Photophoresis

Last updated April 26, 2024

Photophoresis denotes the phenomenon that small particles suspended in gas (aerosols) or liquids (hydrocolloids) start to migrate when illuminated by a sufficiently intense beam of light. The existence of this phenomenon is owed to a non-uniform distribution of temperature of an illuminated particle in a fluid medium.^[1] Separately from photophoresis, in a fluid mixture of different kinds of particles, the migration of some kinds of particles may be due to differences in their absorptions of thermal radiation and other thermal effects collectively known as thermophoresis. In laser photophoresis, particles migrate once they have a refractive index different from their surrounding medium. The migration of particles is usually possible when the laser is slightly or not focused. A particle with a higher refractive index compared to its surrounding molecule moves away from the light source due to momentum transfer from absorbed and scattered light photons. This is referred to as a radiation pressure force. This force depends on light intensity and particle size but has nothing to do with the surrounding medium^{[ clarification needed ]}. Just like in Crookes radiometer, light can heat up one side and gas molecules bounce from that surface with greater velocity, hence push the particle to the other side. Under certain conditions, with particles of diameter comparable to the wavelength of light, the phenomenon of a negative indirect photophoresis occurs, due to the unequal heat generation on the laser irradiation between the back and front sides of particles, this produces a temperature gradient in the medium around the particle such that molecules at the far side of the particle from the light source may get to heat up more, causing the particle to move towards the light source.^[2]

Applications of photophoresis

The applications of photophoresis expand into the various divisions of science, thus physics, chemistry as well as in biology. Photophoresis is applied in particle trapping and levitation,^[3] in the field flow fractionation of particles,^[4] in the determination of thermal conductivity and temperature of microscopic grains^[5] and also in the transport of soot particles in the atmosphere.^[6] The use of light in the separation of particles aerosols based on their optical properties, makes possible the separation of organic and inorganic particles of the same aerodynamic size.^[7]

Recently, photophoresis has been suggested as a chiral sorting mechanism for single walled carbon nanotubes.^[8] The proposed method would utilise differences in the absorption spectra of semiconducting carbon nanotubes arising from optically excited transitions in electronic structure. If developed the technique would be orders of magnitudes faster than currently established ultracentrifugation techniques.

In 2021 Azadi, Popov et al. report "light-driven levitation of macroscopic polymer films with nanostructured surface as candidates for long-duration near-space flight" Using a light intensity comparable to sunlight, they levitated centimeter-scale disks made of commercial 0.5-micron-thick mylar film coated with carbon nanotubes on one side.^[9] Experiments by Schafer, Kim, Vlassak and Keith suggest that photophoretic forces could levitate thin 10 centimetre-scale structures in Earth′s stratosphere indefinitely for the purpose of atmospheric science, especially monitoring high-altitude weather. They describe in 2022 a preliminary design fabricated with available methods of a 10 cm diameter device combining a levitating structure of two membranes^[10] 2 μm apart in a stiff support structure tested to have sufficient strength to withstand transport, deployment, and flight at 25 km altitude. Payload capacity is 300 mg and could support bidirectional radio communication at over 10 Mb/s and some navigational control. By upscaling the structure it might carry payloads of a few grams. They suggest uses for telecommunications, and deployment on Mars.^[11]

Theory of photophoresis

Direct photophoresis is caused by the transfer of photon momentum to a particle by refraction and reflection.^[12] Movement of particles in the forward direction occurs when the particle is transparent and has an index of refraction larger compared to its surrounding medium.^[7] Indirect photophoresis occurs as a result of an increase in the kinetic energy of molecules when particles absorb incident light only on the irradiated side, thus creating a temperature gradient within the particle. In this situation the surrounding gas layer reaches temperature equilibrium with the surface of the particle. Molecules with higher kinetic energy in the region of higher gas temperature impinge on the particle with greater momenta than molecules in the cold region; this causes a migration of particles in a direction opposite to the surface temperature gradient. The component of the photophoretic force responsible for this phenomenon is called the radiometric force.^[13] This comes as a result of uneven distribution of radiant energy (source function within a particle). Indirect photophoretic force depends on the physical properties of the particle and the surrounding medium.

