by Ezra Levant in his book. He subsequently returned as the Director of Planning for the Prime Minister’s Office later in 2011. [26] The website, EthicalOil.org launched a campaign to compare Canada's 'Ethical Oil' against OPEC's 'Conflict Oil' and features controversial advertisements comparing conditions for women, gays and other minorities in OPEC countries to those in Canada. [27] EthicalOil.org has staged counter-protests in response to opposition to the Keystone XL pipeline project. [28] Velshi left Ethical Oil in the fall of 2011, and was replaced by law student and former junior Conservative staffer Kathryn Marshall. [29]

Criticism

Among critics of the 'Ethical Oil' point of view is Andrew Nikiforuk, author of Tar Sands: Dirty Oil and the Future of a Continent (Greystone Books, 2008, ISBN   1-55365-407-2), who referred to Levant's reasoning as "a classic Republican ruse", [30] and dismissed Minister of the Environment Peter Kent's argument as an "infomercial on bitumen". [31] In The Guardian, Leo Hickman points out that China is a major investor in the Canadian oil sands, and asks "Shouldn't this now mean that Canada's tar sands are labelled as 'Conflict Oil', too?" [32] Another opponent, Megan Leslie, the environment critic for the Official Opposition's New Democratic Party, said the debate surrounding the ethics of Canadian oil sands "misses the point" and maintained that "Canada should be working to move beyond fossil fuels toward renewable sources of energy". [33]

CBC's The Current held a debate on the merits of the ethical oil argument in Dec 2011. Nobel laureate and chair of the Nobel Women's Initiative Jody Williams, argued that the ethical oil position was disingenuous and suspect of commercial interests rather than genuine concern for women’s rights. She argued that the oil industry with no history of advocating the case of women’s rights, is ill placed to begin the discussion. Ethical Oil spokesperson Kathryn Marshall responded that the ethical nature of oil production needs to be discussed, and she expected human rights activists to be more inclined to promote dialogue. Dr. Andrew Crane a business ethics professor at York University agreed the ethical argument for oil production should be discussed, but also added the narrow focus of the books argument was prioritizing human rights over other ethical evaluating factors. Dr. Crane further stated that Canada was not taking a leadership position by trying to improve ethical extraction practices overseas and not just in Canada. He argued a primary ethical indicator is leadership, and companies operating in Canada, and Canadian companies operating abroad were not being held accountable within the ethical oil argument for their overseas practices. Kathryn Marshall responded the focus should be on the pushing these "unethical" countries for regulatory action, rather than the pushing the companies to improve in the absence of a regulatory impetus. [34]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Oil sands</span> Type of unconventional oil deposit

Oil sands, tar sands, crude bitumen, or bituminous sands, are a type of unconventional petroleum deposit. Oil sands are either loose sands or partially consolidated sandstone containing a naturally occurring mixture of sand, clay, and water, soaked with bitumen, a dense and extremely viscous form of petroleum.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Athabasca oil sands</span> Oil and bitumen deposits in Alberta, Canada

The Athabasca oil sands, also known as the Athabasca tar sands, are large deposits of bitumen or extremely heavy crude oil that constitute unconventional resources, located in northeastern Alberta, Canada – roughly centred on the boomtown of Fort McMurray. These oil sands, hosted primarily in the McMurray Formation, consist of a mixture of crude bitumen, silica sand, clay minerals, and water. The Athabasca deposit is the largest known reservoir of crude bitumen in the world and the largest of three major oil sands deposits in Alberta, along with the nearby Peace River and Cold Lake deposits.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ezra Levant</span> Canadian media personality and conservative activist

Ezra Isaac Levant is a Canadian conservative media personality, political activist, writer, broadcaster, and former lawyer. Levant is the founder and former publisher of the conservative magazine, The Western Standard. He is also the co-founder, owner, and CEO of the far-right media website Rebel News. Levant has also worked as a columnist for Sun Media, and he hosted a daily program on the Sun News Network from the channel's inception in 2011 until its demise in 2015.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas Homer-Dixon</span> Canadian political scientist

Thomas Homer-Dixon is a Canadian political scientist and author who researches threats to global security. He is the founder and Executive Director of the Cascade Institute at Royal Roads University in Victoria, British Columbia. He is the author of seven books, the most recent being Commanding Hope: The Power We Have to Renew a World in Peril.

