Fast-Fish and Loose-Fish

Last updated

"Fast-Fish and Loose-Fish" is chapter 89 of Herman Melville's 1851 novel Moby-Dick , in which Ishmael, the book's narrator, explains the concept of "Fast-Fish" and "Loose-Fish." If a whale, whether dead or not, is marked by a ship's crew with anything to claim it, such as a harpoon or rope, it is a "fast-fish", that is, it must be left alone by other whalers; if it is not so marked, it is a "loose-fish", which can be claimed by any ship that finds it. The clarity of this doctrine, Ishmael says, prevents disputes from escalating into violence. He describes court cases dealing with disputes between crews of whaling ships, and then extends the concept to society and politics, questioning the concept of ownership and the right to possession.

Contents

Legal scholars use Ishmael's arguments to illustrate that the literal text of a law can be difficult to interpret and that the morality of a law's implications is unclear. [1] Instructors teaching Moby-Dick use the chapter to illustrate one of the book's main themes, the slippery nature of moral principles. [2]

The chapter

Ishmael opens by explaining that when the crew of a whaling ship has harpooned, wounded, or even killed a whale but for some reason is not able to take possession of it, another crew might lay claim to it. This would often lead to "vexatious and violent disputes," Ishmael goes on, creating the need for some "written or unwritten, universal, undisputed law applicable to all cases.” Whalers came to define a fish as "fast" if a ship had either formed a physical connection to it, or had killed and clearly marked it for later pickup; any fish not claimed in either manner was defined as "loose." Two simple rules were then formulated as a means of settling arguments over the ownership of a fish, as follows:

Ishmael then describes a court case in which the crew of one ship's whaleboat chased and harpooned a whale, but then had to abandon the boat in order to save themselves. A second ship later killed and claimed the whale, along with the first ship's boat and harpoon that had remained attached to it. The first crew sued the second for the value of the whale and equipment; the judge awarded the boat to the plaintiffs and the whale and harpoon to the defendants, saying that the plaintiffs had given up their rights to the latter items when they abandoned their chase. Ishmael initially says that the decision was just, as the world as a whole favors the strong over the weak. [3] [4] However, he mentions a divorce case cited by the defense in which a former husband brought suit to lay claim to the property of his divorced and now remarried wife on the theory that she was a "fast-fish" which he retained as property. Ishmael then describes cases with wider and wider implications, building up to an ironic attack on the concept of "loose-fish." In these cases the strong take possession of "loose-fish," that is they take whatever their strength allows them to. He gives examples of the concept, applying them to instances such as slavery in the United States, serfdom in Russia, British rule in Ireland and the American annexation of Texas.[ citation needed ]

In these cases of Fast-Fish, Ishmael asks, "is Possession not the whole of the law?" He then finds that the doctrine of Loose-Fish is universally applicable, as when great powers acquire new territory. He finally asks what are the Rights of Man and the Liberties of the world but Loose-Fish -- "And what are you, reader, but a Loose-Fish and a Fast-Fish, too?" [5] [6]

Thematic use in Moby-Dick

Critics point to meanings beneath the surface. Ishmael's description initially seems to praise the legal concept as solving whaling disputes peacefully, but the critic John Bryant points to the chapter as an example of Melville's ironic style. Melville does not generally have his characters "spout politics," says Bryant, but encourages readers to find the meaning (or meanings) for themselves. In "Fast-fish-Loose-Fish", Bryant continues, the "message of revolt" is not openly announced but "subsumed within the lyric strains of Ishmael's meditation." Ishmael gradually converts his initial off-handed meditation on the legal concept of possession into "a more sanguine, indeed calamitous, tirade" on topics such as British rule in India and the US annexation of Mexican territory, and ends with the question of whether the rights of man and the book's readers themselves are fast fish or loose. [5]

