Master (software)

Last updated

Master is a version of DeepMind's Go software AlphaGo, named after the account name (originally Magister/Magist) used online, which won 60 straight online games against human professional Go players from 29 December 2016 to 4 January 2017. This version was also used in the Future of Go Summit in May 2017. [1] [2] It used four TPUs on a single machine with Elo rating 4,858. [3] DeepMind claimed that AlphaGo Master was 3-stone stronger than the version used in AlphaGo v. Lee Sedol. [4]

Contents

DeepMind released a version of AlphaGo Master in December 2017 that serves as a teaching tool analyzing the win rates of 6,000 Go openings from 230,000 human games. [5] [6]

Matches

Online games

The software was first used to play games against professional players on 29 December 2016 on the Tygem Go server, under the account name 'Magister' (shown as 'Magist' at the server's Chinese version). The account name was changed to 'Master' on 30 December. After playing 30 games on Tygem, it was moved to the FoxGo server on 1 January 2017.

Master played at the pace of 10 games per day. Many quickly suspected it to be an AI player due to little or no resting between games. After winning its 59th game it was revealed in the chatroom that Master was controlled by Aja Huang of the DeepMind team. [7] On 4 January 2017, after these games were completed, Demis Hassabis, the co-founder of DeepMind, confirmed that Magister and Master both played using an updated version of AlphaGo [8] [9] and said, "We're looking forward to playing some official, full-length games later [in 2017] in collaboration with Go organizations and experts". [8] [9]

Gu Li, a 9-dan player and co-founder of FoxGo, offered a bounty of 100,000  RMB (14,400  USD) to the first human player who could defeat Master. [9] However, no one took the bounty since Master's final online record was 60 wins and 0 losses, [10] including three victories over Go's top ranked player, Ke Jie, [11] who had been quietly briefed in advance that Master was a version of AlphaGo. [10]

Master's adversaries included many world champions such as Ke Jie, Park Jeong-hwan, Yuta Iyama, Tuo Jiaxi, Mi Yuting, Shi Yue, Chen Yaoye, Li Qincheng, Gu Li, Chang Hao, Tang Weixing, Fan Tingyu, Zhou Ruiyang, Jiang Weijie, Chou Chun-hsun, Kim Ji-seok, Kang Dong-yun, Park Yeong-hun, and Won Seong-jin, and also included national champions or world championship runners-up such as Lian Xiao, Tan Xiao, Meng Tailing, Dang Yifei, Huang Yunsong, Yang Dingxin, Gu Zihao, Shin Jinseo, Cho Han-seung, and An Sungjoon. [12] All 60 games except one were fast-paced games with three 20 or 30 seconds byo-yomi. Master offered to extend the byo-yomi to one minute when playing with Nie Weiping due to his old age.

