Kvikk case

Last updated

The Kvikk case is about a variety of birth defects in the children of the men who served on HNoMS Kvikk. An investigation found that the ship's electronic systems were not to blame; no other cause has been established.

Contents

Suspicion arose when two former officers accidentally met in the orthopedic department at Haukeland University Hospital in Bergen, and it was later revealed that in all eleven children already had been born with birth defects from 1987 to 1994. [1] In the end, the case counted 17 injured children, and it was also discovered that the phenomenon of birth defects already had started in 1983.

Among the claimed birth defects are clubfoot, thumb hypoplasia, hip dysplasia, congenital heart defects, [2] structural brain damage, cataracts, and other defects. [3] Some of the children have also had developmental delays and behavioral problems. [4]

Kvikk was the only vessel in the Norwegian navy that was used as an electronic warfare (EW) vessel, and one widely discussed theory was that the powerful electromagnetic radiation from the boat's radio communication masts and radar led to several of those who served aboard the ship having children with clubfoot, and in some cases stillborn children. [5] The idea was that the powerful radiation possibly damaged genetic material in the sperm of the men who worked aboard. [6] A total of 17 out of 85 children of officers who served at Kvikk have been born with birth defects. [7]

Of the other theories about the cause of the deformities is one that Kvikk was the only vessel that was used to experiment with different types of camouflage paint.

1987-94: Kvikk used for electronic warfare

In 1987 Kvikk was equipped for electronic warfare, partly by getting an extra radar sender stern rated to 750 watts, [8] which then was used very actively to create radar jamming during exercises and tests. Kvikk went out of service as an EW-vessel in December 1994.

Risk for radiation injuries

The Norwegian Armed Forces knew before the case came up that very powerful radiation had been measured on Kvikk. There had also been measured heavy radiation at other defense vessels as well as land installations that all exceeded NATO's limits for radiation hazard, [9] [10] such as the HNoMS Narvik and HNoMS Tjeld. Kvikk, however, is a much smaller vessel than those, and the radiation distance to the crew was thus smaller. It was also not uncommon for the crew on Kvikk to reside around the mast during noise transmissions, and they were thus directly exposed to strong electromagnetic radiation from the mast that it has been speculated in whether may have affected their genetic material.

As an additional risk factor the radar on Kvikk had a stabilizer that were made to ensure that the radar beam was kept level with the horizon so that it also would work in choppy seas, but this mechanism had a weakness that made the radar tip over many times and thus sending radiation directly down on the deck. Therefore the crew in many cases have been directly exposed to radiation at a very close hold when they were on the deck. [11]

In addition, four fathers who worked as electronic service technicians at the workshop of Haakonsvern got children with chromosome abnormalities. They worked, among other things, to correct errors and deficiencies in telecommunications equipment on Kvikk and other marine vessels, and were therefore under testing exposed to high levels of electromagnetic radiation, mostly from radars [12] and communications equipment.

It is shown in research from the 60's and 70's that non-ionizing radiation in the microwave range can provide genotoxic mechanisms in germ cells in animals which are then relayed to the offspring, as well as practical examples have shown that radiation have led to infertility in humans, [13] but little recent research supports this.[ citation needed ]

The Norwegian Navy, the Norwegian Radiation Protection Authority (NRPA) and a research group at Norwegian University of Science and Technology have concluded that there is no demonstrable link between the non-ionizing radiation on board and that the children were born with birth defects. [14] The parents in the case have stated that they don't trust the research. [15]

1996: The case comes forward

The case became known as the Haakonsvern Navy Base in 1996 issued a press release stating that an unusually high number of children of the employees at the naval base were damaged at birth. Verdens Gang (VG) was the first newspaper that took hold of the case, and the newspaper also found the relationship between the children who were born with birth defects and that their fathers had worked at Kvikk. VG immediately published a headline that read "Crown Prince Haakon Magnus of Norway is one of the many who is currently aboard the MTB vessels and may be exposed to radiation."

