Heads of Proposals

Last updated

The Heads of Proposals was a set of propositions intended to be a basis for a constitutional settlement after King Charles I was defeated in the First English Civil War. [1] The authorship of the Proposals has been the subject of scholarly debate, although it has been suggested that it was drafted in the summer of 1647 by Commissary-General Henry Ireton and Major-General John Lambert. [2]

Contents

Background and Newcastle propositions

In 1646 the Scots captured King Charles I and opened negotiations with Parliament. It demanded the Newcastle propositions that included accepting the covenant, installing a Presbyterian form of church government, giving Parliament control of the Army for 20 years, and turn over key supporters for punishment. Charles refused to accept these stiff terms. [3]

Drafting the Proposals

In June 1647, the New Model Army seized King Charles I, entered a Solemn Engagement not to disband until their grievances had been redressed. The army then began to march towards London. Parliament sent negotiators to treat with the army leadership. As part of these negotiations, the army agreed to draft a series of proposals, laying out their blueprint for settling the kingdom and ending the strife of the Civil War. Henry Ireton and one other officer (probably John Lambert) were "sequestered" from the treaty negotiations and tasked with drawing up the proposals. [4] On July 17, Ireton presented a draft of these "Heads of the Proposals" at a meeting of the General Council of the Army in Reading. [5] In the Reading Debates, and in the two weeks that followed, these draft proposals were debated and fine-tuned. The King and his closest advisors were allowed to comment on the proposals, resulting in significant modifications. Also present at the Reading Debates on the Heads was a delegation of the army's most strenuous allies from London (including the future Levellers John Wildman, William Walwyn, and Maximilian Petty). [6] The proposals may also have been edited in consultation with important Independent MPs and Lords, some of whom were present at Reading as part of parliament's negotiating team. Henry Ireton's surviving papers contain documents, some in Ireton's own hand, revealing the process of drafting and editing that produced the final version of the Heads. [7] On August 1, after a final set of edits to address the king's objections, the army council approved a completed draft of the "Heads of the Proposals." Copies were sent to the king, parliament and the city of London, and the completed peace plan was dispatched to be printed for public view. [8]

Main propositions

The main propositions were:

King Charles' reaction

Even after the occupation of London by the New Model Army had taken place, Parliament, instead of taking up the Heads of the Proposals as the basis of a settlement of the kingdom, sent to the King a revised edition of the Newcastle Propositions, differing mainly in that it proposed a limited toleration for dissentient Puritans, whilst forbidding all use of the book of Common Prayer. In his reply to their propositions, the King, on 14 September, expressed a preference for the Proposals of the Army, as more conducive "to the satisfaction of all interests and a fitter foundation for a lasting peace". [9] Major Huntington's letter [10] shows that the King expected the leaders of the Army to stand by him in procuring an offer of better terms from parliament. [11]

The question of a new treaty was discussed in the House of Commons on 22 and 23 September 1647. Henry Marten and his party were eager for the passing of a vote to make no further addresses to the King. Cromwell and Ireton, on the other hand, opposed Marten's motion, and the House finally resolved on 23 September that they would once again make application to the King. This decision led to much discontent amongst the Levelling party in the Army as also outside of it, and "the credit and reputation" of both Cromwell and Ireton was much blasted thereby. [12] They were accused of falsely representing it to be the desire and sense of the Army that this new application should be made to the King. The charge is thus stated by Wildman in his Putney Projects (p. 43). [11]

Because Oliver Cromwell and Henry Ireton negotiated with the King, they lost the army radicals' support. The radicals criticized their "servility" to the king. Without an amicable solution between the Army, King, English Parliament, and the Scots the Second English Civil War started.

Historical importance

Although the "Heads of Proposals" was never adopted, Ireton promoted it in the Putney Debates. He presented it as a moderate alternative to the Agreement of the People. Elements of "Heads of Proposals" were incorporated in the Instrument of Government. [13] [14] The Instrument of Government was the written constitution that defined Oliver Cromwell's powers as Lord Protector. The religious settlement proposed by Ireton in 1647 was virtually identical to that finally adopted in the Toleration Act 1688.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Oliver Cromwell</span> English military and political leader (1599–1658)

Oliver Cromwell was an English statesman, politician, and soldier, widely regarded as one of the most important figures in the history of the British Isles. He came to prominence during the 1639 to 1653 Wars of the Three Kingdoms, initially as a senior commander in the Parliamentarian army and latterly as a politician. A leading advocate of the execution of Charles I in January 1649, which led to the establishment of The Protectorate, he ruled as Lord Protector from December 1653 until his death in September 1658. Cromwell remains a controversial figure due to his use of the army to acquire political power, and the brutality of his 1649 campaign in Ireland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Levellers</span> 1640s English political movement

The Levellers were a political movement active during the Wars of the Three Kingdoms who were committed to popular sovereignty, extended suffrage, equality before the law and religious tolerance. The hallmark of Leveller thought was its populism, as shown by its emphasis on equal natural rights, and their practice of reaching the public through pamphlets, petitions and vocal appeals to the crowd.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">New Model Army</span> English Civil War army (1645–60)

