The Doctor (painting)

Last updated

The Doctor
The Doctor Luke Fildes crop.jpg
Artist Luke Fildes
Year1891
MediumOil on canvas
Dimensions166 cm× 242 cm(65 in× 95 in)
Location Tate Gallery, London

The Doctor is an 1891 painting by Luke Fildes that depicts a Victorian doctor observing the critical stage in a child's illness while the parents gaze on helplessly from the periphery. It has been used to portray the values of the ideal physician and the inadequacies of the medical profession. Different theories exist as to the painting's origin but it is most likely based upon Fildes' own experience of the death of his son. Critics have noted that Fildes omitted common medical equipment of his era in order to focus on the relationship between physician and patient.

Contents

Origins

Self-portrait, Luke Fildes, 1911. Royal Academy of Arts, London. Sir Luke Fildes RA (1843-1927) - Self Portrait - 03-718 - Royal Academy of Arts.jpg
Self-portrait, Luke Fildes, 1911. Royal Academy of Arts, London.

The painting was commissioned by Henry Tate in 1890 as a work of "social realism" on a topic of Fildes' choosing to be displayed in the National Gallery of British Art, now known as the Tate Gallery London. [1] Fildes was paid £3,000 for the work, a sum he felt was too small for such a painting and less than he expected for painting portraits. [2] Two Victorian doctors, Dr Thomas Buzzard (neurologist) and Dr Gustavus Murray (obstetrician), have been particularly associated with the painting, as has the genre of the period in which it was painted. [3] Fildes had the particular desire "to put on record the status of the doctor in our time". [1]

Different theories exist as to the origins of the painting. [4]

Fildes' personal loss

The most important personal influence was probably the death of Fildes' first child, his one-year-old son, Philip, from typhoid fever on Christmas morning, 1877. [5] Fildes' biographer has described how the boy's death compelled Fildes to paint a picture revolving around the compassionate Dr Murray visiting his dying child. The story was confirmed later by Fildes' second son, who described this as Fildes' "quickest painted of his 'big' pictures". [6]

The Widower, Luke Fildes, 1876. A precursor of The Doctor. Sir Luke Fildes - The widower - Google Art Project.jpg
The Widower, Luke Fildes, 1876. A precursor of The Doctor.

Fildes' experiences

Documentation of Fildes' work with the homeless reveals that a child was once brought into the studio by a labourer, a scenario which prompted the painting The Widower (1876). This painting included many features later seen in The Doctor. [1]

Fildes most likely modelled the characters in the painting on his own family and himself. Observing photographs of himself, Fildes guided his models, who were frequently his friends. His daughter was likely the prototype of the sick child, and a professional model was used for the mother. [8] The child's resting hand and extended arm may have been drawn from Fildes' older son. Despite reports that doctors visited Fildes in the hope of being used as models, the final painting of the doctor resembles Fildes himself. [6]

Paying tribute to his family origins in the fishing industry, Fildes adds a fishing net hanging from the ceiling. His father was a mariner and shipping agent. [9]

On Queen Victoria's orders

The cottage setting has led some to believe that the painting was ordered by Queen Victoria to honour her own physician, Sir James Clark. This alternative account also originates in the story about her physician being sent to Balmoral to care for the sick child of a servant. [4] [10] This account, however, is simply groundless because not a single contemporary reviewer mentioned this episode when the picture was first exhibited in 1891 at the Royal Academy in London and Fildes himself made no mention of Queen Victoria in his several interviews concerning the painting. [11]

Social context

18th and 19th century concerns by society of the rise of scientific medicine also could have possibly influenced the format of the painting. [4]

Composition

Preparation

The painting was first exhibited in 1891. [4] Prior to completion, a number of sketches were made which are preserved at the Tate Gallery and depict various alternative compositions such as the doctor being on the right side of the canvas, the child seated rather than lying down, and different facial expressions for the doctor. [12] Fildes built a model cottage to copy after visiting numerous cottages in north-east Scotland, ensuring that the picture included authentic detail of roof rafters, tablecloth, lampshade, and lighting. [10] Particular attention was paid to ensuring the room had a poor, Victorian, multi-purpose appearance. [9]

Doctor and patient

Detail of the doctor and patient The Doctor by Luke Fildes (detail).jpg
Detail of the doctor and patient

The focus of the picture is the worried but sympathetic physician and the sick child, with everything else in the shadows. The child had experienced a 'crisis', the critical stage of a potentially life-threatening illness. [4] The ' dawn' light through the window, represents recovery and hope as the child survived the night. [12]

