Why Not Me (album)

Last updated

Why Not Me
TheJuddsWhyNotMe.jpg
Studio album by
ReleasedOctober 15, 1984 (1984-10-15)
RecordedMay–July 1984
StudioCreative Workshop
Genre Country [1]
Length31:54
Label RCA Nashville
Producer Brent Maher
The Judds chronology
Wynonna & Naomi
(1984)
Why Not Me
(1984)
Rockin' with the Rhythm
(1985)
Singles from Why Not Me
  1. "Why Not Me"
    Released: September 1984
  2. "Girls Night Out"
    Released: January 1985
  3. "Love Is Alive"
    Released: May 1985

Why Not Me is the debut studio album by American country music duo the Judds. It was released on October 15, 1984, by RCA Nashville and was produced by Brent Maher. Why Not Me was recorded in a traditional acoustic format using only a handful of musicians. It contained a collection of ten tracks, including their previously released single, "Mama He's Crazy." It also included three singles that would become number one hits: the title track, "Girls' Night Out" and "Love Is Alive."

Contents

Why Not Me received positive reviews from critics following its release. Critics praised the album's production detail as well as the duo's vocal harmonies. The album topped the Billboard country albums chart and reached other charts as well. The record would become the Judds' first full-length studio album and their most successful studio release to date. It has since received sales certifications from both the United States and Canada. The album has been reissued several times in different formats.

Background

In 1983, the Judds (mother Naomi and daughter Wynonna Judd) signed their first recording contract with RCA Records in Nashville, Tennessee. The same year, they recorded their first album, a collection of six songs that comprised a "mini-album" entitled Wynonna & Naomi. The album included the duo's first major hit, "Had a Dream (For the Heart)." However, RCA had yet to release a full-length album by the pair. [2] [3] With the success of their debut single, the mother-daughter team were informed by RCA they would release their first full-length album. In addition, the label was going to include "Mama He's Crazy," a single that had been spawned from their mini-album offering. A music video was also to be made in correlation with the promotion of the record. [4]

Content and recording

The Judds recorded Why Not Me between May and July 1984 at the Creative Workshop, a studio located in Nashville. The duo had previously cut Wynonna & Naomi at the same location in sessions produced by Brent Maher. He would also produce their debut studio offering. [5] Maher co-wrote the album's title track with Harlan Howard and Sonny Throckmorton. In her 1993 autobiography, Naomi Judd considered the song to have "one of the strongest melodic hooks I'd ever heard." Bandleader and guitarist, Don Potter, created guitar "licks," which Judd called in her book to be "a little slice of heaven." [6] Also included on the album was Naomi Judd's song entitled "Mr. Pain." According to Judd, the song merged the stories of her friends' previous relationships and the conflicts that arose from them. Songwriter Kent Robbins collaborated with Judd on the track. He also wrote the song "Love Is Alive" for the album as well. Also included was a cover version of Jody Reynolds' "Endless Sleep." [5]

In addition, Maher and Potter collaborated on the track "Sleeping Heart," which Judd called "sweetly sad" in her autobiography. [6] Also included was the song "Bye Bye Baby Blues", which was also written in collaboration between Harlan Howard, Brent Maher and Sonny Throckmorton. [5] As a producer, Maher chose a select group of session musicians for the album's recording. [1] This included Don Potter, as well as Eddie Bayers on drums, Mark Casstevens on guitar, Bobby Ogdin on keyboards and Sonny Garrish on steel guitar. These musicians (among others) were previously included on the sessions for the duo's Wynnona & Naomi album. [5] According to Judd's autobiography, Maher "liked to leave the room for the listener's imagination," with the use of minimal acoustic arrangements. [7] Maher himself later commented on the album in an interview explaining that the album has withstood the test of time. He also commented that he was happy to have worked with the Judds in creating their first full-length studio project. [8]

Critical reception

Professional ratings
Review scores
SourceRating
AllMusic Star full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svg [1]
Robert Christgau B [9]

