Discourses Concerning Government

Last updated
Title page of Discourses Concerning Government, 1698 Algernon Sidney 1622-1683 Discourses 1698.jpg
Title page of Discourses Concerning Government, 1698

Discourses Concerning Government is a political work published in 1698, and based on a manuscript written in the early 1680s by the English Whig activist Algernon Sidney who was executed on a treason charge in 1683. It is one of the treatises on governance produced by the Exclusion Crisis of the last years of the reign of Charles II of England. [1] Modern scholarship regards the 1698 book as "fairly close" to Sidney's manuscript. [2] According to Christopher Hill, it "handed on many of the political ideas of the English revolutionaries to eighteen-century Whigs, American and French republicans." [3]

Contents

Views

The Discourses was written in the period when John Locke was working on his Second Treatise on Government , and the books have common features. They have been described together as "essentially radical and popular theories of resistance." [4] Jonathan Scott, however, has proposed that Sidney was "far more inclined to commonwealth principles and far more predisposed to resistance" than Locke. [5] Mihoko Suzuki mentions "the lasting importance of the English Revolution and radical Protestantism" for "Sidney's political thought and his commitment to republican principles." [6] He was included in the "Whig canon" of writers introduced by Caroline Robbins, with principles in line with those of radical dissidents from the 1689 Settlement of the English monarchy. [7]

Leopold von Ranke's History of England (in the translation by the School of Modern History at Oxford) [8] stated that:

The work, more discursive than systematic in its character, contains the results of many varied studies, as far as the existing learning made them in any way possible; it offers wide prospects and general points of view, but bears at the same time the character of the moment, and is founded on the disputes of the time. [9]

Ranke's summation in the English context is "His idea is first of all to restrain the monarchy within the narrowest limits." [9]

Scott A. Nelson, editor of the 1993 edition of the Discourses, commented:

The text displays a disorganized prose that must have been worthless as a tract of insurrection. But a careful reading displays a remarkably consistent view of government [...] [10]

Contra Patriarcha

The Discourses is explicitly a rebuttal of Patriarcha, or The Natural Power of Kings , a work published in 1680 by the political theorist Robert Filmer, who had died in 1659. It seeks support from authors criticised by Filmer, such as George Buchanan and Hugo Grotius. [11] Ranke states that Sidney opposed Filmer "in every point". [9]

Sidney's real target in the work was absolutism. [11] While he concedes that absolute monarchy is an institution with Biblical support, and equates it with Plato's political philosophy, he denies that hereditary monarchy has any such standing. [12] On the spectrum of English representatives of classical republicanism of the time, Scott places Sidney with John Milton as "moral humanists". [13] Nicholas von Maltzahn considers that Sidney's was "a voice closer to Milton's than any other in the Restoration, one sharing his republican vocabulary and priorities to a remarkable degree." [14]

Scott writes:

Sidney's reply to Filmer is an attack on the political system of inheritance, and its substitution with a politics of virtue [...] [15]

Sidney took the view in the Discourses that the government of the Rump Parliament, in which he sat,"produced more examples of pure, complete, incorruptible, and invincible virtue than Rome oe Greece could ever boast". [16] He argues in the Discourses that "the variety of forms of government between mere democracy and absolute monarchy is almost infinite", that good government is always a blend (of monarchy, aristocracy and democracy), and that Filmer was narrow and short-sighted. [17]

Influence and Sidney's reputation

Worden writes in The Cambridge History of Political Thought that the influence of the Discourses was "probably wider than that of any other republican work of the seventeenth century." [18] An extended review by Jacques Bernard appeared in three successive issues of Nouvelles de la république des lettres in 1700. Discours sur le gouvernement, a French translation in three volumes of the Discourses, was published at The Hague in 1702. [19] Sidney was praised in works of 1719 by Gottlieb Treuer (de:Gottlieb Treuer) and of 1720 by Thémiseul Saint-Hyacinthe (fr:Thémiseul de Saint-Hyacinthe). [20] [21]

Sidney was one of the republican writers cited by Henry St John, 1st Viscount Bolingbroke in his works Remarks on the History of England (1730–31) and A Dissertation upon Parties (1733–34) discussing the ancient constitution of England. [22] He was one of the republican influences on Alberto Radicati, an exile from Piedmont of the 1720s who came to London. [23] [24] [25]

Pocock in The Machiavellian Moment calls Sidney in the Discourses

"... a voice from the past, recalling the Good Old Cause of the fifties and even the Tacitism of an earlier generation still, condemn[ing] absolute monarchy for corrupting the subject and equat[ing] virtue with a framework of mixed government so austerely defined as to be virtually an aristocratic government. [26]

