The proposed merger of Korean Air and Asiana Airlines is a policy announced by the Government of South Korea in November 2020, which would result in Korean Air absorbing Asiana Airlines creating a dominant carrier in South Korea. [1]
The merger is now viewed as increasingly unlikely given the regulatory headwinds. [2]
For the merger to proceed, antitrust approval is necessary from competition authorities in key markets for the carriers. Out of the six essential markets, approval has been granted in all except one. As of February 2024, authorities in one essential market, which is the United States, have yet to approve the merger. [3]
In February 2023, it was confirmed that the merger would not proceed without approval from authorities in the European Union and the United States. At the time, the Korean government did not view approval in the EU and US as likely. Backup plans such as an equity investment from foreign backers (with the UAE-based Mubadala Investment Company suggested) into Asiana to help it remain viable are being explored. [4]
In May 2023, it was reported that the United States Department of Justice is considering filing suit to block the merger as anticompetitive. [5]
In August 2023, the Korea Economic Daily reported that the Korean Development Bank was seeking a plan B in preparation for the proposed merger's collapse. [6] This was due to a rising belief that American and European authorities would block the consolidation. On September 27, 2023, Yonhap reported that Korean Air had submitted an amended application to the European Commission, proposing divestment of Asiana's cargo division and giving up slots at some EU airports, including Barcelona, Rome, Paris, and Frankfurt to satisfy competition concerns. [7] [8]
On November 16, 2020, South Korea's Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport announced Korean Air's proposed acquisition the Asiana Airlines. [9] The merger plan was approved by Korean Air's board on the same date. [10] [11]
Korea Development Bank, a state-owned bank, agreed to provide 800 billion won (655.73 million USD) to Hanjin Group to help finance the merger between the airlines. [1]
Korean Air is currently a member of SkyTeam while Asiana is a Star Alliance member. If the merger is approved and completed, the combined airline will become a member of SkyTeam. [12] If the merger proceeds, South Korea's Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport intends to integrate the carriers' low-cost carrier subsidiaries (Air Busan, Air Seoul, and Jin Air) into a combined low-cost carrier which will focus on regional airports in Korea. [13]
Specifics of the merger if approved would include the following: [14] [15]
Korean Air Chairman/CEO Walter Cho and President Woo Kee-hong confirmed that the company plans to fold Asiana Club into Korean Air's SKYPASS at a later date. [17] [18]
In March 2021, Korean Air announced that its merger with Asiana Airlines would be delayed pending approval from relevant competition authorities. For the time being, Asiana Airlines would be operated as a subsidiary with its operations, IT, and other systems run by Korean Air until 2024. [19] [20]
On June 30, 2021, it was reported that the post-merger plans between the two airlines were finalized and approved by the Korea Development Bank pending regulatory approval. [21] [22] [23]
For the merger to proceed, the impact on competition must be evaluated and approved by competition authorities in six key markets for the carriers. These markets were deemed "essential" requiring approval for the merger to be viable.
The consolidation has been denied approval by the Department of Justice in the United States, an essential market for the carrier, pending submission and review of further remedies from the carrier. [24] The merger has been approved by South Korea's competition authority as well as China, Japan, the European Union, and the United Kingdom.
Country | Status | Notes |
---|---|---|
China | Approved | Approved by Ministry of Commerce on December 26, 2022. [25] |
European Union | Approved | Formal objection filed by the European Commission to proposed merger. [26] Amend application submitted on November 2, 2023 and received on November 3. [27] Conditionally approved by the European Commission on February 13, 2024. [28] |
Japan | Approved | Approved by Fair Trade Commission on January 31, 2024. [29] [30] |
South Korea | Approved | Approved by Fair Trade Commission in conditional approval on December 26, 2023. [31] |
United Kingdom | Approved | Approved by Competition and Markets Authority on May 1, 2023. [32] [33] |
United States | Blocked | Blocked by Department of Justice for monopoly concerns May 22, 2023. [34] |
On December 26, 2022, the Ministry of Commerce of China announced its approval of Korean Air’s merger with Asiana Airlines. [35]
On March 17, 2023, the European Commission (EC) released the results of an in-depth investigation concluding that the merger would restrict competition with a concentration of market power between Europe and Korea. [36] Specifically, the Commission cited reduced competition on passenger routes between South Korea and France, Germany, Italy, and Spain and reduced competition for air cargo between all of Europe and South Korea. [37] The Commission suspended its investigation into the merger in June 2023 due to the companies' failure to provide proposed corrective remedies before the Commission's deadline. [37]
In October 2023, Korean Air announced proposed remedies to address the Commission's concerns by divesting routes to Barcelona, Frankfurt, Paris, and Rome and surrendering them (alongside slots at the relevant airports) to T'way Air, a South Korean low-cost carrier, while leasing Airbus A330 aircraft with flight crew. [38] Korean Air would also sell Asiana Airlines' cargo division, with the Asiana board giving its approval to the plan in November 2023. [39] [40] [41]
