State v. Yanz

Last updated

State v. Yanz
Court Connecticut Supreme Court of Errors
Full case nameThe State of Connecticut v. George Yanz
DecidedSeptember 27, 1901 (1901-09-27)
Citation(s)74 Conn. 177; 50 A. 37; 1901 Conn. LEXIS 91
Court membership
Judges sitting Andrews, Torrance, Baldwin, Hamersley, Hall
Case opinions
Decision byBaldwin
ConcurrenceTorrance and Hall
DissentAndrews and Hamersley

State v. Yanz, 50 A. 37 (Conn. 1901), was a case decided by the Supreme Court of Connecticut (then called the Connecticut Supreme Court of Errors) that held that a provocation defense that reduced a murder charge to one of manslaughter is still valid even in the presence of a reasonable mistake of fact. [1] Specifically, in the case where a man reasonably believed his wife was committing adultery and kills her alleged paramour, even where that belief was mistaken, the provocation would be enough to reduce the charge from murder to manslaughter. [2]

Contents

Facts and procedural background

George Yanz, an employee at the Winchester Repeating Arms factory, left work early on June 20, 1900 after noticing his co-worker, machinist George H. Goering had left early. Yanz suspected that Goering was having an affair with Yanz's wife Kitty, and went to his home in the Highwood neighborhood of Hamden, Connecticut. [3] [4] Yanz, discovering his wife and Goering "in a compromising position", [5] took his Winchester rifle and shot Goering in the head, killing him. [6] Yanz surrendered himself to police the same afternoon. [3]

Yanz was arraigned June 22, and held without bail. [7] He initially claimed that he did not realize the person he was shooting was Goering, and that he initially believed he was protecting his wife against a rapist. Public opinion at the time was that he was claiming this to defend his wife's reputation. [5] Yanz was indicted for murder by the grand jury, and his case was deferred to October. [8] The trial began the second week of October, [9] with closing arguments held the morning of October 17. [10] That afternoon, the jury found Yanz guilty of second degree murder after two hours of deliberation, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment. [11]

At least one contemporary report noted that public opinion was on Yanz's side in his motion for a new trial. [12]

Appeal and aftermath

In a 3-2 decision, the Supreme Court of Errors overturned the conviction, ordering a new trial. The majority opinion, authored by Justice Baldwin and joined by Justices Torrance and Hall, held that there was error in the jury instructions that led to an improper conviction. The basis for this decision rested upon four factors. First, Connecticut's statute defining murder in the second degree required "implied malice". Second, the court applied State v. Johnson, 41 Conn. 584 (1874), holding that malice cannot be implied where "the fatal act was the sudden result of what the law deems either a sufficient provocation or an uncontrollable passion naturally excited by the circumstances of the occasion". Third, the court held that Yanz's discovery of his wife with a paramour would have amounted to such sufficient provocation. Finally, even if Yanz had believed Goering was his wife's paramour, but been reasonably mistaken in that belief, the charge of second degree murder would still be reduced to manslaughter. [13]

Justice Hamersley dissented from the majority, and was joined by Chief Justice Andrews. The main point of disagreement was on the effect of a reasonable mistake on a defendant's part as to whether the act he witnessed was in fact adultery: The dissent argued that in the presence of a reasonable mistake, the crime would still be murder. [14]

After his conviction was vacated and a new trial ordered, Yanz entered a plea of guilty to manslaughter on October 16, 1901. He was sentenced to five years in prison. [15]

Related Research Articles

The gay panic defense or homosexual advance defence is a strategy of legal defense, which refers to a situation in which a heterosexual individual charged with a violent crime against a homosexual individual claims they lost control and reacted violently because of an unwanted sexual advance that was made upon them. A defendant will use available legal defenses against assault and murder, with the aim of seeking an acquittal, a mitigated sentence, or a conviction of a lesser offense. A defendant may allege to have found the same-sex sexual advances so offensive or frightening that they were provoked into reacting, were acting in self-defense, were of diminished capacity, or were temporarily insane, and that this circumstance is exculpatory or mitigating.

In law, provocation is when a person is considered to have committed a criminal act partly because of a preceding set of events that might cause a reasonable individual to lose self control. This makes them less morally culpable than if the act was premeditated (pre-planned) and done out of pure malice. It "affects the quality of the actor's state of mind as an indicator of moral blameworthiness."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ella Grasso</span> American politician (1919–1981)

Ella Rosa Giovianna Oliva Grasso was an American politician and member of the Democratic Party who served as the 83rd Governor of Connecticut from January 8, 1975, to December 31, 1980, after rejecting past offers of candidacies for Senate and Governor. She was the first woman elected to this office and the first woman to be elected governor of a U.S. state without having been the spouse or widow of a former governor. She resigned as governor due to her battle with ovarian cancer.

