Radio Galaxy Zoo

Last updated

Radio Galaxy Zoo Radio galaxy zoo.jpg
Radio Galaxy Zoo

Radio Galaxy Zoo (RGZ) is an internet crowdsourced citizen science project that seeks to locate supermassive black holes in distant galaxies. [1] [2] It is hosted by the web portal Zooniverse. The scientific team want to identify black hole/jet pairs and associate them with the host galaxies. Using a large number of classifications provided by citizen scientists they hope to build a more complete picture of black holes at various stages and their origin. [3] [4] It was initiated in 2010 by Ray Norris in collaboration with the Zooniverse team, and was driven by the need to cross-identify the millions of extragalactic radio sources that will be discovered by the forthcoming Evolutionary Map of the Universe survey. RGZ is now led by scientists Julie Banfield and Ivy Wong. [5] RGZ started operations on 17 December 2013. [3]

Contents

RGZ Data Sources

Australia Telescope Compact Array CSIRO ScienceImage 3881 Five Antennas at Narrabri - restoration1.jpg
Australia Telescope Compact Array

The project's scientific team are drawn mostly from Australia, with support from Zooniverse developers and other institutions. [6] They use data taken by the Faint Images of the Radio Sky at Twenty-Centimeters (FIRST) survey which was observed at the Very Large Array between 1993 and 2011. Also used was data from the Australia Telescope Large Area Survey (ATLAS), taken with the Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA) in rural New South Wales. The infrared astronomy used was observed by Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE) and the Spitzer Space Telescope. [6]

RGZ Publications

Image of a Black Hole's Jets Best-Ever Snapshot of a Black Hole's Jets.jpg
Image of a Black Hole's Jets

RGZ has published five scientific studies (May 2018).

i) Radio Galaxy Zoo: host galaxies and radio morphologies derived from visual inspection. (November 2015) [1] [7]

The abstract begins: "We present results from the first twelve months of operation of Radio Galaxy Zoo, which upon completion will enable visual inspection of over 170,000 radio sources to determine the host galaxy of the radio emission and the radio morphology." [1] It then explains that RGZ "uses 1.4GHz radio images from both the Faint Images of the Radio Sky at Twenty Centimeters (FIRST) and the Australia Telescope Large Area Survey (ATLAS) in combination with mid-infrared images at 3.4μm from the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE) and at 3.6μm from the Spitzer Space Telescope." [1] Its aims are that when complete, RGZ will measure the relative populations and properties of host galaxies; processes that might also provide an avenue for finding radio structures that are rare and extreme. [1]

On the International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR) website, an article from September 2015 named "Volunteer black hole hunters as good as the experts" explains how citizen scientists are as good as professionals at RGZ's tasks. [8] The research team tested trained citizen scientists and ten professional astronomers using a hundred images to help quantify the quality of the data gathered. As the initial results were published, facts and figures from RGZ became available. More than 1.2 million radio images have been looked at, which enabled 60,000 radio sources to be matched to their host galaxies: "A feat that would have taken a single astronomer working 40 hours a week roughly 50 years to complete." [8]

Radio Galaxy 3C 83.1B an example of a Wide-angle Tail Radio Galaxy 3c83p1 21cm opt 6in hi.tif
Radio Galaxy 3C 83.1B an example of a Wide-angle Tail Radio Galaxy

ii) Radio Galaxy Zoo: discovery of a poor cluster through a giant wide-angle tail radio galaxy. (May 2016) [9] [10]

The abstract begins: "We have discovered a previously unreported poor cluster of galaxies (RGZ-CL J0823.2+0333) through an unusual giant wide-angle tail radio galaxy found in the Radio Galaxy Zoo project." It continues to explain that the analysis of 2MASX J08231289+0333016's surrounding environment indicates that it is within a poor cluster. Radio morphology suggests that, firstly, "the host galaxy is moving at a significant velocity with respect to an ambient medium like that of at least a poor cluster" and secondly that "the source may have had two ignition events of the active galactic nucleus with 10^7yrs in between." [9] These suggestions reinforce the idea that there is an association between RGZ J082312.9+033301 and the newly discovered poor cluster. [9]

