Keith Meinhold

Last updated
Keith Meinhold
Born1963 (1963) (age 60)
Known forOne of the first openly gay United States Navy service members to be honorably discharged

Keith Meinhold (born c. 1963) is an American former Navy first class petty officer. He is a veteran of the US Navy who successfully challenged the Navy's attempt to discharge him for coming out as gay in 1992 and ended his Navy career in 1996, one of the first openly gay U.S. service members to be honorably discharged.

Contents

Early career

Volker Keith Meinhold grew up in Stuart, Florida. On April 10, 1980, at the age of 17, rather than repeat the 11th grade at Martin County High School, [1] he enlisted in the U.S. Navy. [2] He realized he was gay after enlisting [3] and came out to his family in 1990 at Christmas. [1]

During his first decade of service in the Navy, Meinhold received merit promotions and was commended in his performance evaluations for "outstanding job performance," "positive influence on squadron morale," and "excellent rapport with both seniors and his peers." He left the Navy in July 1985 and re-enlisted in October 1985. He worked as a flight sonar analyst and instructor at Moffett Field Naval Air Station, near San Jose, California, where, according to later court filings, he was "consistently praised by students for his teaching abilities." [4] Meinhold flew missions throughout the Pacific and Indian Ocean and the Persian Gulf.

He supervised a team of 32 Navy instructors and was recognized as "Aircrew Instructor of the Year". [5] In September 1991, he was awarded the title "Master Training Specialist", an honor granted to those rated in the top ten percent of all Navy instructors. [4]

Meinhold worked with a group that helped gays being discharged from the Navy find employment. They were overwhelmed by anti-homosexual campaigns–he called them "witch hunts"–on certain ships, the USS Blue Ridge (LCC-19) and USS Independence (CV-62). He contacted the Human Rights Campaign about the problem and they arranged for him to speak with the media about the witch hunts and about being gay in the Navy. [3] On May 19, 1992, he declared his homosexuality in an interview on the ABC News program World News Tonight when he told a television interviewer: "Yes, in fact, I am gay." [6] [7]

Discharge proceedings

On the basis of that statement, the Navy convened a discharge board to consider his case. Several officers testified on his behalf and one apologized for any inadvertent prejudice and said he had changed his opinion about homosexuals as a result of knowing Meinhold. The Navy decided to discharge Meinhold on June 30, and he was separated from the Navy on August 12, 1992. [7]

Meinhold sued in federal court contending that his discharge had violated the Constitution's equal protection guarantee and that the Navy board had acted unfairly by refusing to tell him at his discharge hearing whether he was being judged for acknowledging his homosexuality or for engaging in homosexual acts, something he consistently denied. On November 7, 1992, U.S. District Court Judge Terry J. Hatter, Jr. issued a temporary injunction against the Navy and ordered Meinhold reinstated. [8]

Meinhold returned to work, where many of his colleagues had known he was gay before his television appearance. He told reporters that "Some people have asked to be excused from performing military duties because of religious objections–that homosexuality is wrong." Their commander officers excused them from working alongside him. "I think that was wrong," Meinhold said. [6]

On November 12, President-elect Bill Clinton, in response to a reporter's question at his first post-election press conference about the injunction in Meinhold's case, reaffirmed his commitment to lift restrictions on military service by gays and lesbians early in his presidency. [9] [10]

Hatter made the injunction permanent when he issued his decision in the case on January 28, 1993. He wrote that Meinhold's discharge violated the Constitution's guarantee of equal protection and that a discharge was unjustifiable "in the absence of sexual conduct which interferes with the military mission." He wrote: "Gays and lesbians have served, and continue to serve, the United States military with honor, pride, dignity and loyalty. The Department of Defense's justifications for its policy banning gays and lesbians from military service are based on cultural myths and false stereotypes. These justifications are baseless and very similar to the reasons offered to keep the military racially segregated in the 1940s." Hatter cited a study commissioned by the Defense Department in 1988 that found that sexual orientation was not related to job performance and quoted Lawrence J. Korb, an Assistant Secretary of Defense in the Reagan administration, who had said "there is no longer any justification for the armed services' current ban on homosexuals serving in the military." [11]

On January 29, Clinton reached an agreement with Senate leaders, led by Sen. Sam Nunn, chairman of the Senate Armed Forces Committee, to delay until July any changes in policies with respect to military service by gays and lesbians. At a joint news conference with Nunn, Clinton praised Judge Hatter's ruling, which he said had strengthened his hand in the negotiations: "It makes the practical point I have been making all along." [12] Meinhold appeared on the February 1 cover of Newsweek that carried the headline "Gays and the Military". [13]

