The Chicago Lake Shore and South Bend Railway

Last updated

The Chicago Lake Shore and South Bend Railway formed in 1901, is the earliest predecessor of the Chicago South Shore and South Bend Railroad (and South Shore Line).

Contents

History

At its formation on November 30, 1901, the corporate title was the Chicago & Indiana Air Line Railway (Air Line). The Air Line was controlled by Frank and James Seagrave, brothers from Toledo, Ohio, who had envisioned an electrically operated freight and passenger railroad from Toledo to Chicago, Illinois. The Seagrave brothers had completed their Toledo and Western Railroad mainline across the former Great Black Swamp from Toledo to Pioneer, Ohio, in an area that otherwise had no direct rail service to Toledo. A branch was constructed from Sylvania, Ohio, to Adrian, Michigan. [1] The Seagraves’ anticipated that they would build west to Goshen, Indiana, where they would obtain trackage rights from the Indiana Electric Railroad Company (later the Chicago, South Bend and Northern Indiana; successor company to the first commercial electric trolley line in North America) to South Bend where it would connect with the Air Line for Chicago. [2]

Financing to complete the railroad was announced on January 17, 1903. [3] Property acquisition and engineering from South Bend west to the St. Joseph – LaPorte county line was completed within the year. [4] The Seagraves’ also obtained franchises for operation in the streets of South Bend, New Carlisle, and Michigan City. The Seagraves’ began street railway operations at East Chicago during September, 1903. [5] Grading for the railroad was begun in St. Joseph County during 1903, but the Rich Man's Panic put an end to the work and apparently the Seagraves’ interest in the company. [6]

The historical significance of the Seagraves’ effort in developing what would become the South Shore Line was that in 1903 there was no business model for a short line regional high-speed electrified railroad handling freight and passengers. Economic historians George Hilton and John Due noted in their history of the interurbans that the Seagraves’ effort was probably the first. [7] But for the Panic of 1903, the Seagraves’ would have likely completed what is recognized today as a regional high-speed electrified railroad from Toledo to Chicago.

The directors of the Air Line voted for a corporate name change on July 30, 1904: The Chicago, Lake Shore and South Bend Railway Company (South Shore Lines). [8] In 1907, with the easing of monetary pressures, property acquisition, engineering, and construction began again under the direction of a new promoter, James B. Hanna. [9] Although the scope of the project was then limited to a rail line from Chicago to South Bend, the business model posited by the Seagraves’ remained.

The first phase of construction from South Bend to Michigan City was completed and in scheduled service on July 1, 1908. The remainder of the line from Michigan City to Hammond was in service on September 6, 1908, [10] only twenty-one days before the first Ford Model T automobile left the Piquette Avenue Plant in Detroit. [11] Not only was the South Shore Lines embroiled in a transportation war with the automobile, but it was also unwittingly embroiled in the War of the Currents waged by Thomas Edison and George Westinghouse. Edison famously clung to his original direct current system, while Westinghouse embraced the alternating current system developed by Nikola Tesla. [12] While alternating current proved to be superior to direct current for municipal power grids, the technology to precisely control the speed of an AC motor was still being developed, while control technology for DC motors was well-established.

Some twenty other interurbans adopted the Westinghouse system, most between 1904 and 1908. The alternating current system was not perfected however, and nearly all the lines operating with it were quickly converted to direct current, some in as little as three years. The South Shore Lines never found itself in a financial position to convert to direct current despite the high expense of maintaining the alternating current system. [13]

Wreck at Shadyside, Indiana, 19 June 1909. The motorman of eastbound car #73 (foreground) overran a meeting point and collided with westbound car #3. As a result, twelve were killed and 25 injured. Cls shadyside wreck 19 june 1909 rppc.jpg
Wreck at Shadyside, Indiana, 19 June 1909. The motorman of eastbound car #73 (foreground) overran a meeting point and collided with westbound car #3. As a result, twelve were killed and 25 injured.

