The Silent Enemy (1958 film)

Last updated

The Silent Enemy
Silenpos.jpg
Original US release film poster by Reynold Brown
Directed by William Fairchild
Screenplay byWilliam Fairchild
Based onCommander Crabb
by Marshall Pugh
Produced byBertram Ostrer
Raymond Anzarut
Starring Laurence Harvey
Dawn Addams
John Clements
Michael Craig
Sid James
Cinematography Otto Heller
Edited byAlan Osbiston
Music by William Alwyn
Production
company
Distributed by Universal-International
Release date
  • 4 March 1958 (1958-03-04)
Running time
112 minutes
CountryUnited Kingdom
LanguageEnglish

The Silent Enemy is a black and white 1958 British action film directed by William Fairchild and starring Laurence Harvey, Dawn Addams, Michael Craig and John Clements. [1] Based on Marshall Pugh's 1956 book Commander Crabb, the film follows the publicity created by Lionel Crabb's mysterious disappearance and likely death during a Cold War incident 2 years earlier (April 1956).The film depicts events in Gibraltar harbour during the World War II Italian frogman and manned torpedo attacks, although the film's depiction of the events is highly fictionalised[ citation needed ]. It was the first Universal Pictures film in SuperScope.

Contents

Enlisted men refer to Crabb as "Crabbie" throughout, alluding to his crabby nature.

Plot

During the 1941 Italian manned torpedo raid on Alexandria, two British battleships, HMS Queen Elizabeth and HMS Valiant, are severely damaged. The British are worried that this new tactic will afford the Italians naval supremacy in the Mediterranean and the ability to strike their primary target, the Royal Navy base at Gibraltar.

To counter this threat, bomb-disposal expert Lionel Crabb is posted to Gibraltar. He organises a small team of divers to intercept the Italian attacks and defuse the bombs. Meanwhile, from Algeciras in neutral Spain, Italian expert on underwater operations Antonio Tomolino is secretly watching the British base in Gibraltar and planning new attacks.

After the Italians mount a failed attack upon a cruiser in Gibraltar, Crabb and his divers recover one of the manned torpedoes and begin to repair it. Chief Petty Officer Thorpe takes command of physical and diving training.

After a further series of attacks against ships in Gibraltar harbour and an attempt to recover secret documents from a wrecked aircraft, Crabb visits Algeciras to discover the Italians' base of operations. After following a man with an Italian tattoo to the interned Italian ship the Olterra , he discovers that the ship's hold is being used as a workshop and base for the operations. The ship's underwater door is used for the manned torpedoes and by frogmen, which leaves them undiscovered by Spanish authorities. Crabb reports the discovery of the Olterra to his superiors, but under the laws of neutrality, he cannot arrange an attack without top-level authority.

Meanwhile, the Italians plan a major attack on a British convoy. Crabb ignores orders and, with the manned torpedo repaired, he and another diver infiltrate the docks at Algeciras, launching a preemptive strike on the Olterra that destroys the ship, workshop and crew.

The next morning, with the convoy leaving Gibraltar, Thorpe informs Crabb that for his bravery in this operation he has been awarded the George Medal, commenting to his men: "You all deserve a ruddy medal!"

Cast

Production

The film was announced in June 1957. Filming took place in England, Malta and Gibraltar. [2]

Harvey was injured in the leg and hospitalised during filming in Malta. [3]

Michael Craig had been suspended by the Rank Organisation for refusing the lead in The Gypsy and the Gentleman (1958) but was removed from the project after James Woolf of Romulus Films offered Craig's annual salary to Rank. Craig said that Laurence Harvey "was good company, generous to his friends and, in spite of his reputation as a user, I liked him a lot." [4]

Critical reception

The Monthly Film Bulletin wrote: "Free of jingoism and high-flown heroics, The Silent Enemy is more perceptive than most comparable war melodramas, allowing that war is a tragedy which affects both sides. The enemy are shown not as fanatics or political extremists, but simply as men with an irksome job to do. Unfortunately the film fails to present a particularly convincing or authentic picture of Crabb; the main role is played with boyish earnestness and stereotyped heroic style by a bearded Laurence Harvey. Otherwise the film is competent, interesting, often exciting. The underwater scenes, beautifully photographed by Egil Woxholt, forcefully recreate the gloomy, claustrophobic atmosphere of the Mediterranean depths." [5]

The Radio Times Guide to Films gave the film 3/5 stars, writing: "This distinguished British war film celebrates the exploits of celebrated Royal Navy frogman Lt Lionel "Buster" Crabb, played here by Laurence Harvey, whose explosive temperament is a perfect match for the volatile character he plays. The underwater shooting is well done, and the plot has more excitement than many fictional tales. The saga is shot through with a rich vein of humour, a credit to writer/director William Fairchild." [6]

In British Sound Films: The Studio Years 1928–1959 David Quinlan rated the film as "good", writing: "Undemanding war film with excitement and a vein of humour." [7]

British film critic Leslie Halliwell said: "Stereotyped naval; underwater adventures, adequately presented." [8]

Historical inaccuracies

The British divers are shown as using Davis Submerged Escape Apparatus, with the Italians using the British Chariot manned torpedoes rather than Italian Maiale manned torpedoes.

