Ultrasonic antifouling

Last updated

Ultrasonic antifouling is a technology that uses high frequency sound (ultrasound) to prevent or reduce biofouling on underwater structures, surfaces, and medium. Ultrasound is just high frequency sound (which humans can not hear). Ultrasound has the same physical properties as human-audible sound. The method has two primary forms: sub-cavitation intensity and cavitation intensity. Sub-cavitation methods create high frequency vibrations, whilst cavitation methods cause more destructive microscopic pressure changes. Both methods inhibit or prevent biofouling by algae and other single-celled organisms.

Contents

Background

Ultrasound was discovered in 1794 when Italian physiologist and biologist Lazzarro Spallanzani discovered that bats navigate through the reflection of high frequency sounds. [1] Ultrasonic antifouling is believed to have been discovered by the US Navy in the 1950s[ citation needed ]. During sonar tests on submarines, it is said that the areas surrounding the sonar transducers had less fouling than the rest of the hull [ citation needed ].

Antifouling (the removal of biofouling) has been attempted since ancient times, initially using wax, tar or asphalt. Copper and lead sheathings were later introduced by Phoenicians and Carthaginians." [2] The Cutty Sark is one example of such copper sheathing, available to view in Greenwich, England.

Theory

Ultrasound

Range of sound frequencies including audible and inaudible sound Sound and ultrasound.jpg
Range of sound frequencies including audible and inaudible sound

Ultrasound (ultrasonic) is sound at a frequency high enough that humans can not hear it. Sound has a frequency (low to high) and an intensity (quiet to loud).

Ultrasound is used to clean jewellery, weld rubber, treat abscesses, and sonography. These applications rely on the interaction of sound with the media through which the sound travels. In maritime applications, ultrasound is the key ingredient in sonar; sonar relies on sound at frequences ranging from infrasonic to ultrasonic.

Biofilm

The three main stages are formation of a conditioning biofilm, microfouling and macrofouling. A biofilm is the accretion of single-celled organisms on a surface. This creates a habitat that enables other organisms to establish themselves. The conditioning film collects living and dead bacteria, creating the so-called the primary film. [2]

Ultrasonic antifouling

The two approaches to ultrasonic antifouling are:

Cavitation: Ultrasound of high enough intensity causes water to boil, creating cavitation. This physically annihilates living organizsm and the supporting biofilm. One concern is to the potential effect on the hull. Cavitation [3] can be predicted mathematically through the calculation of acoustic pressure. Where this pressure is low enough, the liquid can reach its vaporisation pressure. This results in localised vaporisation, forming small bubbles; these collapse quickly and with tremendous energy and turbulence, generating heat on the order of 5,000 K (4,730 °C; 8,540 °F) and pressures of the order of several atmospheres. [4] Such systems are more appropriate where power consumption is not a factor, and the surfaces-to-be-protected can tolerate the forces involved.

Sub-cavitation: The sound vibrates the surfaces (e.g. hull, sea chests, water coolers) to which the transducer is attached. The vibrations prevent the cyprid stage of the biofouling species from attaching themselves permanently to the substrate by disrupting the Van Der Waals Force that allow their microvilli to hold themselves to the surface . [5]

Different frequencies and intensities (or power) of ultrasonic waves have varying effects on marine life, such as barnacles, [5] mussels and algae.

Components

The two main components of an ultrasonic antifouling system are:

Applications

Commercial systems are available in a wide range of energies and configurations. All use ceramic piezoelectric transducers as the sound source. Dedicated systems support:

Algae control

Ultrasonic algae control is a commercial technology that has been claimed to control the blooming of cyanobacteria, algae, and biofouling in lakes, and reservoirs, by using pulsed ultrasound. [6] [7] The duration of such treatment is supposed to take up to several months, depending on the water volume and algae species. Despite the experimental demonstration of certain bioeffects in small samples under controlled laboratory and sonication conditions, there is no scientific foundation for outdoors ultrasonic algae control.

