Pitts and Lee v. Florida

Last updated

Pitts and Lee v. Florida (1963) (often referred to as the Pitts-Lee case) was a criminal case in which two African-American defendants were charged with murder. The case is remembered for its Civil Rights implications, and because it involved two death-row inmates who were later exonerated. The prosecutors deliberately tampered with evidence, and the men were sentenced to death by an all-white jury, Freddie Lee Pitts and Wilbert Lee (the defendants) were imprisoned for twelve years before being pardoned by then-Florida Governor Reubin Askew on September 20, 1975.

Contents

Background

The crime occurred on August 1, 1963, in Port St. Joe, Florida. On the night of the crime, Freddie Pitts (age 19), Wilbert Lee (28), and several other people went to a Mo-Jo gas station in the small town. Pitts and Lee went to use the restroom, but the restrooms in the facility were only for whites. This caused Pitts and Lee to get into an argument with the attendants, two white men named Grover Floyd Jr. and Jesse Burkett. [1] [2]

Floyd and Burkett were found dead three days later. They had been shot to death. After being coerced by the police into making an accusation, [2] a woman who was with Pitts and Lee accused Pitts and another man of the crime. This other suspect was a soldier who worked for the military, and they provided an alibi for him. The woman then changed her accusation, accusing Pitts and Lee of the crime. [1]

Pitts and Lee confessed to the crime after the police beat them and threatened to harm Lee's wife, among other examples of cruel treatment. Their lawyer, who had been appointed by the Court, advised them to plead guilty. [1] [3] The two men did not have a trial, as they had confessed to the crime and pleaded guilty. They were sentenced to death by an all-white jury on August 28, 1963. [1] [2]

In 1966, a man named Curtis Adams confessed to the murders of Floyd and Burkett. [4]

Appeals

Pitts and Lee spent over a decade appealing their case. In 1964 they appealed to the Florida Supreme Court, alleging that the judge in their case had made procedural errors. However, the Court ruled against them. [5]

They then filed a motion objecting to the composition of the jury that had sentenced them, and after the trial court ruled against them, they appealed to the Florida First District Court of Appeal. The Court upheld the lower court's ruling. [6]

Pitts and Lee filed another attack on their convictions in 1967. They argued several points. They objected to the fact that one lawyer had represented both of them, that people who opposed the death penalty had not been included on the jury, they argued that their guilty plea was based on coercion, that their lawyer had been inadequate, that the State had withheld evidence that supported their innocence, and that Curtis Adams had confessed to the crime. [7]

Not only had Adams confessed to the crime, but the woman who accused them was now saying that she had been coerced into fingering them. However, there was considerable resistance in the state to acknowledging these facts. When the Gulf County sheriff was told about Adams' confession, he said that "`I got two niggers on Death Row who already did it.'" [2]

However, in Court the prosecutors refused to grant Adams immunity for his crime, so he pleaded the Fifth Amendment. While the Court had ample evidence that Adams had told other people about his guilt (including testimony from Adams' girlfriend), they could not use it because of Adams pleading the fifth. [2] [7]

Warren Holmes, the man who had taken Adams' confession under a lie detector, mentioned the case to his friend Gene Miller. Holmes told Miller that he believed Pitts and Lee were innocent. Miller, a reporter for the Miami Herald, began to investigate the case. [2] He wrote a book on his findings, Invitation to a Lynching, which argued that Pitts and Lee had been wrongfully convicted. [8] In 1976, Miller would be awarded a Pulitzer Prize in Local General or Spot News Reporting for his work on "Invitation to a Lynching". [9] This book convinced Florida Attorney General Robert Shevin to testify to the Florida Supreme Court that he believed the State had wrongfully withheld evidence, and that the two men were actually innocent. Shevin later admitted that this confession of error likely cost him his chances at being elected governor, "But it was right and I had to do it. [2]

