The Painful Experience

Last updated
The Painful Experience
Kekal - The Painful Experience.jpg
Studio album by
ReleasedOctober 2001
RecordedVision Studio, Jakarta, Indonesia; The Dream Dome, Bandung, Indonesia
Genre Black metal, heavy metal, power metal , progressive metal, thrash metal, symphonic black metal
Length49:52
Label Fear Dark, THT, Clenchedfist, HROM/HIRAX
Producer Jeff/Kekal
Kekal chronology
Embrace the Dead
(1999)
The Painful Experience
(2001)
Chaos & Warfare
(2002)

The Painful Experience is the third full-length studio album by Indonesian extreme metal band Kekal. It marks the transition of Kekal from straightforward melodic black metal to a more distinct progressive metal style, while still retaining the intensity and speed. The title refers to the recording sessions for Embrace the Dead . [1] Guitarist Leo Setiawan left the band before the recording sessions began and moved to Melbourne, Australia, but he was still listed on the album credits as a guitarist due to his contribution to the album's songwriting and general concept. [2] [3] The album was released by four independent labels: Fear Dark in the Netherlands for the European market, Clenchedfist Records in the United States for the North American market, Indonesian label THT Productions for the Southeast Asian market, and HROM/HIRAX for Eastern European market. [4]

Contents

Reception

Professional ratings
Review scores
SourceRating
Arising Realm Magazine6.0/10 [5]
Lords of Metal80/100
Matt MorrowStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar half.svgStar empty.svg [6]
Metal Storm 6/10 [7]
Powermetal.deVery favorable [8]

Kekal experimented greatly on The Painful Experience, and received mixed to positive reviews. The album was praised by critics for its numerous experiments and emotional quality, [6] but was criticized for Jeff's falsetto screaming on some of the songs, which drew comparisons to King Diamond. [9] [10] Austrian magazine Arising Realm Magazine rated the album 6.0 out of 10, stating that the band had potential but that the album was vague. [5] Staff member Promonex of Metal Storm also rated the album 6/10, [7] while Stefan Lang from Powermetal.de viewed the album very favorably. [8] Peter Doorakers of Lords of Metal rated the album 80 out of 100, concluding that "All in all a fine album. The more adventurous black metalfans should give it a try." [11] In 2010, Christian contemporary hard-music music magazine HM Magazine ranked it number 59 on their Top 100 Christian metal albums of all-time list with Lloyd Harp stating about the album: "This Indonesian band's early work was primitive black metal. The Painful Experience took the harshness of black metal, but infused it with lots of melodies and some progressive sensibilities. It hinted at the ground their later works would traverse, but The Painful Experience is perhaps the most successful of their fusion of progressive metal and extreme black metal." [12]

Style

The diverse style of the album includes elements of black, thrash, power, classic, and symphonic black metal. [6] [11] In a recent interview with the band's Facebook staff, Jeff stated that he had forgotten how much energy and intensity he and the other band members put into recording the album. He also admitted that album contains a fair amount of Iron Maiden influence, and that he had been listening to a lot of Iron Maiden material at the time of recording. [13]

Lyrical themes

For this release, the band expanded its lyrical approach to tackle the current socio-political scene in Indonesia. [6] The opening track "The Monsters Within" is based on a true story of an impoverished man who is reduced to stealing but is caught and beaten by a mob. The song "Mean Attraction" is about terrorism and is based on the Indonesian Christmas Eve church bombings of 2000. The title track is about the painfulness of life and how Christians have to take up their cross. [14]

Track listing

All tracks are written by Jeff Arwadi.