No.DatePlayer (dan during the game)Time controlMovesMaster color and result
129 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Pan Tingyu (1 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi146White won by resignation
229 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Zhang Ziliang (1 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi174White won by resignation
329 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Ding Shixiong (3 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi151Black won by resignation
429 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Xie Erhao (4 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi222White won by resignation
529 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Yu Zhiying (5 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi113Black won by resignation
629 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Li Xiangyu (3 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi131Black won by resignation
729 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Qiao Zhijian (4 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi163Black won by resignation
829 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Han Yizhou (5 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi104White won by resignation
929 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Meng Tailing (6 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi275Black won by 4.5 points
1029 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Meng Tailing (6 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi148White won by resignation
1130 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Chen Hao (5 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi170White won by resignation
1230 December 2016 Flag of South Korea.svg Ryu Suhang (5 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi144White won by resignation
1330 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Wang Haoyang (6 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi136White won by resignation
1430 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Yan Zaiming (3 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi129Black won by resignation
1530 December 2016 Flag of South Korea.svg Park Junghwan (9 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi150White won by time
1630 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Lian Xiao (7 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi122White won by resignation
1730 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Lian Xiao (7 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi164White won by resignation
1830 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Ke Jie (9 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi228Black won by 5.5 points
1930 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Ke Jie (9 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi128White won by resignation
2030 December 2016 Flag of South Korea.svg Park Junghwan (9 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi255Black won by 5.5 points
2131 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Chen Yaoye (9 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi270White won by 5.5 points
2231 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Chen Yaoye (9 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi277White won by 4.5 points
2331 December 2016 Flag of South Korea.svg Kim Jung-hyun (6 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi135Black won by resignation
2431 December 2016 Flag of South Korea.svg Park Junghwan (9 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi223Black won by resignation
2531 December 2016 Flag of South Korea.svg Park Junghwan (9 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi261White won by 0.5 points
2631 December 2016 Flag of South Korea.svg Yun Chanhee (6 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi217Black won by resignation
2731 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Fan Tingyu (9 dan)three 30-second byo-yomi215Black won by resignation
2831 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Meng Tailing (6 dan)three 20-second byo-yomi163Black won by resignation
2931 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Mi Yuting (9 dan)three 30-second byo-yomi311White won by 0.5 points
3031 December 2016 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Tang Weixing (9 dan)three 30-second byo-yomi186White won by resignation
311 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Li Qincheng (9 dan)1 minute + three 20-second byo-yomi179Black won by resignation
322 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Gu Li (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi154White won by resignation
332 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Gu Li (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi191Black won by resignation
342 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Dang Yifei (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi149Black won by resignation
352 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Jiang Weijie (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi280White won by 1.5 points
362 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Gu Zihao (5 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi209Black won by resignation
372 January 2017 Flag of South Korea.svg Park Yeong-hun (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi173Black won by resignation
382 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Tuo Jiaxi (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi239Black won by resignation
392 January 2017 Flag of Japan.svg Yuta Iyama (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi135Black won by resignation
402 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Meng Tailing (6 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi274White won by 2.5 points
412 January 2017 Flag of South Korea.svg Kim Ji-seok (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi170White won by resignation
423 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Yang Dingxin (4 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi125Black won by resignation
433 January 2017 Flag of South Korea.svg Kang Dong-yun (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi165Black won by resignation
443 January 2017 Flag of South Korea.svg An Sung-joon (7 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi260White won by 2.5 points
453 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Shi Yue (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi167Black won by resignation
463 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Lian Xiao (7 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi144White won by resignation
473 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Tan Xiao (7 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi191Black won by resignation
483 January 2017 Flag of South Korea.svg Park Junghwan (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi270White won by 1.5 points
493 January 2017 Flag of South Korea.svg Won Seong-jin (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi222White won by resignation
503 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Ke Jie (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi178White won by resignation
514 January 2017 Flag of the Republic of China.svg Chou Chun-hsun (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi118White won by resignation
524 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Fan Tingyu (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi202White won by resignation
534 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Huang Yunsong (5 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi133Black won by resignation
544 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Nie Weiping (9 dan)1 minute + three 60-second byo-yomi254Black won by 7.5 points
554 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Chen Yaoye (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi267White won by 1.5 points
564 January 2017 Flag of South Korea.svg Cho Han-seung (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi171Black won by resignation
574 January 2017 Flag of South Korea.svg Shin Jin-seo (6 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi139Black won by resignation
584 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Chang Hao (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi178White won by resignation
594 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Zhou Ruiyang (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi161Black won by resignation
604 January 2017 Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg Gu Li (9 dan)1 minute + three 30-second byo-yomi235White won by 2.5 points

Future of Go Summit

The Master version also participated in the Future of Go summit in May 2017. [1] It defeated Ke Jie in a three-game match by three to zero and beat a human team with five top Go professionals.

