Political positions of Libertas

Last updated

The political positions of Libertas were the political positions of members or affiliates of Libertas, the umbrella title given to a constellation of organizations associated with Declan Ganley. Candidates and parties underneath its pan-European arm, Libertas.eu contended the 2009 European Parliament elections.

Contents

Preamble

Libertas is a political party founded by Declan Ganley that took part in the 2009 European Parliament election in several member states of the European Union. For the purposes of contending those elections, Libertas candidates ran under lists (the lists of candidates presented to voters in a European election) branded with the Libertas identity, as exemplified by the French approach. [1] [2] Each list was made up of some combination of the following:

Their political positions were as follows:

EUProfiler

The EUProfiler was produced by a consortium of three institutions (Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies, Kieskompas and the University of Zurich) [4] analysing parties taking part in the 2009 elections. Some of those parties were Libertas. A summary of their analyses is given below.

Hix-Lord diagram

Six Libertas party positions at 29 May 2009 (see description for sources). Hix-Lord model Libertas May 29 2009.PNG
Six Libertas party positions at 29 May 2009 (see description for sources).

The EUProfiler gave the positions of political parties on the left-right and Eurosceptic spectra. Six of those parties were Libertas parties. They were as follows:

Those positions are summarized on the Hix-Lord diagram (a type of political compass) on the right. The Eurosceptic parties are towards the bottom, Europhile parties towards the top, the left-wing parties are towards the left, and right-wing parties towards the right.

Profile

The EUProfiler also collated party statements into their positions on distinct questions. A summary of those collations for the six Libertas parties analysed is as follows:

CategoryQuestionLICPNTMPFLPMPTC
Finances and taxesThe EU should acquire its own tax raising powersCompletely disagreeTend to disagreeCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeTend to disagreeCompletely disagree
Economy and workThe EU should drastically reduce its subsidies to Europe's farmersTend to disagreeCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeTend to agree
European integrationThe European Union should be enlarged to include TurkeyCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeNo opinionNo opinion
Society, religion and cultureEuthanasia should be legalisedCompletely disagreeNo opinionCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeTend to agree
European integrationIndividual member states of the EU should have less veto powerCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeNo opinionTend to agree
Society, religion and cultureThe legalisation of same sex marriages is a good thingCompletely disagreeNo opinionCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeNo opinionTend to agree
Welfare, family and healthGreater efforts should be made to privatise healthcare services in your member stateNo opinionTend to disagreeNo opinionNeutralTend to disagreeCompletely disagree
Migration and immigrationImmigration policies oriented towards skilled workers should be encouraged as a means of fostering economic growthTend to disagreeNo opinionCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeNeutralTend to agree
Foreign policyOn foreign policy issues, such as the relationship with Russia, the EU should speak with one voiceNeutralNo opinionCompletely disagreeTend to disagreeTend to disagreeNo opinion
Society, religion and cultureThe decriminalisation of the personal use of soft drugs is to be welcomedNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeTend to agree
Finances and taxesGovernments should bail out failing banks with public moneyNo opinionTend to disagreeCompletely agreeCompletely disagreeNo opinionTend to disagree
European integrationEuropean integration is a good thingTend to agreeCompletely disagreeCompletely disagreeNeutralNo opinionTend to agree
Environment, transport and energyThe promotion of public transport should be fostered through green taxes (e.g. road taxing)No opinionCompletely disagreeNo opinionNo opinionTend to agreeNeutral
Law and orderRestrictions of civil liberties should be accepted in the fight against terrorismNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionTend to disagree
Foreign policyThe European Union should strengthen its security and defence policyNo opinionNo opinionNeutralNo opinionTend to disagreeNo opinion
Finances and taxesGovernment spending should be reduced in order to lower taxesNo opinionNo opinionCompletely agreeNo opinionTend to disagreeTend to disagree
Economy and workGovernments should reduce workers' protection regulations in order to fight unemploymentNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNo opinionNeutral
Environment, transport and energyPolicies to fight global warming should be encouraged even if it hampers economic growth or employmentNo opinionTend to agreeNo opinionCompletely disagreeTend to agreeNeutral
Environment, transport and energyRenewable sources of energy (e.g. solar or wind energy) should be supported even if this means higher energy costsNo opinionTend to disagreeTend to agreeCompletely disagreeCompletely agreeTend to agree
European integrationYour member state is much better off in the EU than outside itTend to agreeTend to agreeCompletely disagreeTend to disagreeNo opinionCompletely agree
Welfare, family and healthSocial programmes should be maintained even at the cost of higher taxesNo opinionTend to agreeCompletely disagreeNeutralCompletely agreeTend to agree
Society, religion and cultureReligious values and principles should be shown greater respect in politicsCompletely agreeTend to disagreeTend to agreeCompletely agreeNo opinionCompletely disagree
European integrationThe European Parliament should be given more powersTend to agreeCompletely agreeNo opinionTend to agreeTend to disagreeNeutral
Law and orderCriminals should be punished more severelyNo opinionNeutralCompletely agreeCompletely agreeNo opinionTend to agree
Migration and immigrationImmigrants from outside Europe should be required to accept our culture and valuesTend to agreeNo opinionCompletely agreeCompletely agreeNo opinionTend to agree
Welfare, family and healthState subsidies for crèches and child care should be increased substantiallyNo opinionCompletely agreeTend to agreeCompletely agreeTend to agreeCompletely agree
Migration and immigrationImmigration into your member state should be made more restrictiveCompletely agreeCompletely agreeCompletely agreeTend to agreeNeutralTend to agree
European integrationAny new European Treaty should be subject to approval in a referendum in your member stateCompletely agreeCompletely agreeCompletely agreeCompletely agreeCompletely agreeCompletely agree
Sources