Meinhold assessed his work environment following Hatter's decision: "Some people are openly supportive, others give closet support and others, by their vibes alone, are not happy with my return". [14]

On March 12, 1993, lawyers for the Department of Defense failed to get an emergency stay of Hatter's order from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. The court noted that Clinton had issued a directive on January 29 that precluded discharges for homosexuality and directed instead that homosexual military personnel be transferred to standby reserve, which did not conflict with Hatter's injunction. [15]

As part of the appeals process, Capt. Gregory Markwell, Meinhold's commander, provided in a sworn statement his negative assessment of the impact Meinhold's presence was having. As the national debate about modifying the rules banning gays and lesbians from the Armed Forces continued, Navy officials opposed to changing the policy made legislators aware of Markwell's statement and two Congressional committees requested it and made it public. Markwell's declaration described how work schedules were being modified to accommodate those who did not want to work with Meinhold and said that his reinstatement had "reduced morale, efficiency and mission focus" and "struck a discordant note with the troops." [16] [17]

In the weeks that followed, Meinhold testified before the House Armed Services Committee [18] and then the Senate Armed Services Committee. [19]

On August 31, 1994, a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit ruled unanimously that the Navy could not discharge Petty Officer Meinhold merely because he said he is gay. The court wrote: "a military service cannot discharge a service member solely because of a statement of sexual orientation devoid of a concrete, expressed desire to act on his homosexual propensity", distinguishing between declaration of sex orientation and the military's judgment of "conduct". It noted that "No similar assumption is made with respect to service members who are heterosexual" unless they are guilty of such prohibited conduct as adultery, sodomy or bigamy. Meinhold's lawyers saw this analysis as a direct attack on the assumptions behind the proposed "Don't ask, don't tell" (DADT) policy, then under consideration. One commented: "This decision says it is improper for the Government to make a presumption that a person who says he or she is gay will conduct himself or herself in prohibited conduct. That presumption is the linchpin for the Clinton Administration policy." [20] The court read the Navy's regulation "to mandate separation due to a statement of homosexuality only when that statement itself indicates more than the inchoate 'desire' or 'propensity' that inheres in status", not when a statement "manifests no concrete, expressed desire to commit homosexual acts". [7]

The Department of Defense did not appeal the decision, [21] since it related to old regulations that had now been replaced by DADT, and the administration had won a different case, that of Joseph Steffan, a week earlier. Meinhold, now working at Naval Air Station at Whidbey Island in Washington, was warned that under DADT, if he repeated the same statement that had prompted the Navy's discharge proceedings, he would be discharged. His attorney commented: "He was told by the executive officer of his squadron that he has a clean slate, and that he would be permitted to remain, but that if he says he's gay again, then they would be taking action against him under the new policy. It's ridiculous. They live with a known homosexual so long as he doesn't show how gay he is. It shows how symbolic the policy really is." [22]

Later career

In July 1995, Hatter ordered the government to pay Meinhold $440,000 in court costs. [23] The government appealed and the Ninth circuit again found for Meinhold, on February 4, 1997. [7]

In his final Navy tour, Meinhold was recognized for photographic intelligence quality with two Lens Master and one Golden Lens awards. His crew was honored as the most combat effective P-3 crew in the Pacific Fleet as both the "Crew of the Quarter" and "Crew of the Year". Meinhold left active duty after 16 years of service in March 1996 and was awarded the Navy Achievement Medal. [5] [24]

In 1999, asked if he blamed DADT for the murder of Pfc. Barry Winchell by a fellow soldier, Meinhold told CBS News: "Absolutely. Not just the policy, but the lack of proper implementation of the policy is responsible for his death. I think what has happened out of the policy is that the Pentagon has perpetuated this anti-gay sentiment and hasn't done anything to prevent this." [25]

He lives in Florida with his partner Steven Weiss. He works in marketing and graphic design for a hedge fund based in Coconut Grove. [3]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Don't ask, don't tell</span> Former policy on gay people serving in the US military

