Stop the Church

Last updated
Stop the Church
Stop the Church.jpg
Activist carried out of St. Patrick's Cathedral during the Stop the Church action
DateDecember 10, 1989 (1989-12-10)
Location St. Patrick's Cathedral, New York, NY
Type Demonstration
Theme AIDS activism
Participants4,500 [1]

Stop the Church was a demonstration organized by members of AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power (ACT UP) on December 10, 1989, that disrupted a Mass being said by Cardinal John O'Connor at St. Patrick's Cathedral in New York City. One-hundred and eleven protesters were arrested, 53 of whom were arrested inside the church. The main objective of the demonstration was to protest O'Connor's opposition to the teaching of safe sex in the public school system, and his opposition to the distribution of condoms to curb the spread of AIDS. [2] During planning, the protest was joined by Women's Health Action and Mobilization (WHAM!), who opposed the Catholic position on abortion rights.

Contents

The protest was condemned in media editorials and by national figures such as President George H. W. Bush, and was controversial in the gay community. The protest, and especially the desecration of the Eucharist, made headline news in the US and several European countries. [3] The protest was a major effort for ACT-UP.

Background

ACT UP opposed the public position of the church on condom use and safe sex education to control the spread of AIDS, and identified pronouncements such as O'Connor's statement that "Good morality is good medicine" as harmful. [4] The protest was organized following a meeting of senior clergy where they had reinforced doctrine opposing the use of condoms. [4] ACT UP nicknamed the cleric "Cardinal O'Condom." [4] They also opposed the church's anti-abortion position. [5] In the 1980s, O'Connor wielded a great deal of power in both the church and in society at large. [6] WHAM! subsequently joined the protest, swelling its numbers and adding the issue of abortion rights. [4]

Protest

Stop the Church was held on December 10, 1989, at St. Patrick's Cathedral in New York City. [7] [8] [4] [8] [9] The idea had originated with ACT UP members Vincent Gagliostro and Victor Mendolia. [5] Cardinal John O'Connor was celebrating a Mass attended by Mayor Ed Koch and other political leaders. [7] Koch and the other dignitaries attended as a sign of support to O'Connor. [7]

The protesters had indicated in advance that they planned to protest. While pretending to be church ushers, some handed out flyers explaining why they would disrupt the service to those entering the catherdral. [4] [7] [9] The crowd outside grew to 4,500 people. [1] [10] [7] [9] [11] The demonstrators stood outside the cathedral shouting and raising placards that read "Eternal life to Cardinal O'Connor now," "Know your scumbags," "Curb your dogma," "Papal Bull," and the like. [12] Some tried to "storm" the church, but police stopped those who were obvious protesters from entering. [9] Plainclothes police officers, expecting trouble, were sitting in the pews during Mass. [7]

At the outset of Mass, O'Connor said he knew there were a number of protesters in attendance but asked for a peaceful service. [9] Originally, the plan was a silent protest with a "die-in" during the homily portion of the Mass. [7] When it appeared that the protest was having little effect on O'Connor, who continued on with Mass, Michael Petrelis stood on a pew and shouted, "You bigot O'Connor, you're killing us!" [5] [4] [2] The cathedral then descended into "pandemonium." [7] [5] A few dozen activists interrupted Mass, chanted slogans, blew whistles, "kept up a banshee screech," chained themselves to pews, threw condoms in the air, waved their fists, and lay down in the aisles to stage a "die-in." [1] [10] [12] [7] [9]

Ann Northrop was inside the Cathedral and said, "I happened to be the last person carried out, and by that time, everything had calmed down and was silent. So I started saying — and it was ringing through the cathedral — 'We're fighting for your lives, too. We're fighting for your lives, too.'" [13] O'Connor asked worshipers to "pay no attention to" those disrupting the Mass. [4] The organist also played in an attempt to drown the protesters out. [3]

One protester, Tom Keane, [14] took the consecrated communion wafer (Eucharist) from the priest, crumbled it into pieces, and dropped the pieces to the floor. [15] [16] [1] [17] [9] [2] He then lay on the floor of the church in an attempt to prevent others from receiving Communion and was later arrested. [7] Keane's desecration of the Eucharist became the biggest news story in the days to come. [9] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] Years later, Keane said he decided to act in the moment and, while in hindsight he might not have repeated the act, he felt no regret. [9]