The South Shore Lines found itself in financial difficulty from the start as passenger revenues were insufficient to cover the railway's bonded indebtedness. This was exacerbated by claims resulting from two head-on wrecks in 1909 that resulted in an unfunded legislative mandate to install a costly block signal system. [14] [15] [16] Despite these setbacks, service had been extended to Pullman on Chicago's South Side on April 4, 1909. [17] An agreement with the Illinois Central Railroad dated May 25, 1912, called for non-motorized trail coaches to be attached to trains originating in Gary to be hauled by steam locomotives for the run to Randolph Street near Chicago's Loop. [18]

Attempting to overcome inadequate earnings, the South Shore Lines made every effort to develop freight service in 1916, [19] and an excursion business to bring Chicagoans to the Indiana Dunes, the amusement park at Michigan City, and the Casino at Hudson Lake. The most significant of the rail excursions to the development of Northwest Indiana were the regular outings of the Prairie Club of Chicago on the South Shore Lines that began in 1909. [20] The access to the Dunes that the South Shore Lines provided to the Prairie Club led the members to erect cabins in the Dunes. With assistance from Stephen Mather, the first director of the National Park Service, The Prairie Club soon waged a lobbying campaign for the creation of a Sand Dunes National Park that for a time was unsuccessful, but did culminate in the opening of the Indiana Dunes State Park in 1925. Congressional authorization of a National Park Service unit in the Dunes in 1966 resulted in the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore (now Indiana Dunes National Park). [21]

In 1925, the Cleveland Trust Company still held the original construction bonds of the South Shore Lines in the amount of $9,500,000. [22] Earlier, in 1924, Samuel Insull, a utilities developer who had electric and gas utility investments throughout much of the United States sought a means of developing a new customer base with a balanced electrical load in the Indiana Dunes country. [23] After investigating both the South Shore Lines and the Chicago, South Bend and Northern Indiana, Insull had the South Shore Lines appraised. Based upon the depreciated appraised value of $6,463,076, [24] and with a commitment to invest $2,500,000 in the property, Insull purchased the original construction debt from Cleveland Trust in exchange for 6% noncumulative debentures. Insull controlled a 60% majority stock interest in the new company. The closing of the transaction took place on June 29, 1925, six days after Insull formed the South Shore Line. [25]

Preserved Equipment

South Shore Lines #73 undergoing restoration. South Shore Lines -73 Copper Roof.jpg
South Shore Lines #73 undergoing restoration.

One wooden passenger car has survived from the South Shore Lines. Combination coach-baggage car #73 was built by the Niles Car and Manufacturing Company in 1908. #73 is currently undergoing restoration. [26]

The interior of South Shore Lines #73 while undergoing restoration. Cls 73 interior main.jpg
The interior of South Shore Lines #73 while undergoing restoration.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Interurban</span> Type of electric railway which runs within and between cities or towns

The interurban is a type of electric railway, with tram-like electric self-propelled rail cars which run within and between cities or towns. The term "interurban" is usually used in North America, with other terms used outside it. They were very prevalent in North America between 1900 and 1925 and were used primarily for passenger travel between cities and their surrounding suburban and rural communities. The concept spread to countries such as Japan, the Netherlands, Switzerland, Belgium, Italy and Poland. Interurban as a term encompassed the companies, their infrastructure, their cars that ran on the rails, and their service. In the United States, the early 1900s interurban was a valuable economic institution, when most roads between towns, many town streets were unpaved, and transportation and haulage was by horse-drawn carriages and carts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Samuel Insull</span> American businessman (1859–1938)

Samuel Insull was a British business magnate. He was an innovator and investor based in Chicago who helped create an integrated electrical infrastructure in the United States. Insull created holding companies that purchased utilities and railroads. Insull was responsible for the building of the Chicago Civic Opera House in 1929. Due to the Great Depression, his vast Midwest holding company empire collapsed, and he was accused of profiting personally by selling worthless stock to unsuspecting investors who trusted him because of his position and reputation. Following a seven-week trial, he and 16 co-defendants were acquitted of all charges after two hours of jury deliberation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cincinnati and Lake Erie Railroad</span> Interurban railway in Ohio, US

The Cincinnati and Lake Erie Railroad (C&LE) was a short-lived electric interurban railway that operated in 1930–1939 Depression-era Ohio and ran between the major cities of Cincinnati, Dayton, Springfield, Columbus, and Toledo. It had a substantial freight business and interchanged with other interurbans to serve Detroit and Cleveland. Its twenty high-speed "Red Devil" interurban passenger cars operated daily between Cincinnati and Cleveland via Toledo, the longest same equipment run by an interurban in the United States. The C&LE failed because of the weak economy and the loss of essential freight interchange partners. It ceased operating in 1939.