<i>Connecticut Post</i> Newspaper in Bridgeport, Connecticut

The Connecticut Post is a daily newspaper located in Bridgeport, Connecticut. It serves Fairfield County and the Lower Naugatuck Valley. Municipalities in the Post's circulation area include Ansonia, Bridgeport, Darien, Derby, Easton, Fairfield, Milford, Monroe, New Canaan, Orange, Oxford, Redding, Ridgefield, Seymour, Shelton, Stratford, Trumbull, Weston, Westport and Wilton. The newspaper is owned and operated by the Hearst Corporation, a multinational corporate media conglomerate with $4 billion in revenues. The Connecticut Post also gains revenue by offering classified advertising for job hunters with minimal regulations and separate listings for products and services.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nick Pietrosante</span> American football player (1937–1988)

Nicholas Vincent Pietrosante was an American professional football fullback who played in the National Football League (NFL) for the Detroit Lions and the Cleveland Browns. He was the NFL Rookie of the Year in 1959, and a Pro Bowler in 1960 and 1961. Between 1959 and 1965, he set a Lions franchise record with 3,933 rushing yards. He played college football for Notre Dame and was named third-team All-American in 1958.

On 14 October 2004, Pádraig Nally, an Irish farmer living in County Mayo, Republic of Ireland shot dead Irish Traveller John "Frog" Ward, who had been trespassing on his property. In November 2005 Nally was sentenced to six years' imprisonment for manslaughter. His conviction was quashed in October 2006 and, after a retrial in December 2006, he was found not guilty of manslaughter.

The Connecticut Open is the Connecticut state open golf tournament, open to both amateur and professional golfers. It is organized by the Connecticut State Golf Association. It has been played annually since 1931 at a variety of courses around the state. It was considered a PGA Tour event in the 1930s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">J. Michael Farren</span>

John Michael Farren is a former American lawyer who served as Deputy White House Counsel in the Office of Counsel to the President under the 43rd President of the United States George W. Bush from 2007 to 2009. Farren also served as Under Secretary of Commerce for International Trade at the United States Department of Commerce and head of the International Trade Administration under the 41st President of the United States George H. W. Bush from 1989 to 1992. He is currently serving a 15-year jail sentence for the attempted murder of his then-wife.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tacks Latimer</span> American baseball player (1875–1936)

Clifford Wesley "Tacks" Latimer was an American professional baseball catcher who played in Major League Baseball for the New York Giants, Louisville Colonels, Pittsburgh Pirates, Baltimore Orioles, and Brooklyn Superbas from 1898 to 1902. Including the years he played only in the minor leagues or as a semi-professional, Latimer's career ranged from 1895 to 1908.

Lorenzo W. (L.W.) Housel was a Connecticut state legislator who later ran for Congress and statewide office in Iowa. Running as a Democrat in an era in which Republicans dominated Iowa politics, Housel was unsuccessful in each of his Iowa races.

People v. Berry is a voluntary manslaughter case that is widely taught in American law schools for the appellate court's unusual interpretation of heat of passion doctrine. Although the defendant had time to "cool down" between his wife's verbal admission of infidelity and the killing, the California Supreme Court held that the provocation in this case was adequate to reduce a murder charge to manslaughter. The lower court had relied on the traditional definition of "adequate provocation" in its jury instructions. The California Supreme Court reversed Berry's murder conviction, while affirming Berry's conviction for assault using deadly force.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cheshire home invasion murders</span> 2007 triple-murder in Cheshire, Connecticut, US

On July 23, 2007, Linda Hayes and Joshua Komisarjevsky invaded the residence of the Petit family in Cheshire, Connecticut. Though initially planning only to rob the house, Hayes and Komisarjevsky murdered Jennifer Hawke-Petit and her two daughters, 17-year-old Hayley Petit and 11-year-old Michaela Petit. Their father, Dr. William Petit, escaped with severe injuries.

Manslaughter is a crime in the United States. Definitions can vary among jurisdictions, but manslaughter is invariably the act of causing the death of another person in a manner less culpable than murder. Three types of unlawful killings constitute manslaughter. First, there is voluntary manslaughter which is an intentional homicide committed in "sudden heat of passion" as the result of adequate provocation. Second, there is the form of involuntary manslaughter which is an unintentional homicide that was committed in a criminally negligent manner. Finally, there is the form of involuntary manslaughter which is an unintentional homicide that occurred during the commission or attempted commission of an unlawful act which does not amount to a felony.

