Fair Food Program

Last updated

The Fair Food Program (FFP) is a partnership between growers, farmworkers, and food company buyers to improve conditions for farmworkers. [1] [2] It was launched by the Coalition of Immokalee Workers (CIW), a worker-based human rights organization in Immokalee, Florida in 2011. The Fair Food Program functions through legally binding agreements between the CIW and large retail companies that pledge to buy produce only from growers who follow the Fair Food Program's Code of Conduct, paying an extra penny a pound to farmworkers. [3] By signing an agreement with the CIW, companies pledge to cease purchasing from any grower that violates the standards. [3] [4] The Fair Foods Standards Council (FFSC) oversees the program and ensures that standards are upheld. [5]

Contents

The Fair Food Program is credited with helping eradicate modern-day slavery and forced labor on participating farms and has extended its protections to workers in 10 states and nine crops domestically. [1] [6] Several current participating buyers in the Fair Food Program have pledged their support for expanding the enforceable protections for workers in the three countries with pilot farms, including Mexico, Chile, and South Africa. [6] Major participating buyers include McDonald's, Walmart, Whole Foods, Trader Joes, and Yum Brands. [7] [8] In spite of pressure and protests, some supermarket chains, including Kroger and Publix, refuse to join the Fair Food Program. [9] [10]

Implementation

A series of interlocking mechanisms define the Fair Food Program: large retail corporations become Participating Buyers, who agree to only source relevant produce from farms that follow the Fair Food Program's code of conduct by signing an agreement with the Coalition of Immokalee Workers (CIW). In turn, farms, or Participating Growers, which follow the worker-developed Code of Conduct gain access to sell their produce to Buyers with preferential ordering. [11] The Fair Food Standards Council, which is a third-party monitoring group, ensures farms’ compliance with the Code of Conduct. [5] According to the Coalition of Immokalee Workers, two unique driving forces behind the Fair Food Program are that workers are empowered to be the monitors of their own rights, and that it is backed by meaningful market consequences for farms that do not follow the Code of Conduct. [12]

Fair Food Label

The CIW has also developed a consumer-facing "Fair Food Label" to help promote the program in supermarkets. [2]

Code of Conduct

The Fair Food Program's Code of Conduct is developed by farmworkers and applies both to the working and living conditions of farmworkers. [13] It contains zero-tolerance provisions such as forced labor, sexual assault, and systemic child labor mandating a farm's suspension from the program until they address the violations. [11] More broadly, the code outlines a series of worker protections including: a timekeeping system to prevent wage theft, freedom to speak without retaliation for voicing complaints or grievances, a premium pay generally referred to as an extra “penny per pound” of produce harvested that raises wages, and housing conditions compliant with state and federal regulations. [11] The Code of Conduct further mandates periods of rest for workers during the hottest months of the year, as well as mandates access to water, bathrooms, and shade. [14]

Fair Food Standards Council

The Fair Food Standards Council (FFSC) is an independent human rights monitoring body ensuring the implementation of the Fair Food Program. [15] The FFSC performs field audits interviewing a majority of farmworkers on each participating farm seasonally, operates a 24/7 confidential hotline maintained by Spanish, Haitian Creole, and English-language speakers allows workers to anonymously voice complaints regarding living and working conditions, and sends reports of code of conduct violations to growers in the form of corrective action plans. [1] [16] The FFSC also works with the CIW to host on-the-clock education sessions informing farmworkers on participating farms of their rights and responsibilities under the program. [17] [18]

Judge Laura Safer Espinoza, a retired New York State Supreme Court Justice is the current executive director of the FFSC. [5]

Participating buyers and growers

Buyers

Ahold USA, Aramark, Bon Appétit Management Co., Burger King, Chipotle Mexican Grill, Compass Group, Sodexo, The Fresh Market, McDonald's, Subway, Trader Joe's, Walmart, Whole Foods Market, and Yum Brands. [19]