Pitts and Lee then had an actual trial, but they were again declared guilty by an all-white jury. Neither Adams' confession nor the prosecution's earlier suppression of evidence were allowed to be presented to the jury. [10] The US Supreme Court's decision in Furman v. Georgia caused their death penalty sentences to be commuted to life imprisonment. [11] Pitts and Lee made an appeal to the US Supreme Court, but the Governor would pardon them before the Supreme Court decided whether to grant certiorari. [2]

Pardon

Arthur Canaday, General Counsel to Governor Reubin Askew, read an early copy of Miller's Invitation to a Lynching. Canaday found the book persuasive and he told Askew that there was a real chance that the defendants were innocent. Askew launched an investigation into the case, and he too became convinced that Pitts and Lee were innocent. The Governor and three members of the cabinet [12] (Attorney General Robert Shevin, (whom Canaday previously worked for), Treasurer Phil Ashler, and Education Commissioner Ralph Turlington), signed a pardon that freed Pitts and Lee after twelve years in prison. [1] [2]

Aftermath

After being pardoned, Lee worked for the Florida Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services as a juvenile counselor. However, Lee lost his job in 1985 after Florida passed a law banning former felons from working with children. Lee took legal action, and although a lower court ruled against him, the Florida 3rd District Court of Appeal ruled in his favor. The Court ruled that Askew's pardon made Lee free from any legal consequences of his conviction. [13]

Pitts and Lee would work for years to try to gain some sort of compensation for their wrongful imprisonment. A bill was introduced multiple times in the Florida Legislature to grant them money to attempt to make up for their imprisonment, but it failed nineteen times. The legislation was regularly defeated by a traditional Southern Democratic faction of conservative legislators from the Panhandle. [2] [14]

In 1998, Kendrick Meek reintroduced the bill in the Florida House, and Betty Holzendorf reintroduced it in the Senate. Holzendorf and Meek, along with a faction of more liberal Democrats, forged an alliance with Florida Republicans over getting the bill passed. [14] [15]

However, the House wanted to give the men substantially less money than the Senate did. The Florida House ended up passing a bill that would allow a hearing officer from the Florida Department of Administrative Hearings to grant the men a reward of up to $350,000. A committee in the Senate voted to directly give each man $1.5 million. [15] The Senate and House were eventually able to reach a compromise. April 30, 1998, Florida Governor Lawton Chiles signed a bill into law that granted each man $500,000 as long as a state administrative judge concurred with the assertion that the state had wronged them. [2]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Groveland, Florida</span> City in Florida

Groveland is a city in Lake County, Florida, United States. The population was 18,505 at the 2020 census. It is located at the intersection of State Road 19 and State Road 33/50.

Chambers v. Florida, 309 U.S. 227 (1940), was a landmark United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the extent to which police pressure resulting in a criminal defendant's confession violates the Due Process Clause.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reubin Askew</span> American politician (1928–2014)

Reubin O'Donovan Askew was an American politician, who served as the 37th governor of Florida from 1971 to 1979. A member of the Democratic Party, he served as the 7th U.S. Trade representative from 1979 to 1980 under President Jimmy Carter. He led on tax reform, civil rights, and financial transparency for public officials, maintaining an outstanding reputation for personal integrity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henry Lee Lucas</span> American murderer (1936–2001)

Henry Lee Lucas, also known as The Confession Killer, was an American convicted murderer. Lucas was convicted of murdering his mother in 1960 and two others in 1983. He rose to infamy as a claimed serial killer while incarcerated for these crimes when he falsely confessed to approximately six hundred other murders to Texas Rangers and other law enforcement officials. Many unsolved cases were closed based on the confessions and the murders officially attributed to Lucas. Lucas was convicted of murdering eleven people and condemned to death for a single case with a then-unidentified victim, later identified as Debra Jackson.

Randall Dale Adams was an American man wrongfully convicted of murder and sentenced to death after the 1976 shooting of Dallas police officer Robert W. Wood. His conviction was overturned in 1989.