No.TitleLength
1."The Monsters Within"4:41
2."Crave for Solid Ground"5:10
3."Mean Attraction"4:17
4."There's No Other Way to Go"4:18
5."Behind Closed Doors"5:49
6."Like After the Storm"5:42
7."Given Words"4:44
8."Militia Christi"4:03
9."The Painful Experience"7:58
10."Via Dolorosa"4:10
Bonus tracks
No.TitleLength
11."Voice from Heaven" (Clenchedfist Records)5:14
12."Like There's No Other Way to Remix" (Fear Dark Records)5:17

Personnel

Line-up:

Additional Credits:

Related Research Articles

<i>Psycho Surgery</i> 1991 studio album by Tourniquet

Psycho Surgery is the second studio album by the American Christian metal band Tourniquet. It was originally released on Intense Records and Metal Blade Records in 1991. A remastered version was released on Pathogenic Records in 2001 as Psychosurgery and includes revised artwork, an expanded album booklet, and bonus tracks that include live versions of songs featuring then-lead vocalist Luke Easter as well as demos; the title was changed since co-founder and drummer Ted Kirkpatrick always felt that it should have been just one. Retroactive Records released a Collector's Edition remaster on June 26, 2020, retaining the original album title and including an extended booklet as well as different bonus tracks. Considered by critics to be Tourniquet's most balanced of the band's first three albums, Heaven's Metal fanzine ranked Psycho Surgery Christian metal's second-best album of all time.

Unblack metal is a religious philosophy and subgenre within black metal, inheriting several characteristics of it, such as the melody, the lyrics and the aesthetics, whose artists either directly oppose the Satanism prevalent in most black metal, or promote Christianity in their lyrics and imagery. Unblack metal artists are controversial within the black metal subculture, because black metal's pioneers, especially those of the Second Wave, were anti-Christian. It is also suggested that Christianity contradicts black metal's dark nature and the individualistic and misanthropic ideals of many bands.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kekal</span> Indonesian metal band

Kekal is a heavy metal and electronic music band formed in 1995 in Jakarta, Indonesia. According to AllMusic, Kekal was one of the first heavy metal bands from Indonesia to make international inroads, and according to sociologist of heavy metal, Keith Kahn-Harris, was one of the few extreme metal bands from Southeast Asia to ever make more than a minimal impression on the global scene. Founded by two musicians known simply Yeris and Newbabe, the band underwent some shifts in lineup in its early years, but emerged with a consistent lineup of three key-members, guitarist/vocalist Jeff Arwadi, bassist Azhar Levi Sianturi, and guitarist Leo Setiawan. Frequently labeled as black metal, progressive metal, and avant-garde metal, Kekal plays a very diverse range of music styles within the frame of metal and rock, incorporating many other music genres such as ambient, electronic, jazz fusion, and progressive rock. Over the course of its career, Kekal has transitioned from a heavy metal-based style to a more experimental and electronic sound.

<i>The Habit of Fire</i> 2007 studio album by Kekal

The Habit of Fire is a 2007 album by Indonesian avant-garde metal band Kekal. Released on 15 May in North America, Japan & Australia and 15 March in Europe & South America, it is their sixth full-length album. The album was constructed during Jeff's move to Canada, and was the last album recorded in his home studio in Indonesia. There is an official music video for the song "Isolated I".

Altera Enigma is a Christian metal band formed by Melbourne, Australia-based Jason De Ron, the former guitarist and front man of Paramaecium, and Jakarta, Indonesia native Jefray Arwadi, former guitarist, vocalist, and front man of Kekal. Both of these musicians have a career that has seen them record and release nearly 20 albums between them. According to Jason De Ron, the name Altera Enigma was chosen because it represents something mysterious and unique. Kenny Cheong, a jazz fusion bassist, joined the project in 2005, and Altera Enigma's first album was released in 2006. Jayson Sherlock, a former band-mate of De Ron in Paramecium and also a former member of the band Mortification and the sole member of Horde, joined on drums in 2007. In 2009, Jeff Arwadi, having relocated from Indonesia to Canada in 2007, decided to step down from the project.

<i>Alteration</i> (album) 2006 studio album by Altera Enigma

Alteration is the debut album by Australian/Indonesian band Altera Enigma, recorded over 2 years and released in January 2006. The emotional and sophisticated style found on the album drew comparisons to Liquid Tension Experiment, Gordian Knot, and Cynic.

<i>Saviour Machine I</i> 1993 studio album by Saviour Machine

Saviour Machine I is the 1993 debut album of the American metal band Saviour Machine. In 2010, HM Magazine ranked it #72 on the Top 100 Christian metal albums of all-time list.