Why Not Me received mostly positive reviews from critics following its release. In October 1984, Billboard magazine took notice of the album's attention to detail and highlighted several tracks in their review: "The meteoric success story of this duo is no accident. It's predicated on exactly the kind of purity, acoustic brilliance and attention to detail that shines here on the sisters' first full album". [10] Music journalist Robert Christgau gave the album a mostly favorable response, but disliked the production style at times, giving it a "B" rating: "After defying convention by indulging not a single soppy song on their tryout EP, they've flabbed the follow-up several times. And I bet they get even more complacent." [9]

AllMusic's Thom Jurek called the album a "bona fide classic" and praised its "soaring harmonies" as well as the lead vocals from Wynonna Judd. He also noticed a connection between neo-traditional country and classic country from the early 60s, drawing comparisons to Patsy Cline. Jurek concluded by saying, "Of all their recordings, Why Not Me is their best-known, best-selling, and deservedly so. It's perfect." [1]

Release and chart performance

Prior to its release, "Mama He's Crazy" had already become a number one single on the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart. [2] In September 1984, the title track was released as the first proper single. [11] It spent a total of 22 weeks on the Billboard country songs chart before also reaching the top position that December. [12] The song also peaked at number three on the Canadian RPM Country Singles chart. [13] On October 15, 1984, the album itself was officially released on RCA Records. [5] The album was issued originally as a vinyl LP, cassette and compact disc. In February 1985, the album reached number one on the Billboard Top Country Albums chart, becoming their first album to do so in their career. It would spend a total of 195 weeks on the list. [14] In March 1985, Why Not Me peaked at number 71 on the Billboard 200 albums chart after a 26-week run. [15]

With the success of the title track, "Girls' Night Out" was issued as the album's second single in January 1985. [11] Spending 22 weeks on the Billboard country chart, it also topped the list. [16] It reached the same position on the Canadian country singles chart as well. [13] "Love Is Alive" was released in May 1985 and was the album's final single spawned. [11] By August, the song had also topped the Billboard country chart and the became the duo's fourth number one single. [17] [11] It was the duo's third number one single in Canada as well. [13] Why Not Me was also the Judds' first studio album to sell beyond 500,000 copies in the United States. In April 1985, the album certified gold for this sales achievement by the Recording Industry Association of America. In 1986, the company certified the album platinum in sales for exceeding one million copies. Then, in 1992 Why Not Me received a certification of two-times platinum for sales exceeding two million copies. [18]

Track listing

Vinyl version

Side one
No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Why Not Me"3:29
2."Mr. Pain"3:17
3."Drops of Water"Roy Freeland3:24
4."Sleeping Heart"3:03
5."My Baby's Gone" Dennis Linde 2:48
Side two
No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Bye Bye Baby Blues"
  • Howard
  • Maher
  • Throckmorton
2:52
2."Girls Night Out"
  • Jeffrey Bullock
  • Maher
2:50
3."Love Is Alive"Robbins3:54
4."Endless Sleep"
3:06
5."Mama He's Crazy" Kenny O'Dell 3:14

Cassette version

Side one
No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Why Not Me"
  • Howard
  • Maher
  • Throckmorton
3:29
2."Mr. Pain"
  • Judd
  • Robbins
3:17
3."Drops of Water"Freeland3:24
4."Sleeping Heart"
  • Fleming
  • Potter
3:03
5."My Baby's Gone"Linde2:48
Side two
No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Bye Bye Baby Blues"
  • Howard
  • Maher
  • Throckmorton
2:52
2."Girls Night Out"
  • Bullock
  • Maher
2:50
3."Love Is Alive"Robbins3:54
4."Endless Sleep"
  • Nance
  • Reynolds
3:06
5."Mama He's Crazy"O'Dell3:14

Compact disc versions

Why Not Me (1996) (2003) [5]
No.TitleWriter(s)Length
1."Why Not Me"
  • Howard
  • Maher
  • Throckmorton
3:29
2."Mr. Pain"
  • Judd
  • Robbins
3:17
3."Drops of Water"Freeland3:24
4."Sleeping Heart"
  • Fleming
  • Potter
3:03
5."My Baby's Gone"Linde2:48
6."Bye Bye Baby Blues"
  • Howard
  • Maher
  • Throckmorton
2:52
7."Girls Night Out"
  • Bullock
  • Maher
2:50
8."Love Is Alive"Robbins3:54
9."Endless Sleep"
  • Nance
  • Reynolds
3:06
10."Mama He's Crazy"O'Dell3:14

Personnel

All credits are adapted from the liner notes of Why Not Me. [5]

The Judds

Musical personnel

Technical personnel

Charts

Certifications

RegionCertification Certified units/sales
Canada (Music Canada) [24] Platinum100,000^
United States (RIAA) [25] 2× Platinum2,000,000^

^ Shipments figures based on certification alone.