Innovative moves

Go experts were extremely impressed by Master's performance and by its non-human play style in its online games. Ke Jie stated, "After humanity spent thousands of years improving our tactics, computers tell us that humans are completely wrong... I would go as far as to say not a single human has touched the edge of the truth of Go". [10]

Master played many innovative moves and inspired professional players. [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19]

In the 23rd online game Master invaded the 3-3 point at a very early stage. [20]

Go ul.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo ur.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo 19.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go dl.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo dr.svg
Online game 23, Master (black) v. Kim Jung-hyun

In the 24th online game Master played six stones along the second line. [20]

Go ul.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo ur.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo 41.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo w.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo 30.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo 29.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo 31.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 32.svgGo 33.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo 34.svgGo 35.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 36.svgGo 37.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 38.svgGo 39.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 40.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go dl.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo dr.svg
Online game 24 Master (black) v. Park Junghwan

Operator errors

On 20 January 2017, DeepMind team members Fan Hui [21] and Aja Huang [22] disclosed that Master's operator accidentally entered a move other than AlphaGo's choice in two situations during the online games.

In the 9th online game, Master recommended point a for Move 107.

Go ul.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo ur.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 07.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo A.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo x.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go dl.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo dr.svg
Online game 9, Master (black) v. Meng Tailing.

In the 39th online game, Master recommended point a for Move 99.

Go ul.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo ur.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 99.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo x.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo A.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo x.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo x.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo b.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo w.svgGo b.svgGo r.svg
Go dl.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo dr.svg
Online game 39, Master (black) v. Yuta Iyama

Example game

Online game 30: Master (white) v. Tang Weixing (31 December 2016), Master won by resignation. White 36 was widely praised. [23]

Go ul.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo ur.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 69.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 83.svgGo 68.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w2.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo -.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b1.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 73.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 71.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 72.svgGo 70.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo 58.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 76.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo 56.svgGo 57.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 82.svgGo 78.svgGo .svgGo 74.svgGo 75.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo 54.svgGo 15.svgGo -.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo -.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 80.svgGo 79.svgGo .svgGo 77.svgGo 67.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo 52.svgGo 53.svgGo 36.svgGo 37.svgGo .svgGo 47.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 81.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo 48.svgGo 39.svgGo 27.svgGo .svgGo 46.svgGo 41.svgGo 40.svgGo 51.svgGo 92.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 84.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo 42.svgGo 38.svgGo b9.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 44.svgGo 45.svgGo .svgGo 26.svgGo .svgGo 91.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 98.svgGo 93.svgGo r.svg
Go 64.svgGo 43.svgGo b7.svgGo w8.svgGo 10.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 25.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 90.svgGo 89.svgGo .svgGo 85.svgGo .svgGo 87.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo 13.svgGo 22.svgGo .svgGo 28.svgGo 29.svgGo 19.svgGo 24.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 66.svgGo .svgGo 86.svgGo .svgGo 88.svgGo w6.svgGo 99.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo 62.svgGo 11.svgGo w4.svgGo .svgGo 21.svgGo .svgGo 17.svgGo 18.svgGo -.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 30.svgGo .svgGo 34.svgGo 97.svgGo 96.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo 49.svgGo 12.svgGo 14.svgGo .svgGo b5.svgGo .svgGo 20.svgGo 16.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 23.svgGo 31.svgGo 35.svgGo b3.svgGo 32.svgGo 95.svgGo r.svg
Go 55.svgGo 50.svgGo 59.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 65.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 33.svgGo 94.svgGo r.svg
Go 63.svgGo 60.svgGo 61.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo dr.svg
First 99 moves
Go ul.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo u.svgGo ur.svg
Go l.svgGo 48.svgGo 46.svgGo 47.svgGo .svgGo 36.svgGo 54.svgGo 53.svgGo 51.svgGo .svgGo 27.svgGo 14.svgGo 13.svgGo 17.svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo 85.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo 34.svgGo 29.svgGo 33.svgGo 35.svgGo w8.svgGo .svgGo 52.svgGo 26.svgGo b9.svgGo 23.svgGo 12.svgGo b .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 83.svgGo 84.svgGo r.svg
Go 42.svgGo 31.svgGo 30.svgGo w.svgGo 37.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 22.svgGo 18.svgGo 15.svgGo 10.svgGo 11.svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo .svgGo 80.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo 32.svgGo 41.svgGo 43.svgGo 68.svgGo 40.svgGo 38.svgGo 70.svgGo .svgGo 24.svgGo 21.svgGo 19.svgGo 16.svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo 81.svgGo 82.svg
Go l.svgGo 45.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 44.svgGo 39.svgGo 64.svgGo 63.svgGo .svgGo 69.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 20.svgGo 71.svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo w .svgGo 78.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 65.svgGo 66.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 75.svgGo 25.svgGo 72.svgGo 73.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo 28.svgGo .svgGo 67.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 74.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 86.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo -.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 76.svgGo 55.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo b.svgGo b .svgGo b3.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo 77.svgGo .svgGo 62.svgGo w6.svgGo .svgGo w4.svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo 79.svgGo w2.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo 56.svgGo b5.svgGo 57.svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo b7.svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo w .svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo r.svg
Go w.svgGo b .svgGo b .svgGo w .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo 00.svgGo .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo b .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo r.svg
Go l.svgGo w .svgGo b .svgGo w.svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo w .svgGo -.svgGo 60.svgGo 58.svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo w.svgGo b .svgGo w .svgGo b1.svg
Go l.svgGo b .svgGo w .svgGo w .svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo w .svgGo w .svgGo 61.svgGo 59.svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo b .svgGo b .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo r.svg
Go b.svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo .svgGo b .svgGo w .svgGo r.svg
Go b.svgGo d.svgGo b.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo d.svgGo dr.svg
Moves 100-186 (149 at 131, 150 at 130)