Syncrude Canada Ltd. is one of the world's largest producers of synthetic crude oil from oil sands and the largest single source producer in Canada. It is located just outside Fort McMurray in the Athabasca Oil Sands, and has a nameplate capacity of 350,000 barrels per day (56,000 m3/d) of oil, equivalent to about 13% of Canada's consumption. It has approximately 5.1 billion barrels (810,000,000 m3) of proven and probable reserves situated on 8 leases over 3 contiguous sites. Including fully realized prospective reserves, current production capacity could be sustained for well over 90 years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Keystone Pipeline</span> Oil pipeline in North America

The Keystone Pipeline System is an oil pipeline system in Canada and the United States, commissioned in 2010 and owned by TC Energy and, as of March 2020, the Government of Alberta. It runs from the Western Canadian Sedimentary Basin in Alberta to refineries in Illinois and Texas, and also to oil tank farms and an oil pipeline distribution center in Cushing, Oklahoma.

Ecojustice Canada, is a Canadian non-profit environmental law organization that provides funding to lawyers to use litigation to defend and protect the environment. Ecojustice is Canada's largest environmental law charity.

Alykhan Velshi is a lawyer, policy analyst, and ministerial assistant. He has worked at the predominantly neoconservative American Enterprise Institute and was manager of research at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, where he co-founded the Center for Law and Counterterrorism with Andrew C. McCarthy. He has written pieces in support of George W. Bush's foreign and military policies. Velshi previously worked as director of issues management for Stephen Harper. He used to work as chief of staff for two leaders of the official opposition of Ontario, Patrick Brown and Vic Fedeli, who were then leader of the Ontario Progressive Conservative Party. Currently he is working in the private sector as Huawei Technologies Canada's vice-president of corporate affairs.

The Enbridge Northern Gateway Pipelines were a planned-but-never-built project for a twin pipeline from Bruderheim, Alberta, to Kitimat, British Columbia. The project was active from the mid-2000s to 2016. The eastbound pipeline would have imported natural gas condensate, and the westbound pipeline would have exported diluted bitumen from the Athabasca oil sands to a marine terminal in Kitimat for transportation to Asian markets via oil tankers. The project would have also included terminal facilities with "integrated marine infrastructure at tidewater to accommodate loading and unloading of oil and condensate tankers, and marine transportation of oil and condensate." The CA$7.9 billion project was first proposed in the mid-2000s but was postponed several times. The project plan was developed by Enbridge Inc., a Canadian crude oil and liquids pipeline and storage company.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sun News Network</span> Defunct Canadian cable news TV channel

Sun News Network was a Canadian English language Category C news channel owned by Québecor Média through a partnership between two of its subsidiaries, TVA Group and Sun Media Corporation. The channel was launched on April 18, 2011 in standard and high definition and shut down February 13, 2015. It operated under a Category 2 licence granted by the Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) in November 2010, after the network aborted a highly publicized attempt for a Category 1 licence that would have given it mandatory access on digital cable and satellite providers across Canada.

The National Business Book Award is an award presented to Canadian business authors. The award, presented every year since 1985, is sponsored by Bennett Jones, The Globe and Mail, and The Walrus, DeGroote, and supported by CPA Canada and with prize management by Freedman & Associates.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Beaver Lake Cree Nation</span> Canadian First Nation

The Beaver Lake Cree Nation is a First Nations band government located 105 kilometres (65 mi) northeast of Edmonton, Alberta, representing people of the Cree ethno-linguistic group in the area around Lac La Biche, Alberta, where the band office is currently located. Their treaty area is Treaty 6. The Intergovernmental Affairs office consults with persons on the Government treaty contacts list. There are two parcels of land reserved for the band by the Canadian Crown, Beaver Lake Indian Reserve No. 131 and Blue Quills First Nation Indian Reserve. The latter reserve is shared by six bands; Beaver Lake Cree Nations, Cold Lake First Nations, Frog Lake First Nation, Heart Lake First Nation, Kehewin Cree Nation, Saddle Lake Cree Nation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Emily Hunter</span> Canadian activist, author and filmmaker

Emily Hunter is a Canadian activist, author and filmmaker. She is the daughter of the late Robert Hunter, first president of Greenpeace and Bobbi Hunter, co-founder of Greenpeace. She has been a campaigner for nearly a decade on numerous environmental causes, from fighting whaling to climate change. She is known in Canada as a writer for THIS magazine and as environmental correspondent for MTV News.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tzeporah Berman</span>