It has been speculated that ultrasound produced at the resonance frequencies of cells or their membranes may cause them to rupture. The center frequencies of the ultrasound pulses used in academic studies lie between 20 kHz and 2.5 MHz. [8] The acoustic powers, pressures, and intensities applied vary from low, not affecting humans, [9] [10] to high, unsafe for swimmers. [11]

According to research at the University of Hull, ultrasound-assisted gas release from blue-green algae cells may take place from nitrogen-containing cells, but only under very specific short-distance conditions, which are not representative for intended outdoors applications. [12] In addition, a study by Wageningen University on several algae species concluded that most claims on outdoors ultrasonic algae control are unsubstantiated. [13]

Limitations

Surface Cleaning

Ultrasonic antifouling systems are generally only capable of maintaining a clean surface. They can't clean a surface that already has a well established and mature biofouling infestation. To this end, they are a preventative measure with the goal of an ultrasonic antifouling system being to maintain the protected surface as close to its optimum clean state as possible.

Hull materials

Ultrasonic systems are ineffective on wooden-hulled vessels, or vessels made from ferro-cement as these materials dampen the vibrations from the transducers. Composite hulls with a sandwich construction may also require modification to form monolithic plinths of solid material at each transducer location.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cavitation</span> Low-pressure voids formed in liquids

Cavitation in fluid mechanics and engineering normally refers to the phenomenon in which the static pressure of a liquid reduces to below the liquid's vapour pressure, leading to the formation of small vapor-filled cavities in the liquid. When subjected to higher pressure, these cavities, called "bubbles" or "voids", collapse and can generate shock waves that may damage machinery. These shock waves are strong when they are very close to the imploded bubble, but rapidly weaken as they propagate away from the implosion. Cavitation is a significant cause of wear in some engineering contexts. Collapsing voids that implode near to a metal surface cause cyclic stress through repeated implosion. This results in surface fatigue of the metal, causing a type of wear also called "cavitation". The most common examples of this kind of wear are to pump impellers, and bends where a sudden change in the direction of liquid occurs. Cavitation is usually divided into two classes of behavior: inertial cavitation and non-inertial cavitation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sonar</span> Acoustic sensing method

Sonar is a technique that uses sound propagation to navigate, measure distances (ranging), communicate with or detect objects on or under the surface of the water, such as other vessels.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ultrasound</span> Sound waves with frequencies above the human hearing range

Ultrasound is sound with frequencies greater than 20 kilohertz. This frequency is the approximate upper audible limit of human hearing in healthy young adults. The physical principles of acoustic waves apply to any frequency range, including ultrasound. Ultrasonic devices operate with frequencies from 20 kHz up to several gigahertz.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anti-fouling paint</span> Specialized paint for ship hulls

Anti-fouling paint is a specialized category of coatings applied as the outer (outboard) layer to the hull of a ship or boat, to slow the growth of and facilitate detachment of subaquatic organisms that attach to the hull and can affect a vessel's performance and durability. It falls into a category of commercially available underwater hull paints, also known as bottom paints.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Biofouling</span> Growth of marine organisms on surfaces

Biofouling or biological fouling is the accumulation of microorganisms, plants, algae, or small animals where it is not wanted on surfaces such as ship and submarine hulls, devices such as water inlets, pipework, grates, ponds, and rivers that cause degradation to the primary purpose of that item. Such accumulation is referred to as epibiosis when the host surface is another organism and the relationship is not parasitic. Since biofouling can occur almost anywhere water is present, biofouling poses risks to a wide variety of objects such as boat hulls and equipment, medical devices and membranes, as well as to entire industries, such as paper manufacturing, food processing, underwater construction, and desalination plants.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sonication</span> Application of sound energy

Sonication is the act of applying sound energy to agitate particles in a sample, for various purposes such as the extraction of multiple compounds from plants, microalgae and seaweeds. Ultrasonic frequencies (> 20 kHz) are usually used, leading to the process also being known as ultrasonication or ultra-sonication.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ultrasonic cleaning</span> Method of cleaning using ultrasound

Ultrasonic cleaning is a process that uses ultrasound to agitate a fluid, with a cleaning effect. Ultrasonic cleaners come in a variety of sizes, from small desktop units with an internal volume of less than 0.5 litres (0.13 US gal), to large industrial units with volumes approaching 1,000 litres.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ultrasonic testing</span> Non-destructive material testing using ultrasonic waves

Ultrasonic testing (UT) is a family of non-destructive testing techniques based on the propagation of ultrasonic waves in the object or material tested. In most common UT applications, very short ultrasonic pulse waves with centre frequencies ranging from 0.1-15 MHz and occasionally up to 50 MHz, are transmitted into materials to detect internal flaws or to characterize materials. A common example is ultrasonic thickness measurement, which tests the thickness of the test object, for example, to monitor pipework corrosion and erosion. Ultrasonic testing is extensively used to detect flaws in welds.