The concentrated focus of the doctor on the child shows the patient as a person and individual and the doctor as a compassionate carer with empathy for the patient's suffering. [5] [13] In 2002, Douglas wrote in the British Medical Journal , "So his manner is all, and Fildes captures it forever: the furrowed brow; the hand propping the firm bearded chin; the calm, concerned authority". [4]

Parents

The parents are insignificant, helpless, and not central to the picture. A father gives support to his wife by extending his arm and resting his hand on her shoulder. She appears to be crying and possibly praying. [5] He, however, is also helpless and peers on at the doctor and child. [4]

Lighting and room

The artificial light from the lamp on the table and the natural rising sunlight beginning to shine through the single window suggest that the doctor has been in attendance all night. [6] A distressed, poor, and modest family is depicted by one small carpet and the washing suspended in a small room. [6] Two mismatched chairs, pressed together, construct a makeshift bed in the labourer's cottage. [4] A couple of scrunched up papers lie on the floor, "most probably a filled prescription" which has been frustratingly discarded. [9] An easily missed medicine bottle is placed in the shadow of the lamp and in close proximity to the doctor and his control, not the parents'. [9]

Accuracy

Fildes stated that his choice of subject was "to put on record the status of the doctor in our own time", [4] but his depiction of 19th-century healthcare is not entirely accurate. There is no stethoscope, microscope, sphygmomanometer, or thermometer in the picture, well-known instruments of physicians in the late 19th century which saved time. [4] It may be that these instruments were omitted in order to show the doctors' "professional and personal commitment". [6] Fildes does include a pestle and mortar, and a cup and a spoon, equipment used before the scientific era of medicine. [4]

It has also been pointed out that it was unlikely that a Victorian physician would make an overnight home visit to a poor family, such services being available only to the middle class and the wealthy. [4]

Reception and legacy

The Doctor used ironically in a 1911 Punch cartoon by Bernard Partridge commenting on the effects of the National Insurance Act 1911 Health-Doctors-Cartoons-Punch-1911-06-14-461.jpg
The Doctor used ironically in a 1911 Punch cartoon by Bernard Partridge commenting on the effects of the National Insurance Act 1911

The painting caught the public's attention and toured Britain. Received with a striking admiration, there is one report of an observer who, overwhelmed at the painting, died on the spot. [9] The work is considered one of the most famous depictions of the practice of medicine and has been described as "iconic". [6] It epitomises an idyllic kind of medicine [1] and has often been used to illustrate the virtues of a good doctor and the inadequacies of the medical profession. [4]

Subsequently, the painting received comments including this by surgeon W. Mitchell Banks: "What do we not owe to Mr. Fildes for showing to the world the typical doctor as we would all like him to be shown – an honest man and a gentle man, doing his best to relieve suffering?" He continued: "A library of books written in your honour would not do what this picture has done and will do for the medical profession in making the hearts of our fellow men warm to us with confidence and affection". [9]

Seen today as "Victorian spin" by some, in its time the depiction of the doctor as a hero serving the poor raised the status of the medical profession during a period when public opinion was critical of the increasingly impersonal nature of medicine. [4]

The Doctor, after Luke Fildes, Joseph Tomanek, 1933 The Doctor Luke Fildes.jpg
The Doctor, after Luke Fildes, Joseph Tomanek, 1933
AMA Centennial stamp of the United States, 1947 Doctors AMA Centennial 3c 1947 issue U.S. stamp.jpg
AMA Centennial stamp of the United States, 1947

The painting has inspired poetry and film. [4] In 1911 it featured in a Punch cartoon commenting satirically on the effect of the National Insurance Act 1911 on doctors. [14] In 1933, the American artist Joseph Tomanek painted a version of the painting making small changes to the composition. [16] In 1947 it was reproduced on a United States postage stamp for the centenary of the American Medical Association, [9] which in 1949 used it in their campaign against nationalised medical care as proposed by President Harry S. Truman. The image was printed on 65,000 posters and brochures with the slogan, "Keep Politics Out of this Picture". This has been described as contributing to public distrust of nationalised medical care in the United States. [17] By contrast, in Britain it was used as the emblem for a celebration of Britain's National Health Service. [9]