For pressures $p$ , where the free mean path of the gas is much larger than the characteristic size $r_{0}$ of the suspended particle (direct photophoresis), the longitudinal force is ^[14]

\mathbf {F} _{\text{phot}}=-{\frac {\pi }{3}}\,\alpha \,\alpha _{\text{m}}{\frac {p}{\sqrt {{\overline {T_{\text{gas}}^{\text{out}}}}\,T_{\text{gas}}^{\text{in}}}}}\,r_{0}^{2}\,{\frac {I\,J_{1}}{{\frac {k}{r_{0}}}+4\sigma _{\text{SB}}\varepsilon \,T_{\text{black body}}^{3}}}\,\mathbf {e} _{z}

where the mean temperature of the scattered gas is (thermal accommodation coefficient $\alpha$ , momentum accommodation coefficient $\alpha _{\text{m}}$ )

{\overline {T_{\text{gas}}^{\text{out}}}}=T_{\text{gas}}^{\text{in}}+\alpha \left(T_{\text{black body}}-T_{\text{gas}}^{\text{in}}\right)

and the black body temperature of the particle (net light flux $I=\varepsilon \,I_{0}$ , Stefan Boltzmann constant $\sigma _{\text{SB}}$ , temperature of the radiation field $T_{\text{opt}}$ )

T_{\text{black body}}={\sqrt[{4}]{{\frac {I_{0}}{4\sigma _{\text{SB}}}}+T_{\text{opt}}^{4}}}

.

$k$ is the thermal conductivity of the particle. The asymmetry factor for spheres $J_{1}$ is usually $1/2$ (positive longitudinal photophoresis). For non-spherical particles, the average force exerted on the particle is given by the same equation where the radius $r_{0}$ is now the radius of the respective volume-equivalent sphere.^[15]

Related Research Articles

In physics and chemistry, an equation of state is a thermodynamic equation relating state variables, which describe the state of matter under a given set of physical conditions, such as pressure, volume, temperature, or internal energy. Most modern equations of state are formulated in the Helmholtz free energy. Equations of state are useful in describing the properties of pure substances and mixtures in liquids, gases, and solid states as well as the state of matter in the interior of stars.

Rayleigh scattering, named after the 19th-century British physicist Lord Rayleigh, is the predominantly elastic scattering of light, or other electromagnetic radiation, by particles with a size much smaller than the wavelength of the radiation. For light frequencies well below the resonance frequency of the scattering medium, the amount of scattering is inversely proportional to the fourth power of the wavelength, e.g., a blue color is scattered much more than a red color as light propagates through air.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Radiation pressure</span> Pressure exerted upon any surface exposed to electromagnetic radiation

Radiation pressure is mechanical pressure exerted upon a surface due to the exchange of momentum between the object and the electromagnetic field. This includes the momentum of light or electromagnetic radiation of any wavelength that is absorbed, reflected, or otherwise emitted by matter on any scale. The associated force is called the radiation pressure force, or sometimes just the force of light.

An aerosol is a suspension of fine solid particles or liquid droplets in air or another gas. Aerosols can be generated from natural or human causes. The term aerosol commonly refers to the mixture of particulates in air, and not to the particulate matter alone. Examples of natural aerosols are fog, mist or dust. Examples of human caused aerosols include particulate air pollutants, mist from the discharge at hydroelectric dams, irrigation mist, perfume from atomizers, smoke, dust, sprayed pesticides, and medical treatments for respiratory illnesses.

The thermal conductivity of a material is a measure of its ability to conduct heat. It is commonly denoted by $,, or and is measured in W\cdotm -1 \cdotK -1 .$

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kinetic theory of gases</span> Understanding of gas properties in terms of molecular motion

The kinetic theory of gases is a simple classical model of the thermodynamic behavior of gases. It treats a gas as composed of numerous particles, too small to see with a microscope, which are constantly in random motion. Their collisions with each other and with the walls of their container are used to explain physical properties of the gas—for example the relationship between its temperature, pressure and volume. The particles are now known to be the atoms or molecules of the gas.

In physics, mean free path is the average distance over which a moving particle travels before substantially changing its direction or energy, typically as a result of one or more successive collisions with other particles.

