The History of British India

Last updated

The History of British India
History of British India 1817 James Mill.jpg
Title page of the first edition
Author James Mill
CountryUnited Kingdom
LanguageEnglish
Genre history, political philosophy
PublisherBaldwin, Cradock and Joy
Publication date
1817
Media typePrint
OCLC 898934488
Website vol. I, vol. II, vol. III

The History of British India is a three-volume work by the Scottish historian, economist, political theorist, and philosopher James Mill, charting the history of Company rule in India. The work, first published in 1817, was an instant success and secured a "modicum of prosperity" for Mill. Mill categorized Indian history into the Hindu, Muslim and British periods on the basis of dominant political powers and their religious affiliations. [1] Mill noted that he had never been to India and was unable to speak any Indian languages, though he claimed that this improved the work's moral objective. In the work, Mill frequently denounced Hindu culture and traditions, and it has been seen by historians as an example of anti-Indian sentiments in Britain during the period. [2]

Contents

Genesis

James Mill began writing a work on the history of Company rule in India in 1808, expecting it to take him about seven years, but its completion proved to take instead twelve years, with three substantial volumes eventually being published in early 1818. [2] The work was immediately successful and secured for Mill for the first time a "modicum of prosperity". It led, with the support of David Ricardo and Joseph Hume, to Mill's appointment in 1819 as assistant (later chief) examiner of correspondence at the British East India Company at an annual salary of £800. By 1836, when he died, this income had risen to about £2,000. [2]

Mill's biographer Bruce Mazlish took a practical view of Mill's purpose in beginning to write the work, noting that

By 1802, unable to find a parish and disillusioned with a religious career, he "emigrated" to England. There he quickly obtained a position as editor and writer, married, and began to raise a family. To secure his position, he began to write a great work, The History of British India, in 1806, the same year as his first-born, John Stuart, arrived on the scene... James finally finished The History of British India, and on the basis of it secured the post of an examiner at the East India Company, rising to the top in a few years. [3]

Summary

The History of British India is a monumental work in which James Mill set out to display the history, character, religion, literature, arts, and laws of India, also explaining the influence of the Indian climate. He also aimed to locate the accumulated information on India within a wider theoretical framework. [4] [5]

The work begins with a preface in which Mill notes that he had never visited India and knew none of its native languages. [6] To him, these are guarantees of his objectivity, and he claimed that –

A duly qualified man can obtain more knowledge of India in one year in his closet in England than he could obtain during the course of the longest life, by the use of his eyes and ears in India. [5]

However, Mill goes on in this preface to say that his work is a "critical, or judging history", encompassing singularly harsh judgements of Hindu customs and denouncements of a "backward" culture notable for superstition, ignorance, and the mistreatment of women. [2] [7] His work was influential in the eventual banning by the British of the Hindu tradition of a widow being forced to immolate herself after her husband's death, known as Sati, in 1829.

From the historical perspective, Mill tells the story of the English and, later, British acquisition of wide territories in India, criticising those involved in these acquisitions and in the later administration of the conquered territories, as well as illuminating the harmful effects of commercial monopolies such as those held by the East India Company. [8] As a philosopher, Mill applied political theory to the description of the civilisations of India. His interest is in institutions, ideas, and historical processes, while his work is relatively lacking in human interest, in that he does not seek to paint memorable portraits of Robert Clive, Warren Hastings, and the other leading players in the history of British India, nor of its famous battles. [2] Indeed, the History has been called "a work of Benthamite 'philosophical history' from which the reader is supposed to draw lessons about human nature, reason and religion." [9]

Despite the fact that Mill had never been to India, his work had a profound effect on the British system of governing the country, as did his later official connection with India. [10]

The Orientalist Horace Hayman Wilson edited later editions and extended the history to 1835 with a continuation entitled The History of British India from 1805 to 1835. He also added notes to Mill's work, based on his own knowledge of India and its languages. The History of British India is still in print. [11] [12]

In his introduction to Ungoverned Imaginings: James Mill's The History of British India and Orientalism (1993), historian Javed Majeed argued against "colonialist discourse" approaches to the work, [13] while in James Mill and the Despotism of Philosophy (2009), David McInerney considered how Mill's History of British India relates to Enlightenment historiography and in particular William Robertson's Historical Disquisition Concerning the Knowledge the Ancients had of India. He argues that Mill first published his theory of government in The History of British India, and that in the work Mill's use of history is not rationalist but entails an empirical conception of how historical records relate to the improvement of governance. [14]

Views of Indians

According to historian Thomas Trautmann, "James Mill's highly influential History of British India (1817) – most particularly the long essay 'Of the Hindus' comprising ten chapters – is the single most important source of British Indophobia and hostility to Orientalism." [15] In the chapter titled "General Reflections in 'Of the Hindus'", Mill wrote "under the glosing[ sic ] exterior of the Hindu, lies a general disposition to deceit and perfidy." [16]