Korean Air resubmitted its application to the European Commission with these concessions for evaluation on November 2, 2023. [42] However, Yonhap has reported that the Commission has not resumed its investigation due to "missing information" in the submission provided by Korean Air and Asiana. [37]
In January 2024, Reuters reported that the European Commission is expected to approve the merger following concessions offered by the airlines. [43] In February 2024, Korean Air secured conditional Commission approval for the consolidation of South Korea's aviation market contingent on an acceptable buyer being identified for its cargo business and making assets available to T'way Air to start service on routes to Barcelona, Frankfurt, Paris, and Rome. [44]
In November 2023, Japan officially moved to block the merger, citing the combined power the merged carrier would have on air traffic between Japan and South Korea where it would represent nearly 70% of flying. The objection also cited the planned merger of the two airlines' three low-cost carrier subsidiaries. [45]
Japan approved the merger on January 31, 2024. [46] As part of the agreement, the consolidated carrier has agreed to surrender slots on 7 routes if remedy takers choose to operate on them, the routes being Seoul–Incheon to Fukuoka, Nagoya, Osaka–Kansai, and Sapporo, as well as the Busan to Osaka, Sapporo, and Fukuoka to competitors. [47]
The Fair Trade Commission (FTC) approved the merger on February 22, 2022 with conditional clearance requiring the combined airline to give up some of their airport slots and transportation rights in certain regions. [48] [49] [50] The Commission assessed that the merger would result in a monopoly on 26 international routes and 14 domestic routes but deferred to overseas authorities to on corrective action by granting 10 year conditional clearance with the following conditions: [51] [52] [53]
The UK's Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) postponed the review of the merger in November 2022, citing monopoly concerns, giving Korean Air time to propose a plan to resolve competition concerns. [54] Korean Air proposed transferring slots for seven weekly operation rights to Virgin Atlantic to launch a London–Heathrow to Seoul–Incheon route as a remedy. [55]
The United Kingdom officially approved the merger on March 1, 2023. [32] [33]
In May 2023, it was reported that the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) is considering filing suit to block the merger as anticompetitive. [5] [56]
To gain approval for the merger, Korean Air proposed transferring several operations to Air Premia. The transfer would include aircraft and flight crews. [57] The DOJ has rejected this proposal. [58]
In addition to essential countries, the companies sought review of the merger by authorities in countries considered to be "non-essential" markets.
In June 2021, the Philippines was the first "non-essential country" to approve the merger. [59] Singapore, Malaysia, Turkey, Vietnam, Taiwan, Thailand, and Australia have also officially approved the merger. [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65]
In October 2023, labour unions representing workers at Asiana Airlines protested the merger claiming that the ultimate goal of the deal is "the dismantling of Asiana Airlines" and that the merger "is not in the interest of the nation or the convenience of the people". [66]
In the United States, an analyst described the merger as a "tie-up between the largest U.S. carrier to South Korea (Delta Air Lines) and the two large South Korean airlines" virtually eliminating competition between the United States and Korea. [67]
Incheon International Airport is the main international airport serving Seoul, the capital of South Korea. It is also one of the largest and busiest airports in the world.
Star Alliance is the world's first global airline alliance. Founded on 14 May 1997, it is headquartered on the grounds of Frankfurt Airport in Frankfurt, Germany, with a subsidiary management company in Singapore. Star Alliance is also the world's largest airline alliance by market share as of April 2024, with 17.4% of the market share, compared to 13.7% of SkyTeam and 11.9% of Oneworld.
Korean Air Lines Co., Ltd., operating as Korean Air, is the flag carrier of South Korea and its largest airline based on fleet size, international destinations, and international flights. It is owned by the Hanjin Group.
Asiana Airlines Inc. is a South Korean airline headquartered in Seoul. In 2019, it accounted for 25% of South Korea's international aviation market and 20% of its domestic market. It maintains its international hub at Incheon International Airport in Seoul and Gimhae International Airport in Busan, and its domestic hub at Gimpo International Airport in Seoul. It is a full-service airline and a member of Star Alliance.
SkyTeam is one of the world's three major airline alliances. Founded in June 2000, SkyTeam was the last of the three alliances to be formed, the first two being Star Alliance and Oneworld, respectively. Its annual passenger count is 437 million customers (2023), the second largest of the three major alliances. As of January 2024, SkyTeam consists of 19 active carriers from five continents and operates with the slogan "Caring more about you". It also operates a cargo alliance named SkyTeam Cargo, which partners ten carriers, all of them SkyTeam members. Its centralised management team, SkyTeam Central, is based in Amstelveen, Netherlands.
Air Europa Líneas Aéreas, S.A.U., branded as Air Europa, is the third-largest Spanish airline after Iberia and Vueling. The airline is headquartered in Llucmajor, Mallorca, Spain; it has its main hub at Adolfo Suárez Madrid–Barajas Airport with focus city operations at Palma de Mallorca Airport and Tenerife North Airport. Air Europa flies to over 44 destinations in Spain, the rest of Europe, South America, North America, the Caribbean, Morocco and Tunisia. Since September 2007, Air Europa has been member of the SkyTeam alliance.