In 1933, a sculpture of the scene in the painting was made using the "life-size, life-like, new art form" of sculpticolor and displayed at the Petrolagar laxative exhibit in the Hall of Science at the Chicago Century of Progress exhibition. It was cast from a model made by the sculptor John Paulding and then painted by Rudolph F. Ingerle, the entire work measuring 15 feet (4.6 m) in length, 11 feet (3.4 m) in height, and 9 feet (2.7 m) in depth. Publicity stated that "The Doctor impressively emphasizes the ideal relationship between physician and patient - 'The Human Touch'". [18] [19]

As late as 1951, the painting was used in advertising for Wyeth pharmaceuticals, which repeated the story that Queen Victoria commissioned it, adding: "the pictured child recovered despite the inadequacies of her humble home–a tribute to her doctor's genius and to the progress of medical science". [20]

Since the mid-1990s, the medical humanities journals The Lancet and the British Medical Journal have revived interest in the painting, stimulating discussion about the role of the doctor. [9] Debate on the role and status of doctors has led to the inclusion of medical humanities in medical schools, where this painting has been used as a teaching aid for medical students. [5]

The reason for the painting's popularity has been much debated. The universal sentiment associated with a doctor tending to a sick child appears simple. Ultimately, it is likely that The Doctor was hailed as iconic due to the wish to be cared for with single-minded attentiveness. [9]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lawrence Alma-Tadema</span> Dutch-born British painter (1836–1912)

Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema,, RWS was a Dutch painter who later settled in the United Kingdom, becoming the last officially recognised denizen in 1873. Born in Dronryp, the Netherlands, and trained at the Royal Academy of Antwerp, Belgium, he settled in London, England in 1870 and spent the rest of his life there.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Everett Millais</span> British painter and illustrator (1829–1896)

Sir John Everett Millais, 1st Baronet was an English painter and illustrator who was one of the founders of the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood. He was a child prodigy who, aged eleven, became the youngest student to enter the Royal Academy Schools. The Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood was founded at his family home in London, at 83 Gower Street. Millais became the most famous exponent of the style, his painting Christ in the House of His Parents (1849–50) generating considerable controversy, and he produced a picture that could serve as the embodiment of the historical and naturalist focus of the group, Ophelia, in 1851–52.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henry Scott Tuke</span> English painter and photographer

Henry Scott Tuke, was an English artist; primarily a painter, but also a photographer. His most notable work was in the Impressionist style, and he is best known for his paintings of nude boys and young men.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stanley Spencer</span> English painter (1891–1959)

Sir Stanley Spencer, CBE RA was an English painter. Shortly after leaving the Slade School of Art, Spencer became well known for his paintings depicting Biblical scenes occurring as if in Cookham, the small village beside the River Thames where he was born and spent much of his life. Spencer referred to Cookham as "a village in Heaven" and in his biblical scenes, fellow-villagers are shown as their Gospel counterparts. Spencer was skilled at organising multi-figure compositions such as in his large paintings for the Sandham Memorial Chapel and the Shipbuilding on the Clyde series, the former being a First World War memorial while the latter was a commission for the War Artists' Advisory Committee during the Second World War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Luke Fildes</span> English painter

Sir Samuel Luke Fildes was a British painter and illustrator born in Liverpool and trained at the South Kensington and Royal Academy Schools. He was the grandson of the political activist Mary Fildes.

<i>The Sick Child</i> (Munch) Painting series by Edvard Munch

The Sick Child is the title given to a group of six paintings and a number of lithographs, drypoints and etchings completed by the Norwegian artist Edvard Munch between 1885 and 1926. All record a moment before the death of his older sister Johanne Sophie (1862–1877) from tuberculosis at 15. Munch returned to this deeply traumatic event repeatedly in his art over a period of more than 40 years. In the works, Sophie is typically shown on her deathbed accompanied by a dark-haired, grieving woman assumed to be her aunt Karen; the studies often show her in a cropped head shot. In all the painted versions Sophie is sitting in a chair, obviously suffering from pain, propped by a large white pillow, looking towards an ominous curtain likely intended as a symbol of death. She is shown with a haunted expression, clutching hands with a grief-stricken older woman who seems to want to comfort her but whose head is bowed as if she cannot bear to look the younger girl in the eye.

<i>Autumn Leaves</i> (painting) Painting by John Everet Millais

Autumn Leaves (1856) is a painting by John Everett Millais exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1856. It was described by the critic John Ruskin as "the first instance of a perfectly painted twilight." Millais's wife Effie wrote that he had intended to create a picture that was "full of beauty and without a subject".