"Don't ask, don't tell" (DADT) was the official United States policy on military service of non-heterosexual people, instituted during the Clinton administration. The policy was issued under Department of Defense Directive 1304.26 on December 21, 1993, and was in effect from February 28, 1994, until September 20, 2011. The policy prohibited military personnel from discriminating against or harassing closeted homosexual or bisexual service members or applicants, while barring openly gay, lesbian, or bisexual persons from military service. This relaxation of legal restrictions on service by gays and lesbians in the armed forces was mandated by Public Law 103–160, which was signed November 30, 1993. The policy prohibited people who "demonstrate a propensity or intent to engage in homosexual acts" from serving in the armed forces of the United States, because their presence "would create an unacceptable risk to the high standards of morale, good order and discipline, and unit cohesion that are the essence of military capability".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Allen R. Schindler Jr.</span> American sailor murdered for being gay (1969–1992)

Allen R. Schindler Jr. was an American Radioman Petty Officer Third Class in the United States Navy who was murdered for being gay. He was killed in a public toilet in Sasebo, Nagasaki, Japan, by Terry M. Helvey, who acted with the aid of an accomplice, Charles E. Vins, in what Esquire called a "brutal murder". The case became synonymous with the debate concerning LGBT members of the military that had been brewing in the United States, culminating in the "Don't ask, don't tell" policy.

<i>McVeigh v. Cohen</i> 1998 lawsuit in U.S. federal court

McVeigh v. Cohen was a 1998 lawsuit in U.S. federal court in which a member of the U.S. Armed Forces challenged the military's application of its "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" (DADT) policy, which established guidelines for service by gays and lesbians in the U.S. military. The U.S. Navy sought to discharge Timothy R. McVeigh for declaring his homosexuality, which he had allegedly done via anonymous Internet posts. McVeigh's suit denied he had made such a declaration and charged the Navy with failure to adhere to its own DADT policy and, in the course of investigating him, with violating the Electronic Communications Privacy Act by collecting his private online communications.

<i>Holmes v. California National Guard</i>

Andrew Holmes v. California National Guard, 124 F.3d 1126 was a federal court case heard by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, that upheld the "don't ask, don't tell" policy that restricted service by gays and lesbians in the California National Guard of the United States. The court decided that a member of the National Guard could not be discharged for saying publicly that he or she is homosexual or bisexual, but could be restricted to assignments that did not require recognition by the federal government.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Perry Watkins</span> US Army soldier

Perry Watkins was an American soldier. A gay man, he was one of the first servicemembers to challenge the ban against homosexuals in the United States military.

Joseph Charles Steffan is an American lawyer and gay activist. He was expelled from the U.S. Naval Academy in Annapolis in 1987 shortly before graduation after disclosing his homosexuality. He sued the U.S. Department of Defense, claiming that his oral avowal of homosexuality could not be construed as an indication that he ever had or intended to engage in sexual relations with another man. He lost a protracted court battle for reinstatement in 1994.

Darren Manzella was a United States Army Sergeant, Army medic and gay activist from Portland, New York, who was discharged under the Don't ask, don't tell policy. Manzella served in Iraq and Kuwait, and was stationed in Fort Hood, Texas.

<i>Unfriendly Fire</i> 2009 American political book

Unfriendly Fire: How the Gay Ban Undermines the Military and Weakens America is an American 2009 political book by Nathaniel Frank that argues that the "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" policy banning openly gay servicemen and women from the United States armed forces weakened military and national security. According to Frank, 12,000 people — 800 of whom had previously been deemed "mission critical" by the U.S. government — were discharged from the military between 1993 and 2008, based on policies that Frank describes as "rooted in denial, and deception, and repression."

The United States military formerly excluded gay men, bisexuals, and lesbians from service. In 1993, the United States Congress passed, and President Bill Clinton signed, a law instituting the policy commonly referred to as "Don't ask, don't tell" (DADT), which allowed gay, lesbian, and bisexual people to serve as long as they did not reveal their sexual orientation. Although there were isolated instances in which service personnel were met with limited success through lawsuits, efforts to end the ban on openly gay, lesbian, and bisexual people serving either legislatively or through the courts initially proved unsuccessful.

<i>Log Cabin Republicans v. United States</i> Federal lawsuit

Log Cabin Republicans v. United States, 658 F.3d 1162 was a federal lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of 10 U.S.C. § 654, commonly known as don't ask, don't tell (DADT), which, prior to its repeal, excluded homosexuals from openly serving in the United States military. The Log Cabin Republicans (LCR), an organization composed of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) Republicans, brought the suit on behalf of LCR members who serve or served in the military and were subject to DADT.