CPDS

The University of Bern Institute for Political Science (Universität Bern, Institut für Politikwissenschaft) maintains comparative political datasets CPDS I,II and III classifying political parties from the OECD and EU into distinct political families. Two of those parties were Libertas parties. The CPDS characterized those parties as follows:

Libertas member/affiliatePolitical familySources
League of Polish Families Religious [ permanent dead link ]
Komma Fileftheron Liberal [ permanent dead link ]

Human rights monitors

The Anti-Defamation League, United Nations, and Council of Europe monitor parties for use of racist, xenophobic and/or anti-Semitic discourse. Two of those parties were Libertas parties. They are as follows:

Libertas member/affiliateSources
League of Polish Families [ permanent dead link ]
Mouvement pour la France [ permanent dead link ]

Left-right positions

The Oscarsson and Dahlberg paper "Mapping the European Party Space: Does Party System Simplicity produce Democratic Legitimacy?" [ permanent dead link ] characterized parties on the left-right spectrum. Three of those parties were Libertas parties. Oscarsson and Dahlberg characterized those parties as follows (data from 2004):

Libertas member/affiliateScore (0=extreme left, 10=extreme right)Sources
League of Polish Families 7.25 [ permanent dead link ]
Komma Fileftheron 6.27 [ permanent dead link ]
Mouvement pour la France 6.27 [ permanent dead link ]

Notes

  1. "Libertas Poland" here refers to the party of that name in Poland, not to the Libertas list of the same name, a coalition of Libertas Poland with NP, PSL Piast, PR, LPF candidates

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Euroscepticism</span> Body of criticism of the European Union

Euroscepticism, also spelled as Euroskepticism or EU-scepticism, is a political position involving criticism of the European Union (EU) and European integration. It ranges from those who oppose some EU institutions and policies, and seek reform, to those who oppose EU membership and see the EU as unreformable. The opposite of Euroscepticism is known as pro-Europeanism, or European Unionism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rurality Movement</span> Agrarianist political party in France

The Rurality Movement, formerly Hunting, Fishing, Nature and Traditions is an agrarianist political party in France that aims to defend the traditional values of rural France. Its leader is Eddie Puyjalon. The party states it is neither right nor left but represents rural people on the whole in their diversity.

The Movement for France was a conservative Eurosceptic French political party, founded on 20 November 1994, with a marked regional stronghold in the Vendée. It was led by Philippe de Villiers, once communications minister under Jacques Chirac.

Daniel Mirosław Pawłowiec is a Polish politician and journalist. He was a deputy in the Sejm V term and was a deputy minister in the government of Jaroslaw Kaczynski.

Declan James Ganley is an English-born Irish entrepreneur, businessman, and political activist. He was the founder and leader of the Irish branch of the eurosceptic Libertas Party.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">European political foundation</span> Type of political foundation operating on a pan-European level

A European political foundation, formally a political foundation at European level, informally a Eurofoundation, is a research and advocacy organization close to, but independent from a Europarty. They are funded by the European Parliament. Their purpose is to act as platforms aiming at developing forward-looking ideas and concepts for their respective political family and providing a forum where those ideas can be widely debated. There are nine Eurofoundations as of 16 March 2009.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Svobodní</span> Political party in the Czech Republic

Svobodní is a classical liberal and right-libertarian, Eurosceptic political party in the Czech Republic founded in 2009 by Petr Mach, an economist and professor of macroeconomics. Before assuming his position as an MEP, Mach taught economics at VŠFS and VŠEM. The party is led by Libor Vondráček.