Aegean Airlines S.A. is the flag carrier of Greece and the largest Greek airline by total number of passengers carried, by number of destinations served, and by fleet size. A Star Alliance member since June 2010, it operates scheduled and charter services from Athens and Thessaloniki to other major Greek, European and Middle Eastern destinations. Its main hubs are Athens International Airport in Athens, Macedonia International Airport in Thessaloniki and Larnaca International Airport in Cyprus. It also uses other Greek airports as bases, some of which are seasonal. It has its head office in Kifisia, a suburb of Athens.
Air Astana is an airline group and the flag carrier of Kazakhstan. Based in Almaty, Kazakhstan, the airline, previously jointly owned by the Government of Kazakhstan’s sovereign wealth fund Samruk Kazyna (51%) and BAE Systems PLC (49%), has since February 2024 been publicly listed on the London, Astana, and Almaty Stock Exchanges. It is the largest airline in Central Asia and the Caucasus region with 69% and 40% of market share on domestic and intra-regional routes from Kazakhstan.
Jeju International Airport is the second-largest airport in South Korea, just behind Incheon Airport in Incheon. It is located in the city of Jeju. The airport opened in 1968.
Eastar Jet is a South Korean low-cost airline with its headquarters in Banghwa-dong, Gangseo-gu, Seoul. On January 7, 2009, Eastar Jet made its maiden flight from Gimpo International Airport to Jeju International Airport. Now, the airline operates a scheduled passenger network to 14 destinations in eight countries. Its main base is Gimpo International Airport, with a hub at Jeju International Airport.
Olympic Air S.A. is a regional airline, a subsidiary of the Greek carrier Aegean Airlines. It was formed as part of the privatization of the former Greek national carrier Olympic Airlines, a company that carried the name Olympic Airways from 1957 to the beginning of the 21st century. Olympic Air commenced limited operations on 29 September 2009, after Olympic Airlines ceased all operations, the full-scale opening of the company taking place two days later on 1 October 2009. Its main hubs are Thessaloniki International Airport and Athens International Airport. Rhodes International Airport serves as a small secondary hub. The airline's headquarters are in Building 57 at Athens International Airport in Spata, and its registered seat is in Koropi, Kropia, East Attica.
International Consolidated Airlines Group S.A., trading as International Airlines Group and usually shortened to IAG, is an English-Spanish multinational airline holding company with its registered office in Madrid, Spain, and its corporate headquarters in London, England. It was formed in January 2011 after a merger agreement between British Airways and Iberia, the flag carriers of the United Kingdom and Spain respectively, when British Airways and Iberia became wholly owned subsidiaries of IAG. British Airways shareholders were given 55% of the shares in the new company.
Fast Colombia S.A.S., trading as Viva Air Colombia and formerly VivaColombia, was a Colombian ultra low-cost airline based in Rionegro, Antioquia, Colombia. It was a subsidiary of Irelandia Aviation and, as of its bankruptcy in March 2023, the third largest airline in the country. The company was not legally affiliated with Mexico's Viva Aerobus, another low-cost carrier co-founded by Irelandia which also uses the "Viva" brand, although they did have a codeshare agreement for their flights. The company filed for insolvency in February 2023, and on February 27, 2023, the airline suspended, and eventually ceased, all operations, citing rising fuel prices and Aerocivil's failure to approve its planned acquisition by Avianca.
AIX Connect, formerly known as AirAsia India, is an Indian low-cost airline headquartered in Bangalore (Bengaluru), Karnataka and a wholly-owned subsidiary of Air India Limited which in turn is owned by Tata Group. The airline was founded as a joint venture between Tata Sons and AirAsia Bhd and commenced operations in June 2014 with Bangalore as its primary operating base. From 2020 to 2022, AirAsia Bhd gradually disinvested its shares in the joint venture and sold them to Tata Sons. In December 2022, after the entire shares of AirAsia India was acquired by Tata Sons, the airline was renamed AIX Connect ahead of its merger with Air India Express.
Air Seoul (Korean: 에어서울) is a South Korean low-cost carrier and a subsidiary of Asiana Airlines. The airline is based at Incheon International Airport just outside of Seoul, from which it operates flights to international destinations. It launched operations on 11 July 2016.
IST Entertainment (Korean: 아이에스티엔터테인먼트) is a South Korean entertainment company under Kakao Entertainment.
Air Premia, Inc. is a South Korean airline based in Seoul. It describes itself as a "hybrid airline", providing a higher level of service than low-cost airlines while having lower operating costs than larger, full-service airlines. The airline was founded in 2017 by the former president of Jeju Air, Kim Jong-chul.
Vistara-Air India merger is a merger of Vistara, a 51:49 percent joint venture between Tata Sons and Air India and, an Indian Government operated airlines for 69 years. Both the airlines possess majority in market share among the direct flights operating between the International and domestic markets on the routes operating between Singapore and Indian cities of New Delhi, Mumbai,Chennai and Tiruchirapalli. The deal makes Air India, as India's top International carrier and second after Indigo for domestic operations.
{{cite web}}
: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link){{cite web}}
: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)