<i>K. M. Nanavati v. State of Maharashtra</i> 1959 Indian court case

Commander K. M. Nanavati vs. State of Maharashtra was a 1959 Indian court case where Kawas Manekshaw Nanavati, a Naval Commander, was tried for the murder of Prem Ahuja, his wife's lover. Commander Nanavati, accused under section 302, was initially declared not guilty by a jury, but the verdict was dismissed by the Bombay High Court and the case was retried as a bench trial. The case is often erroneously believed to be the last jury trial in India, but there were several trials afterwards that used juries, some well into the 1960s. Nanavati was finally pardoned by Vijayalakshmi Pandit, newly appointed Governor of Maharashtra and sister of Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru.

Gene Miller (1928–2005) was a longtime investigative reporter at the Miami Herald who won two Pulitzer Prizes for reporting that helped save innocent men on Florida's Death Row from execution. He was also a legendary editor, mentoring generations of young reporters in how to write crisp, direct, and entertaining stories. When he died of cancer in 2005, the Herald called him "the soul and the conscience of our newsroom."

A false confession is an admission of guilt for a crime which the individual did not commit. Although such confessions seem counterintuitive, they can be made voluntarily, perhaps to protect a third party, or induced through coercive interrogation techniques. When some degree of coercion is involved, studies have found that subjects with highly sophisticated intelligence or manipulated by their so-called "friends" are more likely to make such confessions. Young people are particularly vulnerable to confessing, especially when stressed, tired, or traumatized, and have a significantly higher rate of false confessions than adults. Hundreds of innocent people have been convicted, imprisoned, and sometimes sentenced to death after confessing to crimes they did not commit—but years later, have been exonerated. It was not until several shocking false confession cases were publicized in the late 1980s, combined with the introduction of DNA evidence, that the extent of wrongful convictions began to emerge—and how often false confessions played a role in these.

Coker v. Georgia, 433 U.S. 584 (1977), held that the death penalty for rape of an adult woman was grossly disproportionate and excessive punishment, and therefore unconstitutional under the Eighth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. A few states continued to have child rape statutes that authorized the death penalty. In Kennedy v. Louisiana (2008), the court expanded Coker, ruling that the death penalty is unconstitutional in all cases that do not involve intentional homicide or crimes against the State.

The Groveland Four were four African American men, Ernest Thomas, Charles Greenlee, Samuel Shepherd, and Walter Irvin. In July 1949, the four were accused of raping a white woman and severely beating her husband in Lake County, Florida. The oldest, Thomas, tried to elude capture and was killed that month. The others were put on trial. Shepard and Irvin received death sentences, and Greenlee was sentenced to life in prison. The events of the case led to serious questions about the arrests, allegedly coerced confessions and mistreatment, and the unusual sentencing following their convictions. Their incarceration was exacerbated by their systemic and unlawful treatment—including the death of Shepherd, and the near-fatal shooting of Irvin. Greenlee was paroled in 1962 and Irvin in 1968. All four were posthumously exonerated by the state of Florida in 2021.

Wrongful execution is a miscarriage of justice occurring when an innocent person is put to death by capital punishment. Cases of wrongful execution are cited as an argument by opponents of capital punishment, while proponents say that the argument of innocence concerns the credibility of the justice system as a whole and does not solely undermine the use of the death penalty.

Richard Jason Ofshe is an American sociologist and professor emeritus of sociology at the University of California, Berkeley. He is known for his expert testimony relating to coercion in small groups, confessions, and interrogations.

This is a list of notable overturned convictions in the United States.

The Norfolk Four are four former United States Navy sailors: Joseph J. Dick Jr., Derek Tice, Danial Williams, and Eric C. Wilson, who were wrongfully convicted of the 1997 rape and murder of Michelle Moore-Bosko while they were stationed at Naval Station Norfolk. They each declared that they had made false confessions, and their convictions are considered highly controversial. A fifth man, Omar Ballard, confessed and pleaded guilty to the crime in 2000, insisting that he had acted alone. He had been in prison since 1998 because of violent attacks on two other women in 1997. He was the only one of the suspects whose DNA matched that collected at the crime scene, and whose confession was consistent with other forensic evidence.

Sharon Faye Keller is the Presiding Judge of the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. She is a Republican.