Libertas was a pan-European political party founded by Declan Ganley that took part in the 2009 European Parliament election in several member states of the European Union. It won one seat in France.

Polish Social Movement Forward, more usually rendered as Forward Poland was a national-conservative and Eurosceptic political party in Poland. It contended the 2009 European Parliament elections under a common banner with Polish People's Party "Piast". It was formed mainly by former members of the League of Polish Families (LPR), including its leader Janusz Dobrosz.

Libertas Poland was a political party in Poland. It contended the 2009 European Parliament elections under a common banner with Libertas Party Limited, the organization founded by Declan Ganley.

Libertas France is the name given to the activities of Declan Ganley's Libertas Party in France. Unlike Libertas in other countries, Libertas France was not a political party in its own right. Instead, candidates from Mouvement pour la France (MPF) and Chasse, Pêche, Nature et Traditions (CPNT) contended the 2009 European Parliament elections in France under common lists branded with the Libertas identity. The candidates retained their membership of their national parties and the national parties retained their legal identity.

Libertas UK may refer to three political parties in the United Kingdom: two are regional affiliates of Declan Ganley's Libertas Party Limited, one of which, Pro-Democracy: Libertas.eu, contended the 2009 European Parliament elections under a common banner with Libertas Party Limited. The third was formed by an associate of the United Kingdom Independence Party (UKIP).

Libertas Sweden is a political party in Sweden. It intended to contend the 2009 European Parliament elections under a common banner with Declan Ganley's Libertas.eu.

Libertas Ireland was a minor, Eurosceptic political party in Ireland. It contended the 2009 European Parliament elections in Ireland under a common banner with Declan Ganley's Libertas.eu. It shared a headquarters with Libertas.eu but was a national party in its own right for the purposes of Irish electoral law.

Libertas.cz is a eurosceptic party in the Czech Republic that was founded in 2009 by the former media entrepreneur and MEP Vladimír Železný. After some controversies it became an associate of Declan Ganley's pan-European alliance Libertas.eu.

Libertas Malta was a political party in Malta set up to contest the 2009 European Parliament elections under a common banner with Libertas.eu. Its only candidate Mary Gauci failed to be elected and the party has been inactive since.

Libertas Netherlands is a political party in the Netherlands. It contended the 2009 European Parliament elections under a common banner with Libertas Party Limited, the organization founded by Declan Ganley.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Responsibility – Social Democratic Alliance of Political Parties</span> Latvian political party

Responsibility – Social Democratic Alliance of Political Parties was a political coalition in Latvia, until 2010 called Libertas.lv, which was the local branch of Declan Ganley's Libertas Party. Unlike Libertas in other countries, Libertas Latvia was not a political party in its own right. Instead, candidates from Mūsu Zeme, Sociālā Taisnīguma Partija and Latvijas Atmoda contended the 2009 European Parliament elections in Latvia under common lists branded with the Libertas identity. The candidates retained their membership of their national parties and the national parties retained their legal identity.

Libertas Spain is the name given to the activities of Declan Ganley's Libertas.eu in Spain. Unlike Libertas in other countries, Libertas Spain was not a political party in its own right. Instead, candidates with no national party affiliation and candidates from Citizens – Party of the Citizenry, Partido Social Demócrata and Unión del Pueblo Salmantino contended the 2009 European Parliament elections in Spain under a common list branded with the Libertas identity. The candidates retained their membership of their national parties and the national parties retained their legal identity.

References

  1. "Européennes : Frédéric Nihous et Philippe de Villiers feront campagne commune" Archived 2009-06-13 at the Wayback Machine , La Tribune, March 4, 2009, English translation here Archived 2017-05-11 at the Wayback Machine
  2. "Villiers et Nihous pour un «protectionnisme européen»" Archived 2009-04-03 at the Wayback Machine , Le Figaro Archived 2004-11-09 at the Wayback Machine , 9 March 2009
  3. "Hjälp Libertas bli ett registrerat parti" Archived 2009-02-27 at the Wayback Machine Thursday, 26 February 2009 from the Libertas website Archived June 4, 2009, at the Wayback Machine
  4. "EUProfiler:FAQ". Archived from the original on 2009-06-26. Retrieved 2009-06-03.