Growers

Ag-Mart Produce d/b/a Santa Sweets, Alderman Farms, DiMare Homestead, DiMare Ruskin, HarDee/Diamond D Triple D, Gargiulo, Lady Moon Farms, Lipman Family Farms, Pacific Tomato Growers d/b/a Sunripe Certified Brands, West Coast Tomato / McClure Farms, Smoky Mountain Family Farms, Fresh Tulips LLC d/b/a Bloomia, Araucania Flowers – Bloomia Chile, Sun Valley Wholesale Florist, Watkins Farm, Rancho Durazno, Hardee Fresh, Good Dog Farm. [19]

Background

In 2005, after the CIW boycotted Taco Bell for almost four years, the company agreed to sign a Fair Food Agreement, committing the company to pay a “penny more per pound” on its tomatoes, to be passed on as wage bonus to tomato harvesters, and to work with CIW to improve conditions in the fields. [20] College campuses were a major impetus for this agreement; twenty-two colleges banned Taco Bell from operating. [21] The CIW then targeted McDonald's for two years; in 2007, McDonald's signed a Fair Food Agreement with CIW. Other fast-food chains and food retailers followed suit. [22]

Despite this success, in 2007, the Florida Tomato Growers, which is the state's largest tomato producer, slowed the CIW's progress. They threatened farms with $100,000 worth of fines if they passed through "penny per pound" monies. In 2010, Pacific Tomato Growers and Lipman, two of the nation's largest producers, signed on to the program, effectively ending the industry boycott. Just months later, the Florida Tomato Growers Exchange signed onto the Fair Food Program, which began widespread implementation of the model. [3]

Through its nationwide campaigns, the Coalition of Immokalee Workers pressured growers that produce 90 percent of Florida's tomatoes to increase wages for their 30,000 workers and follow strict standards that mandate rest breaks and forbid sexual harassment and verbal abuse. [3] Building on CIW's prior agreements with food industry buyers (e.g., passthrough payments and a supplier code of conduct), the FFP established the Fair Food Standards Council (FFSC), a third-party monitor to audit suppliers, investigate worker complaints, and provide educational programs for workers. [14] By 2011, the Fair Food Program in its current form was fully functioning, with Participating Buyers, Growers, as well as human rights investigators from the Fair Food Standards Council. [3]

Walmart joined the Fair Food Program on January 16, 2014. [23] The company sells 20% of the United States’ fresh tomatoes. [3] Walmart additionally agreed to help expand the Program outside of Florida and expand into other crops. [3]

Success and expansion

Protection

The Fair Food Program is credited with eliminating cases of forced labor from farms inside the Fair Food Program. [24] [25] In addition, the Fair Food Program is reported to have dramatically transformed the working conditions in portions of the agricultural sector in which it has participating farms. [3] The FFP has been lauded by the United Nations as an “international benchmark” in the fight against modern-day slavery and called one of “the most important social-impact success stories of the past century” by the Harvard Business Review. [26] [27]

Currently, the Fair Food Programs covers crops in 10 states including Florida, Maryland, Virginia, New Jersey, and California and includes tomatoes, peonies, tulips, cantaloupes, sweet potatoes, peaches, lettuce, dill, mint, and squash. [19] In 2023, the Department of Labor's Bureau of International Affairs announced a partnership between the U.S. Government and Fair Food Standards Council to expand the program internationally to Mexico, Chile, and South Africa. [6] The Fair Food Program is also currently being adapted to the fishing industry, with a pilot program launched in 2022 to protect fishermen in the United Kingdom. [28]

Since the Fair Food Program's inception, participating buyers have paid nearly $40 million in premium pay to farm workers and the Fair Food Standards Council has resolved thousands of issues raised by worker complaints and its own audits. [14] “‘When I first visited Immokalee, I heard appalling stories of abuse and modern slavery,' said Susan L. Marquis, dean of the Pardee RAND Graduate School, a public policy institution in Santa Monica, Calif. 'But now the tomato fields in Immokalee are probably the best working environment in American agriculture. In the past three years, they’ve gone from being the worst to the best.'" [3]

Evaluation

Since its launch in 2011, academics and human rights experts have praised the Fair Food Program for its worker-driven approach to rights monitoring and enforcement.