Trevor Colbourn writes that Sidney's political thought was a significant influence on Andrew Eliot, Jonathan Mayhew, Sam Adams and Josiah Quincy, Jr. [27] The Discourses was in the personal libraries of John Adams, Robert Carter I, Robert Carter III and Thomas Jefferson (listed in 1771). [28] Adams in particular was "a lifelong Sidney enthusiast". But in the later 18th century, French republican radicals found that "his arguments were no longer relevant." [29]

Notes

  1. ↑ Ashcraft, Richard (13 July 2021). Revolutionary Politics and Locke's Two Treatises of Government. Princeton University Press. p. 183. ISBN   978-1-4008-2342-0.
  2. ↑ Brown, Michael (30 September 2015). A Political Biography of John Toland. Routledge. p. 50. ISBN   978-1-317-31486-8.
  3. ↑ Hill, Christopher (31 January 2017). The Experience of Defeat: Milton and Some Contemporaries. Verso Books. p. 16. ISBN   978-1-78478-670-0.
  4. ↑ Adams, Sharon; Goodare, Julian (2014). Scotland in the Age of Two Revolutions. Boydell & Brewer Ltd. p. 169. ISBN   978-1-84383-939-2.
  5. ↑ Marshall, John (11 August 1994). John Locke: Resistance, Religion and Responsibility. Cambridge University Press. p. 229. ISBN   978-0-521-46687-5.
  6. ↑ Suzuki, Mihoko (2019). Did the English Seventeenth Century Really End at 1660? Subaltern Perspectives on the Continuing Impact of the English Civil Wars, in Early Modern Histories of Time: The Periodizations of Sixteenth- and Seventeenth-Century England. University of Pennsylvania Press. p. 241. ISBN   978-0-8122-5152-4.
  7. ↑ Pocock, J. G. A. (24 April 1987). The Ancient Constitution and the Feudal Law: A Study of English Historical Thought in the Seventeenth Century. Cambridge University Press. p. 364. ISBN   978-0-521-31643-9.
  8. ↑ Gadd, Ian Anders; Eliot, Simon; Louis, William Roger; Robbins, Keith (November 2013). History of Oxford University Press: Volume II: 1780 to 1896. OUP Oxford. p. 569. ISBN   978-0-19-954315-1.
  9. 1 2 3 Ranke, Leopold von (1875). The later years of Charles II, 1674. Vol. IV. Clarendon Press. p. 123.
  10. ↑ Nelson, Scott A. (1993). The Discourses of Algernon Sidney. Fairleigh Dickinson Univ Press. p. 155. ISBN   978-0-8386-3438-7.
  11. 1 2 Falcão, Luís (27 August 2020). Algernon Sidney between Modern Natural Rights and Machiavellian Republicanism. Cambridge Scholars Publishing. pp. 9–10. ISBN   978-1-5275-5876-2.
  12. ↑ Pangle, Thomas L. (15 October 1990). The Spirit of Modern Republicanism: The Moral Vision of the American Founders and the Philosophy of Locke. University of Chicago Press. p. 65. ISBN   978-0-226-64547-6.
  13. ↑ Scott, Jonathan (20 January 2005). Algernon Sidney and the English Republic 1623-1677. Cambridge University Press. p. 15. ISBN   978-0-521-61195-4.
  14. ↑ Armitage, David; Himy, Armand; Skinner, Quentin (24 September 1998). Milton and Republicanism. Cambridge University Press. p. 239. ISBN   978-0-521-64648-2.
  15. ↑ Scott, Jonathan (20 January 2005). Algernon Sidney and the English Republic 1623-1677. Cambridge University Press. p. 14. ISBN   978-0-521-61195-4.
  16. ↑ Worden, Blair (22 March 2012). God's Instruments: Political Conduct in the England of Oliver Cromwell. OUP Oxford. p. 287 note 219. ISBN   978-0-19-957049-2.
  17. ↑ Scott, Jonathan (20 January 2005). Algernon Sidney and the English Republic 1623-1677. Cambridge University Press. p. 16. ISBN   978-0-521-61195-4.
  18. ↑ Burns, James Henderson; Goldie, Mark (1991). The Cambridge History of Political Thought 1450-1700. Cambridge University Press. p. 460. ISBN   978-0-521-47772-7.
  19. ↑ Mahlberg, Gaby; Wiemann, Dirk (22 April 2016). European Contexts for English Republicanism. Routledge. p. 212. ISBN   978-1-317-13975-1.
  20. ↑ Israel, Jonathan I. (12 October 2006). Enlightenment Contested: Philosophy, Modernity, and the Emancipation of Man 1670-1752. OUP Oxford. p. 336. ISBN   978-0-19-105748-9.
  21. ↑ Israel, Jonathan Irvine (2001). Radical Enlightenment: Philosophy and the Making of Modernity, 1650-1750. Oxford University Press. p. 583. ISBN   978-0-19-820608-8.
  22. ↑ Skinner, Quentin (16 September 2002). Visions of Politics. Vol. II Renaissance Virtues. Cambridge University Press. p. 362. ISBN   978-0-521-58925-3.
  23. ↑ Israel, Jonathan I. (12 October 2006). Enlightenment Contested: Philosophy, Modernity, and the Emancipation of Man 1670-1752. OUP Oxford. p. 227. ISBN   978-0-19-105748-9.
  24. ↑ Barnett, S. J. (19 July 2013). The Enlightenment and religion: The myths of modernity. Manchester University Press. p. 180. ISBN   978-1-84779-593-9.
  25. ↑ Hudson, Wayne; Lucci, Diego (15 April 2016). Atheism and Deism Revalued: Heterodox Religious Identities in Britain, 1650-1800. Routledge. p. 177. ISBN   978-1-317-17758-6.
  26. ↑ Pocock, John Greville Agard (20 September 2016). The Machiavellian Moment: Florentine Political Thought and the Atlantic Republican Tradition. Princeton University Press. p. 412. ISBN   978-1-4008-8351-6.
  27. ↑ Colbourn, H. Trevor (1998). The Lamp of Experience: Whig History and the Intellectual Origins of the American Revolution. Liberty Fund. pp. 72, 93, 95. ISBN   978-0-86597-158-5.
  28. ↑ Colbourn, H. Trevor (1998). The Lamp of Experience: Whig History and the Intellectual Origins of the American Revolution. Liberty Fund. pp. 261, 264, 266 and 268. ISBN   978-0-86597-158-5.
  29. ↑ Israel, Jonathan I. (28 November 2019). The Enlightenment that Failed: Ideas, Revolution, and Democratic Defeat, 1748-1830. Oxford University Press. p. 40. ISBN   978-0-19-105824-0.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Locke</span> English philosopher and physician (1632–1704)

