The Wall (2011 film)

Last updated

The Wall
Directed by Sophie Robert
Release date
  • 8 September 2011 (2011-09-08)
CountryFrance
LanguageFrench

The Wall is a documentary film made in 2011 by Sophie Robert about autism and psychoanalysis, which became the subject of a court case in France. [1] The alternative full name of the film is The Wall or psychoanalysis put to the test on autism.

The film considers the question of whether psychoanalysis is a suitable treatment for autism. The film argues that while the rest of the world considers autism as a neurological disorder caused by anomalies in a specific area of the brain, in France concepts of the condition remain dominated by psychoanalysis, which sees autism as a form of psychosis caused by difficulties in subjective relationships and ultimately caused by the actions of the mother. The film relies on extensive interviews with 11 French psychoanalysts in order to tease out the details of their beliefs, which the film contrasts with the progress made by children who follow other, behavioural, approaches to improving autistic children's ability to communicate. The film argues that the psychoanalytic approach to autism is based on ignorance and misogyny and leads to harmful consequences for autistic children who fall under the care of psychoanalysts. The film ends with Robert asking the psychoanalysts what an autistic child can realistically expect to gain from a psychoanalytic therapy; the psychoanalysts interviewed are shown not to be able to answer this question coherently.

Three of the psychoanalysts interviewed in the film sued Ms Robert. The three plaintiffs (Eric Laurent, Esthela Solano, and Alexandre Stevens) [2] [3] expressed the view that they hold intellectual property rights to the footage filmed by Ms Roberts and that she edited it without their consent and thus distorted their comments. [4]

The court (Lille Regional Court) found against Robert [5] thus banning the film. [6]

However this ban was overturned by a court of appeal in 2014. [7] The appeal court found that while Robert may have misled the psychoanalysts as to the editorial line her film would take, she had not materially misrepresented their views in her editing of the footage. [8] As of 2016 the film is available for viewing online.

Related Research Articles

The International Psychoanalytical Association (IPA) is an association including 12,000 psychoanalysts as members and works with 70 constituent organizations. It was founded in 1910 by Sigmund Freud, from an idea proposed by Sándor Ferenczi.

Jean Laplanche was a French author, psychoanalyst and winemaker. Laplanche is best known for his work on psychosexual development and Sigmund Freud's seduction theory, and wrote more than a dozen books on psychoanalytic theory. The journal Radical Philosophy described him as "the most original and philosophically informed psychoanalytic theorist of his day."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jean-Claude Maleval</span>

Jean-Claude Maleval is a French Lacanian psychoanalyst, member of the École de la Cause Freudienne and emeritus professor of clinical psychology at the University of Rennes 2.

André Green was a French psychoanalyst.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Françoise Dolto</span> French pediatrician and psychoanalyst

Françoise Dolto was a French pediatrician and psychoanalyst.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Élisabeth Roudinesco</span> French historian (born 1944)

Élisabeth Roudinesco is a French scholar, historian and psychoanalyst. She conducts a seminar on the history of psychoanalysis at the École Normale Supérieure.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Juan-David Nasio</span> French psychoanalyst (born 1942)

Juan-David Nasio is an Argentinian psychiatrist, psychoanalyst and writer. He is one of the founders of Séminaires Psychanalytiques de Paris.

Charles Baudouin was a French psychoanalyst and pacifist. His psychoanalytical work combined Freudianism with elements of the thought of Carl Jung and Alfred Adler.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Moustafa Safouan</span> Egyptian psychoanalyst (1921–2020)

Moustafa or Moustapha Safouan was an Egyptian psychoanalyst.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Antoine Vergote</span> Belgian philosopher

Antoine Vergote, also known as Antoon Vergote, was a Belgian Roman Catholic priest, theologian, philosopher, psychologist and psychoanalyst. He was an Emeritus Professor at the Catholic University of Leuven. His extensive publications span multiple disciplines including psychoanalysis, hermeneutics, philosophical anthropology, linguistics, theology, cultural anthropology, and phenomenology.

Raymond de Saussure was a Swiss psychoanalyst, the first president of the European Psychoanalytical Federation. He is the son of the famous linguist Ferdinand de Saussure, and a student of Sigmund Freud.