On The Conversation website in an article "How citizen scientists discovered a giant cluster of galaxies", Ray Norris writes about the above study. [5] He explains that two Russian citizen scientists (CSs), Ivan Terentev and Tim Matorny, were participating in RGZ when they noticed something odd with one of the radio sources. It became clear that the radio source the two CSs had found "was just one of a line of radio blobs that delineate a C-shaped “wide angle tail galaxy” (WATG)." Lead scientist Julie Banfield explained that this was "something that none of us had even thought would be possible." [5]

WATGs are rare objects that are formed when jets of electrons from black holes, usually seen to be straight, are bent into a C shape by intergalactic gas. This characteristic shape is "a sure sign that there is intergalactic gas, signifying a cluster of galaxies, the largest known objects in the universe." [5] The WATG discovered by Terentev and Matorny is one of the largest known and has led to the cluster being named after them. "This cluster, more than a billion light years away, contains at least 40 galaxies, marking an intersection of the sheets and filaments of the cosmic web that make up our universe." [5] Clusters, despite their importance, are hard to find but the use of WATGs might be a way of finding more: However WATGs are rare.

On the National Radio Astronomy Observatory website, Matorny and Terentev commented on their discovery. “I am still amazed and feel more motivated to look for stunning new radio galaxies,” Matorny said. [11] Terentev added, “I got a chance to see the whole process of science … and I have been a part of it!” [11]

iii) Radio Galaxy Zoo: A Search for Hybrid Morphology Radio Galaxies. (December 2017) [12]

The abstract begins: "Hybrid morphology radio sources are a rare type of radio galaxy that display different Fanaroff-Riley classes on opposite sides of their nuclei." The authors explain that RGZ has enabled them to discover 25 new candidate hybrid morphology radio galaxies (HyMoRS). These HyMoRS are at distances between redshifts z=0.14 and 1.0. Nine of the host galaxies have previous spectra and include quasars and a rare Green bean galaxy. It states: "Although the origin of the hybrid morphology radio galaxies is still unclear, this type of radio source starts depicting itself as a rather diverse class." [12] The abstract ends:"While high angular resolution follow-up observations are still necessary to confirm our candidates, we demonstrate the efficacy of the Radio Galaxy Zoo in the pre-selection of these sources from all-sky radio surveys, and report the reliability of citizen scientists in identifying and classifying complex radio sources." [12]

In an article on the ARC Centre of Excellence for All-Sky Astrophysics CAASTRO website named "Citizen scientists bag a bunch of 'two-faced' galaxies", the author explains the findings of the above study. [13] The lead scientist is Anna Kapinska with CS Ivan Terentev named second. Kapinska's team have been looking for rare types of galaxies named Hybrid Morphology Radio Galaxies (HyMoRS). These show galaxy characteristics that are combined, rather than distinct. The article states: "Finding more HyMoRS helps us understand what kind of galaxy can turn out this way, and what gives them their unusual properties. Knowing that, in turn, helps us better understand how all galaxies evolve." [13]

The first recognised HyMoRS was discovered in 2002 and since then 30 more. RGZ near doubled the discoveries by adding 25 more. Galaxies with black holes that produce jets are often "divided into two classes, Fanaroff-Riley I and Fanaroff-Riley II (or FR I and II). FR I galaxies have jets that fade away as they extend outwards, while FR II galaxies have jets that end in a bright, strongly-emitting region (a ‘hotspot’)." [13] Explanations include the behaviour of the central black hole, different densities of matter in the surrounding environment or simply illusions because of different distances. [13]

iv) Radio Galaxy Zoo: Cosmological Alignment of Radio Sources (November 2017) [14]

Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope GMRT antenna at sunset.jpg
Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope

In November 2017, a team led by Omar Contigiani published a paper in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society studying the mutual alignment of radio sources. [14] Using data drawn from the Faint Images of the Radio Sky at Twenty Centimeters (FIRST) and TIFR GMRT Sky Survey (TGSS), they investigate the most powerful radio sources, namely the largest elliptical galaxies emitting plasma-filled jets. The abstract begins: "We study the mutual alignment of radio sources within two surveys, FIRST and TGSS. This is done by producing two position angle catalogues containing the preferential directions of respectively 30059 and 11674 extended sources distributed over more than 7000 and 17000 square degrees." [14] The FIRST sample sources were identified by participants in RGZ, while the TGSS sample was the result of an automated process. Marginal evidence of local alignment is found in the FIRST sample, which has a 2% probability of being by chance. This supports other recent research by scientists using the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope. The abstract ends: "The TGSS sample is found to be too sparsely populated to manifest a similar signal." Results suggest that there is a relative alignment present at cosmological distances. [14]

v) Radio Galaxy Zoo: Compact and extended radio source classification with deep learning (May 2018). [15]

In May 2018, Lukic and team published a study in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society concerning machine learning techniques. The abstract begins: "Machine learning techniques have been increasingly useful in astronomical applications over the last few years, for example in the morphological classification of galaxies." [15]

Gems of the Galaxy Zoos (ZooGems)

During the next two years, up to 105 RGZ objects will be observed with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) as a result of Program 15445, whose P.I. is William Keel. [16] [17] The program's abstract begins: "The classic Galaxy Zoo project and its successors have been rich sources of interesting astrophysics beyond their initial goals. Green Pea starbursts, AGN ionization echoes, dust in backlit spirals, AGN in pseudobulges, have all seen HST followup programs." [16] As a result of NASA 'gap fillers' initiative, it is hoped that significant scientific progress can be made by HST observations of a total of 304 objects, which have been chosen by voters using a Zooniverse custom-made interface. [16] Keel stated: "Each one of them might not be enough for an individual study, but when you put them all together it adds up to an interesting study." [17]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Galaxy</span> Large gravitationally bound system of stars and interstellar matter

A galaxy is a system of stars, stellar remnants, interstellar gas, dust, and dark matter bound together by gravity. The word is derived from the Greek galaxias (γαλαξίας), literally 'milky', a reference to the Milky Way galaxy that contains the Solar System. Galaxies, averaging an estimated 100 billion stars, range in size from dwarfs with less than a hundred million stars, to the largest galaxies known – supergiants with one hundred trillion stars, each orbiting its galaxy's center of mass. Most of the mass in a typical galaxy is in the form of dark matter, with only a few percent of that mass visible in the form of stars and nebulae. Supermassive black holes are a common feature at the centres of galaxies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Globular cluster</span> Spherical collection of stars

A globular cluster is a spheroidal conglomeration of stars that is bound together by gravity, with a higher concentration of stars towards their centers. They can contain anywhere from tens of thousands to many millions of member stars, all orbiting in a stable, compact formation. Globular clusters are similar in form to dwarf spheroidal galaxies, and the distinction between the two is not always clear. Their name is derived from Latin globulus. Globular clusters are occasionally known simply as "globulars".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hubble sequence</span> Galaxy morphological classification scheme advocated by Edwin Hubble

The Hubble sequence is a morphological classification scheme for galaxies published by Edwin Hubble in 1926. It is often colloquially known as the Hubble tuning-fork diagram because the shape in which it is traditionally represented resembles a tuning fork. It was invented by John Henry Reynolds and Sir James Jeans.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Andromeda Galaxy</span> Barred spiral galaxy in the Local Group

The Andromeda Galaxy is a barred spiral galaxy and is the nearest major galaxy to the Milky Way. It was originally named the Andromeda Nebula and is cataloged as Messier 31, M31, and NGC 224. Andromeda has a diameter of about 46.56 kiloparsecs and is approximately 765 kpc from Earth. The galaxy's name stems from the area of Earth's sky in which it appears, the constellation of Andromeda, which itself is named after the princess who was the wife of Perseus in Greek mythology.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Astronomical object</span> Large natural physical entity in space

An astronomical object, celestial object, stellar object or heavenly body is a naturally occurring physical entity, association, or structure that exists within the observable universe. In astronomy, the terms object and body are often used interchangeably. However, an astronomical body or celestial body is a single, tightly bound, contiguous entity, while an astronomical or celestial object is a complex, less cohesively bound structure, which may consist of multiple bodies or even other objects with substructures.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Messier 87</span> Elliptical galaxy in the Virgo Galaxy Cluster