Thermal radiation is electromagnetic radiation emitted by the thermal motion of particles in matter. Thermal radiation transmits as an electromagnetic wave through both matter and vacuum. When matter absorbs thermal radiation its temperature will tend to rise. All matter with a temperature greater than absolute zero emits thermal radiation. The emission of energy arises from a combination of electronic, molecular, and lattice oscillations in a material. Kinetic energy is converted to electromagnetism due to charge-acceleration or dipole oscillation. At room temperature, most of the emission is in the infrared (IR) spectrum. Thermal radiation is one of the fundamental mechanisms of heat transfer, along with conduction and convection.

Optical tweezers are scientific instruments that use a highly focused laser beam to hold and move microscopic and sub-microscopic objects like atoms, nanoparticles and droplets, in a manner similar to tweezers. If the object is held in air or vacuum without additional support, it can be called optical levitation.

In electromagnetism, the Clausius–Mossotti relation, named for O. F. Mossotti and Rudolf Clausius, expresses the dielectric constant of a material in terms of the atomic polarizability, $α$ , of the material's constituent atoms and/or molecules, or a homogeneous mixture thereof. It is equivalent to the Lorentz–Lorenz equation, which relates the refractive index of a substance to its polarizability. It may be expressed as:

Electrical mobility is the ability of charged particles to move through a medium in response to an electric field that is pulling them. The separation of ions according to their mobility in gas phase is called ion mobility spectrometry, in liquid phase it is called electrophoresis.

A Knudsen gas is a gas in a state of such low density that the average distance travelled by the gas molecules between collisions is greater than the diameter of the receptacle that contains it. If the mean free path is much greater than the diameter, the flow regime is dominated by collisions between the gas molecules and the walls of the receptacle, rather than intermolecular collisions with each other. It is named after Martin Knudsen.

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) It is a method of conducting analytical research that separates and identifies ionized molecules present in the gas phase based on the mobility of the molecules in a carrier buffer gas. Even though it is used extensively for military or security objectives, such as detecting drugs and explosives, the technology also has many applications in laboratory analysis, including studying small and big biomolecules. IMS instruments are extremely sensitive stand-alone devices, but are often coupled with mass spectrometry, gas chromatography or high-performance liquid chromatography in order to achieve a multi-dimensional separation. They come in various sizes, ranging from a few millimeters to several meters depending on the specific application, and are capable of operating under a broad range of conditions. IMS instruments such as microscale high-field asymmetric-waveform ion mobility spectrometry can be palm-portable for use in a range of applications including volatile organic compound (VOC) monitoring, biological sample analysis, medical diagnosis and food quality monitoring. Systems operated at higher pressure are often accompanied by elevated temperature, while lower pressure systems (1–20 hPa) do not require heating.

In mesoscopic physics, ballistic conduction is the unimpeded flow of charge carriers, or energy-carrying particles, over relatively long distances in a material. In general, the resistivity of a material exists because an electron, while moving inside a medium, is scattered by impurities, defects, thermal fluctuations of ions in a crystalline solid, or, generally, by any freely-moving atom/molecule composing a gas or liquid. Without scattering, electrons simply obey Newton's second law of motion at non-relativistic speeds.

Thermophoresis is a phenomenon observed in mixtures of mobile particles where the different particle types exhibit different responses to the force of a temperature gradient. This phenomenon tends to move light molecules to hot regions and heavy molecules to cold regions. The term thermophoresis most often applies to aerosol mixtures whose mean free path $is comparable to its characteristic length scale, but may also commonly refer to the phenomenon in all phases of matter. The term Soret effect normally applies to liquid mixtures, which behave according to different, less well-understood mechanisms than gaseous mixtures. Thermophoresis may not apply to thermomigration in solids, especially multi-phase alloys.$

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Viscosity</span> Resistance of a fluid to shear deformation

The viscosity of a fluid is a measure of its resistance to deformation at a given rate. For liquids, it corresponds to the informal concept of "thickness": for example, syrup has a higher viscosity than water. Viscosity is defined scientifically as a force multiplied by a time divided by an area. Thus its SI units are newton-seconds per square meter, or pascal-seconds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Plasma (physics)</span> State of matter

Plasma is one of four fundamental states of matter characterized by the presence of a significant portion of charged particles in any combination of ions or electrons. It is the most abundant form of ordinary matter in the universe, mostly in stars, but also dominating the rarefied intracluster medium and intergalactic medium. Plasma can be artificially generated, for example, by heating a neutral gas or subjecting it to a strong electromagnetic field.