A decade-long, longitudinal study of human rights in supply chain programs conducted by the Institute of Multi-Stakeholder Initiative Integrity, published in 2020 cited the “Fair Food Program, and the Worker-driven Social Responsibility model as leading examples of new “gold standard” with effective mechanisms for “empowering rights holders to know and exercise their rights.” [29] In 2023, an academic study of the Fair Food Program published in the International Journal of Production Economics finds that “[The Fair Food Program] is unique in the sense that it has been developed and deployed by the workers themselves and has gained a wide acceptance among buyers and farmers. It therefore follows a truly sustainable approach because it is not dependent on some [Corporate Social Responsibility] goodwill.” [30]

A 2022 study published in the Business and Human Rights Journal, finds that Fair Food Program's worker-driven model of rights enforcement in supply chains is more effective at safeguarding workers’ rights than corporate-backed initiatives or multi-stakeholder initiatives, writing “the same independent, third-party monitor, created specifically for the [worker-driven social responsibility] program, investigates complaints from farmworkers and conducts field audits on farms. This creates a virtuous constant feedback loop, in which complaint resolutions provide for ongoing monitoring and enforcement complemented by the broader investigations and more expansive changes enabled through audits and corrective action plans. As a result, WSR programs are better at enforcement than corporate-established initiatives, resulting in real-life improvements for workers.” [31] Moreover, in evaluating long-term changes in the power of farmworkers, the study concludes: “over the 10-year history of the Fair Food Program, complaints by workers made to growers, who then report them to the Fair Food Program independent monitor, have increased. This suggests that at least part of the workforce now trust in the system enough to call their employer first, without fear of any retaliation.” [31]

In 2021, Oxfam Great Britain conducted a survey querying human rights experts about effective means of worker representation in the economy. They found that “The Coalition of Immokalee Workers’ Fair Food Program was the most widely cited example when Oxfam asked 23 experts about effective ways for workers to represent themselves.” [32]

Awards and recognition

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">United Farm Workers</span> Labor union for farmworkers in the United States

The United Farm Workers of America, or more commonly just United Farm Workers (UFW), is a labor union for farmworkers in the United States. It originated from the merger of two workers' rights organizations, the Agricultural Workers Organizing Committee (AWOC) led by organizer Larry Itliong, and the National Farm Workers Association (NFWA) led by César Chávez and Dolores Huerta. They became allied and transformed from workers' rights organizations into a union as a result of a series of strikes in 1965, when the mostly Filipino farmworkers of the AWOC in Delano, California, initiated a grape strike, and the NFWA went on strike in support. As a result of the commonality in goals and methods, the NFWA and the AWOC formed the United Farm Workers Organizing Committee on August 22, 1966. This organization was accepted into the AFL–CIO in 1972 and changed its name to the United Farm Workers Union.

FFP may refer to:

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Farm Labor Organizing Committee</span>

The Farm Labor Organizing Committee (FLOC) is a labor union representing migrant farm workers in the Midwestern United States and North Carolina.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Baldemar Velasquez</span>

Baldemar Velásquez is an American labor union activist. He co-founded and is president of the Farm Labor Organizing Committee, AFL-CIO. He was named a MacArthur Fellow in 1989, and awarded the Order of the Aztec Eagle in 1994, the highest honor Mexico can bestow on a non-citizen.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Coalition of Immokalee Workers</span> Other organization in Immokalee, United States

The Coalition of Immokalee Workers (CIW) is a worker-based human rights organization focusing on social responsibility in corporate supply chains, human trafficking, gender-based violence at work and occupational health and safety.