The Lake Shore and Michigan Southern Railway, established in 1833 and sometimes referred to as the Lake Shore, was a major part of the New York Central Railroad's Water Level Route from Buffalo, New York, to Chicago, Illinois, primarily along the south shore of Lake Erie and across northern Indiana. The line's trackage remains a major rail transportation corridor used by Amtrak passenger trains and several freight lines; in 1998, its ownership was split at Cleveland between CSX Transportation to the east and Norfolk Southern Railway in the west.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">South Shore Line</span> Rail line in Indiana and Illinois, United States

The South Shore Line is an electrically powered interurban commuter rail line operated by the Northern Indiana Commuter Transportation District (NICTD) between Millennium Station in downtown Chicago and the South Bend International Airport in South Bend, Indiana, United States. The name refers to both the physical line and the service operated over that route. The line was built in 1901–1908 by predecessors of the Chicago South Shore and South Bend Railroad, which continues to operate freight service. Passenger operation was assumed by the NICTD in 1989. The South Shore Line is one of the last surviving interurban trains in the United States. In 2022, the system had a ridership of 1,406,400, or about 5,000 per weekday as of the second quarter of 2023.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chicago South Shore and South Bend Railroad</span> American Class III freight railroad

The Chicago South Shore and South Bend Railroad, also known as the South Shore Line, is a Class III freight railroad operating between Chicago, Illinois, and South Bend, Indiana. The railroad serves as a link between Class I railroads and local industries in northeast Illinois and northwest Indiana. It built the South Shore Line electric interurban and operated it until 1990, when it transferred to the Northern Indiana Commuter Transportation District. The railroad is owned by the Anacostia Rail Holdings Company.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Central Station (Chicago terminal)</span> Railroad terminal in Chicago, Illinois

Central Station was an intercity passenger terminal in downtown Chicago, Illinois, at the southern end of Grant Park near Roosevelt Road and Michigan Avenue. Owned by the Illinois Central Railroad, it also served other companies via trackage rights. It opened in 1893, replacing Great Central Station, and closed in 1972 when Amtrak rerouted services to Union Station. The station building was demolished in 1974. It is now the site of a redevelopment called Central Station, Chicago.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chicago North Shore and Milwaukee Railroad</span> Former interurban railroad line between the Chicago Loop and downtown Milwaukee

The Chicago North Shore and Milwaukee Railroad, also known as the North Shore Line, was an interurban railroad that operated passenger and freight service over an 88.9-mile (143.1 km) route between the Chicago Loop and downtown Milwaukee, as well as an 8.6-mile (13.8 km) branch line between the villages of Lake Bluff and Mundelein, Illinois. The North Shore Line also provided streetcar, city bus and motor coach services along its interurban route.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chicago Aurora and Elgin Railroad</span> Defunct American interurban railroad

The Chicago Aurora and Elgin Railroad (CA&E), known colloquially as the "Roarin' Elgin" or the "Great Third Rail", was an interurban railroad that operated passenger and freight service on its line between Chicago and Aurora, Batavia, Geneva, St. Charles, and Elgin, Illinois. The railroad also operated a small branch to Mt. Carmel Cemetery in Hillside and owned a branch line to Westchester.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chicago – New York Electric Air Line Railroad</span>

The Chicago – New York Electric Air Line Railroad (CNY) was a proposed high-speed electric air-line railroad between Chicago and New York City. At roughly 750 miles (1,210 km) it would have been over 150 miles (240 km) shorter than the two primary steam railroads on that route, the New York Central Railroad and Pennsylvania Railroad. The promoters' vision proved wildly optimistic and, in the end, only a short interurban route in the vicinity of Gary, Indiana was built and operated. It was the most ambitious of several such proposals at the dawn of electric railroading, all of which ended in failure.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lake Shore Electric Railway</span>

The Lake Shore Electric Railway (LSE) was an interurban electric railway that ran primarily between Cleveland and Toledo, Ohio by way of Sandusky and Fremont. Through arrangements with connecting interurban lines, it also offered service from Fremont to Fostoria and Lima, Ohio, and at Toledo to Detroit and Cincinnati.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Detroit and Toledo Shore Line Railroad</span>

The Detroit and Toledo Shore Line Railroad is a historic railroad that operated in northwestern Ohio and southeastern Michigan.

The Gary Public Transportation Corporation (GPTC) is a commuter bus system in Gary, Indiana that offers service to numerous stops throughout the city and neighboring suburbs. GPTC is a public corporation owned but not directly controlled by the city.