Heat transfer physics describes the kinetics of energy storage, transport, and energy transformation by principal energy carriers: phonons, electrons, fluid particles, and photons. Heat is thermal energy stored in temperature-dependent motion of particles including electrons, atomic nuclei, individual atoms, and molecules. Heat is transferred to and from matter by the principal energy carriers. The state of energy stored within matter, or transported by the carriers, is described by a combination of classical and quantum statistical mechanics. The energy is different made (converted) among various carriers. The heat transfer processes are governed by the rates at which various related physical phenomena occur, such as the rate of particle collisions in classical mechanics. These various states and kinetics determine the heat transfer, i.e., the net rate of energy storage or transport. Governing these process from the atomic level to macroscale are the laws of thermodynamics, including conservation of energy.

Quantum thermodynamics is the study of the relations between two independent physical theories: thermodynamics and quantum mechanics. The two independent theories address the physical phenomena of light and matter. In 1905, Albert Einstein argued that the requirement of consistency between thermodynamics and electromagnetism leads to the conclusion that light is quantized, obtaining the relation $. This paper is the dawn of quantum theory. In a few decades quantum theory became established with an independent set of rules. Currently quantum thermodynamics addresses the emergence of thermodynamic laws from quantum mechanics. It differs from quantum statistical mechanics in the emphasis on dynamical processes out of equilibrium. In addition, there is a quest for the theory to be relevant for a single individual quantum system.$

Atmospheric lidar is a class of instruments that uses laser light to study atmospheric properties from the ground up to the top of the atmosphere. Such instruments have been used to study, among other, atmospheric gases, aerosols, clouds, and temperature.