<i>Witt v. Department of the Air Force</i>

Witt v. Department of the Air Force, 527 F.3d 806 is a federal lawsuit that challenged the constitutionality of 10 U.S.C. § 654, the law, since repealed, that excluded openly homosexual people from serving in the United States military, commonly known as "Don't ask, don't tell" (DADT). The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled in 2008 that under Lawrence v. Texas DADT constitutes an "[attempt] to intrude upon the personal and private lives of homosexuals" and it is subject to "heightened scrutiny", meaning that the government "must advance an important governmental interest, the intrusion must significantly further that interest, and the intrusion must be necessary to further that interest."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Don't Ask, Don't Tell Repeal Act of 2010</span> 2011 US federal law allowing LGBT people to openly serve in the military

The Don't Ask, Don't Tell Repeal Act of 2010 is a landmark United States federal statute enacted in December 2010 that established a process for ending the "don't ask, don't tell" (DADT) policy, thus allowing gay, lesbian, and bisexual people to serve openly in the United States Armed Forces. It ended the policy in place since 1993 that allowed them to serve only if they kept their sexual orientation secret and the military did not learn of their sexual orientation, which was controversial.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Zoe Dunning</span>

Maria Zoe Dunning is a U.S. Naval Academy graduate and gay rights activist. She is known for being the only openly gay person remaining on active duty in the U.S. military after coming out. She was involved in a series of lawsuits against the U.S. military and the Don't Ask, Don't Tell policy during the 1990s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jase Daniels</span> United States Navy linguist

Jase Daniels is a United States Navy linguist who was discharged from the military twice under the policy known as "don't ask, don't tell" (DADT). Daniels served from 2001 to 2005 and again from 2006 to 2007. After coming out in Stars and Stripes, a newspaper published under the sponsorship of the U.S. Department of Defense, Daniels challenged the "don't ask, don't tell" policy that forbade gay and lesbian service members from serving openly. His case attracted attention in such major U.S. media outlets as Newsweek and the New York Times. Daniels returned to active duty in the United States Navy on December 12, 2011, and is believed to be one of the first servicemembers, and perhaps the first, to return to active duty following the end of restrictions on service by openly gay and lesbian servicemembers in the U.S. Armed Forces.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">American Veterans for Equal Rights</span> American LGBT veteran service organization

American Veterans for Equal Rights (AVER) is the oldest Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) Veterans Service Organization (VSO) in the United States. Founded in 1990, AVER is a non-profit VSO that supports and advocates for the rights of LGBT military veterans, active duty service members, and their families.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Randy Phillips</span>

Randy Phillips is an airman of the United States Air Force whose coming out in September 2011 following the repeal of the "Don't ask, don't tell" policy (DADT) garnered media attention. DADT had banned the service of openly gay members in the United States Armed Forces and Phillips used YouTube, under the alias "AreYouSuprised", to anonymously seek support and to document his life under the policy over several months. His videos included his coming out to his father and mother, which coincided with Phillips showing his face for the first time, and the accidental discovery of his anonymous web presence by his co-workers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Executive Order 12968</span> 1995 US executive order signed by Bill Clinton

Executive Order 12968 was signed by U.S. President Bill Clinton on August 2, 1995. It established uniform policies for allowing employees of the federal government access to classified information. It detailed standards for disclosure, eligibility requirements and levels of access, and administrative procedures for granting or denying access and for appealing such determinations. It expanded on the President Dwight D. Eisenhower's Executive Order 10450 of 1953.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">United States military chaplains</span>

United States military chaplains hold positions in the armed forces of the United States and are charged with conducting religious services and providing counseling for their adherents. As of 2011, there are about 2,900 chaplains in the Army, among the active duty, reserve, and National Guard components.

Tracy William Thorne-Begland is an American judge on the General District Court of Richmond, Virginia, appointed in 2012. He was the first openly gay jurist elected by the Virginia General Assembly.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Malcom Gregory Scott</span> American screenwriter

Malcom Gregory Scott also known as Greg Scott, is an American writer, activist, and AIDS survivor. In 1987, the United States Navy (USN) discharged him for homosexuality, after which Scott worked to overturn the Department of Defense (DoD) directive prohibiting the military service of lesbian and gay Americans. Upon his discharge, Scott also learned he had tested positive for the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), the virus that causes acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS). He was active in the Washington, D.C., chapters of ACT UP and Queer Nation. Scott was an advocate for legal access to medical marijuana, a critic of early HIV prevention education strategies, and a proponent for expanded academic research to support the public policy goals of queer communities. American journalist Michelangelo Signorile once called Scott "the proudest queer in America." Scott worked as a writer for Fox Television's America's Most Wanted, and his writing has appeared in several newspapers and magazines. Scott nearly died of Stage IV AIDS in 1995 and credited marijuana with his survival until effective anti-retroviral therapies became available.