The navy quickly made a decision to investigate whether there was a correlation between the electromagnetic radiation aboard Kvikk and the genes of those who had served there, but then Kvikk was already broken up - only nine days after the original press release from Haakonsvern. [16]

1998: Initial research by the navy

After three officers in February 1996 had notified the navy inspectorate that they had got children with birth defects after serving on Kvikk, the navy the same year gave an internal message that they did not want to hear any more about such abnormalities from the naval staff. [17]

The navy began to investigate whether the damages in this and similar cases could be due to radar and radio radiation. In 1998 they concluded that this was not the case and that there was no relationship between serving on the ship and having children with birth defects, [18] so that there was no basis for liability. In the report, the Navy went far in rejecting any possible link whatsoever between birth defects to their children and that the fathers had served on Kvikk, and suggested statistical clustering as an explanation. [19]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Royal Norwegian Navy</span> Military unit

The Royal Norwegian Navy is the branch of the Norwegian Armed Forces responsible for naval operations of Norway. As of 2008, the Royal Norwegian Navy consists of approximately 3,700 personnel and 70 vessels, including 4 heavy frigates, 6 submarines, 14 patrol boats, 4 minesweepers, 4 minehunters, 1 mine detection vessel, 4 support vessels and 2 training vessels. It also includes the Coast Guard.

<i>Fridtjof Nansen</i>-class frigate Class of ships of the Royal Norwegian Navy.

The Fridtjof Nansen-class frigates are a class of frigates that are the main surface combatant units of the Royal Norwegian Navy. The ships are named after famous Norwegian explorers, with the lead ship of the class bearing the name of Fridtjof Nansen, the Norwegian scientist, explorer and humanitarian. Five ships were ordered from Spanish shipbuilder Bazan.

<i>Marinejegerkommandoen</i> Norwegian naval special operations unit

Marinejegerkommandoen (MJK) is the maritime/naval special warfare unit of the Norwegian Armed Forces and was established in 1953.

HNoMS <i>Helge Ingstad</i> (F313) Fridtjof Nansen-class frigate of the Royal Norwegian Navy

HNoMS Helge Ingstad was a Fridtjof Nansen-class frigate of the Royal Norwegian Navy. The vessel was ordered on 23 June 2000 and constructed by Navantia in Spain. The ship was launched on 23 November 2007 and commissioned on 29 November 2009. Named for Helge Ingstad, a Norwegian explorer, the Fridtjof Nansen class are capable of anti-air, anti-submarine and surface warfare. On 8 November 2018, HNoMS Helge Ingstad was in collision with the tanker Sola TS in Norwegian waters just outside Sture Terminal. Helge Ingstad was severely damaged in the collision and ran aground. On 13 November 2018, the ship sank where she had run aground and became a constructive total loss.

HMS P41 was a Royal Navy U-class submarine built by Vickers-Armstrong. She was transferred to the exiled Royal Norwegian Navy before completion and renamed HNoMS Uredd. She and one of the B-class in 1940 have so far been the only Norwegian submarines to have been sunk.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Naval Strike Missile</span> Anti-ship or land attack cruise missile

The Naval Strike Missile (NSM) is an anti-ship and land-attack missile developed by the Norwegian company Kongsberg Defence & Aerospace (KDA).

<i>Nordkapp</i>-class offshore patrol vessel Class of Norwegian Coast Guard ship

The Nordkapp class is a Norwegian Coast Guard ship class built in the 1980s, and is used for rescue, fishery inspection, research purposes and general EEZ patrol in Norwegian waters. It is a class of ships purpose-built for the Norwegian Coast Guard with a secondary role as wartime naval escorts. The Norwegian Coast Guard is a part of the Royal Norwegian Navy, and has some police authority.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anne-Grete Strøm-Erichsen</span> Norwegian politician

Anne-Grete Hjelle Strøm-Erichsen is a Norwegian politician for the Labour Party. She served as Minister of Defence from 2005 to 2009 and again from 2012 to 2013. She also served as Minister of Health and Care Services from 2009 to 2012. In local politics, she served as the Mayor of Bergen from 1999 to 2000 and its first Chief Commissioner from 2000 to 2003.

HNoMS Kvikk (P984) was a Royal Norwegian Navy fast patrol boat (FPB) of the Snøgg class which was built in 1970, taken out of service in 1994 and scrapped in 1996. The boat gained a lot of media attention in the so called Kvikk case, due to claims that an abnormally high number of the children of the men who had served on the boat were born with club foot or other congenital disorders.

RS Sjøfareren is the largest lifeboat in use by the Norwegian organization Norwegian Society for Sea Rescue.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Widerøe Flight 933</span> 1982 aviation accident, Norwegian DHC-6

Widerøe Flight 933, also known as the Mehamn Accident, was the crash of a de Havilland Canada DHC-6 Twin Otter operated by Norwegian airline Widerøe. The Twin Otter crashed into the Barents Sea off Gamvik, Norway on 11 March 1982 at 13:27, killing all fifteen people on board. The results of the four official investigations were that the accident was caused by structural failure of the vertical stabilizer during clear-air turbulence. A mechanical fault in the elevator control system caused the pilots to lose control of pitch; and either a series of stalls or a high-speed gust of wind caused the aircraft to lose altitude without the ability of the crew to counteract, resulting in the failure of the vertical stabilizer.