Release history

RegionDateFormatLabelRef.
United StatesOctober 15, 1984Vinyl
Cassette
Compact disc
CanadaVinyl
Cassette
GermanyRCA Records
South Korea
United States1996Compact disc
2003Curb Records [5]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wynonna Judd</span> American country singer (born 1964)

Wynonna Ellen Judd, or simply Wynonna, is an American country music singer. She is one of the most widely recognized and awarded female country musicians in history. In all, she has had 19 No. 1 singles, including those with The Judds, making her one of the best-selling country artists of all time. Her solo albums and singles are all credited to—and performed under—the singular stage name, Wynonna. She first rose to fame in the 1980s alongside her mother, Naomi, in their mother-daughter country music duo, The Judds. They released seven albums on Curb Records, in addition to 26 singles, of which 14 were No. 1 hits.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The Judds</span> American country music duo

The Judds were an American country music duo composed of lead vocalist Wynonna Judd and her mother, Naomi Judd. The duo signed to RCA Nashville in 1983 and released six studio albums between then and 1991. The Judds were one of the most successful acts in country music history, winning five Grammy Awards for Best Country Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocal, and nine Country Music Association awards. They also charted more than twenty singles on the Billboard Hot Country Songs charts, including fourteen that went to number one. After eight years as a duo, the Judds disbanded in 1991 after Naomi was diagnosed with Hepatitis C. Wynonna began a solo career soon after, although she and her mother reunited on multiple occasions.

<i>River of Time</i> (The Judds album) 1989 studio album by the Judds

River of Time is the fifth studio album by American country music duo the Judds, released on April 4, 1989 via RCA/Curb Records. It features the singles "Young Love ," "Let Me Tell You About Love," "One Man Woman" and "Guardian Angels." While the first two singles reached #1 on the country charts, the latter two peaked at #8 and #16 respectively, with "Guardian Angels" being their first single since 1983's "Had a Dream " to miss Top Ten. "Do I Dare" is not included on the cassette or vinyl versions.

<i>Heartland</i> (The Judds album) 1987 studio album by The Judds

Heartland is the third studio album by American country music duo The Judds, released on February 3, 1987 via RCA/Curb Records. It features the singles "Don't Be Cruel", "Maybe Your Baby's Got The Blues", "Turn It Loose", and "I Know Where I'm Going". The album was released in Europe under the title Give a Little Love and featured six bonus tracks. It reached number 1 on England's country albums chart in 1987, soon after The Judds toured there.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The Judds discography</span> Band discography

American country music duo The Judds released six studio albums, three live albums, 18 compilation albums, five video albums, two extended plays, one box set, five music videos, 29 singles and 1 album appearance. The duo consisted of mother, Naomi Judd, and her daughter, Wynonna Judd. The pair signed a recording contract with RCA Nashville in 1983. Later that year, their debut single was released called "Had a Dream ". Their next release, "Mama He's Crazy", became their first number one hit on the Billboard Hot Country Singles & Tracks chart. The song's success led to the release of their debut EP in 1984. It peaked at number eight on the Billboard Top Country Albums chart. In October 1984, their debut studio album was released entitled Why Not Me. It peaked at number one on the country albums chart and number 71 on the Billboard 200. Why Not Me would sell over two million copies. It also spawned three number one country hits: the title track, "Girls' Night Out" and "Love Is Alive".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wynonna discography</span> Discography

The discography of American country music artist Wynonna contains nine studio albums, four compilation albums, two video albums, one live album, one extended play (EP), 43 singles, 11 music videos and one other-charting song. She achieved success as one half of the mother-daughter duo, The Judds. In 1991, the duo split and Wynonna signed a solo recording contract with MCA Records that year. In March 1992, her debut studio album entitled Wynonna reached number one on the Billboard Top Country Albums chart and number four on the Billboard 200. The album spawned three number one hits on the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart: "She Is His Only Need," "I Saw the Light" and "No One Else on Earth." The album also sold over five million copies. In 1993, it was followed by Tell Me Why, which certified platinum in the United States. It also topped the country albums chart and reached number five on the Billboard 200 It spawned five more top ten country hits, including the title track and "Rock Bottom."