<i>The Lady of Shalott</i> (painting) Painting by John William Waterhouse

The Lady of Shalott is a painting of 1888 by the English painter John William Waterhouse. It is a representation of the ending of Alfred, Lord Tennyson's 1832 poem of the same name. Waterhouse painted three versions of this character, in 1888, 1894 and 1915. It is one of his most famous works, which adopted much of the style of the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood, though Waterhouse was painting several decades after the Brotherhood split up during his early childhood.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Balthasar van den Bossche</span> Flemish painter (1681–1715)

Balthasar van den Bossche (1681–1715) was a Flemish painter who is mainly known for his wide range of genre subjects and occasional portraits.

<i>The Agnew Clinic</i> Painting by Thomas Eakins

The Agnew Clinic is an 1889 oil painting by American artist Thomas Eakins. It was commissioned to honor anatomist and surgeon David Hayes Agnew, on his retirement from teaching at the University of Pennsylvania.

<i>Ecce Ancilla Domini</i> Painting by Dante Gabriel Rossetti

Ecce Ancilla Domini, or The Annunciation, is an oil painting by the English artist Dante Gabriel Rossetti, first painted in 1850 and now in Tate Britain in London. The Latin title is a quotation from the Vulgate text of the first chapter of the Gospel of Saint Luke, describing the Annunciation, where Mary accepts the message brought to her by the Angel Gabriel that she would give birth to a child (Jesus) by God.

<i>The Beloved</i> (Rossetti) 1865 painting by Dante Gabriel Rossetti

The Beloved is an oil painting on canvas by the English artist Dante Gabriel Rossetti (1828–1882), now in Tate Britain, London. Rossetti signed his initials and the date as "1865-6" on the bottom left of the canvas. It depicts the bride, or "beloved", from the Song of Solomon in the Hebrew Bible as she approaches her bridegroom, with her attendants.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gaetano Meo</span> Italian-British artists model and painter

Gaetano Giuseppe Faostino Meo was an Italian-British artist's model, landscape painter, and a noted craftsman in mosaic and stained glass. His unpublished autobiography is a useful source for art historians of the Aesthetic Movement and Edwardian Era.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henry Woods (painter)</span> English painter

Henry Woods was a British painter and illustrator, and one of the leading Neo-Venetian school artists.

<i>Science and Charity</i> Painting by Pablo Picasso

Science and Charity is an oil on canvas painting by Pablo Picasso, which he painted in Barcelona in 1897. It is an example of one of Picasso's earliest works, as he painted it when he was only 15 years old. The painting depicts a formal composition of a sick patient in bed, attended by a doctor and a nun holding a child. It was the culmination of Picasso's academic training and displays his talent as an artist before he moved away from this style to pursue his own artistic career. The painting is housed in the collection of the Museu Picasso, Barcelona.

<i>The Lovesick Maiden</i> Painting by Jan Steen

The Lovesick Maiden is a c. 1660 oil-on-canvas genre painting by Jan Steen. It shows a young woman suffering from love-sickness surrounded by her doctor and a maid-servant. It is in the collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas Buzzard</span> Victorian English doctor

Thomas Lovell Buzzard MD FRCP was a Victorian English doctor who worked at the National Hospital, Queen Square. He was a pioneering neurologist who founded an epilepsy society and wrote also on Parkinson's disease. One of the last doctors to be trained through the apprenticeship route, Buzzard witnessed the Crimean War and later was a role model for the famous painting The Doctor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gustavus Murray</span>

Gustavus Charles Philip Murray was a British obstetrician who may have been the inspiration for Luke Fildes' 1891 painting The Doctor. His work in the examination of pregnant women was recognised by Adolphe Pinard in 1889 but ignored in England. He was popular with his patients and had a thriving practice with many professional appointments but as a result wrote little. He died at the age of 56 years from heart failure.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Applicants for Admission to a Casual Ward</span> Painting by Luke Fildes

Applicants for Admission to a Casual Ward is an 1874 oil painting by British painter Luke Fildes, a key work in nineteenth-century British social realism. The painting shows a street scene of impoverished and weary men, women and children waiting by the side of the road outside a police station, huddled against the cold evening, waiting to be given a ticket for temporary admission to a workhouse for the night. Many resisted taking up permanent residence at the workhouse, where men and women would be separated, and would be required to work to pay for their board and lodging; once they entered, many only left when they died. Instead, from 1864, if the police in London certified that a person was genuinely in need, they could stay for one night on a "casual" basis, and leave the next morning, but they would have to queue up again for temporary admission the next evening. Poverty and vagrancy were pressing issues in Victorian London, and the issuance of "casual" tickets doubled from around 200,000 in 1864 to over 400,000 in 1869.