Tzeporah Berman is a Canadian environmental activist, campaigner and writer. She is known for her role as one of the organizers of the logging blockades in Clayoquot Sound, British Columbia in 1992–93.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tar Sands Healing Walk</span> Demonstration to help bring awareness of impact of the Athabasca Oil Sands

The Tar Sands Healing Walk was a 14 km annual prayer walk in demonstration against crude oil extraction in the Athabasca tar sands. It began in 2010, starting just north of the city of Fort McMurray, Alberta at a location known as the Syncrude Loop, and traveling through the heart of the tar sands extraction zone. The walk was led by local Indigenous Elders, who prayed for the healing of the land and to bring attention to the destructive impacts of the tar sands.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rebel News</span> Canadian far-right political and social commentary media website

Rebel News is a Canadian far-right political and social commentary media website operated by Rebel News Network Ltd. It has been described as a "global platform" for the anti-Muslim ideology known as counter-jihad. It was founded in February 2015 by former Sun News Network personalities Ezra Levant and Brian Lilley.

Melina Laboucan-Massimo is a climate justice and Indigenous rights advocate from the Lubicon Cree community of Little Buffalo in northern Alberta, Canada. Growing up with firsthand experience of the effects of oil and gas drilling on local communities, she began advocating for an end to resource extraction in Indigenous territories but shifted focus to supporting a renewable energy transition after a ruptured pipeline spilled approximately 4.5 million litres of oil near Little Buffalo in 2011.

The Canadian province of Alberta faces a number of environmental issues related to natural resource extraction—including oil and gas industry with its oil sands—endangered species, melting glaciers in banff, floods and droughts, wildfires, and global climate change. While the oil and gas industries generates substantial economic wealth, the Athabasca oil sands, which are situated almost entirely in Alberta, are the "fourth most carbon intensive on the planet behind Algeria, Venezuela and Cameroon" according to an August 8, 2018 article in the American Association for the Advancement of Science's journal Science. This article details some of the environmental issues including past ecological disasters in Alberta and describes some of the efforts at the municipal, provincial and federal level to mitigate the risks and impacts.

Andrew Leach is a Canadian energy and environmental economist and a contributing writer to a number of Canadian news outlets including The Globe and Mail, and Maclean's. His research areas span energy and environmental economics—including topics such as oil sands regulation, clean energy innovations, with a specific focus on climate change policies.

Petropolis: Aerial Perspectives on the Alberta Tar Sands is a Canadian short documentary film, directed by Peter Mettler and released in 2009. The film provides an aerial view of the environmental destruction wrought by the Alberta oil sands project.