Éric Laurent is a French psychoanalyst and former president of the World Association of Psychoanalysis.

Laurent Mottron in France, is a psychiatrist, researcher, and a professor at Montreal University. He is a specialist in cognitive neuroscience research in autism at the University of Montreal.

Jean-Gerard Bursztein is a French psychoanalyst who has a doctorate in philosophy. He teaches psychoanalysis and practices in Paris. He was a student of Jean-Toussaint Desanti and worked on both philosophy of mathematics and philosophy of science. He continues to explore this field in studying the intrication of psychoanalysis and mathematics. On the basis of his practice he has written the following publications :

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Per Magnus Johansson</span>

Per Magnus Johansson is a Swedish psychoanalyst, psychotherapist and historian of ideas. Through his research on the history of psychoanalysis in Sweden, Johansson has contributed to the understanding of the heritage of Sigmund Freud and the psychoanalytical movement in the 20th century. Johansson's psychoanalytical training took place in Paris, where he completed a training analysis with Pierre Legendre. On Pierre Legendres passing in March 2023, Johansson published an obituary in French, Italian and Swedish describing Legendres contributions to the Freudian legacy.

Gabrielle "Gaby" Clerk was a Canadian psychologist and professor of psychology at the Université de Montréal. She was one of the first psychoanalysts in Canada.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Disability in France</span>

Approximately 12 million French citizens are affected by disability. The history of disability activism in France dates back to the French Revolution when the national obligation to help disabled citizens was recognized, but it was "unclear whether or not such assistance should be public or private." Disabled civilians began to form the first associations to demand equal rights and integration in the workforce after the First World War. Between 1940 and 1945, 45,000 people with intellectual disabilities died from neglect in French psychiatric asylums. After the Second World War, parents of disabled children and charities created specialized institutions for disabled children for whom school was not accessible. In 2018, the French Government began to roll out a disability policy which aimed to increase the allowance for disabled adults to €900 per month, improve the digital accessibility of public services, and develop easy-to-read and understand language among other goals.

Annie Anzieu was a French psychoanalyst and essayist who published a series of psychoanalytic studies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Julie Dachez</span> French disability rights advocate

Julie Dachez is a French social psychologist, lecturer and autism rights activist. She's the author of Invisible Differences and Dans ta bulle!. In 2016, she became the first openly autistic person to defend a thesis on the subject in France.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Autism in France</span> The history of autism in France

The history of autism in France is marked by the strong influence of psychoanalysis, and by the persistence of institutionalization practices that violate the fundamental rights of autistic people. According to estimates at the end of 2016, 0.7 to 1% of the French population has an autism spectrum disorder, most of which is undiagnosed, leading to varying degrees of disability.

References

  1. Jolly, David; Novak, Stephanie (19 January 2012). "A French Film Takes Issue With the Psychoanalytic Approach to Autism". The New York Times.
  2. "Chantal Sicile-Kira: French Psychoanalysts Take Legal Action to Ban Film 'The Wall' About Autism". Huffingtonpost.com. 5 December 2011. Retrieved 25 July 2014.
  3. Sicile, Chantal (7 December 2011). "Judge to Hear Request to Ban Film About Autism". Psychology Today. Retrieved 25 July 2014.
  4. "The Wall: History: November 2011: An astounding court summons and the support builds up | Support The Wall – Le Mur". Supportthewall.org. Retrieved 25 July 2014.
  5. "Official: End of the road for soutenonslemur.org and changes for supportthewall.org | Support The Wall – Le Mur". Supportthewall.org. Retrieved 25 July 2014.
  6. "Autism Documentary – The Wall – Banned by French Courts For Exposing Anti-Scientific Quackery". Bock The Robber. 9 February 2012. Retrieved 25 July 2014.
  7. "Le documentaire Le Mur, la psychanalyse à l'épreuve de l'autisme pourra être diffusé". 17 January 2014.
  8. "" le Mur, la psychanalyse à l'épreuve de l'autisme " à nouveau libre de diffusion". Le Monde. 16 January 2014.