References

↑ Tehranian, Shahram; Giovane, Frank; Blum, Jürgen; Xu, Yu-Lin; Gustafson, Bo Å.S. (2001). "Photophoresis of micrometer-sized particles in the free-molecular regime". International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer. 44 (9). Elsevier BV: 1649–1657. doi:10.1016/s0017-9310(00)00230-1. ISSN 0017-9310.
↑ WATARAI, Hitoshi; MONJUSHIRO, Hideaki; TSUKAHARA, Satoshi; SUWA, Masayori; IIGUNI, Yoshinori (2004). "Migration Analysis of Micro-Particles in Liquids Using Microscopically Designed External Fields". Analytical Sciences. 20 (3). Japan Society for Analytical Chemistry: 423–434. doi:10.2116/analsci.20.423. ISSN 0910-6340. PMID 15068282.
↑ Rosenberg, M.; Mendis, D.A.; Sheehan, D.P. (1999). "Positively charged dust crystals induced by radiative heating". IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science. 27 (1). Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE): 239–242. Bibcode:1999ITPS...27..239R. doi:10.1109/27.763125. ISSN 0093-3813.
↑ Kononenko, V. L.; Shimkus, J. K.; Giddings, J. C.; Myers, M. N. (1997). "Feasibility Studies on Photophoretic Effects in Field-Flow Fractionation of Particles". Journal of Liquid Chromatography & Related Technologies. 20 (16–17). Informa UK Limited: 2907–2929. doi:10.1080/10826079708005600. ISSN 1082-6076.
↑ Zhang, Xuefeng; Bar-Ziv, Ezra (1997). "A Novel Approach to Determine Thermal Conductivity of Micron-Sized Fuel Particles". Combustion Science and Technology. 130 (1–6). Informa UK Limited: 79–95. doi:10.1080/00102209708935738. ISSN 0010-2202.
↑ Rohatschek, Hans (1996). "Levitation of stratospheric and mesospheric aerosols by gravito-photophoresis". Journal of Aerosol Science. 27 (3). Elsevier BV: 467–475. Bibcode:1996JAerS..27..467R. doi:10.1016/0021-8502(95)00556-0. ISSN 0021-8502.
1 2 C. Helmbrecht; C. Kykal; C. Haisch. ""Photophoretic Particle Separation" in Institute of Hydrochemistry, Annual report, 2006" (PDF). p. 11. Archived from the original (PDF) on 25 May 2019. Retrieved 25 May 2019.
↑ Smith, David; Woods, Christopher; Seddon, Annela; Hoerber, Heinrich (2014). "Photophoretic separation of single-walled carbon nanotubes: a novel approach to selective chiral sorting". Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 16 (11). Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC): 5221–5228. Bibcode:2014PCCP...16.5221S. doi: 10.1039/c3cp54812k . ISSN 1463-9076. PMID 24487342.
↑ Azadi, Mohsen; Popov, George A.; Lu, Zhipeng; Eskenazi, Andy G.; Bang, Avery Ji Won; Campbell, Matthew F.; Hu, Howard; Bargatin, Igor (2021-02-12). "Controlled levitation of nanostructured thin films for sun-powered near-space flight". Science Advances. 7 (7). Bibcode:2021SciA....7.1127A. doi:10.1126/sciadv.abe1127. ISSN 2375-2548. PMC 7880585 . PMID 33579712.
↑ Cortes, John; Stanczak, Christopher; Azadi, Mohsen; Narula, Maanav; Nicaise, Samuel M.; Hu, Howard; Bargatin, Igor (April 2020). "Photophoretic Levitation: Photophoretic Levitation of Macroscopic Nanocardboard Plates (Adv. Mater. 16/2020)". Advanced Materials. 32 (16): 2070127. arXiv: 1910.03900 . Bibcode:2020AdM....3206878C. doi:10.1002/adma.202070127. ISSN 0935-9648. S2CID 219111532.
↑ Schafer, Benjamin C.; Kim, Jong-hyoung; Vlassak, Joost J.; Keith, David W. (2022-09-15). "Towards photophoretically levitating macroscopic sensors in the stratosphere". arXiv: 2209.08093 [physics.app-ph].
↑ Ashkin, A. 2000 IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics, 6,841-856.
↑ Yalamov, Yu.I; Kutukov, V.B; Shchukin, E.R (1976). "Theory of the photophoretic motion of the large-size volatile aerosol particle". Journal of Colloid and Interface Science. 57 (3). Elsevier BV: 564–571. Bibcode:1976JCIS...57..564Y. doi:10.1016/0021-9797(76)90234-4. ISSN 0021-9797.
↑ Loesche, C.; Husmann, T. (2016). "Photophoresis on particles hotter/colder than the ambient gas for the entire range of pressures". Journal of Aerosol Science. 102. Elsevier BV: 55–71. arXiv: 1609.01341 . Bibcode:2016JAerS.102...55L. doi:10.1016/j.jaerosci.2016.08.013. ISSN 0021-8502. S2CID 67828668.
↑ Loesche, Christoph; Wurm, Gerhard; Teiser, Jens; Friedrich, Jon M.; Bischoff, Addi (2013-11-08). "Photophoretic Strength on Chondrules. 1. Modeling". The Astrophysical Journal. 778 (2). IOP Publishing: 101. arXiv: 1311.6660 . Bibcode:2013ApJ...778..101L. doi:10.1088/0004-637x/778/2/101. ISSN 0004-637X. S2CID 118462436.

External links

Photophoresis in the context of astrophysics
Negative photophoresis

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.

[1] Tehranian, Shahram; Giovane, Frank; Blum, Jürgen; Xu, Yu-Lin; Gustafson, Bo Å.S. (2001). "Photophoresis of micrometer-sized particles in the free-molecular regime". International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer. 44 (9). Elsevier BV: 1649–1657. doi:10.1016/s0017-9310(00)00230-1. ISSN 0017-9310.

[2] WATARAI, Hitoshi; MONJUSHIRO, Hideaki; TSUKAHARA, Satoshi; SUWA, Masayori; IIGUNI, Yoshinori (2004). "Migration Analysis of Micro-Particles in Liquids Using Microscopically Designed External Fields". Analytical Sciences. 20 (3). Japan Society for Analytical Chemistry: 423–434. doi:10.2116/analsci.20.423. ISSN 0910-6340. PMID 15068282.

[3] Rosenberg, M.; Mendis, D.A.; Sheehan, D.P. (1999). "Positively charged dust crystals induced by radiative heating". IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science. 27 (1). Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE): 239–242. Bibcode:1999ITPS...27..239R. doi:10.1109/27.763125. ISSN 0093-3813.