References

  1. 1 2 AMICUS (2010), Full Record, Library and Archives Canada
  2. ↑ BookNet Canada (September 2010), CBC Bestseller Lists 2010 – Top Canadian Non-Fiction, CBC, retrieved 21 August 2011
  3. ↑ 2011 Winner, The National Business Book Award, archived from the original on 14 July 2011, retrieved 2 August 2011
  4. ↑ Vanderklippe, Nathan (13 September 2010), Blood diamonds, blood oil?, Toronto: The Globe and Mail, retrieved 2 August 2011
  5. ↑ Goddard, John (25 September 2010), "Made in Canada", Toronto Star, retrieved 2 August 2011
  6. ↑ Morrow, Walker (7 February 2011), Review: Ethical Oil: The Case for Canada's Oil Sands, Libertas Post, archived from the original on 24 March 2012, retrieved 2 August 2011
  7. ↑ Levant, Ezra (p. 140)
  8. 1 2 "Muck and brass - Canada's tar sands". The Economist . January 1, 2011. Retrieved October 23, 2019.
  9. ↑ Schindler, David (November 2010), "Tar sands need solid science", Nature , 468 (7323): 499–501, Bibcode:2010Natur.468..499S, doi: 10.1038/468499a , PMID   21107404
  10. ↑ Lynch, Kevin (February 2011), US Energy Security: A Canadian Perspective (PDF), Policy Options, pp. 23–25, archived from the original (PDF) on 17 March 2012, retrieved 1 September 2011
  11. ↑ Owen, Nick; Inderwildi, Oliver R.; King, David A. (August 2010), "The status of conventional world oil reserves—Hype or cause for concern?", Energy Policy, 38 (8): 4743–4749, doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2010.02.026
  12. ↑ Giesy, John; Anderson, Julie C.; Wiseman, Steve B. (2010), "Alberta oil sands development", Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 107 (3): 951–952, Bibcode:2010PNAS..107..951G, doi: 10.1073/pnas.0912880107 , PMC   2824323 , PMID   20080655
  13. ↑ Charpentier, Alex; Bergerson, Joule A; MacLean, Heather L (January–March 2009), "Understanding the Canadian oil sands industry's greenhouse gas emissions", Environmental Research Letters , 4 (1): 014005, Bibcode:2009ERL.....4a4005C, doi: 10.1088/1748-9326/4/1/014005
  14. ↑ Hoyos, Carola (18 May 2009), "Greenpeace warns on Shell oil sands projects", Financial Times, retrieved 5 August 2011
  15. ↑ Gwyn, Morgan (Spring 2011), The ethics of oil in a time of turmoil, CTV News, archived from the original on March 10, 2011, retrieved 5 August 2011
  16. ↑ Savage, Luiza (6 April 2011), Obama: 'questions' about 'destructive' oil sands; Senator wants trade inquiry, Macleans, retrieved 21 August 2011
  17. ↑ Christian, Carol (December 2010), Ezra Levant to speak about book, Ethical Oil, Fort McMurray Today, retrieved 2 August 2011
  18. ↑ Taber, Jane (14 January 2011), Meet Harper's oil-sands muse, Toronto: The Globe and Mail, retrieved 21 August 2011
  19. ↑ Brannan, Andrew (Summer 2011), Ethical Oil: The Case for Canada's Oil Sands (Vol. 6, No. 2), The Objective Standard, retrieved 3 August 2011(subscription required)
  20. ↑ Foster, Peter (21 September 2010), Oil sands opponents are motivated by anti-capitalist, anti-development ideology and organizational self-interest, The Financial Post, archived from the original on 23 March 2012, retrieved 3 August 2011
  21. ↑ Suzuki, David (2 February 2011), Canada's Ethical Oil: A Contradiction in Terms, The Mark News, archived from the original on 9 October 2011, retrieved 3 August 2011
  22. ↑ Collins, John K. (18 September 2010), "Levant's oil polemic witty, but that doesn't make it right", Winnipeg Free Press, retrieved 11 September 2011
  23. ↑ Brethour, Patrick (October 2010), A Slippery Debate, Literary Review of Canada, retrieved 23 November 2011
  24. ↑ Chase, Steven (7 January 2011), Harper's embrace of 'ethical' oil sands reignites 'dirty' arguments, Toronto: The Globe and Mail, retrieved 3 August 2011
  25. ↑ McDowell, Adam (22 September 2010), Alberta tar sands praised as 'ethical oil', National Post, reprint by the Sierra Club, retrieved 5 August 2011
  26. ↑ Clark, Campbell (14 November 2011). "Tory staffer who left Hill to plug 'ethical' oil lands job in Harper's office - The Globe and Mail". The Globe and Mail. Toronto.
  27. ↑ Freeze, Colin (28 July 2011), Ex-Tory message maven tailors his spin to oil sands, Toronto: The Globe and Mail, retrieved 3 August 2011
  28. ↑ Goodman, Alana (1 September 2011), The "Ethical" Case for the Keystone Pipeline, Commentary Magazine, retrieved 2 September 2011
  29. ↑ "Canada's crude awakening - Macleans.ca" . Retrieved 2015-10-06.
  30. ↑ Naumetz, Tim (13 January 2011), Kent's position as Canada's federal environment minister 'untenable,' says Nikiforuk, The Hill Times, archived from the original on 17 January 2011, retrieved 3 August 2011
  31. ↑ Naumetz, Tim (17 January 2011), Kent talked up 'ethical oil' sands a week before his official department briefing, The Hill Times, archived from the original on 14 July 2012, retrieved 3 August 2011
  32. ↑ Hickman, Leo (28 July 2011), "Canadian campaign puts the spin on 'ethical oil'", The Guardian, London, retrieved 3 August 2011
  33. ↑ 'Ethical oil' campaign polishes oilsands image, CBC News, 29 July 2011, retrieved 3 August 2011
  34. ↑ Tremonti, Anna Maria (host) (6 December 2011). "Ethical Oil". The Current. CBC Radio. Archived from the original on 8 December 2011.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.