In chemistry, the study of sonochemistry is concerned with understanding the effect of ultrasound in forming acoustic cavitation in liquids, resulting in the initiation or enhancement of the chemical activity in the solution. Therefore, the chemical effects of ultrasound do not come from a direct interaction of the ultrasonic sound wave with the molecules in the solution.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Focused ultrasound</span> Non-invasive therapeutic technique

High-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) is a non-invasive therapeutic technique that uses non-ionizing ultrasonic waves to heat or ablate tissue. HIFU can be used to increase the flow of blood or lymph or to destroy tissue, such as tumors, via thermal and mechanical mechanisms. Given the prevalence and relatively low cost of ultrasound generation mechanisms, the premise of HIFU is that it is expected to be a non-invasive and low-cost therapy that can at least outperform care in the operating room.

Sound from ultrasound is the name given here to the generation of audible sound from modulated ultrasound without using an active receiver. This happens when the modulated ultrasound passes through a nonlinear medium which acts, intentionally or unintentionally, as a demodulator.

Megasonic cleaning is a type of acoustic cleaning related to ultrasonic cleaning. It is a gentler cleaning mechanism that is less likely to cause damage. Megasonics are currently used mainly in the electronics industry for preparation of silicon wafers.

Therapeutic ultrasound refers generally to any type of ultrasonic procedure that uses ultrasound for therapeutic benefit. Physiotherapeutic ultrasound was introduced into clinical practice in the 1950s, with lithotripsy introduced in the 1980s. Others are at various stages in transitioning from research to clinical use: HIFU, targeted ultrasound drug delivery, trans-dermal ultrasound drug delivery, ultrasound hemostasis, cancer therapy, and ultrasound assisted thrombolysis It may use focused ultrasound (FUS) or unfocused ultrasound.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ultrasonic transducer</span> Acoustic sensor

Ultrasonic transducers and ultrasonic sensors are devices that generate or sense ultrasound energy. They can be divided into three broad categories: transmitters, receivers and transceivers. Transmitters convert electrical signals into ultrasound, receivers convert ultrasound into electrical signals, and transceivers can both transmit and receive ultrasound.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ultrasonic horn</span>

An ultrasonic horn is a tapering metal bar commonly used for augmenting the oscillation displacement amplitude provided by an ultrasonic transducer operating at the low end of the ultrasonic frequency spectrum. The device is necessary because the amplitudes provided by the transducers themselves are insufficient for most practical applications of power ultrasound. Another function of the ultrasonic horn is to efficiently transfer the acoustic energy from the ultrasonic transducer into the treated media, which may be solid or liquid. Ultrasonic processing of liquids relies of intense shear forces and extreme local conditions generated by acoustic cavitation.

Microbubbles are bubbles smaller than one hundredth of a millimetre in diameter, but larger than one micrometre. They have widespread application in industry, medicine, life science, and food technology. The composition of the bubble shell and filling material determine important design features such as buoyancy, crush strength, thermal conductivity, and acoustic properties.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Copper alloys in aquaculture</span>

Copper alloys are important netting materials in aquaculture. Various other materials including nylon, polyester, polypropylene, polyethylene, plastic-coated welded wire, rubber, patented twine products, and galvanized steel are also used for netting in aquaculture fish enclosures around the world. All of these materials are selected for a variety of reasons, including design feasibility, material strength, cost, and corrosion resistance.

A biomimetic antifouling coating is a treatment that prevents the accumulation of marine organisms on a surface. Typical antifouling coatings are not biomimetic but are based on synthetic chemical compounds that can have deleterious effects on the environment. Prime examples are tributyltin compounds, which are components in paints to prevent biofouling of ship hulls. Although highly effective at combatting the accumulation of barnacles and other problematic organisms, organotin-containing paints are damaging to many organisms and have been shown to interrupt marine food chains.