Student/Farmworker Alliance (SFA) is a network of students and youth formally organized in 2000 in the United States. SFA campaigns for the improvement of working conditions in the agricultural fields of the United States. The organization cooperates with the Coalition of Immokalee Workers (CIW), a membership-led organization of mostly Mexican, Guatemalan and Mayan Indian immigrants working in agricultural and other low-wage jobs throughout the state of Florida.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">International Labor Rights Forum</span> Nonprofit organization

The International Labor Rights Forum (ILRF) is a nonprofit advocacy organization headquartered in Washington, D.C., U.S., that describes itself as "an advocate for and with the working poor around the world." ILRF, formerly the "International Labor Rights Education & Research Fund", was founded in 1986, and the organization's mission statement reads: "ILRF believes that all workers have the right to a safe working environment where they are treated with dignity and respect, and where they can organize freely to defend and promote their rights and interests. ILRF works to develop practical and effective tools to assist workers in winning enforcement of protections for their basic rights, and hold labor rights violators accountable."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Farmworker</span> Performs agricultural labor

A farmworker, farmhand or agricultural worker is someone employed for labor in agriculture. In labor law, the term "farmworker" is sometimes used more narrowly, applying only to a hired worker involved in agricultural production, including harvesting, but not to a worker in other on-farm jobs, such as picking fruit.

The legal issues of Burger King include several legal disputes and lawsuits involving the international fast food restaurant chain Burger King (BK) as both plaintiff and defendant in the years since its founding in 1954. These have involved almost every aspect of the company's operations. Depending on the ownership and executive staff at the time of these incidents, the company's responses to these challenges have ranged from a conciliatory dialog with its critics and litigants to a more aggressive opposition with questionable tactics and negative consequences. The company's response to these various issues has drawn praise, scorn, and accusations of political appeasement from different parties over the years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wendy's</span> American international fast food chain

Wendy's is an American international fast food restaurant chain founded by Dave Thomas on November 15, 1969, in Columbus, Ohio. Its headquarters moved to Dublin, Ohio, on January 29, 2006. As of December 31, 2018, Wendy's was the world's third-largest hamburger fast-food chain with 6,711 locations, following Burger King and McDonald's. On April 24, 2008, the company announced a merger with Triarc Companies Inc., a publicly traded company and the parent company of Arby's. The merger was completed on September 29, 2008. Wendy's headquarters remained in Dublin. Following the merger, Triarc became known as Wendy's/Arby's Group, and later as the Wendy's Company following the sale of Arby's to Roark Capital Group.

<i>The Harvest</i> (2010 film) 2010 American film

The Harvest is a 2010 documentary film about agricultural child labor in America. The film depicts children as young as 12 years of age who work as many as 12 hours a day, six months a year, subject to hazardous conditions: heat exposure, pesticides, and dangerous work. The agriculture industry has been subject to significantly more lenient labor laws than any other occupation in the United States. As a result, lack of consistent schooling significantly limits their opportunities of succeeding in high school or more. The hazardous conditions threaten their health and lives. The purpose of the documentary is to bring awareness of the harsh working conditions which tens of thousands of children face in the fields of the United States each year and to enact the Children's Act for Responsible Employment which will bring parity of labor conditions to field workers that are afforded to minors in other occupations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">T'ruah</span> US-based human rights organization

T'ruah: The Rabbinic Call for Human Rights, often referred to as T'ruah, is a left-wing nonprofit organization of rabbis who act on the Jewish imperative to respect and protect the human rights of all people in North America, Israel, and the Palestinian Territories. Approximately 2,000 American and Canadian rabbis and cantors, very predominantly non-orthodox in denomination, are affiliated with T'ruah. T'ruah was founded as Rabbis for Human Rights-North America (RHR-NA) in 2002. On January 15, 2013, RHR-NA ended its formal affiliation with Rabbis for Human Rights in Israel, and was renamed T'ruah. The name T’ruah is based on one of the sounds of the shofar acting as a call to take action.

The Food Chain Workers Alliance (FCWA) is a national coalition of 31 worker-based organizations of workers in many sectors of the food chain, including agriculture, processing, selling, and serving. Its program areas include strategic campaigns, leadership development, policy and standards, and education and communications. FCWA members represent over 300,000 workers. The Alliance is based in Los Angeles, California, and was founded in 2009.