<i>Wynonna & Naomi</i> 1984 EP by The Judds

Wynonna & Naomi is the first extended play by American country duo The Judds. It was released in February 1984 by RCA Nashville and was produced by Brent Maher. It was the duo's first album release in their career and would be followed later in the year by their first full-length album, Why Not Me. The album was part of a "mini-album" marketing strategy designed by RCA to promote up-and-coming acts on their roster.

"My Strongest Weakness" is a song written by Naomi Judd and Mike Reid, and recorded by American country music artist Wynonna. It was released in December 1992 as the fourth and final single from Wynonna's self-titled debut album. The song peaked at number 4 on the Billboard Hot Country Singles & Tracks charts.

<i>Sing: Chapter 1</i> 2009 studio album by Wynonna Judd

Sing: Chapter 1 is the seventh studio album from country music singer Wynonna Judd, released on February 3, 2009. It is her seventh solo studio album and the follow-up to her 2003 album What the World Needs Now Is Love and her holiday-themed 2006 release A Classic Christmas. This release celebrates Wynonna's 25th Anniversary in the music business.

"Change of Heart" is a song written by Naomi Judd, and recorded by American country music duo The Judds on their debut January 1984 extended play, Wynonna & Naomi. It was re-released in October 1988 as the second single from their Greatest Hits compilation album. The song was their twelfth number one country single. The single went to number one on the Billboard Hot Country Singles for one week and spent a total of fifteen weeks on the country chart.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Let Me Tell You About Love</span> 1989 single by The Judds

"Let Me Tell You About Love" is a song written by Carl Perkins, Paul Kennerley and Brent Maher, and recorded by American country music duo The Judds. It was released in June 1989 as the second single from the album River of Time. The song was The Judds' fourteenth and final number one on the country chart. The RCA/Curb single, 8947-7-R, b/w "Water of Love", went to number one for one week and spent a total of fifteen weeks on the country chart. The record also reached number one on the Canadian RPM Country Tracks chart.

"Born to Be Blue" is a song written by Mike Reid, Brent Maher and Mack David, and recorded by American country music duo The Judds. It was released in August 1990 as the first single from the album Love Can Build a Bridge. The song reached number 5 on the Billboard Hot Country Singles & Tracks chart.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Girls with Guitars</span> 1994 single by Wynonna Judd

"Girls with Guitars" is a song written by Mary Chapin Carpenter, and recorded by American country music artist Wynonna. It was released in June 1994 as the fifth single from the album Tell Me Why. The song reached number 10 on the Billboard Hot Country Singles & Tracks chart. Judd's mother, Naomi Judd, and Lyle Lovett sing background vocals on the song.

"I Will Stand by You" is a song written by Steven Lee Olsen and Robert Ellis Orrall. It was recorded by Canadian country group High Valley and released as the lead single to the group's second self-titled album in early 2010. The song reached the top 20 of the Billboard Canada Country chart. The song was also recorded by American country duo The Judds and released as a single in September 2010. The song was the only single released off of the 2011 compilation album, I Will Stand by You: The Essential Collection.

<i>The Judds Reunion Live</i> 2000 live album by The Judds

The Judds Reunion Live is the second live album by American country duo The Judds. It was released on May 9, 2000, in conjunction with Curb Records and Mercury Records. It was produced by Larry Strickland and contained a total of 23 tracks. Reunion Live was the duo's second live effort issued in their career and their first album as a duo in almost ten years.

<i>Collectors Series</i> (The Judds album) 1990 compilation album by The Judds

Collector's Series is a compilation album by American country duo The Judds. It was released on August 21, 1990 via Curb Records and RCA Nashville. It was produced by Brent Maher and consisted of eight tracks of previously-recorded material. The album was part of RCA's "Collector's Series" compilations, which had also been released by several artists.