In reality, Crabb spent several months deactivating mines brought ashore by other divers before learning to dive himself.

The real divers did not initially wear fins. Crabb and Knowles were the first to use them after removing them from the Italian chariot divers.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frogman</span> Tactical scuba diver

A frogman is someone who is trained in scuba diving or swimming underwater in a tactical capacity that includes military, and in some European countries, police work. Such personnel are also known by the more formal names of combat diver, combatant diver, or combat swimmer. The word frogman first arose in the stage name the "Fearless Frogman" of Paul Boyton in the 1870s and later was claimed by John Spence, an enlisted member of the U.S. Navy and member of the OSS Maritime Unit, to have been applied to him while he was training in a green waterproof suit.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Submarine films</span> Subgenre of war film

The submarine film is a subgenre of war film in which the majority of the plot revolves around a submarine below the ocean's surface. Films of this subgenre typically focus on a small but determined crew of submariners battling against enemy submarines or submarine-hunter ships, or against other problems ranging from disputes amongst the crew, threats of mutiny, life-threatening mechanical breakdowns, or the daily difficulties of living on a submarine.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diver propulsion vehicle</span> Powered device for diver mobility and range extension

A diver propulsion vehicle (DPV), also known as an underwater propulsion vehicle, sea scooter, underwater scooter, or swimmer delivery vehicle (SDV) by armed forces, is an item of diving equipment used by scuba divers to increase range underwater. Range is restricted by the amount of breathing gas that can be carried, the rate at which that breathing gas is consumed, and the battery power of the DPV. Time limits imposed on the diver by decompression requirements may also limit safe range in practice. DPVs have recreational, scientific and military applications.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ian Edward Fraser</span> Royal Navy Victoria Cross recipient (1920–2008)

Ian Edward Fraser, was an English diving pioneer, sailor and recipient of the Victoria Cross, the highest award for gallantry in the face of the enemy that can be awarded to British and Commonwealth forces. Fraser was born in Ealing in Middlesex and went to school in High Wycombe. After initially working on merchant ships and serving in the Royal Naval Reserve, he joined the Royal Navy at the start of the Second World War. After being awarded the Distinguished Service Cross for actions while serving on submarines, he was placed in command of a midget submarine during an attack in Singapore codenamed Operation Struggle. For his bravery in navigating the mined waters, and successfully placing mines on a Japanese cruiser, Fraser was awarded the Victoria Cross.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Human torpedo</span> Early form of diver propulsion vehicle

Human torpedoes or manned torpedoes are a type of diver propulsion vehicle on which the diver rides, generally in a seated position behind a fairing. They were used as secret naval weapons in World War II. The basic concept is still in use.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Decima Flottiglia MAS</span> Italian naval commando frogman unit of the Fascist era

The Decima Flottiglia MAS was an Italian flotilla, with marines and commando frogman unit, of the Regia Marina created during the Fascist regime.

Italian submarine <i>Scirè</i> (1938) Italian submarine

Italian submarine Scirè was an Adua-class submarine, built in the 1930s which served during World War II in the Regia Marina. It was named after a northern region of Ethiopia, at the time part of Italian East Africa.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Clearance diver</span> Navy diver specialist with explosives

A clearance diver was originally a specialist naval diver who used explosives underwater to remove obstructions to make harbours and shipping channels safe to navigate, but the term "clearance diver" was later used to include other naval underwater work. Units of clearance divers were first formed during and after World War II to clear ports and harbours in the Mediterranean and Northern Europe of unexploded ordnance and shipwrecks and booby traps laid by the Germans.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Luigi Durand de la Penne</span> Italian admiral (1914–1992)

Marquis Luigi Durand de la Penne was an Italian Navy admiral who served as naval diver in the Decima MAS during World War II. He was born in Genoa, where he also died.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Russian commando frogmen</span> Tactical scuba diving unit