The New Model Army or New Modelled Army was a standing army formed in 1645 by the Parliamentarians during the First English Civil War, then disbanded after the Stuart Restoration in 1660. It differed from other armies employed in the 1639 to 1653 Wars of the Three Kingdoms in that members were liable for service anywhere in the country, rather than being limited to a single area or garrison. To establish a professional officer corps, the army's leaders were prohibited from having seats in either the House of Lords or House of Commons. This was to encourage their separation from the political or religious factions among the Parliamentarians.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henry Ireton</span> English politician (1611–1651)

Henry Ireton was an English general in the Parliamentarian army during the Wars of the Three Kingdoms, and the son-in-law of Oliver Cromwell. He died of disease outside Limerick in November 1651.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Wildman</span> English politician and soldier

Sir John Wildman was an English politician and soldier.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edward Sexby</span> English puritan soldier

Colonel Edward Sexby was an English Puritan soldier and Leveller in the army of Oliver Cromwell. Later he turned against Cromwell and plotted his assassination, which Sexby considered tyrannicide, as a decapitation strike, which would then be followed by a joint regime change uprising by both Cavaliers and Levellers. Failing in his efforts, Sexby was taken prisoner and died in the Tower of London.

This is a timeline of events leading up to, culminating in, and resulting from the English Civil Wars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Putney Debates</span> 1647 debates about British government

The Putney Debates, which took place from 28 October to 8 November 1647, were a series of discussions over the political settlement that should follow Parliament's victory over Charles I in the First English Civil War. The main participants were senior officers of the New Model Army who favoured retaining Charles within the framework of a constitutional monarchy, and radicals such as the Levellers who sought more sweeping changes, including one man, one vote and freedom of conscience, particularly in religion.

The Corkbush Field Mutiny occurred on 15 November 1647, during the early stages of the Second English Civil War at the Corkbush Field rendezvous, when soldiers were ordered to sign a declaration of loyalty to Thomas Fairfax, the commander-in-chief of the New Model Army (NMA), and the Army Council. When some refused to do this they were arrested, and one of the ringleaders, Private Richard Arnold, was executed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert Lilburne</span> English parliamentarian soldier

Robert Lilburne (1613–1665) was an English Parliamentarian soldier, the older brother of John Lilburne, the well known Leveller. Unlike his brother, who severed his relationship with Oliver Cromwell, Robert Lilburne remained in the army. He is also classed as a regicide for having been a signatory to the death warrant of King Charles I in 1649. He was forty-seventh of the fifty nine Commissioners.

The Army Council was a body established in 1647 to represent the views of all levels of the New Model Army. It originally consisted of senior commanders, like Sir Thomas Fairfax, and representatives elected by their regiments, known as Agitators.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas Rainsborough</span> English religious and political radical (1610–1648)

Thomas Rainsborough, or Rainborowe, 6 July 1610 to 29 October 1648, was an English religious and political radical who served in the Parliamentarian navy and New Model Army during the Wars of the Three Kingdoms. One of the few contemporaries whose personal charisma and popularity rivalled that of Oliver Cromwell, he has also been described as "a soldier of impressive professional competence and peerless courage".

Thomas Rawton was one of the highest-ranking officers to support the Levellers, and served with Parliament on both land and sea. He was the eldest son of Captain John Rawton, a naval officer who made his fortune in the Baltic trade, and inherited his father's property in the London Borough of Southwark.

Robert Hammond was an officer in the New Model Army under Oliver Cromwell during the First English Civil War and a politician who sat in the House of Commons in 1654. He is best known for his year-long role in keeping Charles I of England in custody.

Events from the year 1647 in England.

Events from the year 1648 in England. The Second English Civil War begins.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Instrument of Government</span> 1653 constitution of England, Scotland and Ireland

The Instrument of Government was a constitution of the Commonwealth of England, Scotland and Ireland. Drafted by Major-General John Lambert in 1653, it was the first sovereign codified and written constitution in England.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">George Joyce</span> Officer in the New Model Army

Lieutenant-Colonel George Joyce was an officer and Agitator in the Parliamentary New Model Army during the English Civil War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert Tichborne</span>

Sir Robert Tichborne was an English merchant, politician, author and military officer who served as Lord Mayor of London in 1656. He was a regicide of Charles I.

William Eyre, was an English Parliamentary army officer in the English Civil War and a Leveller.

References

Attribution

Footnotes

  1. Plant, Heads of the Proposals, 1647
  2. Smith, D. (1994). Constitutional Royalism and the search for settlement, c.1640-1649. p. 132.
  3. Charles L. Hamilton, "Anglo-Scottish Militia Negotiations, March–April 1646." Scottish Historical Review (1963): 86-88 in JSTOR.
  4. Como, David R. (2020). "Making 'the Heads of the Proposals': The King, the Army, the Levellers, and the Roads to Putney". English Historical Review. 135 (577): 1390.
  5. Como (2020), pp. 1389-1390
  6. Como (2020), pp. 1390-1408
  7. Como (2020), pp. 1390-1406
  8. Como (2020), pp. 1416-1422
  9. Firth (1901), Cites: Rushworth vii. 810.
  10. Firth (1901), p. 225.
  11. 1 2 Firth (1901)
  12. Firth (1901), p. 228.
  13. Tyacke p. 69
  14. Farr pp. 80,81. See Declaration of Representation of 14 June 1647