Mill's History of British India begins with a remarkable preface. He says that his never having been to India and knowing none of the native languages are an advantage, and a guarantee of his objectivity. But, far from being objective, his is, as he says, a 'critical, or judging history' whose judgements on Hindu customs and practices are particularly harsh. He denounces their 'rude' and 'backward' culture for its ignorance, superstition, and mistreatment of women, and leaves no doubt that he favours a thoroughgoing reform of Indian institutions and practices. [2]

Max Müller argued against the opinion that Indians were an 'inferior race', not only because such a view was wrong but because it made an Englishman's life there a 'moral exile'. One source of such mistaken notions and 'poison' had been, and still was, James Mill's History of British India, which in his view was 'responsible for some of the greatest misfortunes' that had happened to India. Those who were going out to rule India 'should shake off national prejudices, which are apt to degenerate into a kind of madness'.

Editions

Fifth edition

The fifth edition (1858), in ten volumes, is edited by Horace Hayman Wilson. The first six volumes are based on an earlier six volume edition, while volumes seven to nine are based on an earlier three volume edition. The tenth volume is an index volume, split into two indexes, the first index for volumes one to six, the second index for volumes seven to nine.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Mill</span> Scottish intellectual (1773–1836)

James Mill was a Scottish historian, economist, political theorist, and philosopher. He is counted among the founders of the Ricardian school of economics. He also wrote The History of British India (1817) and was one of the prominent historians to take a colonial approach. He was the first writer to divide Indian history into three parts: Hindu, Muslim and British, a classification which has proved surpassingly influential in the field of Indian historical studies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John William Kaye</span> British military historian (1814–1876)

Sir John William Kaye was a British military historian, civil servant and army officer. His major works on military history include a three-volume work on The History of the Sepoy War in India. This work was revised later by George Bruce Malleson and published in six volumes in 1890 as Kaye and Malleson's History of the Indian Mutiny.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Horace Hayman Wilson</span> British Indologist (1786–1860)

Horace Hayman Wilson was an English orientalist who was elected the first Boden Professor of Sanskrit at Oxford University.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Tod</span> Officer of the British East India Company and an Oriental scholar (1782–1835)

Lieutenant-Colonel James Tod was an officer of the British East India Company and an Oriental scholar. He combined his official role and his amateur interests to create a series of works about the history and geography of India, and in particular the area then known as Rajputana that corresponds to the present day state of Rajasthan, and which Tod referred to as Rajast'han.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Third Anglo-Mysore War</span> Conflict between the Kingdom of Mysore and the English East India Company and its allies

The Third Anglo-Mysore War (1790–1792) was a conflict in South India between the Kingdom of Mysore and the British East India Company, the Kingdom of Travancore, the Maratha Empire, and the Nizam of Hyderabad. It was the third of four Anglo-Mysore Wars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Prinsep</span> English scholar, orientalist and antiquary

James Prinsep FRS was an English scholar, orientalist and antiquary. He was the founding editor of the Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal and is best remembered for deciphering the Kharosthi and Brahmi scripts of ancient India. He studied, documented and illustrated many aspects of numismatics, metallurgy, meteorology apart from pursuing his career in India as an assay master at the mint in Benares.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Walter Elliot (naturalist)</span> Scottish civil servant and naturalist

Sir Walter Elliot, KCSI was a British civil servant in colonial India. He was also an eminent orientalist, linguist, archaeologist, naturalist and ethnologist who worked mainly in the Presidency of Madras. Born in Edinburgh, he studied at the East India Company College at Haileybury and joined the East India Company's civil service at Madras in 1820 and worked on until 1860. He was invested Knight Commander of the Order of the Star of India (KCSI) in 1866.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Grant Duff</span> British soldier and historian (1789–1858)

James Grant Duff was a British soldier and historian from Scotland, who was active in British India.

The History of India, as Told by Its Own Historians is a book comprising translations of medieval Persian chronicles based on the work of Henry Miers Elliot. It was originally published as a set of eight volumes between 1867-1877 in London. The translations were in part overseen by Elliot, whose efforts were then extended and edited posthumously by John Dowson.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">R. C. Majumdar</span> Indian historian and academic (1888–1980)

Ramesh Chandra Majumdar was a historian and professor of Indian history. Majumdar is a noted historian of modern India. He was a former Sheriff of Kolkata.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jadunath Sarkar</span> Indian historian

Sir Jadunath Sarkar, was a prominent Indian historian and a specialist on the Mughal dynasty.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">British Raj</span> 1858–1947 British colonial rule on the Indian subcontinent