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Demis Hassabis</span> British entrepreneur and artificial intelligence researcher (born 1976)

Demis Hassabis is a British computer scientist, artificial intelligence researcher and entrepreneur. In his early career he was a video game AI programmer and designer, and an expert board games player. He is the chief executive officer and co-founder of DeepMind and Isomorphic Labs, and a UK Government AI Advisor. He is a Fellow of the Royal Society, and has won many prestigious awards for his work on AlphaFold including the Breakthrough Prize, the Canada Gairdner International Award, and the Lasker Award. In 2017 he was appointed a CBE and listed in the Time 100 most influential people list.

In the game of Go, a ladder,(征子) is a basic sequence of moves in which an attacker pursues a group in atari in a zig-zag pattern across the board. If there are no intervening stones, the group will hit the edge of the board and be captured.

The KGS Go Server, known until 2006 as the Kiseido Go Server, is a game server first developed in 1999 and established in 2000 for people to play Go. The system was developed by William M. Shubert and its code is now written entirely in Java. In Spring of 2017, Shubert transferred ownership to the American Go Foundation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Google DeepMind</span> Artificial intelligence division

DeepMind Technologies Limited, doing business as Google DeepMind, is a British-American artificial intelligence research laboratory which serves as a subsidiary of Google. Founded in the UK in 2010, it was acquired by Google in 2014, The company is based in London, with research centres in Canada, France, Germany and the United States.

AlphaGo is a computer program that plays the board game Go. It was developed by the London-based DeepMind Technologies, an acquired subsidiary of Google. Subsequent versions of AlphaGo became increasingly powerful, including a version that competed under the name Master. After retiring from competitive play, AlphaGo Master was succeeded by an even more powerful version known as AlphaGo Zero, which was completely self-taught without learning from human games. AlphaGo Zero was then generalized into a program known as AlphaZero, which played additional games, including chess and shogi. AlphaZero has in turn been succeeded by a program known as MuZero which learns without being taught the rules.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fan Hui</span> Chinese-born French Go player

Fan Hui is a Chinese-born French Go player. Becoming a professional Go player in 1996, Fan moved to France in 2000 and became the coach of the French national Go team in 2005. He was the winner of the European Go Championship in 2013, 2014 and 2015. As of 2015, he is ranked as a 2 dan professional. He additionally won the 2016 European Professional Go Championship.