<i>Chesham Street</i> Painting by George Lambert

Chesham Street is a 1910 oil-on-canvas painting by Australian artist George Washington Lambert. The work depicts a doctor performing an auscultation on a man with his shirt lifted and torso exposed. The work was painted at the Rossetti Studios on Flood Street in London. The painting is one of a set of "puzzle pictures" painted by Lambert between 1910 and 1914. These paintings are said to "appear to have a meaning and yet are not strictly narrative; they invite the viewer to provide their own interpretation.".

The man sits boldly in front of the viewer, holding up his shirt and revealing his entire torso. His head is held high, his lips are closed and he looks down at the viewer, seeming somewhat superior. His pale flesh, with the play of light on it, gleams against the dark surroundings.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 "The Doctor by Luke Fildes: an icon in context". Journal of Medical Humanities. 28 (2). ISSN   1573-3645.
  2. "Luke Fildes". Spartacus Educational. Archived from the original on 25 May 2023. Retrieved 4 December 2017.
  3. Rinsler, Albert (1 August 1993). "The Doctor". Journal of Medical Biography. 1 (3): 165–170. doi:10.1177/096777209300100307. PMID   11615259. S2CID   5671206.(subscription required)
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Moore, Jane (1 March 2008). "What Sir Luke Fildes' 1887 painting The Doctor can teach us about the practice of medicine today". Br J Gen Pract. 58 (548): 210–213. doi:10.3399/bjgp08X279571. ISSN   0960-1643. PMC   2249807 . PMID   18318983.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Shankar, Ravi; Morgan, Huw (March 2012). "The Doctor, by Luke Fildes". Academic Medicine. 87 (3): 332–333.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Friedlaender, Linda K.; Friedlaender, Gary E. (2015). "Art in Science: The Doctor by Luke Fildes: Putting the Patient First". Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research. 473 (11): 3355–3359. doi:10.1007/s11999-015-4527-z. PMC   4586218 . PMID   26341896.
  7. The Widower. Art Gallery of New South Wales. Retrieved 7 December 2017.
  8. Sweeney, Patrick J (1998). "The Doctor". The Lancet. 352 (9131): 912. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(05)60059-1 . PMID   9743023. S2CID   44811367.
  9. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Milligan, Barry (September 2016). "Luke Fildes' The Doctor, narrative painting, and the selfless professional ideal". Victorian Literature and Culture. 44 (3): 641–668. doi: 10.1017/S1060150316000097 . ISSN   1060-1503.
  10. 1 2 "The Doctor by Luke Fildes". www.thefamousartists.com. Retrieved 4 December 2017.
  11. Chun, Dongho (31 August 2020). "The Image of the Ideal Doctor: Reviewing Luke Fildes' The Doctor of 1891". Journal of the Association of Western Art History. 53: 59–87. doi:10.16901/jawah.2020.08.53.059. ISSN   1229-2095. S2CID   225267444.
  12. 1 2 "'The Doctor', Sir Luke Fildes, exhibited 1891". TATE. Retrieved 3 December 2017.
  13. Rakel, Robert (2015). Textbook of family medicine. Rakel, Robert E.,, Rakel, David (Ninth ed.). Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier. pp. 3–16. ISBN   9780323239905. OCLC   905231381.
  14. 1 2 Punch, 14 June 1911, p. 461.
  15. The Doctor (with apologies to Sir Luke Fildes, R.A.) (David Lloyd George). National Portrait Gallery. Retrieved 7 December 2017.
  16. 1 2 The Doctor. U.S. National Library of Medicine, Digital Collections. Retrieved 4 December 2017.
  17. Kao, A. C. (1 July 2022). "What Is Represented "Worthily" in Luke Fildes' The Doctor?". AMA Journal of Ethics. 24 (7): E697–713. doi: 10.1001/amajethics.2022.697 . ISSN   2376-6980. PMID   35838401.
  18. A Souvenir of the famous painting "The Doctor", Petrolagar Laboratories, Chicago, 1933.
  19. A Remembrance of the Famous Painting The Doctor by Sir Luke Fildes, R.A.", Petrolagar Laboratories, Chicago, 1933.
  20. The 1951 Vigil. Hahnemann Hospital School of Nursing, Philadelphia, 1951. pp. 97–98.

Commons-logo.svg Media related to The Doctor (1891 painting) at Wikimedia Commons