Human trafficking in Florida is the illegal trade of human beings for sexual exploitation or forced labor as it occurs in the state of Florida. After California and New York, Florida has the most human trafficking cases in the United States. Florida has had cases of sex trafficking, domestic servitude, and forced labor.

<i>Food Chains</i> 2014 American film

Food Chains is a 2014 American documentary film about agricultural labor in the United States directed by Sanjay Rawal. It was the Recipient of the 2015 James Beard Foundation Award for Special/Documentary.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Labor trafficking in the United States</span>

Labor trafficking in the United States is a form of human trafficking where victims are made to perform a task through force, fraud or coercion as it occurs in the United States. Labor trafficking is typically distinguished from sex trafficking, where the task is sexual in nature. People may be victims of both labor and sex trafficking.

Susan L. Marquis is the Charles and Marie Robertson Visiting Professor at the Princeton School of Public and International Affairs. According to her biography on the Princeton University website, “She teaches and writes on new approaches to public policy and policy analysis with the intent of affecting change in our communities through the combined efforts of the government, nonprofit, philanthropic, and private sectors.”

California's Assembly Bill 1066, Phase-In Overtime for Agricultural Workers Act of 2016, was authored by Assemblymember Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher and was signed by Governor Jerry Brown on September 12, 2016. This bill allows farmworkers in California to qualify for overtime pay after working 8 hours in a single day or 40 hours in a workweek. Prior to the passage of AB 1066, farmworkers were only eligible for overtime pay after working 10 hours.

Greg Asbed is an American activist, labor organizer, and human rights strategist. He is the co-founder of the Coalition of Immokalee Workers, a worker-based human rights organization based in Immokalee, Florida working to eradicate modern slavery in the Floridian agriculture industry. In 2017 Asbed was named a MacArthur Fellow for "transforming conditions for low-wage workers with a visionary model of worker-driven social responsibility."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Farmworkers in the United States</span>