Reaction

One-hundred and eleven protesters were arrested, including 43 inside the church. [3] Some, who refused to move, had to be carried out of the church on stretchers. [7] Only minor charges were filed, punished primarily by community service sentences; some protesters who refused the sentences were tried, but did not serve jail time. [3]

The protests were condemned by politicians and editorials in the major daily newspapers. Some in the gay community also considered that invading the privacy of worship was at odds with the gay community's arguments on sexual privacy. [17] Mayor Ed Koch viewed it as disrespectful and New York Governor Mario Cuomo "deplored the demonstration." The cathedral protest was criticized as "stupid and wrong-headed" by Andy Humm, a spokesman for the Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Rights, while one ACT UP leader, Peter Staley, denounced the protest as an "utter failure" and a "selfish, macho thing." [25]

During its planning, members of ACT UP were divided on the wisdom of the protest with some saying that protest should not target worshipers; others said it was more important to gain attention than it was to avoid offending the people attending the Mass. [7] Shortly after the protest, Larry Kramer, Robert Garcia, Ann Northrop, Mark Harrington, and Peter Staley appeared on a television panel to discuss the protest, where they faced oftentimes hostile questions from the audience. [26] [27]

Legacy

O'Connor ministered to those dying at an AIDS hospice, bathing them and changing their bedpans, [9] [28] [29] and supported others who did so. [6] [2] He also stated that he would never object to anyone peacefully protesting outside the cathedral, [30] which had happened before, [31] but did object to disrupting Mass and especially to the acts of desecration. [30]

The protest became one of ACT UP's most well known actions. [32] Protests at the cathedral continued for the next few years, though they were smaller and less disruptive. [33] In 1992, another woman crumbled the consecrated communion wafer (Eucharist), but it was unclear if the action was tied to the larger protest. [33] O'Connor feared, however, that it would start a trend. [33]

Robert Hilferty's documentary about the protest, Stop the Church, was originally scheduled to air on PBS. The film was eventually dropped from national broadcast by PBS, but still aired on public-access television cable TV stations in several major cities including Los Angeles, New York City, and San Francisco. [34] [33] The documentary used footage filmed "guerrilla-style" by Hilferty, an ACTUP member. [33]

"ACT UP activists now say the St. Patrick's protest changed the way many Americans viewed the Catholic Church. It was no longer untouchable, and its policies – on everything from condoms and abortion to gay marriage and women priests – were no longer sacrosanct." [3] Filmmaker Jim Hubbard, a member of ACT UP and director of the documentary United in Anger: A History of ACT UP, said, "I wasn't clear about what going inside the church would add at the time. But now I think that the shock of going inside and confronting the cardinal really worked. It helped bring ACT UP to mainstream attention. It brought the crisis to a point where the government and the mainstream media really had to start dealing with it." [3]

In June 2019, the main characters of the television series Pose , radicalized by members of their community now fighting AIDS, participate in the Stop the Church action and are arrested. [35]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John O'Connor (cardinal)</span> American Roman Catholic bishop and cardinal

John Joseph O'Connor was an American prelate of the Catholic Church. He served as Archbishop of New York from 1984 until his death in 2000, and was made a cardinal in 1985. He previously served as a U.S. Navy chaplain (1952–1979, including four years as Chief, auxiliary bishop of the Military Vicariate of the United States, and Bishop of Scranton in Pennsylvania.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edward Egan</span> American Catholic cardinal (1932–2015)

Edward Michael Egan was an American cardinal of the Catholic Church. He served as bishop of the Diocese of Bridgeport in Connecticut from 1988 to 2000 and as archbishop of the Archdiocese of New York in New York City from 2000 to 2009. He was elevated to the cardinalate in 2001.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">ACT UP</span> International AIDS activism, direct action and advocacy group

AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power is an international, grassroots political group working to end the AIDS pandemic. The group works to improve the lives of people with AIDS through direct action, medical research, treatment and advocacy, and working to change legislation and public policies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Host desecration</span> Form of sacrilege in some Christian denominations