The French critic Agnès Derail points out that the cases Ishmael refers to all give the property to whoever had control of it. Ishmael condemns the principle “possession is the whole of the law”: to legitimize the right of the strongest is to legitimize all systems of exploitation. She also points out that Melville himself treated much published literary and whaling material as "loose fish" to be freely appropriated, [7] including literary works. [8]

The chapter has been taught in law school classrooms as raising questions in property law and the concept "Fast-Fish and Loose-Fish" is sometimes used to characterize legal ownership of any type of property. [9] One law school instructor wrote that the chapter may be particularly useful in helping students understand the concept fee simple absolute as it relates to a property dispute. [10] Another wrote that she uses "Melville's elegant and pithy meditation" on "the law's limitations" in a “rules” course like Civil Procedure. Most students believe the course principally involves memorization of the rules, so it is "often difficult for them to perceive the ambiguity of meaning and application that even some of the most apparently straightforward rules offer." They also learn the "importance of words," that "fast" does not mean "speedy", and that the text of the law is often not as important as how it is used and interpreted. [11]

Notes

  1. ↑ Lamb, Robert Paul (2005). "Fast-Fish and Loose-Fish: Teaching Melville's Moby-Dick in the College Classroom". College Literature. 32 (1): 42–62. doi:10.1353/lit.2005.0011.
  2. ↑ Corey-Gruenes, Jeremy (September 28, 2012). "Are you a fast-fish or are you a loose-fish?". Albert Lea Tribune. Retrieved 13 December 2014.
  3. ↑ Herman Melville, Moby-Dick, Chapter 89 – Fast-Fish and Loose-Fish.
  4. ↑ Pardes, Ilana (2008). Melville's Bibles. University of California Press. p. 112. ISBN   978-0-520-94152-6 . Retrieved 13 December 2014.
  5. 1 2 Bryant (1998), p. 77-78.
  6. ↑ Noah, Harold J. (October 1974). "Fast-Fish and Loose-Fish in Comparative Education". Comparative Education Review. 18 (3): 341–347. doi:10.1086/445790. JSTOR   1187865. S2CID   144048809 . Retrieved 13 December 2014.
  7. ↑ Derail (2019).
  8. ↑ Hansen, Anne Mette (2006). The Book as Artefact, Text and Border. Rodopi. pp. 264–266. ISBN   9789042018884.
  9. ↑ Callies, David L.; Hylton, J. Gordon (2012). Concise Introduction to Property Law. LexisNexis. ISBN   978-0-327-17436-3 . Retrieved 13 December 2014.
  10. ↑ Finley (2011), p. 175-176.
  11. ↑ Piety, Tamara R. "Something Fishy: Or Why I Make My Students Read Fast-Fish And Loose-Fish" (PDF). Vermont Law Review. 29 (33): 33, 37, 39. Retrieved 13 December 2014.
  12. ↑ Lehner, Christine (Summer 2006). "No, I am not a loose-fish and neither are you". Southwest Review. 91 (3): 366–386. Retrieved 13 December 2014.
  13. ↑ Scott, Saul (2000), "Mysteries of the Postmodern Deep: Laurie Anderson's Songs and Stories from Moby Dick", Theater, 30 (2): 160–163, doi:10.1215/01610775-30-2-160, S2CID   144066287

Related Research Articles

<i>Moby-Dick</i> 1851 novel by Herman Melville

Moby-Dick; or, The Whale is an 1851 novel by American writer Herman Melville. The book is the sailor Ishmael's narrative of the maniacal quest of Ahab, captain of the whaling ship Pequod, for vengeance against Moby Dick, the giant white sperm whale that bit off his leg on the ship's previous voyage. A contribution to the literature of the American Renaissance, Moby-Dick was published to mixed reviews, was a commercial failure, and was out of print at the time of the author's death in 1891. Its reputation as a Great American Novel was established only in the 20th century, after the 1919 centennial of its author's birth. William Faulkner said he wished he had written the book himself, and D. H. Lawrence called it "one of the strangest and most wonderful books in the world" and "the greatest book of the sea ever written". Its opening sentence, "Call me Ishmael", is among world literature's most famous.