[4] Kononenko, V. L.; Shimkus, J. K.; Giddings, J. C.; Myers, M. N. (1997). "Feasibility Studies on Photophoretic Effects in Field-Flow Fractionation of Particles". Journal of Liquid Chromatography & Related Technologies. 20 (16–17). Informa UK Limited: 2907–2929. doi:10.1080/10826079708005600. ISSN 1082-6076.

[5] Zhang, Xuefeng; Bar-Ziv, Ezra (1997). "A Novel Approach to Determine Thermal Conductivity of Micron-Sized Fuel Particles". Combustion Science and Technology. 130 (1–6). Informa UK Limited: 79–95. doi:10.1080/00102209708935738. ISSN 0010-2202.

[6] Rohatschek, Hans (1996). "Levitation of stratospheric and mesospheric aerosols by gravito-photophoresis". Journal of Aerosol Science. 27 (3). Elsevier BV: 467–475. Bibcode:1996JAerS..27..467R. doi:10.1016/0021-8502(95)00556-0. ISSN 0021-8502.

[2006report-7] 1 2 C. Helmbrecht; C. Kykal; C. Haisch. ""Photophoretic Particle Separation" in Institute of Hydrochemistry, Annual report, 2006" (PDF). p. 11. Archived from the original (PDF) on 25 May 2019. Retrieved 25 May 2019.

[8] Smith, David; Woods, Christopher; Seddon, Annela; Hoerber, Heinrich (2014). "Photophoretic separation of single-walled carbon nanotubes: a novel approach to selective chiral sorting". Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 16 (11). Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC): 5221–5228. Bibcode:2014PCCP...16.5221S. doi: 10.1039/c3cp54812k . ISSN 1463-9076. PMID 24487342.

[9] Azadi, Mohsen; Popov, George A.; Lu, Zhipeng; Eskenazi, Andy G.; Bang, Avery Ji Won; Campbell, Matthew F.; Hu, Howard; Bargatin, Igor (2021-02-12). "Controlled levitation of nanostructured thin films for sun-powered near-space flight". Science Advances. 7 (7). Bibcode:2021SciA....7.1127A. doi:10.1126/sciadv.abe1127. ISSN 2375-2548. PMC 7880585 . PMID 33579712.

[10] Cortes, John; Stanczak, Christopher; Azadi, Mohsen; Narula, Maanav; Nicaise, Samuel M.; Hu, Howard; Bargatin, Igor (April 2020). "Photophoretic Levitation: Photophoretic Levitation of Macroscopic Nanocardboard Plates (Adv. Mater. 16/2020)". Advanced Materials. 32 (16): 2070127. arXiv: 1910.03900 . Bibcode:2020AdM....3206878C. doi:10.1002/adma.202070127. ISSN 0935-9648. S2CID 219111532.

[11] Schafer, Benjamin C.; Kim, Jong-hyoung; Vlassak, Joost J.; Keith, David W. (2022-09-15). "Towards photophoretically levitating macroscopic sensors in the stratosphere". arXiv: 2209.08093 [physics.app-ph].

[12] Ashkin, A. 2000 IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics, 6,841-856.

[13] Yalamov, Yu.I; Kutukov, V.B; Shchukin, E.R (1976). "Theory of the photophoretic motion of the large-size volatile aerosol particle". Journal of Colloid and Interface Science. 57 (3). Elsevier BV: 564–571. Bibcode:1976JCIS...57..564Y. doi:10.1016/0021-9797(76)90234-4. ISSN 0021-9797.

[14] Loesche, C.; Husmann, T. (2016). "Photophoresis on particles hotter/colder than the ambient gas for the entire range of pressures". Journal of Aerosol Science. 102. Elsevier BV: 55–71. arXiv: 1609.01341 . Bibcode:2016JAerS.102...55L. doi:10.1016/j.jaerosci.2016.08.013. ISSN 0021-8502. S2CID 67828668.

[15] Loesche, Christoph; Wurm, Gerhard; Teiser, Jens; Friedrich, Jon M.; Bischoff, Addi (2013-11-08). "Photophoretic Strength on Chondrules. 1. Modeling". The Astrophysical Journal. 778 (2). IOP Publishing: 101. arXiv: 1311.6660 . Bibcode:2013ApJ...778..101L. doi:10.1088/0004-637x/778/2/101. ISSN 0004-637X. S2CID 118462436.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]