HNoMS <i>Hitra</i>

HNoMS Hitra is a Royal Norwegian Navy submarine chaser that saw action during World War II. She is named after the Norwegian island of Hitra.

HNoMS <i>Tyr</i> (N50)

HNoMS Tyr was a mine control vessel used for underwater search and recovery by the Royal Norwegian Navy. It was decommissioned in 2014 and sold to private owners.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kjersti Toppe</span> Norwegian politician

Kjersti Toppe is a Norwegian doctor and politician representing the Centre Party. She has served as minister of children and families since 2021, and an MP from Hordaland since 2009.

HNoMS <i>Hessa</i>

The HNoMS Hessa was a Royal Norwegian Navy submarine chaser that saw action during World War II. She was named after the Norwegian island of Hessa.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Helge André Njåstad</span> Norwegian politician

Helge André Njåstad is a Norwegian politician for the Progress Party. He was elected to the Parliament of Norway from Hordaland in 2013 where he serves as the chair of the Standing Committee on Local Government and Public Administration. He was mayor of Austevoll from 2003 to 2013.

Allied Forces South Norway (SONOR) was a NATO command tasked with the defense of Southern Norway. SONOR's area of responsibility included all of Norway with the adjacent sea territory excluding the three northernmost counties of Norway, which were under Allied Forces North Norway.

A Town Betrayed is a 2010 Norwegian documentary about the prelude of the Srebrenica massacre (1995), written and directed by journalists Ola Flyum and David Hebditch and produced by Fenris Films, NRK, among others. It was shown on NRK's Brennpunkt on 26 April 2011 and SVT on 28 August 2011.

HNoMS <i>Maud</i>

HNoMS Maud is a replenishment oiler constructed at Daewoo Shipbuilding & Marine Engineering in South Korea. She was built on behalf of the Norwegian Defense Materials Agency Forsvarsmateriell, for service in the Royal Norwegian Navy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marte Mjøs Persen</span> Norwegian politician (born 1975)

Marte Mjøs Persen is a Norwegian politician from the Labour Party. She has served as minister of labour and social inclusion since 2022, and minister of petroleum and energy from 2021 to 2022. She served as the mayor of Bergen from 2015 until being elected to the Storting in 2021.

References

  1. ↑ NTNU universitetsavisa: Kvikk ble frikjent (Norwegian)
  2. ↑ bt.no: Fikk ingen advarsler (Norwegian)
  3. ↑ Aftenposten.no: 17 millioner til «Kvikk»-barna
  4. ↑ Dagbladet.no: «Kvikk»-barn får oftere klumpfot (Norwegian)
  5. ↑ NRK Hordaland: Lover erstatning til «Kvikk»-ofre (Norwegian)
  6. ↑ Medical chief at Haakonsvern marine base Jan Helge Halleraker to Forsvarets Forum the 26 March 1997: «Om vi sitter igjen med bevis på at sædceller påvirkes og skades av elektromagnetisk stråling i visse frekvenser, da har vi tatt medisinen ett hakk videre» (Norwegian) (Translated: "If we can prove that sperm cells are affected and damaged by electromagnetic radiation at certain frequencies, then we have taken medicine a step further"
  7. ↑ NRK Hordaland: Nyttig "Kvikk"-granskning (Norwegian)
  8. ↑ bt.no: - «Kvikk» burde vært stengt (Norwegian)
  9. ↑ bt.no: - «Kvikk» burde vært stengt (Norwegian)
  10. ↑ NRK Hordaland: -Ingen jubel (Norwegian)
  11. ↑ NRK Hordaland: Feil førte til radarstråling (Norwegian)
  12. ↑ NRK Hordaland: Stråling kan ha gitt misdannelser (Norwegian)
  13. ↑ bt.no: En nysgjerrig forsker (Norwegian)
  14. ↑ NRK Hordaland: Feil førte til radarstråling (Norwegian)
  15. ↑ NRK Hordaland: Full gjennomgang av Kvikk-saken (Norwegian)
  16. ↑ Aftenposten.no: 17 millioner til «Kvikk»-barna (Norwegian)
  17. ↑ NRK Hordaland: Forventar full gransking (Norwegian)
  18. ↑ bt.no: «Kvikk»-ofre får erstatning (Norwegian)
  19. ↑ Teknisk Ukeblad: Ingen fasit for Kvikk (Norwegian)
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.