Microbes can be damaged or killed by elements of their physical environment such as temperature, radiation, or exposure to chemicals; these effects can be exploited in efforts to control pathogens, often for the purpose of food safety.

In-water cleaning, also known as in-water surface cleaning, is a collection of methods for removing unwanted material in-situ from the underwater surface of a structure. This often refers to removing marine fouling growth from ship hulls, but also has applications on civil engineering structures, pipeline intakes and similar components which are impossible or inconvenient to remove from the water for maintenance. It does not generally refer to cleaning the inside of underwater or other pipelines, a process known as pigging. Many applications require the intervention of a diver, either to provide the power, or to direct a powered tool.

References

  1. "The History of Ultrasound". Ultrasound Schools Guide. 21 October 2014. Retrieved 20 January 2021.
  2. 1 2 Nurioglu, Ayda G.; Esteves, A. Catarina C.; De With, Gijsbertus (2015). "Non-toxic, non-biocide-release antifouling coatings based on molecular structure design for marine applications". Journal of Materials Chemistry B. 3 (32): 6547–6570. doi: 10.1039/C5TB00232J . PMID   32262791 . Retrieved 20 January 2021.
  3. ""Acoustic Cavitation Explained – H2oBioSonic"" (PDF).
  4. Environmental Health Perspectives, Vol 64, pp. 233–252, 1985. "Free radical generation by ultrasound in aqueous and nonaqueous solutions. P. Riesz, D. Berdahl, and CL Christman
  5. 1 2 Guo, S. F.; Lee, H. P.; Chaw, K. C.; Miklas, J.; Teo, S. L. M.; Dickinson, G. H.; Birch, W. R.; Khoo, B. C. (2011). "Effect of ultrasound on cyprids and juvenile barnacles". Biofouling. 27 (2): 185–192. doi:10.1080/08927014.2010.551535. PMID   21271409. S2CID   36405913.
  6. Utiger, Taryn (14 April 2015). "Soundwaves kill algae in reservoir". Stuff (company).
  7. "Literature Review of the Effects of Ultrasonic Waves on Cyanobacteria, Other Aquatic Organisms, and Water Quality" (PDF). Wisconsin DNR.Gov.
  8. Kotopoulis S, Schommartz A, Postema M (2008). "Safety radius for algae eradication at 200 kHz 2.5 MHz". 2008 IEEE Ultrasonics Symposium (PDF). pp. 1706–1709. doi:10.1109/ULTSYM.2008.0417. ISBN   978-1-4244-2428-3. S2CID   21382938.
  9. Wu X, Mason TJ (June 2017). "Evaluation of Power Ultrasonic Effects on Algae Cells at a Small Pilot Scale". Water. 9 (7): 470. doi: 10.3390/w9070470 .
  10. Suslick JS, Didenko Y, Fang MM, Hyeon T, Kolbeck KJ, McNamara WB, Wong M (1999). "Acoustic cavitation and its chemical consequences" (PDF). Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A. 357 (1751): 335–353. Bibcode:1999RSPTA.357..335S. doi:10.1098/rsta.1999.0330. S2CID   12355231.
  11. Postema M, Schommartz A (2008). "Ultrasound and swimmer safety". Fortschritte der Akustik: DAGA 2008, 34. Deutsche Jahrestagung für Akustik, 10.-13. März 2008 in Dresden, Deutsche Gesellschaft für Akustik, Mar 2008, Dresden, Germany. Fortschritte der Akustik: 467–468.
  12. Kotopoulis S, Schommartz A, Postema M (2009). "Sonic cracking of blue-green algae". Applied Acoustics. 70 (10): 1306–1312. doi:10.1016/j.apacoust.2009.02.003. S2CID   110406431.
  13. Lürling M, Tolman Y (2014). "Beating the blues: Is there any music in fighting cyanobacteria with ultrasound?". Water Research. 66 (1): 361–373. Bibcode:2014WatRe..66..361L. doi:10.1016/j.watres.2014.08.043. PMID   25240117.