Host desecration is a form of sacrilege in Christian denominations that follow the doctrine of the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist. It involves the mistreatment or malicious use of a consecrated host—the bread used in the Eucharistic service of the Divine Liturgy or Mass. It is forbidden by the Catholic, Oriental Orthodox, and Eastern Orthodox Churches, as well as in certain Protestant traditions. In Catholicism, where the host is held to have been transubstantiated into the body of Jesus Christ, host desecration is one of the gravest sins. Intentional host desecration incurs the penalty of excommunication latae sententiae. Throughout history, a number of groups have been accused of desecrating the Eucharist, often with grave consequences due to the spiritual importance of the consecrated host.

This is a list of notable events in the history of LGBT rights that took place in the year 1989.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Open communion</span> Protestant Christian religious practise

Open communion is the practice of some Protestant Churches of allowing members and non-members to receive the Eucharist. Many but not all churches that practice open communion require that the person receiving communion be a baptized Christian, and other requirements may apply as well. In Methodism, open communion is referred to as the open table, meaning that all may approach the Communion table.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rainbow Sash Movement</span>

The Rainbow Sash Movement is an organisation of gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender Catholics, with their families and friends, who are publicly calling the Catholic Church to a "conversion of heart around issues of human sexuality".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cormac Murphy-O'Connor</span> English Catholic prelate (1932–2017)

Cormac Murphy-O'Connor was a British cardinal, the Archbishop of Westminster and president of the Catholic Bishops' Conference of England and Wales. He was made cardinal by Pope John Paul II in 2001. He submitted his resignation as archbishop on reaching his 75th birthday in 2007; Pope Benedict XVI accepted it on 3 April 2009.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sacramental bread</span> Bread used in the Christian Eucharist ritual

Sacramental bread, also called Communion bread, Communion wafer, Sacred host, Eucharistic bread, the Lamb or simply the host, is the bread used in the Christian ritual of the Eucharist. Along with sacramental wine, it is one of two elements of the Eucharist. The bread may be either leavened or unleavened, depending on tradition.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alfonso López Trujillo</span> Colombian Catholic cardinal

Alfonso López Trujillo was a Colombian Cardinal Bishop of the Roman Catholic Church and president of the Pontifical Council for the Family.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Theology of Pope Benedict XVI</span>

The theology of Pope Benedict XVI, as promulgated during his pontificate, consists mainly of three encyclical letters on love (2005), hope (2007), and "charity in truth" (2009), as well as apostolic documents and various speeches and interviews. Pope Benedict XVI's theology underwent developments over the years, many of which were characterized by his leadership position in the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which is entrusted with preserving the Catholic faith in its entirety.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carlo Caffarra</span> Italian prelate of the Catholic Church

Carlo Caffarra was an Italian prelate of the Catholic Church. He was Archbishop of Bologna from 2003 until 2015, when he retired. His previous positions included President of the Pontifical John Paul II Institute for Studies on Marriage and Family from 1981 to 1995 and Archbishop of Ferrara-Comacchio from 1995 to 2003. He was created a Cardinal in the consistory of 24 March 2006 by Pope Benedict XVI.

Ann Northrop is a journalist and activist, and the current co-host of TV news program Gay USA.

Canon 915, one of the canons in the 1983 Code of Canon Law of the Latin Church of the Catholic Church, forbids the administration of Holy Communion to those upon whom the penalty of excommunication or interdict has been imposed or declared, or who obstinately persist in manifest grave sin:

Those who have been excommunicated or interdicted after the imposition or declaration of the penalty and others obstinately persevering in manifest grave sin are not to be admitted to holy communion.

The Catholic Church is a major provider of medical care to HIV/AIDS patients. Much of its work takes place in developing countries, although it has also had a presence in the global north. Its opposition to condoms, despite their effectiveness in preventing the spread of HIV, has invited criticism from public health officials and anti-AIDS activists.

Because the Catholic Church opposes abortion as a matter of doctrine, some Catholic bishops have refused or threatened to refuse communion, or threatened to declare excommunication upon Catholic politicians who support abortion rights. In some cases, officials have stated that ministers should refuse communion to such politicians per canon 915 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law; elsewhere, that the politicians should, on their own, refrain from receiving communion ad normam canon 916; and in other cases, excommunication has been suggested.