Ishmael (<i>Moby-Dick</i>) Fictional character from the novel Moby-Dick

Ishmael is a character in Herman Melville's Moby-Dick (1851), which opens with the line "Call me Ishmael." He is the first-person narrator of much of the book. Because Ishmael plays a minor role in the plot, early critics of Moby-Dick assumed that Captain Ahab was the protagonist. Many either confused Ishmael with Melville or overlooked the role he played. Later critics distinguished Ishmael from Melville, and some saw his mystic and speculative consciousness as the novel's central force rather than Captain Ahab's monomaniacal force of will.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Harpoon</span> Long spear-like instrument used in marine hunting

A harpoon is a long spear-like projectile used in fishing, whaling, sealing, and other hunting activities to shoot, kill, and capture large fish or marine mammals such as seals, sea cows and whales. It accomplishes its task by impaling the target animal and securing it with barb or toggling claws, allowing the fishermen or hunters to use an attached rope or chain to pull and retrieve the animal. A harpoon can also be used as a ranged weapon against other watercraft in naval warfare.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Queequeg</span> Fictional character from the novel Moby-Dick

Queequeg is a character in the 1851 novel Moby-Dick by American author Herman Melville. The story outlines his royal, Polynesian descent, as well as his desire to “visit Christendom” that led him to leave his homeland. Queequeg is visually distinguished by his striking facial tattoos and tan skin. Ishmael encounters Queequeg in Chapter Four and they become unlikely friends. Once aboard the whaling ship the Pequod, Queequeg becomes the harpooner for the mate Starbuck.

<i>Ann Alexander</i> (ship)

The Ann Alexander was a three-masted ship from New Bedford, Massachusetts. She is notable for having been rammed and sunk by a wounded sperm whale in the South Pacific on August 20, 1851, some 30 years after the famous incident in which the Essex was stove in and sunk by a whale in the same area.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mocha Dick</span> Sperm whale that inspired the novel Moby Dick

Mocha Dick was a male sperm whale that lived in the Pacific Ocean in the early 19th century, usually encountered in the waters near Mocha Island, off the central coast of Chile. American explorer and author Jeremiah N. Reynolds published his account, "Mocha Dick: Or The White Whale of the Pacific: A Leaf from a Manuscript Journal" in 1839 in The Knickerbocker. Mocha Dick was an albino and partially inspired Herman Melville's 1851 novel Moby-Dick.

The cetology in Herman Melville's 1851 novel, Moby-Dick, is a running theme that appears most importantly in Ishmael's zoological classification of whales, in Chapter 32, "Cetology". The purpose of that chapter, the narrator says, is "to attend to a matter almost indispensable to a thorough appreciative understanding of the more special leviathanic revelations and allusions of all sorts which are to follow." Further descriptions of whales and their anatomy occur in seventeen other chapters, including "The Sperm Whale's Head -- Contrasted View" and "The Right Whale's Head -- Contrasted View".

<i>Pequod</i> (<i>Moby-Dick</i>) Fictional ship from the novel Moby-Dick

Pequod is a fictional 19th-century Nantucket whaling ship that appears in the 1851 novel Moby-Dick by American author Herman Melville. Pequod and her crew, commanded by Captain Ahab, are central to the story, which, after the initial chapters, takes place almost entirely aboard the ship during a three-year whaling expedition in the Atlantic, Indian and South Pacific oceans. Most of the characters in the novel are part of Pequod's crew.