<i>From the Heart: 15 Career Classics</i> 1992 compilation album by The Judds

From the Heart: 15 Career Classics is a compilation album by American country duo The Judds. It was released in 1992 by the Curb and RCA Nashville labels. The album was co-produced by Brent Maher, Norman Miller and Paul White. From the Heart was the duo's first album exclusively released for the Canadian market. It contained a total of 15 tracks and reached Canadian record chart positions following its release.

<i>Reflections</i> (The Judds album) 1994 compilation album by The Judds

Reflections is a compilation album by American country duo The Judds. It was released on August 16, 1994 via Curb and RCA Nashville. It was mostly produced by Brent Maher, but also included some assistance from Don Potter. Reflections was The Judds's sixth compilation release in their career and among several to reach a charting position on a Billboard survey.

<i>Number One Hits</i> (The Judds album) 1994 compilation album by The Judds

Number One Hits is a compilation album by American country music duo The Judds. It was released on October 25, 1994 on the Curb and RCA Nashville labels. The album contained music produced by Brent Maher and Don Potter. Number One Hits was the eleventh compilation released in The Judds's discography. It contained 12 of their number one hits on the country charts during the 1980s. The album itself also reached major chart positions and sales certifications.

<i>Great Video Hits of The Judds</i> 1990 video by The Judds

Great Video Hits of The Judds is a video album by American country music duo The Judds. It was released in 1990 by RCA Nashville. It was the duo's second video album released in their career and their second to sell over 500,000 copies in the United States. The album contained the duo's music videos released from the RCA label.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Jurek, Thom. "Why Not Me: The Judds: Songs, Reviews, Credits". Allmusic . Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  2. 1 2 Huey, Steve. "The Judds: Biography & History". Allmusic . Retrieved November 10, 2020.
  3. Judd, Naomi & Schaetzle, Bud 1993, p. 260-61.
  4. Judd, Naomi & Schaetzle, Bud 1993, p. 283.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Judds, The (October 15, 1984). "Why Not Me (2003 CD Liner Notes and Album Information)". RCA Records .
  6. 1 2 Judd, Naomi & Schaetzle, Bud 1993, p. 287.
  7. Judd, Naomi & Schaetzle, Bud 1993, p. 288.
  8. Thompson, Gayle. "The Judds' Why Not Me Goes Platinum". The Boot. Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  9. 1 2 Christgau, Robert. "Robert Christgau: CG: The Judds (from Consumer Guide)". Robert Christgau. Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  10. "Reviews". Billboard . Vol. 96, no. 42. October 27, 1984. p. 62. Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  11. 1 2 3 4 Whitburn, Joel (2008). Hot Country Songs 1944 to 2008. Record Research, Inc. ISBN   978-0-89820-177-2.
  12. ""Why Not Me" chart history". Billboard . Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  13. 1 2 3 "Results - RPM - Library and Archives Canada (Country Singles)". RPM . Retrieved November 27, 2010.
  14. "Why Not Me chart history (Country Albums)". Billboard . Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  15. "Why Not Me chart history (Billboard 200)". Billboard . Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  16. ""Girls' Night Out" chart history". Billboard . Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  17. ""Love Is Alive" chart history". Billboard . Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  18. "Gold & Platinum -- The Judds". Recording Industry Association of America . Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  19. "Results - RPM - Library and Archives Canada (Top Albums/CDs)". RPM . Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  20. "The Judds Chart History (Billboard 200)". Billboard. Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  21. "The Judds Chart History (Top Country Albums)". Billboard. Retrieved November 14, 2020.
  22. "Top Country Albums – Year-End 1985". Billboard. Retrieved June 7, 2021.
  23. "Top Country Albums – Year-End 1986". Billboard. Retrieved June 9, 2021.
  24. "Canadian album certifications – The Judds – Why Not Me". Music Canada.
  25. "American album certifications – The Judds – Why Not Me". Recording Industry Association of America.

Books

  • Judd, Naomi; Schaetzle, Bud (1993). Love Can Build a Bridge. New York: Villard Books. ISBN   0-679-41247-6.