The 1901 Army Cadets football team represented the United States Military Academy in the 1901 college football season. In their first and only season under head coach Leon Kromer, the Cadets compiled a 5–1–2 record, shut out four opponents, and outscored all opponents by a combined total of 98 to 22. The team's only loss was by a 6 to 0 score against an undefeated Harvard team that has been recognized as a co-national champion for the 1901 season. The Cadets also tied with Yale (5–5) and Princeton (6–6). In the annual Army–Navy Game, the Cadets defeated the Midshipmen by an 11 to 5 score.

Samuel Orcutt was an American historian and genealogist. He is the author of many books on Connecticut towns and family histories. Orcutt also wrote a history called The Indians of the Housatonic and Naugatuck Valleys.

The 1948 Connecticut Huskies football team represented the University of Connecticut in the 1948 college football season. The Huskies were led by 14th-year head coach J. Orlean Christian and completed the season with a record of 3–5.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dwight Weist</span> Radio actor and announcer (1910–1991)

Dwight Weist, Jr. was an actor and announcer in the era of old-time radio.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arthur Frederick Bettinson</span> Manager and promoter of the National Sporting Club

Arthur Frederick "Peggy" Bettinson was a skilled pugilist, becoming English Amateur Boxing Association Lightweight Champion in 1882. In 1891 Bettinson co-founded the National Sporting Club (NSC). As its manager, he implemented a strict code of conduct, rules and etiquette that was adhered to by both boxers and spectators, ushering in a culture change that brought respect and legitimacy to what had been a barely regulated, lawless and chaotic sport. He was one of boxing's most prominent and powerful advocates in England's courtrooms in an era when boxing's legal status was uncertain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John W. Brady</span> American lawyer (died 1943)

John W. Brady was an American lawyer. He served as a county attorney from 1902 to 1910, the assistant attorney general for the state, and a judge on the Texas Third Court of Civil Appeals. In 1929 he was convicted of murder, and sentenced to three years in prison.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Will P. Brady</span> American lawyer (1876–1943)

William Paul Brady was an American lawyer. From 1909 to around 1914, he served as the first district attorney for Texas' 70th judicial district, and from 1917 to 1919 he was the judge for the newly created El Paso County Court at Law. Brady prosecuted several high-profile murder cases as a district attorney, including of Agnes Orner, and in a death-penalty case that has since been termed a "legal lynching" of a Mexican boy charged with killing a white woman.

References

  1. ↑ Bonnie, R.J. et al. Criminal Law, Second Edition. Foundation Press, New York, NY: 2004, p. 816
  2. ↑ "Recent Decisions" . Columbia Law Review. 1 (8): 555. December 1901. Retrieved January 6, 2016– via HeinOnline.
  3. 1 2 "Shot by an Angry Husband". Naugatuck Daily News. Vol. 6, no. 58. June 21, 1900. p. 3. Retrieved January 6, 2016– via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
  4. ↑ "Husband Kills Man he Finds with Wife". Bridgeport Herald. Vol. 9, no. 508. June 24, 1900. p. 5. Retrieved January 7, 2016– via Google News. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
  5. 1 2 "Evidence for Yanz". Naugatuck Daily News. Vol. 6, no. 71. July 10, 1900. p. 2. Retrieved January 6, 2016– via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
  6. ↑ "Jealous Man Kills his Chum". Alexandria Gazette. Vol. 101, no. 147. June 22, 1900. p. 2. Retrieved January 6, 2016– via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
  7. ↑ "Yanz Held without Bail". Fitchburg Sentinel. Vol. 28, no. 41. June 23, 1900. p. 7. Retrieved January 6, 2016– via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
  8. ↑ "Yanz is very Cheerful". Naugatuck Daily News. Vol. 6, no. 129. September 26, 1900. p. 2. Retrieved January 6, 2016– via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
  9. ↑ "Murder in Second Degree". The Plain Speaker. Hazleton, Pennsylvania. October 18, 1900. p. 1. Retrieved January 6, 2016– via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
  10. ↑ "Yanz on Trial". Naugatuck Daily News. Vol. 6, no. 147. October 17, 1900. p. 2. Retrieved January 6, 2016– via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
  11. ↑ "Life Imprisonment for Yanz". Naugatuck Daily News. Vol. 6, no. 148. October 18, 1900. p. 2. Retrieved January 6, 2016– via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
  12. ↑ "Is Willing to Wait". Bridgeport Herald. Vol. 9, no. 537. January 20, 1901. p. 6. Retrieved January 7, 2016– via Google News. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
  13. ↑ State v. Yanz,50A.37, 38–39(Conn.1901).
  14. ↑ State v. Yanz,50A.37, 39–41(Conn.1901).
  15. ↑ "Five Years for Yanz". Naugatuck Daily News. Vol. 7, no. 139. October 16, 1901. p. 1. Retrieved January 6, 2016– via Newspapers.com. Open Access logo PLoS transparent.svg
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.