<i>Moby Dick</i> (1956 film) 1956 film by John Huston

Moby Dick is a 1956 period adventure drama film directed and produced by John Huston, adapted by Huston and Ray Bradbury from Herman Melville's 1851 novel Moby-Dick. It stars Gregory Peck as Captain Ahab, Richard Basehart as Ishmael, and Leo Genn as Starbuck, with supporting performances by James Robertson Justice, Harry Andrews, Friedrich von Ledebur, Bernard Miles, Noel Purcell and Orson Welles. The film was a co-production of the United Kingdom and the United States.

<i>Whale Adventure</i>

Whale Adventure is a 1960 children's book by the Canadian-born American author Willard Price featuring his "Adventure" series characters, Hal and Roger Hunt.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Whaler</span> Specialized ship designed for whaling

A whaler or whaling ship is a specialized vessel, designed or adapted for whaling: the catching or processing of whales.

Moby-Dick is an 1851 novel by Herman Melville that describes the voyage of the whaleship Pequod, led by Captain Ahab, who leads his crew on a hunt for the whale Moby Dick. There have been a number of adaptations of Moby-Dick in various media.

<i>Moby Dick</i> (1930 film) 1930 film

Moby Dick is a 1930 American pre-Code film from Warner Bros., directed by Lloyd Bacon, and starring John Barrymore, Joan Bennett and Walter Lang. The film is a sound remake of the 1926 silent movie, The Sea Beast, which also starred Barrymore. It is the first film adaptation of Herman Melville's 1851 novel Moby Dick that includes a soundtrack.

<i>Moby-Dick</i> (opera) Opera by Jake Heggie

Moby-Dick is an American opera in two acts, with music by Jake Heggie and libretto by Gene Scheer, adapted from Herman Melville's 1851 novel Moby-Dick. The opera received its premiere at Dallas Opera in Dallas, Texas, on 30 April 2010. Heggie dedicated the opera to Stephen Sondheim.

<i>Moby Dick</i> (1998 miniseries) 1998 American television miniseries

Moby Dick is a 1998 American television miniseries directed by Franc Roddam, written by Roddam, Anton Diether, and Benedict Fitzgerald, and executive produced by Francis Ford Coppola. It is based on Herman Melville's 1851 novel of the same name. It was filmed in Australia in 1997 and first released in the United States in 1998. The miniseries consisted of two episodes, each running two hours with commercials on March 15 and 16 of 1998 on the USA Network. This is Gregory Peck's final on-screen role.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Captain Ahab</span> Fictional character from the novel Moby-Dick

Captain Ahab is a fictional character and one of the protagonists in Herman Melville's Moby-Dick (1851). He is the monomaniacal captain of the whaling ship Pequod. On a previous voyage, the white whale Moby Dick bit off Ahab's leg, and he now wears a prosthetic leg made out of whalebone. The whaling voyage of the Pequod ends up as a hunt for revenge on the whale, as Ahab forces the crew members to support his fanatical mission. When Moby Dick is finally sighted, Ahab's hatred robs him of all caution, and the whale drags him to his death beneath the sea and sinks the Pequod.

Father Mapple is a fictional character in Herman Melville's novel Moby-Dick (1851). A former whaler, he has become a preacher in the New Bedford Whaleman's Chapel. Ishmael, the narrator of the novel, hears Mapple's sermon on the subject of Jonah, who was swallowed by a whale but did not turn against God.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Moby Dick (whale)</span> Fictional whale, namesake of the novel Moby-Dick

Moby Dick is a fictional white sperm whale and the primary antagonist in Herman Melville's 1851 novel Moby-Dick. Melville based the whale on an albino whale of that period, Mocha Dick.

Pip, short for Pippin, is the African-American cabin-boy on the whaling-ship Pequod in Herman Melville's 1851 novel, Moby-Dick. When Pip falls overboard he is left stranded in the sea, and rescued only by chance and becomes "mad." The book's narrator, Ishmael, however, thinks that this "madness" gives Pip the power to see the world as it is. Pip is first described as "insignificant," but is the only member of the crew to awaken feelings of humanity in Ahab, the ship's monomaniacal captain.

References

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.