The British Raj was the rule of the British Crown on the Indian subcontinent; it is also called Crown rule in India, or Direct rule in India, and lasted from 1858 to 1947. The Indian Rebellion of 1857 led to the British Crown assuming direct control of India from the East India Company in the form of the new British Raj through the Government of India Act 1858. The region under British control was commonly called India in contemporaneous usage and included areas directly administered by the United Kingdom, which were collectively called British India, and areas ruled by indigenous rulers, but under British paramountcy, called the princely states. The region was sometimes called the Indian Empire, though not officially.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jalandhar district</span> A district in Punjab, India

Jalandhar district is a district in Doaba region of the state of Punjab, India. The district headquarters is the city of Jalandhar.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Gilchrist (linguist)</span> Scottish linguist, philologist and Indologist

John Borthwick Gilchrist was a Scottish surgeon, linguist, philologist and Indologist. Born and educated in Edinburgh, he spent most of his early career in India, where he made a study of the local languages. In later life, he returned to Britain and lived in Edinburgh and London. In his final years, he moved to Paris, where he died at the age of 81.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cornwallis in India</span> British Army officer in India

British General Charles Cornwallis, the Earl Cornwallis, was appointed in February 1786 to serve as both Commander-in-Chief of British India and Governor of the Presidency of Fort William, also known as the Bengal Presidency. He oversaw the consolidation of British control over much of peninsular India, setting the stage for the British Raj. He was also instrumental in enacting administrative and legal reforms that fundamentally altered civil administration and land management practices there. According to historian Jerry Dupont, Cornwallis was responsible for "laying the foundation for British rule throughout India and setting standards for the services, courts, and revenue collection that remained remarkably unaltered almost to the end of the British era."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bibliography of India</span>

This is a bibliography of notable works about India.

James Talboys Wheeler was a bureaucrat-historian of the British Raj.

The Cambridge History of India was a major work of historical scholarship published in five volumes between 1922 and 1937 by Cambridge University Press. Some volumes were also part of The Cambridge History of the British Empire. Production of the work was slowed by the First World War and the ill health of contributors, and Volume II was eventually abandoned.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henry George Keene (1826–1915)</span>

Henry George Keene was an English historian of medieval and modern India.

<i>Ras Mala</i>

Râs Mâlâ: Hindoo Annals of the Province of Goozerat, in Western India is a 1856 historical work by British colonial administrator Alexander Kinloch Forbes. Divided in two volumes, the work has four sections documenting the history and chronicles from 8th century Gujarat to arrival of British and folk literature of Gujarat as well as an historical account of the place and people he came to know during his stay in Gujarat. It was later translated into Gujarati in 1869.

References

  1. "Explained: Who was Prithviraj Chauhan, the fearless hero of folk legend?". The Indian Express. 2022-05-25. Archived from the original on 2022-05-26. Retrieved 2022-05-26.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Mill, James. 1817. The History of British India, XV. London; Ball, Terence. September 2004. "Mill, James (1773–1836)." In Oxford Dictionary of National Biography . Oxford University Press. doi : 10.1093/ref:odnb/18709.
  3. Mazlish, Bruce, James and John Stuart Mill (Transaction Publishers, 1988 ISBN   978-0-88738-727-2), p. 4 at https://books.google.com Archived 2014-06-26 at the Wayback Machine
  4. The History of British India Archived 2011-06-10 at the Wayback Machine at alibris.com [ verification needed ]
  5. 1 2 Marriott, John, The Other Empire: Metropolis, India and Progress in the Colonial Imagination (Manchester University Press, 2003, ISBN   978-0-7190-6018-2), p. 133 at https://books.google.com Archived 2014-06-26 at the Wayback Machine
  6. Ball, Terence (November 30, 2005). "James Mill". Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2008 edition). Archived from the original on 2013-12-02. Retrieved 2008-12-15.
  7. Narasimhan, Sakuntala (1992-01-01). Sati: Widow Burning in India . Doubleday. ISBN   9780385423175. sati.
  8. The History of British India Archived 2011-06-10 at the Wayback Machine at alibris.com [ verification needed ]
  9. Summary at The History of British India Archived 2021-04-14 at the Wayback Machine page of Online Library of Liberty web site.
  10. The History of British India Archived 2011-06-10 at the Wayback Machine at alibris.com [ verification needed ]
  11. The History of British India Archived 2011-06-10 at the Wayback Machine at alibris.com [ verification needed ]
  12. The History of British India (4th ed.) title details at books.google.com
  13. Grewal, Inderpal. 1993. "Ungoverned Imaginings: James Mill's The History of British India and Orientalism by Javed Majeed" (review). The Journal of Asian Studies 52(4):1060–61
  14. Majeed, Javed. 2009. James Mill and the Despotism of Philosophy. ISBN   978-0-415-95612-3. Lay summary.[ dead link ]
  15. Trautmann, Thomas R. (2006) [1997]. Aryans and British India (2nd Indian ed.). New Delhi: YODA Press. p. 117. ISBN   81-902272-1-1.
  16. Mill, James (1858). The History of British India. Madden. p.  150.

Secondary literature