Dissent from the Catholic Church's teaching on homosexuality has come in a number of practical and ministerial arguments from both the clergy and the laity of the Catholic Church. The Catholic Church teaches that while being gay is not a sin in and of itself, any sex outside of marriage, including between same-sex partners, is sinful, and therefore being gay makes one inclined towards this particular sin.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ray Navarro</span>

Raymond Robert Navarro was an American video artist, filmmaker, and HIV/AIDS activist. Navarro was an active member of ACT UP and a founder of Diva TV. His activism was featured in the documentary How to Survive a Plague. Navarro's art was exhibited at the Institute of Contemporary Art, Boston, Museum of Contemporary Art, Los Angeles, Tacoma Art Museum, Bronx Museum of the Arts, and Museum of Contemporary Art, Cleveland, among others. Navarro's papers, videos, and artworks are held at the ONE National Gay & Lesbian Archives at the USC Libraries in Los Angeles.

The Lavender Hill Mob was a militant gay rights activist group operating in the United States in the 1980s in response to the treatment of the AIDS pandemic. It was founded and led by Marty Robinson.

The 1989 Vatican AIDS conference, known officially as the Fourth International Conference of the Pontifical Council for Pastoral Assistance to Health Care Workers, was a three-day academic symposium that ran from November 13 to November 15, 1989. Hosted by the Pontifical Council for the Pastoral Care of Health Care Workers at the Synod Hall in Vatican City, it included over 1,000 delegates, including church leaders and the world's top scientists and AIDS researchers, from 85 countries. The theme was "To live: why? AIDS : Church and health in the world." Attendees gathered to develop a pandemic response that was total, spiritual, cultural, psychological, and medical.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Allen, Peter L. (June 2002), The Wages of Sin: Sex and Disease, Past and Present, University of Chicago Press, p. 143, ISBN   978-0-226-01461-6 , retrieved July 27, 2018
  2. 1 2 3 4 George J. Marlin, Brad Miner, Sons of Saint Patrick: A History of the Archbishops of New York, p312
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Sindelar, Daisy (6 August 2012). "Decades Before Pussy Riot, U.S. Group Protested Catholic Church -- And Got Results". Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Faderman 2015, p. 434.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Riemer & Brown 2019, p. 275.
  6. 1 2 Michael O'Loughlin (December 20, 2019). "The cost of AIDS ministry to a gay priest". Plague: Untold Stories of AIDS & the Catholic Church (Podcast). America . Retrieved January 10, 2019.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 O’Loughlin, Michael J. (June 21, 2019). "'Pose' revisits controversial AIDS protest inside St. Patrick's Cathedral". America. Retrieved June 24, 2019.
  8. 1 2 Crouch, Stanley (10 May 2000). "Mourning the loss of Cardinal O'Connor". Salon . Archived from the original on 2004-09-18. Retrieved 2006-01-01.
  9. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Michael O'Loughlin (December 1, 2019). "Surviving the AIDS crisis as a gay Catholic". Plague: Untold Stories of AIDS & the Catholic Church (Podcast). America . Retrieved January 10, 2019.
  10. 1 2 Faderman 2015, pp. 433–435.
  11. ↑ ACT UP. 10 Year Anniversary of "Stop the Church" Accessed July 4, 2007.
  12. 1 2 Hunter, James Davison (1991). Culture Wars: The Struggle to Define America. Basic Books. p. 153. ISBN   978-0975372500.
  13. ↑ "Ann Northrop Looks Back On The Crucial Role Women Played in ACT UP". www.hivplusmag.com. 2020-02-25. Retrieved 2021-07-12.
  14. ↑ Faderman 2015, pp. 434–435.