Messier 87 is a supergiant elliptical galaxy in the constellation Virgo that contains several trillion stars. One of the largest and most massive galaxies in the local universe, it has a large population of globular clusters—about 15,000 compared with the 150–200 orbiting the Milky Way—and a jet of energetic plasma that originates at the core and extends at least 1,500 parsecs, traveling at a relativistic speed. It is one of the brightest radio sources in the sky and a popular target for both amateur and professional astronomers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Messier 82</span> Starburst galaxy in the constellation Ursa Major

Messier 82 (also known as NGC 3034, Cigar Galaxy or M82) is a starburst galaxy approximately 12 million light-years away in the constellation Ursa Major. It is the second-largest member of the M81 Group, with the D25 isophotal diameter of 12.52 kiloparsecs (40,800 light-years). It is about five times more luminous than the Milky Way and its central region is about one hundred times more luminous. The starburst activity is thought to have been triggered by interaction with neighboring galaxy M81. As one of the closest starburst galaxies to Earth, M82 is the prototypical example of this galaxy type. SN 2014J, a type Ia supernova, was discovered in the galaxy on 21 January 2014. In 2014, in studying M82, scientists discovered the brightest pulsar yet known, designated M82 X-2.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Catalina Sky Survey</span> Project to discover comets, asteroids, and near-Earth objects

Catalina Sky Survey is an astronomical survey to discover comets and asteroids. It is conducted at the Steward Observatory's Catalina Station, located near Tucson, Arizona, in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sombrero Galaxy</span> Galaxy in the constellation Virgo

The Sombrero Galaxy is a peculiar galaxy of unclear classification in the constellation borders of Virgo and Corvus, being about 9.55 megaparsecs from the Milky Way galaxy. It is a member of the Virgo II Groups, a series of galaxies and galaxy clusters strung out from the southern edge of the Virgo Supercluster. It has an isophotal diameter of approximately 29.09 to 32.32 kiloparsecs, making it slightly bigger in size than the Milky Way.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">NGC 6397</span> Globular cluster of stars in the Milky Way

NGC 6397 is a globular cluster in the constellation Ara. It is located about 7,800 light-years from Earth, making it one of the two nearest globular clusters to Earth. The cluster contains around 400,000 stars, and can be seen with the naked eye under good observing conditions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope</span>

The Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT), located near Narayangaon, Pune in India, is an array of thirty fully steerable parabolic radio telescopes of 45 metre diameter, observing at metre wavelengths. It is the largest and most sensitive radio telescope array in the world at low frequencies. It is operated by the National Centre for Radio Astrophysics (NCRA), a part of the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Mumbai. It was conceived and built under the direction of Govind Swarup during 1984 to 1996. It is an interferometric array with baselines of up to 25 kilometres (16 mi). It was recently upgraded with new receivers, after which it is also known as the upgraded Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (uGMRT).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chris Lintott</span> British astrophysicist, author and broadcaster (born 1980)

Christopher John Lintott is a British astrophysicist, author and broadcaster. He is a Professor of Astrophysics in the Department of Physics at the University of Oxford, and since 2023 is the Gresham Professor of Astronomy at Gresham College, London. Lintott is involved in a number of popular science projects aimed at bringing astronomy to a wider audience and is also the primary presenter of the BBC television series The Sky at Night, having previously been co-presenter with Patrick Moore until Moore's death in 2012. He co-authored Bang! – The Complete History of the Universe and The Cosmic Tourist with Moore and Queen guitarist and astrophysicist Brian May.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Galaxy Zoo</span> Crowdsourced astronomy project

Galaxy Zoo is a crowdsourced astronomy project which invites people to assist in the morphological classification of large numbers of galaxies. It is an example of citizen science as it enlists the help of members of the public to help in scientific research.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hanny's Voorwerp</span> Astronomical object appearing as a bright blob, discovered by Hanny van Arkel

Hanny's Voorwerp, is a rare type of astronomical object called a quasar ionization echo. It was discovered in 2007 by Dutch schoolteacher Hanny van Arkel while she was participating as a volunteer in the Galaxy Zoo project, part of the Zooniverse group of citizen science websites. Photographically, it appears as a bright blob close to spiral galaxy IC 2497 in the constellation Leo Minor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Disk Detective</span> NASA-citizen science project