Farmworkers in the United States have unique demographics, wages, working conditions, organizing, and environmental aspects. According to The National Institute for Occupational Safety & Health in Agricultural Safety, approximately 2,112,626 full-time workers were employed in production agriculture in the US in 2019 and approximately 1.4 to 2.1 million hired crop workers are employed annually on crop farms in the US. A study by the USDA found the average age of a farmworker to be 33. In 2017, the Department of Labor and Statistics found the median wage to be $23,730 a year, or $11.42 per hour.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Toussaint, Kristin (2023-03-14). "One Florida Program is Helping Eradicate Modern-day Slavery on Farms". Fast Company. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  2. 1 2 "About". The Fair Food Program. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Greenhouse, Steven (2014-04-24). "In Florida Tomato Fields, a Penny Buys Progress". The New York Times. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  4. "ANALYSIS: Lofty goals… or empty promises?". 2017-01-12. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  5. 1 2 3 "About". Fair Food Standards Council. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  6. 1 2 3 Feroli, Christine (2023-02-14). "US Department of Labor Awards $2.5m Grant to Promote Human, Labor Rights in the International Cut Flower Supply Chains".
  7. Estabrook, Barry (2014-01-17). "Labor Takes Historic Stride Forward as Walmart Joins Fair Food Program". Civil Eats. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  8. Schneider, Mike (2023-03-17). "Farmworkers use Florida march to pressure other companies". AP News. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  9. Wilson, Bill (March 22, 2023). "Farm workers walk to convince Kroger, Publix to join Fair Food Program". Supermarket News. Retrieved September 14, 2023.
  10. Alvarez, Maximillian (March 16, 2023). "Farmworkers in Florida Are Protesting Modern-Day Slavery". Jacobin . Retrieved September 14, 2023. For the Coalition of Immokalee Workers, the main group behind the Fair Food Program, this makes it all the more disappointing that holdouts like fast food chain Wendy's and the supermarket chains Kroger and Publix still refuse to join.
  11. 1 2 3 "2021 State of the Program" (PDF). Fair Food Program. pp. 5–9. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  12. "Remarks: Greg Asbed, United Nations Business and Human Rights Annual Forum, 2015". Coalition of Immokalee Workers. 2015-11-30. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  13. Dearing, Phil (2017-08-10). "The Fair Food Program". The Bridgespan Group. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  14. 1 2 3 4 Jones, Kevin (2023-02-23). "Spotlight on Coalition of Immokalee Workers". American Bar Association. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  15. 1 2 Burkhalter, Holly (2012-09-02). "Fair Food program helps end the use of slavery in the tomato fields". The Washington Post. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  16. "Fair Food Code of Conduct". Fair Food Standards Council. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  17. Angelini, Antonella (2022-11-29). "Centering worker rights: Insights from the Fair Food Program". Business & Human Rights Resource Centre. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  18. Scheiber, Noam (2019-03-07). "Why Wendy's Is Facing Campus Protests (It's About the Tomatoes)". The New York Times. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  19. 1 2 3 "Current Partners". The Fair Food Program. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  20. Nieves, Evelyn (2005-03-09). "Accord With Tomato Pickers Ends Boycott Of Taco Bell". The Washington Post.
  21. "Immokalee Tomato Pickers Win Campaign Against Taco Bell". Democracy Now!. 2005-03-10. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  22. McCabe, Coco (2007-04-10). "US Farmworkers Reach Historic Agreement with McDonald's". Oxfam America. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  23. "Coalition of Immokalee Workers Announces Walmart to Join Groundbreaking Fair Food Program [USA]". Business & Human Rights Resource Centre. 2014-01-16.
  24. Lore, Kristin Leigh (2023-01-03). "Labor contractor sentenced for forced labor conspiracy of H-2A workers". The Packer. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  25. Seidman, Derek (2023-03-11). "Farmworkers Push Wendy's, Kroger and Publix to Take Stance Against Forced Labor". Truthout. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  26. 1 2 "End of visit statement, United States of America (6-16 December 2016) by Maria Grazia Giammarinaro, UN Special Rapporteur in Trafficking in Persons, especially Women and Children". United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner. 2016-12-16. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  27. 1 2 Ditkoff, Susan Wolf; Grindle, Abe (September–October 2017). "Audacious Philanthropy". Harvard Business Review.
  28. "From Florida to Fraserburgh: Can the Fair Food Programme Inspire A 'Fair Fish Programme'?". Fishing News. 2022-12-12. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  29. "Not Fit-for-Purpose The Grand Experiment of Multi-Stakeholder Initiatives in Corporate Accountability, Human Rights and Global Governance" (PDF). MSI Integrity. July 2020. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  30. Kunz, Nathan; Chesney, Thomas; Trautrims, Alexander; Gold, Stefan (April 2023). "Adoption and transferability of joint interventions to fight modern slavery in food supply chains" (PDF). International Journal of Production Economics. 258: 108809. doi: 10.1016/j.ijpe.2023.108809 . S2CID   257179754 via Elsevier Science Direct.
  31. 1 2 Angelini, Antonella; Curphey, Shauna (2022-10-12). "The Overlooked Advantages of the Independent Monitoring and Complaint Investigation System in the Worker-driven Social Responsibility Model in US Agriculture". Cambridge University Press. 7 (3): 494–499. doi: 10.1017/bhj.2022.25 . S2CID   252901481.
  32. "Working in Marks & Spencer's food and footwear supply chains" (PDF). Oxfam Library. January 2021. p. 15. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  33. "A 4th to Remember: CIW honored as 2013 Four Freedoms Award Laureate!". Coalition of Immokalee Workers. 2013-07-02. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  34. Quee, Richard Chin (2013-06-19). "Rape in the Fields: A FRONTLINE/Univision Investigation". WGCU (PBS and NPR for Southwest Florida). Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  35. "Building Partnerships to Eradicate Modern-Day Slavery: Report of Recommendations to the President" (PDF). The White House. April 2013. Retrieved 2023-04-16.
  36. "Greg Asbed, Human Rights Strategist (Class of 2017)". MacArthur Foundation. 2017-10-11. Retrieved 2023-04-16.