<i>Beyond the Glimpse of Dreams</i> 1998 studio album by Kekal

Beyond the Glimpse of Dreams is the debut album by Indonesian extreme metal band Kekal released in 1998. Vocalist Harry left the band after the album's release.

<i>1000 Thoughts of Violence</i> 2003 studio album by Kekal

1000 Thoughts of Violence is the fourth album by Indonesian extreme metal band Kekal, released in 2003. The central theme of the album is moral decline and the violent nature of humanity. This was the first and only major studio album by the band without the skills of additional guitarist Leo Setiawan.

<i>Acidity</i> (album) 2005 studio album by Kekal

Acidity is the fifth album by Indonesian avant-garde metal band Kekal. It was recorded in celebration of the band's tenth anniversary, and was an official reunion album for the band. It marked the return of guitarist Leo Setiawan to the band, and includes the vocal talents of founding member Newbabe. The album was released following the band's successful 2004 European mini-tour, and a promotional concert and release party was held for the album on 13 March 2005 in Indonesia. It was considered by many to be the band's strongest work to date, and is one of four albums available for free download from the band on its website.

<i>Audible Minority</i> 2008 studio album by Kekal

Audible Minority is the seventh full-length studio album by Indonesian experimental metal band Kekal. According to the band, the album is titled "Audible Minority" because the music on the album is of extreme minority status, and is "entirely bleak, gloom and dark." They also said that the album was constructed over almost two years, during various events in the band members lives. Jeff Arwadi recorded the entire songs on this album all by himself, and started shortly after he moved to Canada in 2006.

<i>Embrace the Dead</i> 1999 studio album by Kekal

Embrace the Dead is the second album by Indonesian extreme metal band Kekal. It reached sold-out status in 2004. On 15 August 2010, a new, remastered limited edition entitled Embrace the Dead 1999 was released as a free download, for up to a 1000 downloads. On 18 May 2012, Kekal made the re-mastered edition available for purchase on Bandcamp, citing exorbitant prices for second-hand copies of the original album on sites like Amazon.

<i>8</i> (Kekal album) 2010 studio album by Kekal

8 is the eighth full-length studio album by Indonesian experimental metal band Kekal, announced on 23 June 2010, and made available for purchase on 23 January 2011. While the band has no officially active members, former members Jeff, Leo, and Levi all contributed to the album. The album was set to be released by Whirlwind Records during December 2010, on CD and as a digital download, and on 15 December 2010, the album was available for pre-order, which included an offer of free shipping within Europe up to December 24.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jeff Arwadi</span> Musical artist

Jefray Kurnia "Jeff" Arwadi is an Indonesian musician, music producer, and graphic designer. A native of Jakarta, Indonesia, he now resides in Calgary, Alberta, Canada. He is mostly known as a former guitarist, vocalist, and record producer for the avant-garde/progressive metal band Kekal. Professionally, he has made a career as a graphic designer and has worked at various companies for more than a decade. In the past, he was also known in the music scene for his works as a freelance graphic designer under Soundmind Graphics, and until his 2006 move to Canada, Jeff owned and ran his own home-based recording studio, Vision Studio, in Jakarta. He also was a staff member of the record label THT Productions. In addition to his roles in Kekal, he was also the co-founder of progressive metal project Altera Enigma and was involved with bands such as Armageddon Holocaust and Inner Warfare.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Azhar Levi Sianturi</span> Musical artist

Azhar Levi Sianturi is an Indonesian musician and mechanical engineer. He is mainly known in the music scene as the former bassist for avant-garde/progressive metal band Kekal. He also has his own grindcore project called Mournphagy. His professional occupation is a mechanical engineer where he makes a living from, and he is also known lately as an avid coffee enthusiast and runs his own coffee roastery and brewing shop in Jakarta called Orkidé Coffee.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Leo Setiawan</span> Musical artist

Leonard "Leo" Setiawan is mainly known as a former guitarist for progressive metal band Kekal. His main occupation is civil engineer and he owns and operates a building development firm in Jakarta, Indonesia.