Disk Detective is the first NASA-led and funded-collaboration project with Zooniverse. It is NASA's largest crowdsourcing citizen science project aiming at engaging the general public in search of stars, which are surrounded by dust-rich circumstellar disks, where planets usually dwell and are formed. Initially launched by NASA Citizen Science Officer, Marc Kuchner, the principal investigation of the project was turned over to Steven Silverberg.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Evolutionary Map of the Universe</span>

Evolutionary Map of the Universe, or EMU, is a large project which will use the new ASKAP telescope to make a census of radio sources in the sky. EMU is expected to detect about 70 million radio sources. Most of these radio sources will be galaxies millions of light years away, many containing massive black holes, and some of the signals detected will have been sent less than half a billion years after the Big Bang, which created the universe 13.7 billion years ago. Unlike the NVSS, which mainly detected active galactic nuclei, the greater sensitivity of EMU means that about half the galaxies detected will be star-forming galaxies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Teacup galaxy</span> Low redshift quasar in the constellation Boötes

The Teacup galaxy, also known as the Teacup AGN or SDSS J1430+1339 is a low redshift type 2 quasar, showing an extended loop of ionized gas resembling a handle of a teacup, which was discovered by volunteers of the Galaxy Zoo project and labeled as a Voorwerpje.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Odd radio circle</span> Unexplained circular astronomical object detected only by radio waves

In astronomy, an odd radio circle (ORC) is a very large unexplained astronomical object that, at radio wavelengths, is highly circular and brighter along its edges. As of 27 April 2021, there have been five such objects observed. The observed ORCs are bright at radio wavelengths, but are not visible at visible, infrared or X-ray wavelengths. This is due to the physical process producing this radiation, which is thought to be synchrotron radiation. Three of the ORCs contain optical galaxies in their centers, suggesting that the galaxies might have formed these objects.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gems of the Galaxy Zoos</span>