Rolando Cruz is an American man known for having been wrongfully convicted and sentenced to death, along with co-defendant Alejandro Hernandez, for the 1983 kidnapping, rape, and murder of 10-year-old Jeanine Nicarico in DuPage County, Illinois. The police had no substantive physical evidence linking the two men to the crime. Their first trial was jointly in 1987, and their statements were used against each other and a third defendant.

Spaziano v. Florida was two United States Supreme Court cases dealing with the imposition of the death penalty. In the first case, 454 U.S. 1037 (1981), the Supreme Court, with two dissents, refused Spaziano's petition for certiorari. However, the Florida Supreme Court would reverse Spaziano's death sentence based on the judge's receipt of a confidential report which was not received by either party. On remand, the judge reimposed the death penalty and the Florida Supreme Court upheld the sentence. In the second case, 468 U.S. 447 (1984), the Court heard Spaziano's appeal of his death sentence.

The Martinsville Seven were a group of seven African-American men from Martinsville, Virginia, who were all executed in 1951 by the state of Virginia after being convicted of raping a white woman. At the time of their arrest, all but one were between the ages of 18 and 23. They were quickly tried in six separate trials, and each was convicted and sentenced to death. It was the largest mass execution for rape that had been reported in the United States. On August 31, 2021, the Governor of Virginia pardoned the convictions of all seven men, 70 years after their deaths.

Barry Allan Beach is an American who was sentenced to 100 years in prison without parole in 1984 for the 1979 murder of Kimberly Nees in Poplar, Montana. During the years following his conviction, Beach gained support from influential state and national advocates who said his murder confession, the lynchpin of his conviction, was coerced. In 2015, his sentence was commuted to time served, plus ten years on probation.

Johnny Lee Wilson case refers to the murder of seventy-nine-year-old Pauline Martz of Aurora, Missouri in 1986 that resulted in the wrongful imprisonment of a twenty-year-old man named Johnny Lee Wilson. He had confessed to the murder days after it occurred. As a result of a guilty plea, Wilson did not receive a trial by a jury, and was sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole in 1987. He was incarcerated from 1986 to 1995.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Wooten, James (September 20, 1975). "'It's over' for 2 wrongly held 12 years". New York Times.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 "Nightmare Ends for 2 Wrongly Accused". Miami Herald. May 1, 1998.
  3. ↑ "Pitts and Lee : justice delayed again?". Saint Petersburg Times. May 9, 1990. Retrieved April 27, 2013.
  4. ↑ Oricchio, Michael (September 19, 1985). "Ten Years Later, Freed Men Locked In Personal Prison". Miami Herald.
  5. ↑ Lee v. State,166So.2d131(Fla.1964).
  6. ↑ Lee v. State,188So.2d872(Fla. 1st Dist. App.1966).
  7. 1 2 State v. Pitts,241So.2d399(Fla. 1st Dist. App.1970).
  8. ↑ Miller, Gene (1975). Invitation to a Lynching. Doubleday.
  9. ↑ "The Pulitzer Prizes | Awards". Pulitzer Prize.
  10. ↑ Pitts v. State,307So.2d473(Fla. 1st Dist. App.1975).
  11. ↑ In re Baker,267So.2d331(Fla.1972).
  12. ↑ In Florida, it is not the Governor's Cabinet. The Cabinet consists of independently-elected statewide officers, and the Governor is not a member of the Cabinet. See Tom Raum, "Governor Askew Insists He's Not a Cabinet Member," Tallahassee Democrat, July 8, 1971. Under the Florida Constitution at that time, no pardon was effective unless signed by the Governor and at least three members of the Cabinet. See Fla. Const. art. IV, s. 8 (as in effect at the time).
  13. ↑ "From death row to hero of system". Saint Petersburg Times. December 29, 1987. Retrieved April 25, 2013.
  14. 1 2 Morgan, Lucy (March 5, 1998). "Blacks may test new GOP alliance". Saint Petersburg Times.
  15. 1 2 Morgan, Lucy (April 29, 1998). "With emotion, Pitts - Lee bill moves forward". Saint Petersburg Times.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.