AlphaGo versus Lee Sedol, also known as the DeepMind Challenge Match, was a five-game Go match between top Go player Lee Sedol and AlphaGo, a computer Go program developed by DeepMind, played in Seoul, South Korea between 9 and 15 March 2016. AlphaGo won all but the fourth game; all games were won by resignation. The match has been compared with the historic chess match between Deep Blue and Garry Kasparov in 1997.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ke Jie</span> Chinese Go player

Ke Jie is a Chinese professional Go player of 9 dan rank. He was born on August 2, 1997, in Liandu District, Lishui City, Zhejiang Province.

Tygem is an internet go server owned by South Korean company TongYang Online. Popular in Asia, their website states that over 500 professional Go players use their service.

David Silver is a principal research scientist at Google DeepMind and a professor at University College London. He has led research on reinforcement learning with AlphaGo, AlphaZero and co-lead on AlphaStar.

Aja Huang is a Taiwanese computer scientist and expert on artificial intelligence. He works for DeepMind and was a member of the AlphaGo project.

The Future of Go Summit was held in May 2017 by the Chinese Go Association, Sport Bureau of Zhejiang Province and Google in Wuzhen, Zhejiang, the permanent host of the World Internet Conference. It featured five Go games involving AlphaGo and top Chinese Go players, as well as a forum on the future of AI. It was Google’s biggest public event in partnership with the Chinese government since Google China's search engine was moved out of mainland China to Hong Kong due to the government censorship in 2010. It was seen as a charm offensive launched by Google toward Chinese officials, being part of effort to reopen China's market.

AlphaGo versus Ke Jie was a three-game Go match between the computer Go program AlphaGo Master and current world No. 1 ranking player Ke Jie, being part of the Future of Go Summit in Wuzhen, China, played on 23, 25, and 27 May 2017. AlphaGo defeated Ke Jie in all three games.

AlphaGo Zero is a version of DeepMind's Go software AlphaGo. AlphaGo's team published an article in the journal Nature on 19 October 2017, introducing AlphaGo Zero, a version created without using data from human games, and stronger than any previous version. By playing games against itself, AlphaGo Zero surpassed the strength of AlphaGo Lee in three days by winning 100 games to 0, reached the level of AlphaGo Master in 21 days, and exceeded all the old versions in 40 days.

AlphaGo versus Fan Hui was a five-game Go match between European champion Fan Hui, a 2-dan professional, and AlphaGo, a computer Go program developed by DeepMind, held at DeepMind's headquarters in London in October 2015. AlphaGo won all five games. This was the first time a computer Go program had beaten a professional human player on a full-sized board without handicap. This match was not disclosed to the public until 27 January 2016 to coincide with the publication of a paper in the journal Nature describing the algorithms AlphaGo used.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">AlphaZero</span> Game-playing artificial intelligence

AlphaZero is a computer program developed by artificial intelligence research company DeepMind to master the games of chess, shogi and go. This algorithm uses an approach similar to AlphaGo Zero.

Elmo is a computer shogi evaluation function and book file (joseki) created by Makoto Takizawa (瀧澤誠). It is designed to be used with a third-party shogi alpha–beta search engine.

Tang Weixing is a Chinese professional go player. He has won three international titles, with two championships in the Samsung Cup and one in the Ing Cup (2016).

AlphaStar is a computer program by DeepMind that plays the video game StarCraft II. It was unveiled to the public by name in January 2019. In a significant milestone for artificial intelligence, AlphaStar attained Grandmaster status in August 2019.

Timothy P. Lillicrap is a Canadian neuroscientist and AI researcher, adjunct professor at University College London, and staff research scientist at Google DeepMind, where he has been involved in the AlphaGo and AlphaZero projects mastering the games of Go, Chess and Shogi. His research focuses on machine learning and statistics for optimal control and decision making, as well as using these mathematical frameworks to understand how the brain learns. He has developed algorithms and approaches for exploiting deep neural networks in the context of reinforcement learning, and new recurrent memory architectures for one-shot learning.