John Locke was an English philosopher and physician, widely regarded as one of the most influential of Enlightenment thinkers and commonly known as the "father of liberalism". Considered one of the first of the British empiricists, following the tradition of Francis Bacon, Locke is equally important to social contract theory. His work greatly affected the development of epistemology and political philosophy. His writings influenced Voltaire and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, and many Scottish Enlightenment thinkers, as well as the American Revolutionaries. His contributions to classical republicanism and liberal theory are reflected in the United States Declaration of Independence. Internationally, Locke's political-legal principles continue to have a profound influence on the theory and practice of limited representative government and the protection of basic rights and freedoms under the rule of law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Niccolò Machiavelli</span> Florentine statesman, diplomat and political theorist (1469–1527)

Niccolò di Bernardo dei Machiavelli was a Florentine diplomat, author, philosopher and historian who lived during the Renaissance. He is best known for his political treatise The Prince, written around 1513 but not published until 1532, five years after his death. He has often been called the father of modern political philosophy and political science.

Republicanism is a western political ideology that encompasses a range of ideas from civic virtue, political participation, harms of corruption, positives of mixed constitution, rule of law, and others. Historically, it emphasizes the idea of self-governance and ranges from the rule of a representative minority or aristocracy to popular sovereignty. It has had different definitions and interpretations which vary significantly based on historical context and methodological approach.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Toland</span> Irish Enlightenment Philosopher (1670-1722)

John Toland was an Irish rationalist philosopher and freethinker, and occasional satirist, who wrote numerous books and pamphlets on political philosophy and philosophy of religion, which are early expressions of the philosophy of the Age of Enlightenment. Born in Ireland, he was educated at the universities of Glasgow, Edinburgh, Leiden and Oxford and was influenced by the philosophy of John Locke.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Algernon Sidney</span> English politician and member of the middle part of the Long Parliament

Algernon Sidney or Sydney was an English politician, republican political theorist and colonel. A member of the middle part of the Long Parliament and commissioner of the trial of King Charles I of England, he opposed the king's execution. Sidney was later charged with plotting against Charles II, in part based on his most famous work, Discourses Concerning Government, which was used by the prosecution as a witness at his trial. He was executed for treason. After his death, Sidney was revered as a "Whig patriot—hero and martyr".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rye House Plot</span> Plan to assassinate Charles II of England

The Rye House Plot of 1683 was a plan to assassinate King Charles II of England and his brother James, Duke of York. The royal party went from Westminster to Newmarket to see horse races and were expected to make the return journey on 1 April 1683, but because there was a major fire in Newmarket on 22 March, the races were cancelled, and the King and the Duke returned to London early. As a result, the planned attack never took place.