The Indiana Railroad (IR) was the last of the typical Midwestern United States interurban lines. It was formed in 1930–31 by combining the operations of the five major interurban systems in central Indiana into one entity. The predecessor companies came under the control of Midland Utilities, owned by Samuel Insull. His plan was to modernize the profitable routes and abandon the unprofitable ones. With the onset of the Great Depression, the Insull empire collapsed and the Indiana Railroad was left with a decaying infrastructure and little hope of overcoming the growing competition of the automobile for passenger business and the truck for freight business. The IR faced bankruptcy in 1933, and Bowman Elder was designated as the receiver to run the company. Payments on bonded debt were suspended. Elder was able to keep the system virtually intact for four years, and IR operated about 600 miles (970 km) of interurban lines throughout Indiana during this period. During the late 1930s, the routes were abandoned one by one until a 1941 wreck with fatalities south of Indianapolis put an abrupt end to the Indiana Railroad's last passenger operations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Terre Haute, Indianapolis and Eastern Traction Company</span>

The Terre Haute, Indianapolis and Eastern Traction Company, or THI&E, was the second largest interurban in the U.S. state of Indiana at the 1920s height of the "interurban era." This system included over 400 miles (640 km) of track, with lines radiating from Indianapolis to the east, northwest, west and southwest as well as streetcar lines in several major cities. The THI&E was formed in 1907 by the Schoepf-McGowan Syndicate as a combination of several predecessor interurban and street car companies and was operated independently until incorporation into the Indiana Railroad in 1931. The THI&E served a wide range of territory, including farmlands in central Indiana, the mining region around Brazil, and numerous urban centers. Eventually, it slowly succumbed like all of the other central Indiana interurban lines, to competition from automobiles, trucks, and improved paralleling highways.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Beverly Shores station</span>

Beverly Shores is a train station in Beverly Shores, Indiana, served by the South Shore Line interurban commuter railroad. The station serves the town of Beverly Shores as well as the nearby Town of Pines. It is a flag stop.

Kemil Road was a South Shore Line flag stop located at the corner of Kemil Road and U.S. 12 in Porter County, Indiana. The stop was located at the eastern edge of the Indiana Dunes State Park. It was established in 1977 on the initiative of South Shore Recreation, a citizens group, and closed in 1994.

References

  1. George S. Davis, The Interurban Electric Railways of Ohio, 18 Street Railway Journal 107, 113 (1901).
  2. From Toledo to Chicago, 21 Street Railway Journal 132 (1903).
  3. From Toledo to Chicago, 21 Street Railway Journal 132 (1903).
  4. The Chicago, Lake Shore and South Bend Railway Company Right-of-Way Maps, 1911 (showing parcels with transaction dates).
  5. William D. Middleton, South Shore: The Last Interurban 10 (1st ed. 1970).
  6. Profile - Chicago, Lake Shore & South Bend Railway – South Bend to Hammond (showing dates of engineering and grading, but the overall date of this antique document is not legible).
  7. Hilton & Due, The Electric Interurban Railways in America 264 (1st ed. 1960).
  8. Jay Samuel Hartt, Central Electric Railfan’s Association Address (1962).
  9. Contracts and Contracts, 2 Electric Traction Weekly 44, 47 (1906); An Important Road Contemplated for Indiana, 28 Street Railway Journal 151 (1906).
  10. Norman Carlson, Chicago South Shore & South Bend Railroad: How the Medal Was Won 10 (1985).
  11. Ford Model T, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Model_T.
  12. Margaret Cheney & Robert Uth, Tesla: Master of Lightning 23-33 (1999).
  13. Hilton & Due, The Electric Interurban Railways in America 62 (1st ed. 1960).
  14. Traffic and Transportation, 33 Electric Railway Journal 853, 854 (1909).
  15. Traffic and Transportation, 33 Electric Railway Journal 1178, 1179 (1909).
  16. William D. Middleton, South Shore: The Last Interurban 14 (1st ed. 1970).
  17. The Chicago, Lake Shore & South Bend Railway, 33 Electric Railway Journal 674 (1909).
  18. Interline Steam and Electric Service Between Chicago and Gary, 39 Electric Railway Journal 925 (1912).
  19. High Lights of History of the South Shore Line Transportation Department 14 (1926).
  20. Cathy Jean Maloney, The Prairie Club of Chicago 14 (2001).
  21. Cathy Jean Maloney, The Prairie Club of Chicago 63 (2001).
  22. James Walker, Cost of Reproduction and Cost of Reproduction Less Accrued Depreciation as of May 1, 1925 Based on Prices Prevailing at Time of Appraisal of the Property of The Chicago, Lake Shore and South Bend Railway Company in Indiana 2 (1925).
  23. Samuel Insull, The Memoirs of Samuel Insull: An Autobiography 180-81 (1992).
  24. James Walker, Cost of Reproduction and Cost of Reproduction Less Accrued Depreciation as of May 1, 1925 Based on Prices Prevailing at Time of Appraisal of the Property of The Chicago, Lake Shore and South Bend Railway Company in Indiana Cover Letter (1925).
  25. Norman Carlson, Chicago South Shore & South Bend Railroad: How the Medal Was Won 9,63 (1985).
  26. https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100009400335942 [ user-generated source ]