References

  1. 1 2 "AlphaGo官方解读让三子 对人类高手没这种优势" (in Chinese). Sina. 25 May 2017. Retrieved 1 June 2017.
  2. "各版alphago实力对比 master能让李世石版3子" (in Chinese). Sina. 24 May 2017. Retrieved 2 June 2017.
  3. Silver, David; Schrittwieser, Julian; Simonyan, Karen; Antonoglou, Ioannis; Huang, Aja; Guez, Arthur; Hubert, Thomas; Baker, Lucas; Lai, Matthew; Bolton, Adrian; Chen, Yutian; Lillicrap, Timothy; Fan, Hui; Sifre, Laurent; Driessche, George van den; Graepel, Thore; Hassabis, Demis (19 October 2017). "Mastering the game of Go without human knowledge" (PDF). Nature . 550 (7676): 354–359. Bibcode:2017Natur.550..354S. doi:10.1038/nature24270. ISSN   0028-0836. PMID   29052630. S2CID   205261034. Closed Access logo transparent.svg
  4. "AlphaGo棋力比去年涨三子 柯洁想赢它可能只剩一招" (in Chinese). Sina. 25 May 2017. Retrieved 1 June 2017.
  5. "AlphaGo teaching tool". DeepMind.
  6. "AlphaGo教学工具上线 樊麾:使用Master版本" (in Chinese). Sina.com.cn. 11 December 2017. Retrieved 11 December 2017.
  7. "横扫中日韩棋手斩获59胜的Master发话:我是阿尔法狗". 澎湃新闻. 2017-01-04.
  8. 1 2 Demis Hassabis (4 January 2017). "Demis Hassabis on Twitter: "Excited to share an update on #AlphaGo!"". Demis Hassabis's Twitter account. Retrieved 4 January 2017.
  9. 1 2 3 Elizabeth Gibney (4 January 2017). "Google reveals secret test of AI bot to beat top Go players". Nature . Retrieved 4 January 2017.
  10. 1 2 3 "Humans Mourn Loss After Google Is Unmasked as China's Go Master". Wall Street Journal. 5 January 2017. Retrieved 6 January 2017.
  11. "The world's best Go player says he still has "one last move" to defeat Google's AlphaGo AI". Quartz . 4 January 2017. Retrieved 6 January 2017.
  12. "Full list of human players participating in the 60 games" (in Chinese). Sohu. 13 February 2017. Retrieved 23 April 2017.
  13. Nie Weiping (3 January 2017). "神秘高手Master颠覆了围棋传统,这更证明了藤泽秀行那句话" (in Chinese). Toutiao . Retrieved 24 April 2017.
  14. "韩国研究新版AlphaGo:穿越而来展示未来围棋" (in Chinese). Sina.com. 11 January 2017. Retrieved 24 April 2017.
  15. "金成龙分析AlphaGo:愿你为人类划开围棋的新天地" (in Chinese). Sina.com. 28 January 2017. Retrieved 24 April 2017.
  16. "韩国家队分析AlphaGo60局1 很强但不"完美"" (in Chinese). Sina.com. 31 January 2017. Retrieved 24 April 2017.
  17. "韩国家队分析AlphaGo60局2 井山一局最有机会" (in Chinese). Sina.com. 2 February 2017. Retrieved 24 April 2017.
  18. "阿法狗最令人感动一手 王铭琬:推波助澜" (in Chinese). Sina.com. 6 February 2017. Retrieved 24 April 2017.
  19. Nie Weiping (19 January 2017). "李昌镐学习"阿法狗流",日本棋手放下包袱仍有一战" (in Chinese). Toutiao . Retrieved 24 April 2017.
  20. 1 2 "Innovations of AlphaGo". DeepMind. Archived from the original on 27 July 2019. Retrieved 23 April 2017.
  21. "Clarification". Fan Hui's Sina Weibo. 20 January 2017. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  22. "Clarification". Aja Huang's Facebook. 20 January 2017. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  23. "高手战Master技术分析:人类仍有机会赢AI?" (in Chinese). QQ.com. 2 May 2017. Retrieved 13 May 2017.