The discography of the Indonesian band Kekal includes nine full-length studio albums, two EPs, two compilation albums, two demo tapes, a split album with Slechtvalk, and several contributions to various collaborative albums. Though the band currently has no active members, it continues to exist as an institution, and still releases new material.

Armageddon Holocaust was an Indonesian black metal band formed by two musicians known by the pseudonyms Doctor Dark and Dark Thriller.

<i>Autonomy</i> (album) 2012 studio album by Kekal

Autonomy is the ninth full-length studio album by Indonesian experimental metal band Kekal, first released on 19 December 2012 as CD version by German record label Whirlwind Records and then digitally by Indonesian record label Yes No Wave Music on June 29, 2013. This is a second Kekal album being recorded and released without official band members. The digital version of Autonomy can be downloaded for free from Archive.org.

Vardøger was a Christian extreme metal band from Hamar, Norway. Formed in 1994 under the name Hidden Paradise, the members of the band at the time were all involved in other musical projects and so treated Hidden Paradise as a side project. Several songs were written between 1995 and 1997, almost enough for an entire album, and the band changed its name to Vardøger, but the group disbanded before an album could be released. In 2000, the band contributed the symphonic black metal song "Footprints of Thunder" to the compilation album In the Shadow of Death: A Scandinavian Extreme Music Compilation.

References

  1. Kekal (13 August 2010). "Available for Free Download (Limited to 1000 downloads) - Embrace the Dead 1999 - remastered re-issue". Facebook . Retrieved 5 January 2011.
  2. Lang, Stefan (6 January 2002). "KEKAL: Interview mit Jeff" (in German). Powermetal.de. Retrieved 12 February 2011.
  3. Lepouttre, Thomas (a.k.a. AHFish). "Interview with Kekal on Corazine". Corazine.com. Archived from the original on November 20, 2010. Retrieved 5 January 2011.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link) Archived from the original on 20 November 2010, 09:36:11.
  4. Wallach, Jeremy; Berger, Harris M.; Greene, Paul D. (28 November 2011). Metal Rules the Globe: Heavy Metal Music Around the World . Durham: Duke University Press. p.  50. ISBN   9780822347330 . Retrieved 9 May 2012.
  5. 1 2 "Kekal - The Painful Experience". Arising Realm Magazine (in German). Retrieved 12 June 2012.
  6. 1 2 3 4 Morrow, Matt. "Kekal - The Painful Experience". TheWhippingPost. Retrieved 5 January 2011.
  7. 1 2 Promonex. "Kekal - The Painful Experience - Rating details". Metal Storm . Retrieved 12 June 2012.
  8. 1 2 Lang, Stefan (27 December 2001). "Kekal - The Painful Experience". Powermetal.de (in German). Weihrauch Median Verlang. Retrieved 26 April 2012.
  9. Garwood, Russell (12 October 2002). "Kekal Interview - Ultimate Metal Forum". Ultimate Metal Forum. UltimateMetal.com. Retrieved 5 January 2011.
  10. Stevenson, Stewart. "Kekal - 1000 Thoughts of Violence". HM Magazine . Retrieved 5 January 2011. HM review of 1000 Thoughts of Violence. In the review it refers to The Painful Experience.
  11. 1 2 Doorakkers, Peter (May 2002). "Kekal - The Painful Experience". Lords of Metal. Horst Vonberg. Retrieved May 11, 2015.
  12. Van Pelt, Doug (August 2010). "Top 100 Christian metal albums of all time" (PDF). HM Magazine : 25. ISSN   0161-973X.
  13. Kekal (26 September 2010). "Flashback, 15 Years of Kekal (1995 - 2010) - Part V: The Painful Experience". Facebook . Retrieved 5 January 2011.
  14. mpomusic, Lord Rogoth, Negatyfus, Shamgar, Stefan, Natan, Daffie K. (25–30 January 2002). "An interview with... Kekal". Art for the Ears. Retrieved 5 January 2011.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)