References

  1. 1 2 Orlando Sentinel: "Mother Backs Son's Challenge On Military's Ban Against Gays," November 29, 1992 Archived 2016-03-04 at the Wayback Machine , accessed March 20, 2012
  2. ↑ Gross, Jane (13 November 1992). "Gay Sailor, Blazing Path for Others, Returns to Base After Court Order". New York Times . Retrieved 21 July 2018.
  3. 1 2 3 Miami Herald: Steve Rothaus, "Gay sailor Keith Meinhold, who fought for his career, is still vigilant about 'don't ask, don't tell'," March 2010, accessed March 20, 2012
  4. 1 2 Stanford Law School: Meinhold v. Department of Defense, January 25, 1993 Archived July 5, 2010, at the Wayback Machine , accessed March 20, 2012
  5. 1 2 Palm Center: Rhonda Evans, "U.S. Military Policies Concerning Homosexuals: Development, Implementation and Outcomes" Archived 2012-05-12 at the Wayback Machine , accessed March 20, 2012
  6. 1 2 New York Times: "Reinstated Gay Sailor Revels in Navy Routine," November 2, 1992, accessed March 20, 2012
  7. 1 2 3 4 FindLaw: Meinhold v. Department of Defense, August 28, 1997, accessed March 20, 2012
  8. ↑ New York Times: Jane Gross, "Judge Orders Gay Sailor Temporarily Reinstated," November 8, 1992, accessed March 20, 2012
  9. ↑ George Stephanopoulos, All Too Human: A Political Education (Little, Brown, 1999), available online, accessed March 20, 2012
  10. ↑ Barney Frank, Barney Frank: The Story of America's Only Left-handed, Gay, Jewish Congressman (University of Massachusetts Press, 2009), 398, available online, accessed March 20, 2012
  11. ↑ New York Times: Robert Reinhold, "Homosexual Ban Loses in U.S. Court," January 29, 1993, accessed March 20, 2012
  12. ↑ New York Times: "Excerpts From the News Conferences by Clinton and Nunn," January 30, 1993, accessed March 20, 2012
  13. ↑ Ron Becker, Gay TV and Straight America (Rutgers University Press, 2006), 63
  14. ↑ New York Times: Jane Gross, "Uneasy Silence at Base Where Gay Sailor Serves," January 30, 1993, accessed March 20, 2012
  15. ↑ New York Times: "U.S. Fails to Get Stay in Case of Gay Sailor," March 13, 1993, accessed March 20, 2012
  16. ↑ New York Times: Eric Schmitt, "Months After Order on Gay Ban, Military Is Still Resisting Clinton," March 23, 1993, accessed March 20, 2012
  17. ↑ Deseret News: "Reinstatement of Gay Sailor has Ruined Morale, Navy Says," March 22, 1993, accessed March 20, 2012
  18. ↑ Baltimore Sun: "Joint Chiefs' exclusion from hearing on gays angers some," March 28, 1993, accessed March 20, 2012
  19. ↑ David Mixner, Stranger among Friends (Bantam Books, 1996), 319. Allan Bérubé mistakenly refers to Meinhold as one of several "former gay service members" who testified. Allan Bérubé, My Desire for History: Essays in Gay, Community, and Labor History (University of North Carolina Press, 2011), 228n13
  20. ↑ New York Times: Jane Gross, "Navy Cannot Discharge Gay Officer, Court Rules," September 1, 1994, accessed March 20, 2012
  21. ↑ New York Times: David Johnston, "Gay Sailor Claims a Victory As Court Case Deadline Passes," October 17, 1994, accessed March 20, 2012
  22. ↑ New York Times: Stephen Labaton, "U.S. Drops Effort to Oust a Gay Sailors," November 29, 1994, accessed March 20, 2012
  23. ↑ New York Times: "U.S. Told to Pay Legal Bills of Gay Sailor," July 20, 1995, accessed March 20, 2012
  24. ↑ Congressional Record: Gerry E. Studds, "Extensions of Remarks, " March 27, 1996, accessed March 20, 2012
  25. ↑ CBS News: "Military's Gay Policy On Trial," 2009, accessed March 202, 2012
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.