Gems of the Galaxy Zoos (Zoogems) was a gap-filler project which used the Hubble Space Telescope to take images of unusual objects found by volunteers classifying data from both Galaxy Zoo (GZ) and Radio Galaxy Zoo (RGZ). Between the HSTs' main observations, there is a short time that objects within that field of view can be imaged using gaps which last approximately 12 - 25 mins. The Zoogems project sought to use those small observation gaps to image 300 candidates taken from the two Zoos in order to better study and comprehend them. Starting observations in May 2018, HST Proposal 15445 had by the end of September 2023 imaged 193 of the 300 candidates with many of them having near 11 minute exposures.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 J.K. Banfield; O.I. Wong; K.W. Willett; R.P. Norris; L. Rudnick; S.S. Shabala; B.D. Simmons; C. Snyder; A. Garon; N. Seymour; E. Middelberg; H. Andernach; C.J. Lintott; K. Jacob; A.D. Kapinska; M.Y. Mao; K.L. Masters; M.J. Jarvis; K. Schawinski; E. Paget; R. Simpson; H.R. Klockner; S. Bamford; T. Burchell; K.E. Chow; G. Cotter; L. Fortson; I. Heywood; T.W. Jones; S. Kaviraj; A.R. Lopez-Sanchez; W.P. Maksym; K. Polsterer; K. Borden; R.P. Hollow; L. Whyte (November 2015). "Radio Galaxy Zoo: host galaxies and radio morphologies derived from visual inspection". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 453 (3): 2326–2340. arXiv: 1507.07272 . Bibcode:2015MNRAS.453.2326B. doi:10.1093/mnras/stv1688. S2CID   3352520.
  2. K.W. Willett (8 March 2016). Radio Galaxy Zoo: host galaxies and radio morphologies for large surveys from visual inspection. Conference: The Many Facets of Extragalactic Radio Surveys: Towards New Scientific Challenges, Bologna, October 2015. Proceedings of Science. pp. 1–9. arXiv: 1603.02645v1 . Bibcode:2016arXiv160302645W.
  3. 1 2 "Find black holes while you're on the bus". Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation. 17 December 2013. Archived from the original on 25 March 2018. Retrieved 25 March 2018.
  4. Ivy Wong (31 August 2015). "Join The Hunt For Supermassive Black Holes". Asian Scientist Magazine. Archived from the original on 4 August 2016. Retrieved 16 March 2018.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 Ray Norris (13 June 2016). "How citizen scientists discovered a giant cluster of galaxies". The Conversation Trust (UK) Limited. Archived from the original on 15 June 2016. Retrieved 16 March 2016.
  6. 1 2 The Scientific Team (December 2013). "Radio Galaxy Zoo website". Zooniverse. Archived from the original on 23 February 2018. Retrieved 21 March 2018.
  7. "Volunteer black hole hunters as good as the experts". Phys.org. 7 September 2015. Archived from the original on 29 May 2016. Retrieved 24 March 2018.
  8. 1 2 ICRAR journalist (7 September 2015). "Volunteer black hole hunters as good as the experts". International Centre For Radio Astronomy. Archived from the original on 25 March 2018. Retrieved 16 March 2018.
  9. 1 2 3 J.K. Banfield; H. Andernach; A.D. Kapinska; L. Rudnick; M.J. Hardcastle; G. Cotter; S. Vaughan; T.W. Jones; I. Heywood; J.D. Wing; O.I. Wong; T. Matorny; I.A. Terentev; A.R. Lopez-Sanchez; R.P. Norris; N. Seymour; S.S. Shabala; K.W. Willett (5 May 2016). "Radio Galaxy Zoo: discovery of a poor cluster through a giant wide-angle tail radio galaxy". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 460 (3): 2376–2384. arXiv: 1606.05016 . Bibcode:2016MNRAS.460.2376B. doi:10.1093/mnras/stw1067. S2CID   18327086.
  10. "Writing their name in the stars: Citizen scientists discover huge galaxy cluster". Phys.org. 13 June 2016. Archived from the original on 24 October 2016. Retrieved 24 March 2018.
  11. 1 2 "Citizen Scientists' Discovery Points to Unknown Galaxy Cluster". National Radio Astronomy Observatory. 1 July 2016. Archived from the original on 12 September 2017. Retrieved 24 March 2018.
  12. 1 2 3 A.D. Kapinska; I. Terentev; O.I. Wong; S.S. Shabala; H. Andernach; L. Rudnick; L. Storer; J. K. Banfield; K.W. Willett; F. de Gasperin; C. J. Lintott; A.R. Lopez-Sanchez; E. Middelberg; R.P. Norris; K. Schawinski; N. Seymour; B. Simmons (December 2017). "Radio Galaxy Zoo: A Search for Hybrid Morphology Radio Galaxies". The Astronomical Journal . 154 (6): 16. arXiv: 1711.09611 . Bibcode:2017AJ....154..253K. doi: 10.3847/1538-3881/aa90b7 . S2CID   55589796.
  13. 1 2 3 4 Arc Centre of Excellence For All-Sky Astrophysics journalist (27 November 2017). "Citizen scientists bag a bunch of 'two-faced' galaxies". Australian Government. Archived from the original on 25 March 2018. Retrieved 16 March 2018.
  14. 1 2 3 4 O. Contigiani; F. de Gasperin; G.K. Miley; L. Rudnick; H. Andernach; J.K. Banfield; A.D. Kapińska; S.S. Shabala; O.I. Wong (November 2017). "Radio Galaxy Zoo: Cosmological Alignment of Radio Sources". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 472 (1): 636–646. arXiv: 1708.00301 . Bibcode:2017MNRAS.472..636C. doi:10.1093/mnras/stx1977. S2CID   55724198.
  15. 1 2 V. Lukic; M. Brüggen; J.K. Banfield; O.I. Wong; L. Rudnick; R.P. Norris; B. Simmons (May 2018). "Radio Galaxy Zoo: Compact and extended radio source classification with deep learning". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 476 (1): 246–260. arXiv: 1801.04861 . Bibcode:2018MNRAS.476..246L. doi:10.1093/mnras/sty163. S2CID   52952099.
  16. 1 2 3 "Hubble Space Telescope Observing Program 15445". Space Telescope Science Institute. 22 March 2018. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
  17. 1 2 "Solving Galactic Mysteries a Few Minutes at a Time". University of Alabama. 8 February 2018. Retrieved 31 March 2018.