The Radical Whigs were a group of British political commentators associated with the British Whig faction who were at the forefront of the Radical movement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henry Sydney, 1st Earl of Romney</span> English politician and army officer (1641–1704)

Henry Sydney, 1st Earl of Romney was an English Army officer, Whig politician and peer who served as Master-General of the Ordnance from 1693 to 1702. He is best known as one of the Immortal Seven, a group of seven Englishmen who drafted an invitation to William of Orange, which led to the November 1688 Glorious Revolution and subsequent deposition of James II of England.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">American Enlightenment</span> 18th century US intellectual ferment

The American Enlightenment was a period of intellectual and philosophical fervor in the thirteen American colonies in the 18th to 19th century, which led to the American Revolution and the creation of the United States of America. The American Enlightenment was influenced by the 17th- and 18th-century Age of Enlightenment in Europe and native American philosophy. According to James MacGregor Burns, the spirit of the American Enlightenment was to give Enlightenment ideals a practical, useful form in the life of the nation and its people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Whiggism</span> Political philosophy

Whiggism is a political philosophy that grew out of the Parliamentarian faction in the Wars of the Three Kingdoms (1639–1651). The Whigs advocated the supremacy of Parliament, tolerance of Protestant dissenters, and opposition to a "Papist" on the throne, especially James II or his descendants. It is associated with early conservative liberalism.

Mixed government is a form of government that combines elements of democracy, aristocracy and monarchy, ostensibly making impossible their respective degenerations which are conceived in Aristotle's Politics as anarchy, oligarchy and tyranny. The idea was popularized during classical antiquity in order to describe the stability, the innovation and the success of the republic as a form of government developed under the Roman constitution.

Classical republicanism, also known as civic republicanism or civic humanism, is a form of republicanism developed in the Renaissance inspired by the governmental forms and writings of classical antiquity, especially such classical writers as Aristotle, Polybius, and Cicero. Classical republicanism is built around concepts such as liberty as non-domination, self-government, rule of law, property-based personality, anti-corruption, abolition of monarchy, civics, civil society, common good, civic virtue, popular sovereignty, patriotism and mixed government.

The Good Old Cause was the name given, retrospectively, by the soldiers of the New Model Army, to the complex of reasons that motivated their fight on behalf of the Parliament of England.

A Christian republic is a government that is both Christian and republican. As of the 21st century, the only countries in the world with a republican form of government and with Christianity as the established religion are Costa Rica, Finland, Greece, Armenia, Samoa, Iceland, and Malta. Some other republics, such as Argentina, Georgia, Peru, Guatemala, Panama, El Salvador, and Paraguay, give some credit or preference to Christianity, but without establishing it as the religion of the state. Others, such as Hungary, and Zambia, describe themselves as Christian countries.

The Commonwealth men, Commonwealthmen, Commonwealth's men, or Commonwealth Party were highly outspoken British Protestant religious, political, and economic reformers during the early 18th century. They were active in the movement called the Country Party. They promoted republicanism and had a great influence on Republicanism in the United States, but little impact in Britain.

Jonathan Charles Douglas Clark is a British historian of both British and American history. He received his undergraduate degree at Downing College, Cambridge. Having previously held posts at Peterhouse, Cambridge and All Souls College, Oxford into 1996, he has since held the Joyce C. and Elizabeth Ann Hall Distinguished Professorship of British History at the University of Kansas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert Brady (writer)</span> English academic and historical writer

Robert Brady (1627–1700) was an English academic and historical writer supporting the royalist position in the reigns of Charles II of England and James II of England. He was also a physician.

Country Party was the name employed in the Kingdom of England by political movements which campaigned in opposition to the Court Party.

Richard Laughton (1670?–1723) was an English churchman and academic, now known as a natural philosopher and populariser of the ideas of Isaac Newton.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Revolutionary republic</span> Representative democracy established immediately after overthrow

A revolutionary republic is a form of government whose main tenets are popular sovereignty, rule of law, and representative democracy. It is based in part on the ideas of Enlightenment thinkers, and was favored by revolutionaries during the Age of Revolution. A revolutionary republic tends to arise from the formation of a provisional government after the overthrow of an existing state and political regime. It often takes the form of a revolutionary state, which ostensibly represents the will of its constituents.

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.