The Russian commando frogmen, informally called "commando frogmen" in civilian media, are a Russian Naval Spetsnaz unit under operational subordination to the Main Intelligence Directorate (GRU). It is the special forces unit of the Russian Naval Infantry and is composed of highly trained and elite marines within the Naval Infantry. By virtue of belonging to the Russian Naval Infantry, frogmen fall under the Coastal Troops of the Russian Navy service arm. The Russian Navy proper does not field any special forces or special operations units. Russian FSB special forces Alpha Group and Vympel also have frogman units in their respective naval components.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">British commando frogmen</span> Special Boat Service, whose members are drawn largely from the Royal Marines

Britain's commando frogman force is now the Special Boat Service (SBS), whose members are drawn largely from the Royal Marines. They perform various operations on land as well as in the water. Until the late 1990s, all members of the Special Air Service (SAS) Boat Troop were trained as commando frogmen.

Sydney Knowles, BEM, was a British Royal Navy frogman during and after World War II.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lionel Crabb</span> Royal Navy frogman and MI6 diver

Lieutenant-Commander Lionel Kenneth Phillip Crabb,, known as Buster Crabb, was a Royal Navy frogman and diver who vanished during a reconnaissance mission for MI6 around a Soviet cruiser berthed at Portsmouth Dockyard in 1956.

Italian auxiliary ship<i> Olterra</i> Undercover Italian auxiliary ship from World War II

The auxiliary ship Olterra was a 5,000 ton Italian tanker scuttled by her own crew at Algeciras in the Bay of Gibraltar on 10 June 1940, after the entry of Italy in World War II. She was recovered in 1942 by a special unit of the Decima Flottiglia MAS to be used as an undercover base for manned torpedoes in order to attack Allied shipping at Gibraltar.

Motorised Submersible Canoe WWII British frogman delivery vehicle

The Motorised Submersible Canoe (MSC), nicknamed Sleeping Beauty, was built by the British Special Operations Executive (SOE) during World War II as an underwater vehicle for a single frogman to perform clandestine reconnaissance or attacks against enemy vessels.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kommando Spezialkräfte Marine</span> German postwar commando amphibious warfare force

Naval Special Forces Command, also called the Kampfschwimmer or Verwendungsgruppe 3402 are an elite special operations unit of the German Navy, specializing in commando and amphibious warfare operations. They are the only special-purpose force of the German Navy. The Kampfschwimmer were set up when West Germany joined NATO in 1955 making it the oldest german SOF.

Anthony "Lofty" William Charles Eldridge DSC was a Royal Navy officer of the Second World War who led a human torpedo attack that sank two Japanese ships off Phuket, Thailand, for which he received the Distinguished Service Cross.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Licio Visintini</span> Italian naval officer (1915–1942)

Licio Visintini was an Italian naval officer during World War II. Visintini was decorated for his operations against Allied shipping in Gibraltar during the Battle of the Mediterranean. His brother Mario Visintini was a famous flying ace; both were killed during the war.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Index of underwater divers</span> Alphabetical listing of articles about underwater divers

The following index is provided as an overview of and topical guide to underwater divers:

The Servizio Informazioni Segrete was the intelligence service of the Royal Italian Navy. SIS was instrumental in moulding Italian Army's operations during the Second Italo-Ethiopian War and the Battle of the Mediterranean, primarily due to its cryptanalysis successes and undercover operations.

References

  1. "The Silent Enemy". British Film Institute Collections Search. Retrieved 1 February 2024.
  2. BRITISH PLAN FILM ON 'SILENT ENEMY': Laurence Harvey Will Star in Story Based on Life of Comdr. Lionel Crabb 'Ben Hur' Advances By THOMAS M. PRYOR The New York Times13 June 1957: 37.
  3. James Novel Submitted to Bergman; Injuries Hospitalize Harvey Schallert, Edwin. Los Angeles Times 20 July 1957: B3.
  4. Craig, Michael (2005). The Smallest Giant: An Actor's Life. Allen and Unwin. p. 79.
  5. "The Silent Enemy". The Monthly Film Bulletin . 25 (288): 49. 1 January 1958 via ProQuest.
  6. Radio Times Guide to Films (18th ed.). London: Immediate Media Company. 2017. p. 838. ISBN   9780992936440.
  7. Quinlan, David (1984). British Sound Films: The Studio Years 1928–1959. London: B.T. Batsford Ltd. p. 374. ISBN   0-7134-1874-5.
  8. Halliwell, Leslie (1989). Halliwell's Film Guide (7th ed.). London: Paladin. p. 918. ISBN   0586088946.