  15. ↑ DeParle, Jason (January 3, 1990). "Rude, Rash, Effective, Act-Up Shifts AIDS Policy". New York Times. p. B1. Retrieved August 7, 2018.
  16. ↑ "ACTUP Oral History Project, Interviewee: Tom Keane, Interview Number: 176" (PDF). The New York Lesbian & Gay Experimental Film Festival, Inc. February 24, 2015. pp. 20–21. Archived from the original (PDF) on September 2, 2020. Retrieved August 3, 2018. I put my hands out, and suddenly I have the Communion wafer in my hands, and the priest says, 'This is the body of Christ,' and I say, 'Opposing safe-sex education is murder.' Then I sort of—I didn't really know what to do, and I think in some sense, some part of me was sort of saying, 'Well, fine. You guys think you can tell us that you reject us, that we don't belong, so I'm going to reject you.' So I took it and I crushed it and dropped it.
  17. 1 2 Carroll, Tamar W. (April 20, 2015). Mobilizing New York: AIDS, Antipoverty, and Feminist Activism. University of North Carolina Press. pp. 157–158. ISBN   978-1-4696-1989-7.
  18. ↑ Miller, Andrew; Wockner, Rex (December 24, 1989). "AIDS/ Abortion Rights Demo Halts High Mass at St. Pat's" (PDF). Out Week. No. 2. p. 2. The single incident, considered an act of sacrilege by many, has since consumed reams of newsprint...
  19. ↑ Munt, Sally R. (September 29, 2017). Queer Attachments: The Cultural Politics of Shame. Taylor & Francis. p. 95. ISBN   978-1-351-90715-6 . Retrieved April 21, 2020. Although 111 people were arrested, the news media focused on and distorted a single Catholic demonstrator's personal protest involving a communion wafer.
  20. ↑ "Going to Extremes". Out. Here Publishing. June 2001. pp. 122–123. ISSN   1062-7928 . Retrieved April 21, 2020. The news coverage in that night and in following days was dominated by the desecration of the host.
  21. ↑ Wockner, Rex. "Cardinal Sins" (PDF). Marxism Today. No. March 1990. p. 49. Retrieved April 21, 2020.
  22. ↑ Shaw, Randy (1996). The Activist's Handbook: A Primer for the 1990s and Beyond. University of California Press. pp. 222–223. ISBN   978-0-520-20317-4 . Retrieved April 21, 2020. The coverage most prominently featured the person who threw the wafer;
  23. ↑ Cohen, Peter F. (January 14, 2014). Love and Anger: Essays on AIDS, Activism, and Politics. Routledge. p. 27. ISBN   978-1-317-71225-1 . Retrieved April 21, 2020. ...the crumbling of a communion wafer by just one member came to represent the entire deomnstration in the eyes of the media and the public.
  24. ↑ Petro 2015, p. 137-138"Media accounts of the protest underscored one particular action that occurred within the cathedral: a young man crumbled the sacred host."
  25. ↑ Deparle, Jason (January 3, 1990). "Rude, Rash, Effective, Act-Up Shifts AIDS Policy". The New York Times. Retrieved April 23, 2010.
  26. ↑ Shearn Coan, Jaime. "Crucial Circulations: VHS and Queer AIDS Archives". Center for the Humanities. Retrieved 20 April 2022.
  27. ↑ "1990 Talk Show W/ ACT UP: Larry Kramer, Mark Harrington, Peter Staley, Ann Northrop, Robert Garcia". YouTube. Retrieved 20 April 2022.
  28. ↑ Goldman, Ari L. (July 27, 1987). "300 Fault O'Connor Role on AIDS Commission". The New York Times. Retrieved January 31, 2020.
  29. ↑ Rosin, Hanna; McCarthy, Colman (May 4, 2000). "Cardinal John J. O'Connor Dies". The New York Times. Retrieved April 27, 2020.
  30. 1 2 Petro 2015, p. 138-139.
  31. ↑ Petro 2015, p. 151.
  32. ↑ Petro 2015, p. 139.
  33. 1 2 3 4 5 Petro 2015, p. 138.
  34. ↑ Steinfels, Peter. (September 13, 1991) Channel 13 to Show Film on AIDS Protest New York Times . Accessed July 4, 2007.
  35. ↑ Rodriguez, Mathew (2019-06-12). "Here's the Story Behind the St. Patrick's Cathedral Action Depicted in 'Pose'". The Body. Retrieved 2021-08-20.

Works cited

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.